Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
BRAZILIAN JOURNAL OF ECOLOGY
REVISTA BRASILEIRA DE ECOLOGIA
Publication of the Ecology Society of Brazil
Editores: Dra Edisa F. I. Nascimento
Dra Carla Soraia Soares de Castro
ASSESSOR BOARD
Antonio Domingos Brescovit
Bruno Pastrelli Kamada
Cássia Beatriz R. Munhoz
Claudio de Moura
Cristiane Elizabeth Macedo
Elaine Folly
Evelise Márcia Locatelli
Fabrício Carvalho
Flávia Souza Rocha
Francisco Eduardo Silva Pinto Vilela
Frederico Alexandre Roccia Dal Pozzo Arzolla
Geraldo Ceni Coelho
Gláucia Cortez Ramos de Paula
Helena França
Ingo Isernhagen
Jairo José Zocche
Josué Raizer
Marcelo Dutra da Silva
Márcio Seiji Suganuma
Maria Iracema Bezerra Loiola
Maria Santina de Castro Morini
Marina Janzantti Lapenta
Milton Cezar Ribeiro
Natalia Ghilardi Lopes
Ricardo Augusto Lombello
Vladimir Stolzenberg Torres
Yumi Oki
Zelma Glebya Maciel Quirino
Mailing Adress
Departamento de Ecologia
Rua do Matão, Travessa 14 no. 321. CEP.: 05508-900.
Cidade Universitária – São Paulo, SP.
Phone: (11) 3091 7600
e-mail: contato@seb-ecologia.org.br
site: www.seb-ecologia.org.br
1
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 1
09/10/2012 13:43:51
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
FICHA CATOLOGRÁFICA
Brazilian Journal of Ecology
Revista Brasileira de Ecologia
Vol. 01 Ano 14 – 2012
São Paulo, SP. Ecology Society of Brazil
(Sociedade de Ecologia do Brasil).
V/:il; 27cm
Anual
2010 – 2012, 1
II. Ecologia I. Sociedade de Ecologia do Brasil
2
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 2
09/10/2012 13:43:51
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
BRAZILIAN JOURNAL OF ECOLOGY
A publication on the
ECOLOGY SOCIETY OF BRAZIL
SOCIEDADE DE ECOLOGIA DO BRASIL
BOARD
PRESIDENT
Dra Edisa Ferreira Inocêncio Nascimento - IB/USP,
VICE PRESIDENT
Dr. Welington Braz Carvalho Delitti - IB/USP
1st SECRETARY
Dr.Wladimir Stolzenberg Torres - SMPA
2st SECRETARY
Dr. Júlio Cesar Voltolini – UNITAU
1ST TREASURER
Dra. Tatiana Pavão -CUSC
2ST TREASURER
Dra. Karla Conceição Pereira - APTA/SP
3
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 3
09/10/2012 13:43:51
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
CONSELHO FISCAL
Dra. Marisa Domingos, Brasileira IBt/SP
Dr. Marcelo Dutra da Silva – FURG
Dr. Demétrio Luis Guadagini - FSM
Dra. Ana Tereza Araujo Rodarte – UFS
Dra. Regina Celi Costa Luizão - INPA
CONSELHO CONSULTIVO
Dra. Carla Soraia Soares de Castro – UFPB
Dr. Frederico de Siqueira Neves – UFMG
Dr. José Luiz Campana Camargo – INPA
Dra. Marisa Dantas Bittencourt IB/USP
Dr. Geraldo Ceni Coelho – UFFS
Dr. Philip Martin Fearnside - INPA
Sociedade de Ecologia do Brasil
Departamento de Ecologia - Instituto de Biociências
Universidade de São Paulo
Rua do Matão Travessa 14 no. 321. CEP 05508-900
Phone: (11) 3091-7600 – Cidade Universitária
e-mail: contato@seb-ecologia.org.br
site: www.seb-ecologia.org.br
4
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 4
09/10/2012 13:43:51
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
RAZILIAN JOURNAL OF ECOLOGY
REVISTA BRASILEIRA DE ECOLOGIA
Volune 1 – Ano 14 - 2012
5
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 5
09/10/2012 13:43:51
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
6
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 6
09/10/2012 13:43:52
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Evaluation of aboveground growth and biomass in Glicine
max plants exposed to various concentrations of copper
*Karina Gonçalves – Undergraduate student of the Faculty of Biology, Directorate of Health, University
Nove de Julho (email: kazinhavgt@yahoo.com.br)
Marli Sá Torres- Undergaduate student of the Faculty of Biology, Directorate of Health, University Nove
de Julho (email: satorpp@ig.com.br )
Patrícia Marinho – Undergaduate student of the Faculty of Biology, Directorate of Health, University Nove
de Julho (email: patinalda@hotmail.com)
Juliana de Mello Botelho – Undergraduate student of the Faculty of Biology, Directorate of Health,
University Nove de Julho (email: ju_melbo@hotmail.com)
Armando Reis Tavares – Researcher of the Nucleus of Research on Ornamental Plants of the Botanical
Institute of São Paulo (email: atavares2005@yahoo.com.br)
Shoey Kanashiro – Researcher of the Nucleus of Research on Ornamental Plants of the Botanical
Institute of São Paulo (email: skanashi@uol.com.br)
Ana Paula N. Lamano Ferreira – Professor Doctor in Ecology of the Faculty of Biology, Directorate
of Health, University ‘Nove de Julho’ (email: apbnasci@yahoo.com.br)
Luis Alberto Valotta - Professor Doctor of the Faculty of Biology, Directorate of Health, University
‘Nove de Julho’ (email: lavalotta@yahoo.com)
Cleber da Silva Costa – Full Professor of the Faculty of Biology, Directorate of Health, University
‘Nove de Julho’ (email: costacs@uninove.br)
Rafael Souza Queiroz – Full Professor of the Faculty of Biology, Directorate of Health, University
‘Nove de Julho’ (email: rs.queiroz@gmail.com)
Hilton Lourenço Ozório Filho - Full Professor of the Faculty of Biology, Directorate of Health, University
‘Nove de Julho’ (email: ozoriofi@uninove.br)
Maurício Lamano Ferreira – Doctorate student in Ecology in the Center of Nuclear Energy in Agriculture of the Unversity of São Paulo (CENA/USP) and Professor of the Faculty of Biology, Directorate of
Health, University ‘Nove de Julho’ (email: mauecologia@yahoo.com.br)
ABSTRACT
Soybean (Glycine max) represents a plant-species of considerable economical
importance for Brazil, considered one of the main producers worldwide. The aim here
was to analyze the influence of copper on the development of the plant’s aboveground
growth and biomass. With this in mind, an experiment was developed under natural
conditions of humidity and temperature using 112 plants cultivated in vases with sand.
