Tropical Agricultural Research Vol. 25 (4): 555 – 569 (2014)
Response of Potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) to Increasing Growing Season
Temperature Under Different Soil Management and Crop Protection Regimes
in the Upcountry of Sri Lanka
K.M.R.D. Abhayapala*, W.A.J.M. De Costa1, R.M. Fonseka1, K. Prasannath2
D.M. De Costa3, L.D.B. Suriyagoda1, P.D. Abeythilakeratne4 and M.M. Nugaliyadde5
Postgraduate Institute of Agriculture
University of Peradeniya
Sri Lanka
ABSTRACT: The national average potato yield of Sri Lanka is lower than its global
average with the absence of an optimum temperature regime for tuber bulking being a major
contributory factor. Increasing air temperatures due to the enhanced greenhouse effect have
the potential to further reduce potato yields in Sri Lanka. Therefore, the primary objective of
this study was to determine the response of phenology, growth and yield of potato to
increasing temperature in the upcountry of Sri Lanka, which is the principal potato-growing
region of the country. Furthermore, effectiveness of an integrated pest management (IPM)
package and a modified soil management regime aimed at soil moisture conservation and
reducing excessive use of synthetic pesticides and fertilizers were also tested. A field
experiment was conducted during Maha 2012/2013 at Sita-Eliya (SE) and Rahangala (RG)
of Sri Lanka, which represented a temperature increase of 5.2 oC from 15.1 oC to 20.3 oC.
Potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) variety Arnova was grown with four treatments: T1 –
Recommended crop management; T2 – Mulching with recommended crop protection (nonIPM) and fertilization (100 % inorganic fertilizer); T3 – Mulching with IPM and
recommended fertilization and T4 – Mulching with IPM plus 25% of N provided as organic
amendments. Crops matured a month earlier at the higher temperature site RG, i.e. in 81
days as compared to 111 days at SE. However, the thermal duration from planting to
maturity was approximately similar at both sites (i.e. 1689 oCd and 1662 oCd at SE and RG,
respectively). Crop growth rates were higher at RG, thus compensating for the lower crop
duration so that total dry weights at harvest and tuber yields of T1 did not differ significantly
between the two sites. At both sites, the tuber yield of T2 did not differ significantly from T1.
The growth and yield response to mulching was greater at RG due to the lower rainfall and
low soil fertility as compared to SE. The IPM treatments (i.e. T3 and T4) resulted in an
effective control of the incidence and severity of late blight at SE but not at RG, where the
prevailing temperature regime was optimum for spore formation of the late blight pathogen.
Consequently, while the tuber yields did not show significant inter-treatment variation at SE,
at RG the IPM treatments (i.e. T3 and T4) showed significantly lower yields than the non-IPM
(T1 and T2) treatments. Analysis of the inter-relationships between tuber yield, yield
components and growth data showed that potato yields of the present study were primarily
source-limited.
Keywords: Crop protection, increased temperature, potato, soil management
1
2
3
4
5
*
Department of Crop Science, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Peradeniya, Sri Lanka
Faculty of Agriculture, Eastern University, Batticaloa, Sri Lanka
Department of Agricultural Biology, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Peradeniya, Sri Lanka
Regional Agricultural Institute, Rahangala, Sri Lanka
Agricultural Research Station, Sita-Eliya, Sri Lanka
Corresponding author: ruvini.dilrukshi@yahoo.com
Abhayapala et al.
INTRODUCTION
Potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) ranks fourth among the world’s food crops and is the staple
food of almost half of the world’s population (Khan & Khan, 2010). In Sri Lanka, total
national potato production in 2009/2010 was 51,294 tonnes and the extent under cultivation
was 3,748 ha (Anonymous, 2010). At present, potato is extensively cultivated in highlands in
the districts of Nuwara-Eliya in the up-country wet zone (WU3) and Badulla in the upcountry intermediate zone (IU3d). At present, the local production of potato is not sufficient
to meet Sri Lanka’s potato demand and thus necessitates importation. Therefore, Sri Lanka
has to import 3,000-3,500 tons of seed potato every year at a cost of Rs. 1.7 billion
(Nugaliyadda, 2011). Hence, there is a need to increase local potato production to reduce the
outflow of foreign exchange.
Absence of specific climatic conditions for tuber bulking in potato is a major constraint to
expand its cultivated extent in Sri Lanka. Even in the areas where potato is currently
cultivated, the climatic conditions are not optimum for achieving the yield potential.
Accordingly, the average productivity of potato in Sri Lanka is 13.47 t ha-1 which is much
lower than the global average of 17.18 t ha-1 (Pandey, 2008). Long-term increases in air
temperatures of all agro-climatic regions of Sri Lanka, along with greenhouse effect-induced
global warming (IPCC, 2001 & 2007), are likely to impose further environmental constraints
to increasing potato yields in Sri Lanka. A strong negative impact of climate change on
potato yields in the low latitudes (i.e. the tropics) has been predicted (Hijmans, 2003).
Therefore, one objective of the present study was to quantify the response of potato yields in
Sri Lanka to environmental variation as represented by two experimental sites, namely,
Nuwara-Eliya in the up-country wet zone and Rahangala in the up-country intermediate
zone.