The randomized block design was adopted, with each containing four blocks, seven
treatments and four repetitions, all irrigated for 30 days with a solution of Hoagland &
Arnon, enriched with various concentrations of CuCl2. Subsequent variance analysis
and Tukey testing showed that plants undergoing treatment with 0,9 g CuCl2 L-1 (T6)
7
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 7
09/10/2012 13:43:52
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
were those that presented the least growth in relation to both control plants and those
under lower-grade treatments. The values of stem-dry-mass were equivalent to the tendencies encountered in biometrics, whereby the conclusion that copper at high concentrations can exert an influence on growth in Glycine max plants.
Keywords: Soybean, plant biometrics, aerial organs, copper
INTRODUCTION
In general, micronutrients, even though
required in reduced amounts, are essential for
completion of the plant vegetative cycle. Their deficiency, besides inducing reduced productivity
and alterations in the defense system, may even
interfere in phenology (7). Among such nutrients,
copper is outstanding by being an important cofactor in anti-oxidizing enzymes, as, for example,
the activator of some of the enzymes involved in
oxidation and reduction, besides participating in
the opening and closing of stomata and lignification in some cells (3). Through its involvement in
several physiological and structural aspects in plant
development, copper, in certain concentrations, can
serve as manure, the lack thereof possibly giving
rise to damage to the plant in various forms. Some
of the main symptoms of copper deficiency can be
observed in young leaves, which, besides very often presenting necrotic patches, become dark green
in color, rolled up and deformed. Worthy of note,
copper deficient plants can manifest lower protein
synthesis and diminished photosynthetic activity,
through this nutrient being an activator of those
enzymes which participate in terminal electronic
transport in respiration and photosynthesis. These
symptoms of deficiency occur in newer tissues, due
to their lower mobility in the plant (18). A good example is a study by Zampieri (2010), comprising an
analysis of the effects of copper and zinc on Aechmea blanchetiana (Baker) L.B. Smith, whereby it
was demonstrated that seedlings cultivated under
high concentrations of Cu++ were those that presented the highest structural variation in morphometric and anatomic parameters. In studies by Silva
et al. (2010) on the tolerance of certain Cassia species (Peltophorum dubium) seedlings in soils with
an excess of copper, it was observed that, inversely
to the increase in dose, there was a decrease in plant
biometric parameters, such as height and diameter.
Only required in small amounts in cultures,
copper is one of the ultimate nutrients whereby
symptoms of deficiency develop, when supply does
not attend to plant requirements. Generally occurring at very low rates in the soil, its dynamics is very
much affected by soil characteristics. Thus, besides
pH and humidity, and apart from the plant itself, the
degree of organic material and mineral and biological fractions in the soil, are factors that condition its
availability and utilization by the plant, insofar as
they interfere in the reactions, thereby giving rise to
the formation of products of greater or lesser solubility (3).The normal concentration of this metal in
the soil is 20mg kg-1, with variations to the rate of 6
to 80mg kg-1 (20,11).
Another decisive factor in the activity of
copper is the inner of a soil for the capacity cationic
change (CTC). CTC is intimately linked to both the
concentrations of changeable ions present in the solution of the soil, and the sites of changes on the
colloidal intersurfaces of the system. High CTC
facilitates greater retention of the metal. Organic
material, even though representing only around 5%
of soil components, is responsible for about 30% to
65% of the CTC in mineral soils, and for more than
50% in sandy and organic ones (10, 20).
Besides its natural distribution in the soil,
copper can be further obtained in several other
ways, such as by means of defensive chemicals,
agricultural fertilizers, and more recently, through
the widespread use of domestic and industrial residues. Emphasis must be given to the use of sewage sludge obtained in treatment stations, a mode
which nowadays has been extensively adopted
in several monocultures. Nevertheless, caution
should be taken, for when in large concentrations,
copper can induce toxic effects to plant tissue
8
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 8
09/10/2012 13:43:52
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
and cause a deficiency in other essential nutrients
through adverse interactions (8).
Urban residues, for example, through normally presenting high rates of heavy metals, when
compared to those present in the soil, are liable to
inducing toxicity or altering availability in certain
agroecosystems (13). Furthermore, through possible absorption by plants, there is the possibility of
their entering the food chains (14).
When in excess, the accumulation of copper in different parts of the plant can always be
associated to cellular alteration in various forms,
thereby interfering in physiological processes, to
the point that, the toxicity so caused can eventually
lead to oxidative stress, chlorophyll derangement
and effects on Fe translocation, among others (9).
According to Sfredo (2008), over the latter years, leaf analysis has been applied to evaluating the availability of limitative nutrients for plants,
thereby furnishing a new tool for improving recommendations as regards manure application, as a further means for increasing productivity.
The agricultural use of organic residues is
only plausible, when there are no high inner concentrations of Cd, Pb, Cu, Cr, Ni and Zn, since these
metals are prone to absorption by plant roots, with
the subsequent transference to various organs (3),
and consequently, into foodstuff for human consumption.
For the satisfactory development of a culture of the soybean Glycine max (L.), a grain of
extreme importance in the Brazilian economy, it is
essential that macro- and micronutrients be present
in the appropriate concentrations.
OBJECTIVES
The aim of this study was to analyze the
aboveground growth and biomass of Glycine max
(L.), under different copper treatments and natural
conditions of temperature and humidity.
METHODOLOGY
Study area
The experiment took place in an open area
for experiments of the University ‘Nove de Julho’,
located in metropolitan São Paulo. São Paulo, in
southeast Brazil, is located at around 770 meters
above sea level, within the coordinates 23º30’S and
46º40’W. Characteristically, winters (from June to
August) are dry, and summers (from December to
March) humid.
Plant exposure
During the experiment, the plants were
individually irrigated weekly with 50 ml of a Hoagland & Arnon solution contaminated with 0,0 (T0);
0,000009 (T1); 0,00009 (T2); 0,0009 (T3); 0,009 (T4)
, 0,09 (T5) and 0,9 (T6) g, with CuCl2 L-1 as element
source. Approximately two weeks after germination,
and before exposure to the contaminant, the plants
were initially measured, both for height, starting
from an average height of 10 cm from soil level in the
vase up to the apical bud, as well as for stem diameter. The lot was homogeneous, especially as regards
the required coloring of cotyledonal leaves. The experiments took place from November 6th to December 3rd, 2009. The plants were measured once again
at the end of the experiment, whereat the diameter of
the stem was measured with a common pachymeter,
and height and leaf measurements with a meter tape.
Subsequent to exposure and the collection
of stem and leaf biometric data, the leaf area index
(LAI) were calculated for leaves 1-7 through multiplication of the width by the length, i.e.,.
LAI = WIDTH X LENGTH
After the experimental period, the plants
were collected from the vases and split up by organ,
which were then separately weighed on a digital
balance, to so obtain the weights of fresh-mattermass of the aerial parts and stems. These were then
placed in identified paper bags, and subsequently
dried at 80ºC for 48 hours (12), thereby obtaining
dry-matter-mass values.
Statistical analysis
The process adopted was the statistical
analysis of randomized blocks containing one Glycine max plant per vase with sand, cultivated from
the seedling to the fruit stages. The procedure consisted of seven treatments and four repetitions, with
four plants per treatment, thus 112 plants all told.
The Tukey test was applied to the averages of the results obtained for all the variables in the CuCl2 concentration, using P ≤ 0.05 in the SISVAR program.
9
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 9
09/10/2012 13:43:52
After the experimental period, the plants were collected from the vases and split up by organ, which were then
separately weighed on a digital balance, to so obtain the weights of fresh-matter-mass of the aerial parts and stems.
These were then placed in identified paper bags, and subsequently dried at 80̊-ºC for 48 hours (NAKAZONO et al.,
2001), thereby obtaining dry-matter-mass values.
Brazilian Journal
of Ecology
statistical
analysis ISSN 1516-5868
The process adopted was the statistical analysis of randomized blocks containing one Glycine max plant per
RESULTS
main branch), the lowest LAI values were observed in
T3, and the highest in T1, whereas for the intermedirepetitions, with four plants per treatment, thus 112 plants all told. The Tukey test was applied to the averages of the
ate ones (3, 4 and 5), the tendency for development reRainfall
was
theCuCl
experiment,
results
obtained
forhigh
all thethroughout
variables in the
2 concentration, using P ≤ 0.05 in the SISVAR program.
even more so than that registered in the preceding mained the same until T4. Once again, T6 proved to be
that which presented the lowest development (Table 2).
years. According
RESULTS to data furnished by the Astronomy,
the newest
in years.
this experiGeophysics and
Atmospheric
Sciences
Institute
(IAG),
Rainfall was high throughout the experiment, even more so Amongst
than that registered
in theleaves
preceding
it wasSciences
observed
that,
throughout
the treatfrom University
São
Paulo by
(USP),
the average
dur- andment,
According toofdata
furnished
the Astronomy,
Geophysics
Atmospheric
Institute
(IAG),
from University
ment,
and25%
in the
case
leaf
6, the doses
were insufing theofmonths
of(USP),
studythe
was
around
25%
São Paulo
average
during
thehigher
months than
of study was
around
higher
thanofthat
registered
for the years
ficient to induce statistical differences, whereas for
1993 to 2002
1). 1993 to 2002 (Table 1).
that registered
for (Table
the years
vase with sand, cultivated from the seedling to the fruit stages. The procedure consisted of seven treatments and four
Table 1. Average values of temperature (°C) and relative humidity (%) of the air, rainfall (mm), number of days with
rain, irradiation (MJ/m².dia), and wind velocity (m/s) in the city of São Paulo during the period of culture
Month
October
November
December
Temperature (ºC)
19 (24-15)
23 (29-19)
22 (27-18)
Relative humidity (%)
86 (95-67)
80 (95-56)
84 (95-62)
138.0
234.4
208.5
Rainfall (mm)
Number of days with rain (days)
19
21
22
Irradiation (w/m-2)
13.3
17.6
16.4
wind velocity (m/s)
5.9
6.5
5.8
As regards leaf biometrics, over time there was greater differentiation between treatments. Thus, in the case of
leafLAI
7, the
tendency
was similar
that
leaves 1 and
2 (the oldest
leaves
on the
branch),
the lowest
values
were observed
in T3,to
and
thenoted
highestfor
in the
T1,
Although
there
were
no main
statistic
differAlthough there were no statistic differences between treatments, there was an enhanced tendency for growth in
remainder.
In other
words,
T6
was
theT4.
treatment
in
ences stem
between
treatments,
enhanced
whereas
for diameter
the intermediate
4was
andan
5),The
thegreatest
tendency
development
remained
theofsame
until
Once again,
at the endones
ofthere
the(3,
experiment.
stemfor
heights
encountered
at the end
the experiment
were
which
theT6plants
presented the lowest growth, and
tendency
intostem
diameter
at the
endthose
of related
T6
proved
tofor
begrowth
that which
presented
theand
lowest
development
(Table
2).
those
corresponding
treatments
T0
T1,
whereas
to high
doses were the lowest (Table 2).
and T4 the highest (Table 2).
the experiment.