Apart from the environmental constraints, at present, potato cultivation in Sri Lanka has
several critical issues, which have to be addressed urgently to ensure its long-term
sustainability. Extremely high use of pesticides and inorganic fertilizers on intensive
cultivations of potato on steep slopes of the up-country is one such issue (Watawala et al.,
2009; Wijewardana, 1996; Wijewardana, 2001; Suriyagoda et al., 2012). Because of the high
precipitation levels in the up-country, a high proportion of the applied inorganic fertilizer and
pesticides are leached to ground water causing serious environmental and health hazards
(Wijewardena, 1996; Robertson & Vitousek, 2009; Watawala et al., 2009). Hence, there is a
need to explore the possibility of cultivating potato with reduced use of pesticides and
inorganic fertilizer. Accordingly, another objective of the present work was to determine the
effectiveness of an integrated pest management (IPM) package with reduced pesticide
application and a modified nutrient management regime in which a part of the nitrogen
requirement is supplied by organic manure.
The specific objectives of the study were to determine the response of phenology, vegetative
growth and tuber yield of potato (var. Arnova) to: (a) the environmental variation represented
by the up-country wet zone and the up-country intermediate zone of Sri Lanka; (b) modified
crop protection practices to include IPM aiming minimal use of pesticides and (c) modified
nutrient management to include organic amendments and reduce the use of inorganic
fertilizer. Further objectives were to quantify the disease incidence and assess the
effectiveness of the tested IPM package for potato.
556
Response of potato to increasing growing season temperature
METHODOLOGY
A field experiment was conducted at the Agricultural Research Station, Sita-Eliya to
represent the up-country wet zone and the Agricultural Research Station, Rahangala to
represent the up-country intermediate zone. The environmental conditions of the two sites
are shown in Table 1.
Table 1. Site characters in Sita-Eliya and Rahangala
Location
Agro-ecological
region1
Sita-Eliya
WU3
Rahangala
IU3d
1
Soil type2
Red Yellow
Podsolic
Red Yellow
Podsolic
2
Mean annual
rainfall (mm)2
Mean annual
temperature (0C)3
2000
16.2
1450
19.6
3
Source: Punyawardana (2008); Mapa et al. (1999; 2005); Natural Resource Management Centre, Department of
Agriculture, Sri Lanka. Annual mean temperature was calculated using 10-year monthly average maximum and
minimum temperatures (Sita-Eliya from 2000 to 2009; Rahangala from 1992 to 2001).
The experiment was laid out as a Randomized Complete Block Design (RCBD) with four
treatments in three replicates. The high yielding and heat tolerant potato variety Arnova was
used. Plot size was 25 m2 (5 m × 5 m) and contained 144 plants at inter- and intra-row
spacings of 60 cm and 25 cm, respectively. Plots were separated by a distance of 1 m from
each other. Details of the four treatments are given below.
Treatment 1 (T1) included the current recommended management practices in terms of
fertilization and crop protection by the Department of Agriculture (Anonymous, 1990).
Treatment 2 (T2) included mulching with current recommended fertilization and crop
protection practices. Treatment 3 (T3) included mulching with modified crop protection to
include an integrated pest management (IPM) package with recommended fertilizer
management practices. Treatment 4 (T4) included mulching, modified crop protection (i.e.
IPM) with modified nutrient management. For mulching site specific materials were used at
the rate of 8 t ha-1. Tithonia diversifolia and Panicum spp. were used at Sita-Eliya and
Rahangala, respectively. The IPM package was designed after preliminary laboratory testing
and included following treatment combinations: (a) A soil application of a 2% bleach
solution after crop establishment for eliminating the harmful effects of soil borne pathogens;
(b) A weekly foliar application of baking soda (NaHCO3) solution for controlling the late
blight disease; (c) A monthly application of a talc based biopesticide (Bacillus megaterium)
to the foliage for reducing the fungal pathogens; (d) A one-time application of neem seed
kernel extract solution for the control of insect pests and (e) Establishment of two border
rows of maize around each plot for reducing the abundance of insect pests. The plots
containing the IPM treatments (i.e. T3 and T4) were separated from plots which were
managed with conventional crop protection practices (T1 and T2) by a thick barrier of maize
rows to prevent the pesticide drift. Modified nutrient management included the addition of
25% of the crop’s nitrogen requirement through organic manure while providing 75% of the
nitrogen requirement through inorganic fertilizer. During the periods of heavy rainfall,
mancozeb (80% W.P.) and mancozeb with metalaxyl (80% W.P.) were applied to T1 and T2
treatments at 4-day intervals. When late blight disease incidence was severe, above
mentioned agrochemicals were applied weekly to T3 and T4 treatments as well.
557
Abhayapala et al.