Thenewest
greatest
stem
heights
encoun-it wasT3
Amongst the
leaves
in this
experiment,
observed that, throughout the treatment, and in the case
Equivalence was observed, as regards valtered at the end of the experiment were those corof leaf 6, the doses were insufficient to induce statistical differences, whereas for leaf 7, the tendency was similar to that
responding to treatments T0 and T1, whereas those ues for leaf dry-biomass. Moreover, the same tennoted for the remainder. In other words, T6 was the treatment in which the plants presented the lowest growth, and T3
dency encountered for leaves was also observed for
related to high T6 doses were the lowest (Table 2).
and T4 the highest (Table 2).
As regards leaf biometrics, over time there stem-dry-mass, in that treatments with higher conwas greater differentiation between treatments. Thus, centrations of Cu (T5 and T6) were those in which
in the case of leaves 1 and 2 (the oldest leaves on the plants accumulated less dry mass.
Table 2. Results for mean values and standard deviation of biometric variables in stem height (SH), stem diameter (SD)
and leaf area index (LAI), obtained at the end of plant exposure to the different concentrations of copper.
T0
T1
T2
T3
T4
T5
T6
SH
26.6 ±5.6a
27.1 ±3.8a
23.8 ±2.8a
23.4 ±2.3a
24.5 ±2.7a
23.9 ±1.8a
22.4 ±2.8a
SD
0.4 0.03ab
0.4 ±0.04b
0.4 ±0.04a
0.4 0.02ab
0.4 0.02ab
0.4 0.02ab
0.4 ±0.07a
LAI1
14.1±0.7ab 15.6±1.1b
13.8±2.1ab 13.5±0.2a
15.4±2.2b
15.2±1.5ab 13.3±0.2a
LAI2
14.9±2.6ab 15.2±1.5b
12.9±2.7ab 20.2±13.1a 13.5±0.9ab 13.9±1.1b
LAI3
14.3±1.9b
12.2±1.4a
13.1±2.7ab 12.8±1.9ab 12.4±2.0ab 13.2±1.6ab 12.8±2.4ab 10.9±0.8a
LAI4
14.0±1.4b
13.4±0.7ab 12.9±1.6ab 12.6±1.4ab 12.2±1.6ab 13.2±2.3ab 11.2±1.3a
LAI5
16.6±2.1b
16.3 2.2ab
15.1±1.5ab 16.8±3.1b
LAI6
19.2±1.4a
20.3±4.4a
18.6±1.6a
LAI7
20.2±4.6ab 21.8±0.6ab 18.8±2.7ab 22.0±1.4b
19.7±2.6a
17.6±2.8b
16.3±1.4b
14.7±3.2a
18.5±1.8a
17.6±2.6a
16.5±3.4a
19.5±1.04b 19.4±2.03b 12.6±1.8a
Equivalence was observed, as regards values for leaf dry-biomass. Moreover, the same tendency encountered
for
10leaves was also observed for stem-dry-mass, in that treatments with higher concentrations of Cu (T5 and T6) were
those in which plants accumulated less dry mass.
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 10
09/10/2012 13:43:52
hich plants accumulated less dry mass.
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Table 3. Mean values in grams and standard deviation
es of soils, obtained different results from those
Mean values in gramsofand
deviation
of leaf
and end
stemofdry
at the end of the
experiment.
leafstandard
and stem
dry mass
at the
themass
experiment.
observed
with soybean, since stem-heights did not
Treatment
Dry Mass (leaf)
Dry Mass (stem)
T0
0.96 ±0.08
1.37 ±0.31
T1
1.10 ±0.59
1.30 ±0.26
T2
1.06 ±0.09
1.07 ±0.18
T3
1.00 ±0.20
1.07 ±0.22
T4
1.23 ±0.17
1.17 ±0.30
T5
1.02 ±0.13
1.02 ±0.19
T6
1.11 ±0.24
1.06 ±0.19
DISCUSSION
Heavy rainfall occurred in São Paulo during the period of plant exposure. As was observed
by Bertoni et al. (1999), since the element Cu++ is
extremely prone to edaphic conditions, mainly
humidity, this may have influenced the results,
as regards percolation, the availability of the element and its interaction with the plant. Variations
in chemical attributes in the soil may have induced
changes in the micronutrient content, consequently
leading to its deficiency or toxicity (3). Hence, results which did not present significant differences,
such as the diameter of the stem, the LAI values for
newer leaves, and biomass variables, could be explained by this momentarily excessive rainfall, with
the consequential washing out of the soil. This was
observed by Viera et al. (2005), who, on studying
the availability of nutrients in the soil, the quality
of soybean grains and their productivity in soil manured with sewage sludge, and when evaluating the
rates of N in the soil in the first cultivation of the
plant, demonstrated that, in the treatment I + L3, the
amount of biosolids applied may have induced the
loss of N by lixiviation. Thus, seeing that the plants
were not exposed under controlled conditions of climatic variables, high percolation of the element in
the soil may have interfered in the rates of Cu root
absorption.
On analyzing stem heights, it was noted
that in the first, lower-concentration treatments, the
low doses of Cu++ probably functioned as manure,
hence with a greater tendency to induce growth.
Santos et al. (2009), when analyzing the effects of
Cu++ and Zn++ on sorghum cultivated in three class-
present significant differences between treatments,
whereas diameters did, both as regards treatments
and the soils in which they were cultivated, thus
contrary to our results, whence stem heights were
significantly greater in treatments 0 and 1.
With the exception of new leaves, leaf
measurements followed the same pattern. It was
noted that growth was less in the more concentrated treatments, a possible indication of toxicity,
with the consequential prejudice to the development of organs. Copper is a prerequisite for the
satisfactory development of the plant, seeing that
there is a reduction in leaf area in those with a deficiency or excess of this nutrient (13). According to
Anjos and Mattiazzo (2000), in studies with corn
in soils enriched with a biosolid (sewage sludge),
it was noted that the highest rates of this metal
were concentrated in the leaves, even though in
this method of fertilization, independent of either
the treatment or the soil, this element presented no
toxic effects for the plants.