Daily meteorological data (i.e. rainfall, sunshine duration, maximum and minimum air
temperatures, relative humidity and average wind speed) were recorded in meteorological
stations located at the experimental sites for the duration of the experiment. Soil chemical
properties were determined for soil samples obtained at 0-30 cm depth before crop
establishment. Soil pH and EC were tested by the simple immersing electrode method. Total
soil nitrogen, organic carbon, exchangeable potassium and available phosphorus were
respectively measured using the Modified Kjeldahl method, the Walkley and Black method,
the flame photometer method and the Olsen’s method (Van Ranst et al., 1999). The number
of days to harvest was recorded. Crop biomass and its partitioning to leaves, stems, roots and
tubers were measured by destructive sampling at 50% canopy closure using one plant per
plot. Leaf area was measured using an automatic leaf area meter (AAM9, Hayashi Denko
Co. Ltd, Tokyo) and dry weights were obtained by oven-drying at 60 oC to a constant weight.
The tubers were harvested at 80% leaf senescence. A sample of 10 plants per plot was used
to measure the number of tubers per plant and tuber fresh weight.
Incidence and severity of late blight and incidence of bacterial wilt were quantified at
different stages of the crop growth, namely, the initial (14 and 21 days after planting), crop
development (28 and 35 days after planting), mid-season (42 and 56 days after planting) and
late season (63 and 70 days after planting) stages. The initial stage corresponded to the stolon
development stage while the crop development stage corresponded to the tuberization stage
while mid- and late season stages corresponded to tuber bulking and maturity stages,
respectively. Incidences of late blight and bacterial wilt were quantified as the percentage of
affected plants in a given plot with respect to the total number of plants in the same plot.
Severity of late blight was calculated as the percentage of leaves showing symptoms in 10
randomly selected plants from each plot.
Cumulative thermal duration from planting to harvesting was calculated by cumulating the
daily mean temperatures of each site separately, assuming a base temperature of 0 oC. Crop
growth rate (CGR) s from planting to 50% canopy closure and harvesting were calculated as
the increase in total crop dry weight per m2 per day over the respective periods. Count data
were analyzed using PROC CATMOD and PROC PROBIT procedures and parametric data
were analyzed using analysis of variance in the General Linear Model (PROC GLM) in SAS.
Statistical significance was tested at α=0.05.
RESULTS
Meteorological and soil conditions at the two experimental sites
There were clear differences between the two sites in terms of meteorological conditions. At
Sita-Eliya daily mean temperature ranged between 12-18 °C whereas the corresponding
range at Rahagala was 16-25 °C (Fig. 1). Accordingly, the seasonal mean temperature was
higher at Rahangala with 20.3±1.4°C as compared to Sita-Eliya (15.1±1.4°C). The respective
total rainfall during the season at Sita-Eliya and Rahangala were 914.1 and 411.9 mm with
56 and 37 rain days, respectively. The major individual rainfall events were heavier at SitaEliya, with the highest being 127 mm day-1 in comparison to the highest of 65 mm day-1 at
Rahangala. Soil characteristics of the two sites were also differed appreciably with the SitaEliya soil having a lower pH but a higher EC and greater nutrient and organic matter
contents than at Rahangala (Table 2).
558
Response of potato to increasing growing season temperature
Crop phenology
The duration from planting to final harvest (at 80% leaf senescence) was similar among
treatments in a given site while it differed significantly (p<0.05) between the two sites with
111 and 82 days for Sita-Eliya and Rahangala, respectively. Earlier maturity of potato at
Rahangala was primarily due to its higher temperature, which has been found to be a major
factor regulating crop phenology, biomass accumulation and tuber development in potato
(Bodlaender, 1963; Gregory, 1965; Wheeler et al., 1986; Woff et al., 1990). Interestingly,
despite the substantial difference in the total crop duration between the two sites, the
cumulative thermal time from planting to maturity was approximately similar with 1689 oCd
and 1662 oCd at Sita-Eliya and Rahangala respectively. This showed that temperature was
the primary factor that was controlling the duration of potato crop between the two sites.
Growth parameters
There was a highly significant (p=0.001) treatment (site) effect on LAI at 50% canopy
closure. When the variation of LAI at the two sites were analyzed separately, both sites
showed significant (p<0.05) inter-treatment variation (Fig. 2). At Rahangala, T1 and T2
showed significantly greater LAI than T3 and T4. On the other hand, at Sita-Eliya, T1 and T4
had significantly greater LAI than T2 and T3. T1, which was the control treatment managed
with the current recommended crop management, showed similar LAIs at 50% canopy
closure at both sites. However, there was significant (p<0.05) difference between-site
variation for LAI of T2, T3 and T4. In T2, Rahangala had a greater LAI whereas in T3 and T4,
Sita- Eliya had greater LAI. Severe incidence of late blight (reported elsewhere in this
paper), which had managed with IPM, was a major contributory factor for the substantially
low LAI resulted in T3 and T4 at Rahangala.
25
140
120
25
140
)
C
20
e
r
tu
a
r
e 15
p
m
e
T
n 10
a
e
M
iy 5
a
D
120
o(
20
)
C
o(
re
tu 15
ra
e
p
m
e
T
n
a
e 10
M
iy
a
D
100
80
60
)
m
(m
ll
a
f
n
i
a
R
y
il
a
D
40
5
100
80
60
40
20
20
0
0
0
0
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
80
Days after Planting
Days after Planting
Fig. 1. Seasonal variation of daily mean temperature (curve) and daily rainfall (bars)
at Rahangala (top) and Sita-Eliya (bottom)
559
)
m
(m
ll
a
f
n
i
a
R
y
il
a
D
Abhayapala et al.
Table 2. Initial soil characteristics of the two experimental sites
Site
pH
EC
(µS m-1)
Total N
(mg N g-1
soil)
Exchangeable
K+(mg K kg-1
soil)
Available
Phosphorus
(µg P g-1 soil)
Organic
matter
(%)
Sita-Eliya
Rahangala
5.99a
6.19a
230.5a
102.3b
2.7a
0.8b
30.8a
16.1a
138.4a
42.9b
5.8a
3.5a
Along each column, means with the same letter are not significantly different at p=0.05.
Fig. 2. Variation of LAI of potato at 50% canopy closure in T1-T4 at the two locations:
SE–Sita-Eliya; RG–Rahangala. T1–Recommended nutrient management and
crop protection (Control); T2 – Recommended nutrient management and crop
protection + Mulching at 8 t ha-1; T3–Recommended nutrient management +
Mulching + IPM; T4–Mulching + IPM + 25 % N requirement supplied by
organic manure. Error bars indicate standard errors of mean.
The treatment (site) effect was not significant (p=0.05) for total dry weight (TDW) at 50%
canopy closure, but was highly significant (p=0.0003) for total biomass at final harvest
(Table 3). When the TDW at the two sites was analyzed separately, TDW at the final harvest
showed significant inter-treatment differences at both sites. In contrast, TDW at 50% canopy
closure did not show significant treatment variations at either of the two sites. At Sita-Eliya,
T1 showed a significantly greater TDW at final harvest than the other three treatments, which
did not differ significantly among themselves (Table 3). On the other hand, at Rahangala,
both T1 and T2 showed significantly greater TDW at harvest than T3 and T4.
560
Response of potato to increasing growing season temperature
Table 3. Variation of total crop dry weight and crop growth rate of potato at 50%
canopy closure (50% CC) and final harvest in T1-T4 at the two experimental
sites
Total Dry Weight (g plant-1)
Rahangala
Sita-Eliya
50%
Final
50%
Final
CC
Harvest
CC
Harvest
Crop Growth Rate (g m-2 d-1)
Rahangala
Sita-Eliya
TreatUp to
Total
Up to
Total
ment
50% duration 50% duration
CC
CC
T1
60.9 a 118.6 a
68.1 a 119.1 a
5.89 a 9.76 a
5.89 a 7.15 a
T2
75.7 a 104.4 a
42.6 a 43.4 b
7.32 a 8.59 a
3.69 a 2.60 b
a
b
a
b
a
b
41.2
48.7
61.8
70.4
3.98
4.01
5.35 a 4.23 b
T3
a
b
a
b
a
b
42.2
15.3
47.7
55.6
4.07
1.26
4.13 a 3.34 b
T4
Along each column, means with the same letter are not significantly different at p=0.05.
Within a given treatment, the variation of TDW at 50% canopy closure between the two sites
was broadly similar (Table 3) to that of LAI at 50% cc (Figure 2). While T1 did not differ
between the two sites, there was a significant variation between the two sites for T2, T3 and
T4. Rahangala had shown significantly greater TDW in T2 whereas Sita-Eliya had
significantly greater TDW in T3 and T4. Despite, the substantial difference between the total
crop durations of the two sites, their TDW at final harvest of the T1 treatment were similar
(Table 3). Between-site variations of TDW at final harvest in the rest of the treatments were
similar to those of TDW and LAI at 50% canopy closure.
Crop growth rates (CGR) of T1 up to 50% canopy closure were similar in both sites (Table
3). However, over the entire crop duration, CGR of T1 was higher at Rahangala than at SitaEliya. Over both durations, CGR of T2 was higher at Rahangala. In contrast, the CGR of T3
was higher in Sita-Eliya over both durations. While the CGR of T4 up to 50% cc was similar
between the two sites, over the entire crop duration, Sita-Eliya had a higher CGR. Higher
incidence and severity of late blight (reported elsewhere in this paper) contributed to the
lower CGRs of T3 and T4 at Rahangala.
Yield parameters
There was a highly-significant (p=0.0039) interaction between locations and treatments with
respect to final tuber yield. When the yields of the two locations were analyzed separately,
in Sita-Eliya, there was no significant variation in yield among the four treatments (Fig. 3).
In contrast, at Rahangala, T1 and T2 had significantly greater yields than T3 and T4. The
mean number of tubers per plant (MNTP) did not differ significantly at either of the two sites
(Table 4). In contrast, the mean individual tuber weight (MITW) showed a highly significant
(p<0.0001) inter-treatment variation at Rahangala, but not at Sita-Eliya (Table 4). At
Rahangala, T2 showed the highest MITW followed by T1 while both T3 and T4 had
significantly lower MITW than T2 and T1. Both yield components showed highly significant
(p<0.0001) positive correlations with tuber yield with linear correlation coefficients (r) of
0.761 and 0.841 for MNTP and MITW, respectively. However, there was no significant
correlation between MNTP and MITW. The harvest index did not show significant variation
among treatments or sites either at the mid-harvest stage (data not shown) or the final harvest
stage (Table 4). The tuber yields of T1 and T2 did not differ significantly between the two
sites. In contrast, yields of T3 and T4 at Sita-Eliya were significantly greater than those at
561
Abhayapala et al.