According to Rangel et al. (2006), when
studying the rates of heavy metals in the leaves
and grains of corn on applying sewage sludge, it
was noted that of the heavy metals assayed, copper
was that which presented rates in the leaf within the
range considered to be phytotoxic, although, until
the third culture, notably not above the upper range
of toxicity. Significant effects of the application of
doses of sewage sludge were only observed in leafcopper-rates in the first LB-culture and the third
LF, an indication of the absence of response in leafrates with the application of increased doses of the
sludge. Another factor which came under consideration, not only by Rangel (2006), but also by several
other authors (6, 16), is that Cu+ tends to accumulate
more in roots than in leaves, thereby indicating that
the lower response to the addition of sewer sludge,
in terms of leaf-copper-rates, could also be related
to the low translocation of this nutrient in the plant.
Dry biomass variables presented no statistic differences between treatments. In a study by
Araujo et al. (2005) of the effects of a textile sludge
compound on seedlings of soybean and wheat, it
was observed that the increase in concentrations of
the compound above 19 g L-1 caused a significant
11
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 11
09/10/2012 13:43:52
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
decrease in total dry-matter-mass, height of the aerial part and root length in those of both plant-species. In the case of soybean, there was a reduction,
in relation to the control, of 29% to 34% in total drymatter-mass, 15% to 36% in the height of the aerial
part, and 28% to 67% in root length with the application of 38, 76 and 152 g L-1, respectively. The author emphasized that, although the amount of heavy
metals present in textile sludge was in accordance
with the values stipulated by CETESB, the decrease
in total dry matter could be an indication of the effect of toxicity in the plants induced by heavy metals, especially copper and zinc. Moreover, Araujo
et al. (2005) also noted that in soybean and wheat
seedlings, there was a significant decrease in chlorophyll content, simultaneous with a corresponding
decrease in liquid photosynthesis, from the 76 g L-1
concentration one.
In a study of the growth and mineral nutrition of Eucalyptus maculata and Eucalyptus urophylla in concentrations of Cu++ (19), it was noted
that symptoms of phytotoxicity already appeared
in the first five days of the experiment, even at the
lowest concentrations, such as 32 and 64 μM of
Cu++ supplied as CuSO4. As to the aerial part and
leaf area, there was a decrease in dry matter at concentrations above 32 μM of Cu++. In studies with
sorghum (15), it was noted that doses of 1,07, 1,24
and 1,26 mg/Kg of copper applied induced an increase in dry matter.
In certain studies of toxicity with chlorine,
no direct relationship linking the element with effects on growth was observed. In neither of two
studies, one involving chemical sterilization with
chlorine dioxide in an in vitro culture of Anthurium (4), and the other (21), the in vitro culture of
Eucalyptus pellita in a medium sterilized by NaOCl, were toxic effects arising from these solutions
observed in plant development. On the other hand,
there was a considerable increase, distribution and
accumulation of copper and zinc in conifers (Jatropha curcas), where copper and zinc chlorates were
used as sources of contamination (5). The authors
only noted toxicological effects on increasing the
doses of both elements, which seems to imply that
chlorine itself did not interfere in these effects in
the cultivars analyzed, thereby facilitating transposition to the present work with specimens of G. max,
and thus making it possible to attribute tendencies
for growth in plants cultivated in more concentrated
solutions, only to copper.
CONCLUSION
With these results, it was noted that Glycine
max plants can present a tendency for aboveground
growth inversely proportional to Cu rates, thereby inferring their sensitivity to high doses of this element.
The plants presented no evident toxicological effects under the parameters analyzed in this
study, which can be justified by the possible percolation of the element, as a result of the high rainfall
which occurred during the experimental period. It
is therefore proposed that new experiments be undertaken with G. max and copper under controlled
conditions, in order to determine the relationship of
toxicity between the element and the development
of this plant species.
RESUMO
A soja (Glycine max) apresenta-se como
sendo uma espécie de grande importância econômica para o Brasil, que é considerado um dos grandes
produtores desta cultura. O trabalho objetivou
analisar a influência do cobre sobre o desenvolvimento de órgãos aéreos da espécie. Para tanto foi
desenvolvido experimento em condições naturais
de umidade e temperatura utilizando 112 plantas
cultivadas em vasos com areia. Foi adotado um delineamento de blocos casualisados contendo, quatro
blocos, sete tratamentos e quatro repetições, que
foram irrigadas com solução de Hoagland & Arnon enriquecida com diferentes concentrações de
CuCL2 por 30 dias. Após este período foram realizadas análises de variância e teste Tukey, onde se observou que as plantas submetidas ao tratamento 0,9
g CuCl2 L-1 (T6) foram as que apresentaram menor
crescimento em relação as plantas controles ou aos
menores tratamentos. Os valores de massa seca
do caule apresentaram equivalência às tendências
encontradas na biometria. Conclui-se assim que o
cobre em altas concentrações pode influenciar no
crescimento de plantas de Glycine max.
Palavras chave: soja, biometria vegetal, órgãos
aéreos, cobre.
12
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 12
09/10/2012 13:43:52
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
REFERENCES
1. -Anjos, A. R. M.; MATTIAZZO, M. E. Metais pesados em plantas de milho cultivadas em
latossolos repetidamente tratados com biossólido. Scientia Agricola, Piracicaba, V.57, n.4,
p.769-776, 2000.
2. -Araújo, A. S. F.; Monteiro, R. T. R.; Cardoso, P. F. Composto de lodo têxtil em plântulas de soja e trigo. Pesquisa Agropecuária
Brasileira, Brasília, V.40, n.6, p.549-554, 2005.
3. -BERTONI, J. C.; HOLANDA, F. S. R.; CARVALHO, J. G.; PAULA, M. B.; ASSIS, M. P.
Efeito do cobre na nutrição do arroz irrigado
por inundação- Teores e acumulo de nutrientes.
Ciência e Agrotecnologia, Lavras, V.23, n.3,
p.547-559, 1999.