Rahangala. The substantially greater incidence and severity of late blight (reported elsewhere
in this paper) contributed to the lower yields of T3 and T4 at Rahangala.
Table 4. Variation of yield components and harvest index at final harvest of potato in
T1-T4 at the two experimental sites
Mean number of
Mean individual tuber
Harvest Index (%)
tubers per plant
fresh weight (g)
SE
RG
SE
RG
SE
RG
T1
5.7 a
6.3 a
71.71 a
67.93 b
88.70 a
85.93 a
T2
5.7 a
5.8 a
78.76 a
77.15 a
83.53 a
88.09 a
a
a
a
c
a
4.5
4.1
82.77
46.68
88.05
86.98 a
T3
a
a
a
c
a
T4
5.0
4.8
70.14
42.22
83.82
76.20 a
Along each column, means with the same letter are not significantly different at p=0.05.
Treatment
35
-1
Tuber Yield (t ha )
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
T1
T2
T3
T4
SE
T1
T2
T3
T4
RG
Fig. 3. Variation of tuber yield of potato in T1-T4 at the two experimental sites.
Error bars indicate standard errors of mean.
Relationships between yield and growth parameters
When the data of both sites were pooled, tuber yield showed significant (p<0.05) positive
correlations with LAI at 50% canopy closure (r = 0.405 at p = 0.049) and TDW at final
harvest (r = 0.499 at p = 0.013). Furthermore, there was a highly significant positive
correlation between the number of tubers per plant and TDW at final harvest (r = 0.533 at p
= 0.0073). On the other hand, the MITW showed a significant positive correlation with the
LAI at 50% canopy closure (r = 0.398 at p = 0.054). Among the growth parameters, there
was a significant positive correlation between TDW and LAI at 50% canopy closure (r =
0.409 at p = 0.048). Moreover, the TDW at final harvest showed significant positive
562
Response of potato to increasing growing season temperature
correlations with LAI (r = 0.438 at p = 0.032) and TDW (r = 0.720 at p<0.0001) at 50%
canopy closure.
Disease incidence and severity
Incidence of both late blight and bacterial wilt was either zero or very low at the initial and
crop development stages (Fig. 4). However, the incidence of late blight increased
substantially in the treatments with IPM (i.e. T3 and T4) at Rahangala from mid-season
onwards. In contrast, with conventional non-IPM crop protection practices, which were
mainly based on chemical applications (i.e. T1 and T2), late blight incidence was less than
8% at Rahangala even during the mid- and late season. In contrast to Rahangala, at SitaEliya, the IPM treatment was able to maintain late blight incidence below 30% even at midseason. Interestingly, at Sita-Eliya, the IPM treatments were as effective as the conventional
non-IPM treatments in controlling the incidence of late blight. It is notable that the IPM
package at Sita-Eliya was able to achieve a reduction in late blight incidence during late
season when it was increasing in all other treatments. In comparison to late blight, the
incidence of bacterial wilt was very low at both sites in both IPM and non-IPM treatments.
However, similar to the corresponding observations on the incidence of late blight, the
incidence of bacterial wilt was higher in crops under IPM at Rahangala. On the other hand,
the opposite was true at Sita-Eliya with the crops under IPM showing a lower incidence of
bacterial with in comparison to those without IPM.
The severity of late blight at Rahangala was substantially higher in the IPM treatment as
compared to the non-IPM treatment (Fig. 4). At Sita-Eliya also the severity of late blight
was higher in the IPM treatment from the initial stage up to the mid-season stage. However,
the IPM treatment was able to reduce the severity of late blight during late season.
Therefore, during late season, the severity of late blight was lower in the IPM treatment in
comparison to the non-IPM treatment. In general, within a given crop protection practice,
the incidence of both late blight and bacterial wilt and the severity of late blight were higher
at Rahangala than at Sita-Eliya (Fig. 4).
563
Abhayapala et al.
1.2
Bacterial Wilt Incidence (%)
Late Blight Incidence (%)
100
80
60
40
20
0
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
Initial
Crop
Dev.
Mid.
Sea.
Late
Sea.
Initial
Crop
Dev.
Mid.
Sea.
Non-IPM (RG)
IPM (RG)
Non-IPM (RG)
IPM (RG)
Non-IPM (SE)
IPM (SE)
Non-IPM (SE)
IPM (SE)
Late
Sea.
Late Blight Severity (%)
100
80
60
40
20
0
Initial
Crop
Dev.
Mid.
Sea.
Non-IPM (RG)
IPM (RG)
Non-IPM (SE)
IPM (SE)
Late
Sea.
Figure 4. Variation of disease incidence of late blight and bacterial wilt and severity of
late blight in potato grown in Rahangala (RG) and Sita-Eliya (SE) using
conventional crop protection (Non-IPM) and Integrated Pest Management
(IPM) at different stages of the crops. Crop Dev. – Crop development stage;
Mid. Sea. – Mid-season; Late Sea. – Late season.
564
Response of potato to increasing growing season temperature
DISCUSSION
Response of potato crops to increasing temperature
In the present study, potato crops were grown at two sites which had a mean seasonal
temperature difference of 5.2 oC from the lower temperature site Sita-Eliya (15.1 oC) to the
relatively higher-temperature site Rahangala (20.3 oC). Even though there was a seasonal
rainfall difference of 502.2 mm, supplementary irrigation ensured that the crops were grown
without any limitation of water. Therefore, the observed variation of phenology, growth and
yield of potato crops between the two sites primarily represented the response of these
processes to temperature.
Within the treatment structure of the experiment, between-site variation of the control
treatment (i.e. T1) can be taken as the specific response of potato to a temperature increase in
the range from 15o to 20 oC. Overall growth (Fig. 2 and Table 3) and yield (Fig. 3 and Table
4) performance of T1 shows that both growth and yield of potato remained approximately
constant across the above temperature range despite it representing a substantial increase in
growing temperature. This indicates that the temperature range from 15o to 20 oC is within
the optimum range for potato, which is supported by several previous findings available in
literature. For example, Timlin et al. (2006) found the highest total biomass at harvest at 20
o
C in a controlled environmental chamber experiment which tested six growing constant
temperatures ranging from 12o to 32oC. Sattelmacher et al. (1990) also found that the
optimum temperature for root growth of potato was around 20 oC. Fleisher et al. (2006)
showed that leaf area per plant was maximum within the temperature range from 16.6o to
22.1 oC, again indicating the temperature optimum to be within this range. Furthermore,
Fleisher et al. (2006) have shown that canopy photosynthetic rate of potato decreased at
temperatures above 20 oC. Hammes & De Jager (1990) also showed a similar optimum
temperature for net photosynthetic rate. However, results of the present experiment on the
phenology and supporting growth measurements show that the stability of growth and yield
within the tested temperature range have been achieved by the interplay of several processes
which do respond significantly to the 5 oC temperature increase that was experienced by the
potato crops of the present study.
The substantial temperature difference between the two sites caused a significant difference
in phenological development of the crop at the higher-temperature site Rahangala completing
its life cycle a month earlier by fulfilling the thermal time requirement. This agreed with the
findings of Kooman et al. (1996) who showed that the length of the crop development phase
from emergence to tuber initiation decreased with increasing temperature within the range
from 14o to 22 oC, which included the range of the present experiment (i.e. 15o – 20 oC). On
the other hand, the higher temperature enabled the potato crops at Rahangala to achieve
higher crop growth rates (CGRs) than at Sita-Eliya (Table 3). However, total dry weights at
final harvest of the control treatments of both sites were similar because the lower CGR at
Sita-Eliya was compensated by the longer crop duration. In contrast, despite the higher CGR,
the higher temperature at Rahangala accelerated the phenological development of the crop
and reduced the duration of the crop. The above-described influence of temperature on the
interaction between CGR and phenological development is a major process in the physiology
of yield determination of potato as tuber yield was significantly positively correlated with
total dry weight at final harvest. It would be interesting to investigate the response of these
processes at temperatures which are higher than 20 oC.
565
Abhayapala et al.
Effectiveness of the tested IPM package
Results of the present study clearly showed that the tested IPM package was as effective as
the non-IPM package in controlling late blight at Sita-Eliya, it was not effective at
Rahangala. This was evidenced by the substantially greater incidence and severity of late
blight in the IPM treatments as compared to non-IPM treatments at Rahangala (Fig. 4).
Schumann and Arcy (2000) have shown that the optimum temperature for spore formation of
Phytopthera infestans, the late blight-causing fungi, ranges from 18o to 22 oC. Fig. 1 shows
that the seasonal variation of temperature at Rahangala has been largely confined within the
above range of temperatures, thus providing ideal conditions for development of late blight.
In contrast, the seasonal variation of temperature at Sita-Eliya has largely been below 15 oC,
which is sub-optimal for spore formation of the late blight pathogen. Hence, the IPM
package tested in the present study has to be improved to withstand the stronger inoculum
pool that would be present in the temperature regime prevailing at Rahangala. On the other
hand, even the present IPM package can be used to reduce the application of chemical
fungicides in potato cultivation without suffering a significant reduction in tuber yield in
areas where the growing season temperatures are sub-optimal for disease development (i.e. <
16 – 18 oC).
Effectiveness of mulching
The T2 treatment of the present study included mulching in combination with non-IPM-based
crop protection. In contrast, in the T3 treatment mulching was combined with IPM. The
results clearly showed that when practiced with non-IPM mulching was effective in
promoting growth and yield formation at Rahangala so that LAI, total dry weights and yields
of T2 were on par with those of T1 (Tables 3 & 4 and Figures 2 & 3). The greater response to
mulching at Rahangala may be due to two possible reasons. As Rahangala had a substantially
lower rainfall with a lower number of rain days in comparison to Sita-Eliya (Fig. 1),
mulching probably contributed to improved soil moisture conservation in between
irrigations. Secondly, the poorer soil conditions at Rahangala (Table 2) may have shown a
greater response to the additional input of nutrients from the mulch. The growth
performance of potato crops (in terms of LAI and TDW) under the T2 treatment at Sita-Eliya
was inferior to the rest of the treatments at the same site (Fig. 2 and Table 3). However, in
terms of yield and yield components (Fig. 3 and Table 4), performance of the T2 at Sita-Eliya
was on par with the rest of the treatments. It is possible that the lower temperatures at SitaEliya slowed down the decomposition and release of nutrients from the mulch so that its
beneficial effects were on the processes that were taking place during second half of the life
cycle of the potato crop (i.e. tuber initiation and tuber bulking).