4. -Cardoso, J. C. Notas Científicas Esterilização química de meio de cultura no cultivo in vitro de antúrio. Pesquisa Agropecuaria Brasileira, Brasília, V.44, n.7, p.785-788, 2009.
5. CHAVES, L. H. G.; MESQUITA, E. F.; ARAUJO, D. L.;FRANÇA, C.P. Crescimento, distribuição e acúmulo de cobre e zinco em plantas
de pinhão-manso. Revista Ciência Agronômica,
Fortaleza, V. 41, n. 2, p. 167-176, 2010.
6. JUNIOR, C. H. A.; BOARETTO, A. E.; MURAOKA, T.; KIEL, J. C. Uso agrícola de resíduos orgânicos potencialmente poluentes: propriedades químicas do solo e produção vegetal.
Tópicos em Ciência do Solo, Viçosa, V.4, n. 10,
p. 371-470, 2005.
7. Luchese, A. V.; JUNIOR, A. C. G; LUCHESE,
E. B; BRACCINI, M. C. L. Emergência e absorção de cobre por plantas de milho (Zea mays) em
resposta ao tratamento de sementes com cobre.
Ciência Rural, Santa Maria, V.34, n.6. p. 19491952, 2004.
8. Lui, J. J.; GALBIATI, J. A.; MELHEIROS, E. B.
Efeito da irrigação e utilização de lixo orgânico
na formação de mudas de Eucalipto. Holos Emvironmen, Rio Claro,V.8, n. 2, p. 179-194, 2008.
9. MANTOVANI, A. Composição química de solos
contaminados por cobre ; formas, sorção e efeito
no desenvolvimento de espécies vegetais. 2009.
105 f. Tese (Doutorado em Ciência do solo) - Faculdade de Agronomia, Universidade Federal do
Rio Grande do Sul , Porto Alegre. 2009.
10. MATOS, A. T.; FONTES, M. P. F.; JORDÃO,
C. P.; COSTA, L. M. Heavy metals mobility and
retention forms in a brazilian oxisol. Revista
Brasileira Ciência do Solo, Campinas, V. 20,
n.3, p.379 – 386, 1996.
11. MCBRIDE, M.; SAUVE, S.; HENDERSHOT,
W. Solubility control of Cu, Zn, Cd and Pb in
contaminated soils. European Journal Soil
Science,Oxford, V. 48, n. 2, p. 337 – 346, 1997.
12. NAKAZONO, E. M.; COSTA, M. C. D.; FUTATSUGI, K.; PAULILO, M. T. S. Crescimento
inicial de Euterpe edulis Mart. em diferentes regimes de luz. Revista Brasileira de Botânica,
São Paulo, V. 2, p. 173-179, 2001.
13. PEGORINI, E. S.; ANDREOLK, C. V.; SOUZA, M .L.; FERREIRA, A. 2003. Qualidade
do lodo de esgoto utilizado na reciclagem agrícola na região metropolitana de Curitiba - PR.
In: SIMPÓSIO LATINO AMERICANO DE
BIOSSÓLIDOS, 1., São Paulo.
14. RangeL, O. J. P.; Silva, C. A.; Bettiol, W.;
Dynia, J. F. Efeito de aplicação de lodos de esgoto sobre os teores de metais pesados em folha
e grão de milho. Revista Brasileira de Ciência
do Solo, Campinas, V.30 ,p.583-594, 2006.
15. SANTOS, H. C.; Fraga, V. S.; RaposO,
R. W. C.; PereirA, W. E. Cu e Zn na cultura
do sorgo cultivado em três classes de solos. I.
Crescimento vegetativo e produção. Revista
Brasileira de Engenharia Agrícola e Ambiental,
Campina Grande, V.13, n.2, p.125–130, 2009.
16. Silva, e. b.; TANURE, L. P. P.; SANTOS, S.
R.; JUNIOR, P. S. R. Sintomas visuais de deficiências nutricionais em pinhão-manso. Pesquisa Agropecuária Brasileira, Brasília, V.44,
n.4, p.392-397, 2009.
17. SILVA, R. F.; ANTONIOLLI, Z. I.; LUPATIMI,
M.; TRINDADE, L. L.; SILVA, A. S. Tolerância
de mudas de Canafístula Peltophorum dubium
(SPRENG.) TAUB.) inoculadas com Pisolithus
microcarpus a solo com excesso de cobre. Ciência
Florestal, Santa Maria, V. 20, n. 1,p. 147-156, 2010.
18. SFREDO, G. J. Soja no Brasil; Calagem, adubação e nutrição mineral. Londrina – PR . Embrapa Soja. 2008. P. 48; 81-82
19. SOARES, C. R. F. S.; SIQUEIRA, J. O.; CARVALHO, J. G.; MOREIRA, F. M. S.; GRAZZIOTTI, P. H. Crescimento e nutrição mineral de
13
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 13
09/10/2012 13:43:52
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Eucalyptus maculata e Eucalyptus urophylla em
solução nutritiva com concentração crescente de
cobre. Revista Brasileira de Fisiologia Vegetal,
Campinas, V.12, n.3, P. 213-225, 2000.
20. SODRE, F. F.; LENZI, E. Utilização de modelos
físico-químicos de adsorção no estudo do comportamento do cobre em solos argilosos. Química Nova, São Paulo, V. 24, n.3, p. 324-330, 2001.
21. TEIXEIRA, S. L.; RIBEIRO, J. M.; TEIXEIRA,
M. T. Utilização de hipoclorito de sódio na esterilização de meio de cultura para multiplicação in
vitro de Eucalyptus pellita L. Ciência Florestal,
Santa Maria, V.18, n.2, p.185‑191, 2008.
22. VIEIRA, R. F.; Tanaka, R. T.; Tsai, S. M.;
Pérez, P. Disponibilidade de nutrientes no
solo, qualidade de grãos e produtividade da soja
em solo adubado com lodo de esgoto. Pesquisa
Agropecuária Brasileira, Brasília, V.40, n.9,
p.919-926, 2005.