Effectiveness of modified nutrient management
The T4 treatment of the present study tested the possibility of reducing the application of
inorganic nitrogen fertilizer by applying 25% of the crop’s N requirement through organic
amendments. As the T4 treatment was combined with the IPM package, assessment of the
effect of modified nutrient management has to be done by comparing the performance of T4
with that of T3 in which 100% inorganic N fertilization was combined with IPM. With the
exception LAI at 50% canopy closure at Sita-Eliya, there was no significant difference in
growth and yield performance of potato crops under T4 and T3 treatments at both sites. This
means that it is possible to reduce the use of inorganic fertilizer, specifically N in the present
situation, and provide part of the nutrient requirement through organic amendments without
suffering a significant yield reduction. Furthermore, it is notable that T4 showed a
566
Response of potato to increasing growing season temperature
significantly greater LAI at 50% canopy closure than the corresponding T3 at Sita-Eliya (Fig.
2), thus showing the superiority of the modified nutrient management over the conventional
(i.e.100% inorganic N). Therefore, the option of increasing the fraction of the N requirement
that could be replaced by organic amendments should be explored in future research.
Physiology of yield determination of potato
In addition to providing answers to the three principal research questions that were stated as
specific objectives of the present study, its results provided insights in to the processes
governing the physiology of yield determination of potato within the temperature range
tested. The significant positive correlations between tuber yield and the two yield
components (i.e. mean number of tubers per plant, MNTP, and mean individual tuber weight,
MITW) show that potato yields can be increased by increasing either of the two yield
components or both. The absence of a significant correlation between the two yield
components indicates that they are determined independently and that increasing one yield
component would not decrease the other. The significant positive correlations that the LAI at
50% canopy closure showed with tuber yield and MITW indicate that potato yields in the
present study are primarily source-limited. The significant positive correlation between
MNTP and yield may appear to indicate that yields of the present study are sink-limited as
well. However, it is highly likely that this apparent sink limitation is a secondary effect as
MNTP is positively correlated to TDW at final harvest, which in turn is positively correlated
to LAI at 50% canopy closure.
CONCLUSIONS
The principal conclusions from the present study can be summarized as: (a) Potato yields did
not decrease significantly when seasonal mean temperature in the up-country of Sri Lanka
increased from 15o to 20 oC; (b) Faster phenological development and shorter life cycle
duration of the crop at the higher temperature is compensated by higher crop growth rates,
thus stabilizing the tuber yield across the tested temperature range; (c) The specific IPM
package tested in the present study was effective in controlling the incidence and severity of
late blight at temperatures which are sub-optimal for spore formation of the pathogen.
However, the tested IPM package could not control the disease at temperatures which are
optimum for sporulation; (d) It is possible to reduce the use of inorganic N fertilizer in potato
cultivation in the up-country by replacing 25% of the crop’s N requirement by organic
amendments without a significant reduction in tuber yield; (e) The beneficial effects of
mulching on growth and yield of potato are more pronounced at sites in the higher end of the
temperature range tested in the present study (i.e. ca. 20 oC). The lower rainfall and poorer
soil conditions of these sites also contribute to the pronounced response to mulching; (f)
Potato yields in the up-country of Sri Lanka are source-limited.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This project is being funded by the Higher Education for Twenty First Century (HETC)
Quality and Innovation Grants Window 3 (QIG-3) project of the Ministry of Higher
Education, Sri Lanka. Part of the meteorological data was provided by the Department of
Agriculture, Sri Lanka.
567
Abhayapala et al.
REFERENCES
Anonymous. (2010). Annual Report. Department of Census and Statistics, Colombo.
Anonymous (1990). Crop Recommendations Technoguide. Department of Agriculture. Sri
Lanka.
Bodlaender, K.B.A. (1963). Influence of temperature, radiation and photoperiod on
development and yield. pp. 199–210. In: J.D. Ivins and F.L. Milthorpe (Eds). The Growth of
the Potato. Butterworths, U.K.
De Silva, G.G.R., Dassanayake, A.R. and Mapa, R.B. (2005). Soils of the mid country
intermediate zone. pp. 121-125. In: Mapa, R. B., Dassanayake, A.R. and Nayakekorale, H.
B. (Eds.). Soil of the Intermediate Zone of Sri Lanka. Morphology, Characterization and
Classification. Special Publication No. 4. Soil Science Society of Sri Lanka.
Dissanayake, A.R. and Hettiarachchi, L.S.K. (1999). Soils of the up country wet zone. pp.
122-136. In: Mapa, R.B., Somasiri, S. and Nagarajah, S. (Eds.). Soils of the Wet Zone of Sri
Lanka. Morphology, Characterization and Classification. Special Publication No.1. Soil
Science Society of Sri Lanka.
Fleisher, D., Timlin, D.J. and Reddy, V.R. (2006). Temperature influence on potato leaf and
branch distribution and on canopy photosynthetic rate. Agron. J. 98, 1442 - 1452.
Gregory, L.E. (1965). Physiology of tuberization in plants. Encyclopaedia Plant Physiol. 15,
1328 - 1354.
Hammes, P.S. and De Jager, J.A. (1990). Net photosynthetic rate of potato at high
temperatures. Potato Res. 33, 515 - 520.
Hijmans, R.J. (2003). The effect of climate change on global potato production. American J.
Potato Res. 80, 271 - 280.
IPCC, (2007). Climate Change 2007: Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability. In:
Contribution of Working Group II to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental
Panel on Climate Change. Parry, M.L., Canziani, O.F., Palutikof, J.P., van der Linden, P.J. &
Hanson, C.E. (Eds.), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.
IPCC, (2001). Climate Change, 2001. Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability: In:
Contribution of Working Group II to the Third Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental
Panel on Climate Change, Cambridge University Press.
Khan, M.A. and Khan, S.L. (2010). Potential markets of potato: Report of the Trade
Development Authority of Pakistan.
Kooman, P.L., Haverkort, A.J., Kooman, P.L., Fahem, M. and Tegera, P. (1996). Effects of
climate on different potato genotypes: II. Dry matter allocation and duration of the growth
cycle. European J. Agron. 5, 207 - 217.
Nugaliyadda, M.M. (2011). Cultivation of Potato. Govi Janatha Bulletin. pp. 3-5.
568
Response of potato to increasing growing season temperature
Pandey, S.K. (2008). Potato Research Priorities in Asia and the Pacific Region. [Online].
[Accessed on 28th August 2013]. Available at www.fao.org/docrep/010/io 200e/ IO
200E08.html.
Punyawardana, B.V.R. (2008). Evolution of climatic zoning in Sri Lanka. In:
Agroclimatological Zones and Rainfall Pattern in Sri Lanka (in Sinhala medium). Published
by Department of Agriculture, Sri Lanka. pp. 44-113 (ISBN 978-955-9282-19-8).
Robertson, G.P. and Vitousek, P.M. (2009). Nitrogen in Agriculture: Balancing the cost of
an essential resource. Ann. Rev. Environ. Resour. 34, 97 - 125.
Sattelmacher, B., Marschner, H. and Kühne, P. (1990). Effects of the temperature of the
rooting zone on the growth and development of roots of potato (Solanum tuberosum). Ann.
Bot. 65, 27 - 36.
Schumann, G.L. and Arcy C.J.D. (2000). Late blight of potato and tomato. The Plant Health
Instructor. DOI: 10.1094/PHI-I-2000-0724-01 .Updated 2005.
Suriyagoda, L.D.B., Ranil, R.H.G., Dissanayaka, D.M.S.B., Weerakkody, W.A.P (2012).
The sustainability of intensive vegetable farming systems in Sri Lanka. ISHS: Chronica
Horticulturae. 52, 14 - 17.
Timlin, D., Lutfor Rahman, S.M., Baker, J., Reddy, V.R., Fleisher, D. and Quebedeaux, B.
(2006). Whole plant photosynthesis, development and carbon partitioning of potato as a
function of temperature. Agron. J. 98, 1195 - 1203.
Van Ranset, E., Veloo, M., Dameyer, A. and Pauwels, M. (1999). Manual for the Soil
Chemistry and Fertility Laboratory-Analytical Methods for Soils and Plants, Equipment, and
Management of Consumables. NUGI 835, Ghent, Belgium (ISBN 90-76603 - 01-4).
Watawala, R.C., Liyanage, J.A. and Mallawatantri, A. (2009). Assessment of risk to water
bodies due to residues of agricultural fungicide in intensive farming areas in the up country
of Sri Lanka using an indicator model. Proceedings of the National Conference of Water,
Food Security and Climate Change in Sri Lanka. Water Quality, Environment and Climate
Change.9-11 June 2009, Colombo, 2, 69 - 75. (ISBN 978-92-9090-722-0).
Wheeler, R.M., Steffen, K.L., Tibbitts, T.W. and Palta, J.P. (1986). Utilization of potatoes
for life support systems. II. The effects of temperature under 24-h and 12-h photoperiods.
American Potato J. 63, 639 - 647.
Wijewardena, J.D.H. (1996). Fertilizer management under intensive cropping systems in Sri
Lanka. Proceedings of the Regional Workshop on Fertilizer Concepts with Special Reference
to Organic Fertilizers. 6-9 May 1996, Tagaytay, Philippines.
Wijewardena, J.D.H. (2001). Fertilizer and soil amendments use on potato in relation to soil
fertility in rice based cropping systems of up-country of Sri Lanka. Annals of the Sri Lanka
Department of Agriculture 3, 353 - 363.
Woff, S., Marani, A. and Rudich, J. (1990). Effects of temperature and photoperiod on
assimilate partitioning in potato plants. Ann Bot. 66, 513 - 520.
569