23. ZAMPIERI, M. C. T. Estudo sobre os efeitos
do cobre e zinco no crescimento da plântula
de Aechmea blanchetiana (Baker)L. B. Smith
cultivadas em vitro. Aplicação da analise por
ativação com nêutrons. 160 f. Tese (Mestrado
em Ciência na área de Tecnologia Nuclear- Aplicações) - Instituto de Pesquisas energéticas e
nucleares. Autarquia associada à Universidade
de São Paulo. São Paulo. 2010.
14
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 14
09/10/2012 13:43:52
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Environmental characterization of the Lajeado
Tunas watershed, RS, Brazil
Lisiane Zanella* – Universidade Regional Integrada do Alto Uruguai e das Missões – Campus de Frederico
Westphalen - RS, Laboratório de Geoprocessamento (lisianezanella@gmail.com)
Eloir Missio – Universidade Regional Integrada do Alto Uruguai e das Missões – Campus de Frederico
Westphalen - RS, Laboratório de Geoprocessamento (eloirmissio@unipampa.edu.br)
Rosângela Alves Tristão Borém, Universidade Federal de Lavras – UFLA, Setor de
Ecologia/Departamento de Biologia (tristao@dbi.ufla.br)
Maurício Castro dos Santos – Universidade Regional Integrada do Alto Uruguai e das Missões
Campus de Frederico Westphalen - RS, Laboratório de geoprocessamento (castro86@hotmail.com)
Marcos Antônio Ritterbuch – Universidade Regional Integrada do Alto Uruguai e das Missões – URI,
Laboratório de Geoprocessamento (ritterbuch@fw.uri.br)
ABSTRACT
Geographic Information System (GIS), Remote Sensing Imagery and Global Positioning
System (GPS) coordinates were employed to characterize landscape structure and land
use features of the Lajeado Tunas watershed, Frederico Westphalen, Rio Grande do Sul
State, Brazil. Based on data so obtained, two land-cover maps were compiled. These
were after compared in order to evaluate the methodology employed. The watershed,
spread over approximately 650 ha, is apparently on a mild, east-to-west slope (6.95%).
Due to this relative flatness, local conditions are favorable for farming. Notwithstanding, preservation is a prerequisite for controlling erosion and protecting water resources.
The land uses mapping has shown how the predominant occupation for anthropogenic
usage has exerted negative effects on the quality of the environment and the conservation of biodiversity. Even though only a simple set of GIS tools were used for analyzing
the focal landscape, these have helped to arrive at an adequate understanding of the
structurally important characteristics of the landscape in a regional context. The results
obtained have proved to be of interest for understanding which conservation action is
more appropriate for improving the maintenance of local and regional biodiversity, to so
guarantee the long-term maintenance of agricultural ecosystems, and, in future analyses, for generating knowledge on how local fauna and flora respond to regional landscape characteristics, the key-points for guaranteeing the maintenance of biodiversity.
Key-words: Environmental Planning, Landscape Structure, Sustainable Management,
Geographic Information Systems (GIS)
INTRODUCTION
Increased anthropic action has given rise
to important alterations in the environment, with
consequential impacts. Among the main aspects of
these modifications we can cite the loss of habitat,
and the fragmentation and decrease in quality in the
remaining areas (4). Environmental planning has
acquired pre-eminence over the latter decades, due
to the interest in redirecting for consideration, not
15
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 15
09/10/2012 13:43:52
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
only the environments so created and modified by
human-kind, but also the remaining, surrounding
natural environments.
The growing need to present solutions and
strategies, with a mind to interrupting and reverting the effects of environmental degradation and
the impoverishment of natural resources, has led to
intense questioning, mainly as to (a) how to face the
agglomeration of environmental problems detected
in large urban centers, (b) how to elaborate and develop efficient strategies for their solution, and (c)
how to guarantee the application of such strategies.
In order to respond to such questions, the
environmental issue should be analyzed within a
perspective that surpasses urban limits. We must
take into consideration that cities and human-kind do
not exist apart from the natural elements (water, air,
soil, among others), but all together compile a natural global system – the planet Earth - on which we
have been acting and intervening without concern for
the eventual accumulative effects, thus compromise
not only the present, but especially, the very future
of their own existence. We need to recognize that
human-kind subsist as part of this controversy. Thus,
on contemplating the principles of landscape ecology, anthropic action should come under consideration
throughout all the phases of planning, inasmuch as, if
well conducted, better equilibrated alternatives may
be arrived at, as means of inducing the sustainable
usage of the environment.
16
Even though each study may present distinct forms of partitioning the space to be analyzed
or planned (14), several authors give preference to
water basins, in special watersheds, since these constitute minimum units in the environment planning
approach, due to the agglomeration of important
pertinent components aggregated to their structuring, such as characteristic fauna and flora, besides
the drainage itself (3.12).
The management of watersheds involves
a process that permits formulating an integrated
assemblage of actions on the environment (social,
economic, institutional and legal structures of a watershed), in order to promote the conservation and
sustainable utilization of prevalent natural resources, whereby the prerequisite of acquiring knowledge on the structure, composition and dynamics of
the catchment itself and surroundings.
The Geographic Information System (GIS),
within the context of the integrated planning of
and systemic approach to watersheds, has been the
way of applying the methodology and philosophy
of analysis and synthesis of organizational problems and questions related to the environment, with
world-wide application in terms of relationships and
integration (15). Due to its characteristics of data integration, GIS, together with remote sensing products, functions as probably one of the most adequate
tools in support of decision making for systemicfocusing, in the management of natural resources.
Figure 1 – Localization of the Lajeado Tunas watershed, Frederico Westphalen – RS, Brazil.
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 16
09/10/2012 13:43:53
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Thus, the aim of this study was to apply
two methodologies to the analysis and comparison
of the land use geographic distribution, as well as
to elaborate thematic maps of the study area, with
an eye to the environmental characterization of a
watershed in the south of Brazil, thereby supplying
subsistence for the elaboration of a plan for its territorial management.
METODOLOGY
Localization of the Study Area
The Lajeado Tunas watershed (Fig. 1) is located in Frederico Westphalen County, Rio Grande
do Sul, Brazil, between the parallels 27°22’ and
27°33’ south and the meridians 53°24’ and 53º27’
west. It discharges into the Rio Pardo, pertaining
to the Rio Uruguay Basin, at around 200 m from
the dam of the Companhia Riograndense de Saneamento – CORSAN, thereby contributing to the water supply of the urban area (7).
Frederico Westphalen presents a humid
subtropical climate (Cfa), according to the Köppen
classification, with average minimum and maximum temperatures of 13°C and 31°C, respectively
(8). Annual rainfall, of between 1.800 and 2.100
mm, is well distributed throughout the year (8).
The pattern of drainage in the watershed
is dendrite-like, with wide-spreading branches and
tributaries at various angles (Howard, 1967). Aluminum-ferric red latosoil predominates in the highest and flattest parts, and neosoils closer to the river
mouth (17).
The region of the Upper Uruguay, where
Frederico Westphalen county is located, was originally totally covered by Atlantic Forest latu senso,
composed of deciduous seasonal and mixed ombrophylous forests (17). Based on the biogeographic
region delimitation proposed by Silva & Casteletti
(2003), the study area corresponds to a transition
region between interior and araucaria forests (14).
With the introduction of farming, the original native vegetation experienced profound modifications. The present scenario is composed by forest
fragments, vegetal cover characterized by the predominance of early secondary forest in various successive stages, diversified farming and other agricultural activities (10).
Methodological procedures
The first step involved the construction
of a cartographic base of the study area, using the
softwares Idrisi Kilimanjaro (1) and MapInfo (7.8
9), together with information contained in the topographic chart Folha SG.22-Y-C-II-3 MI 2885/3, of
Frederico Westphalen, scale 1:50.000, elaborated by
the Diretoria de Serviços Geográficos of the Brazilian Army – DSG (IBGE, 1979), and in the LandSat
TM 5 satellite image, orbit 223/079, of 8/3/2004 at
13h 12’ and 59”.
We obtained the watershed delimitation
starting from the identification of the corresponding drainage area, or rather that referring to the area
drained by the entire fluvial system confined within
topographic limits, all projected onto a horizontal
plane (21). The perimeter of the watershed consisted
of the length of an imaginary line drawn along the
water divisors, which in turn coincide with geomorphometric aspects of the region under analysis.
Water bodies and road network were digitized from DSG charts, and complemented with
field data obtained with a Garmin 12 GPS. This
process allowed us to include roads and other forms
of access to rural properties, as well as streams and
springs, which do not appear in the official charts.
The ordering of water courses and drainage density were both used to characterize regional
drainage. This arrangement, which represents the
degree of branching of the system of watershed
drainage (23), was defined according to the classification proposed by Strahler (1952), by which,
watercourses with no tributaries are considered of
the first order, those of the second order only receive tributaries of the first order, independent of
the number of tributaries, those of the third order
receive two or more tributaries of the second order,
although they are also capable of receiving tributaries of the first order, and so on.
Drainage density refers to the efficiency
with which rainwater quits the watershed. It is calculated as the relationship between the total combined length of all the water courses present, and
the entire area occupied by the system (4).
Hypsometry was elaborated from the interpolation of vectorial maps of the level curves, which
gave rise to the generation of a digital elevation
model (DEM). Hypsometry was divided into four
17
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 17
09/10/2012 13:43:53
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
different altimetrical classes (400 – 450 m; 450 – 500
m; 500 – 550 m; 550 – 600 m). A clinographic map,
elaborated with the aid of models available in Idrisi
and using DEM as a base, was applied to classifying
the area into five different patterns of declivity (13).
Land use mapping was based on the application of
two methodologies: (i) the supervised classification
of satellite images and (ii) data obtained in the field
with GPS geographic coordinates.
We used methods of image processing, as
recommended by Easteman (1998) for the supervised classification of the LandSat TM5 satelite
image (bands 3, 4 and 5), thereby simplifying the
elaboration of one of the land use maps with Idrisi
software.
In this study, the following land use for
mapping were defined: (a) natural vegetation; all
the vegetal forms, as fragment forest, riverine forest
and early secondary forest; (b) agriculture – areas
allocated to annual culture and those with exposed
soil in the phase of preparation or implantation of
annual cultures; (c) pasture - areas with pasture
and those allotted to cattle raising; (d) waterbodies – water bodies, either naturally formed or reservoirs and ponds; (e) urban area – urban lots and
rural buildings.
The edition of refinement classification
was done with Mapinfo 7.8 software. On completion, the results were introduced into PhotoImpact
4.0 software for the manipulation of images and
elaboration of the figures corresponding to consolidated thematic charts.
Geographic coordinates obtained in the
field with GPS were used in the second methodology. For mapping the outlines of land use classes in
the watershed, area marking was based on the limits
of rural properties, urban areas and the main land
uses within each rural property. Within the limits
that were being investigated and duly registered,
each point corresponded to an extremity of the polygon or line that was being mapped.
Simultaneous with the collection of points,
a manual outline of the mapped properties was
drawn up, this contributing as a source of orientation for elaborating the layers corresponding to differences in land use and occupation, as recognized
and identified in the field. Field work lasted for
around two months (January and February, 2006),
running up to approximately 400 work-hours carried into effect by a team of 2.
The points collected were transferred from
GPS to the software GPS Track Maker, and stored in
a geographic database. These were introduced into
MapInfo 7.8. for the manipulation and development
of layers corresponding to the following land use
classes: (i) forest – those with primary or secondary
vegetation in an advanced stage of succession; (ii)
secondary forest – areas covered by vegetation in
the initial to mid stages of regeneration; (iii) groves
- areas with few trees which do not constitute a forest; (iv) swamp - flooded areas, generally located
near to springs and reservoirs; (v) annual agriculture – annual cultures and areas with exposed soil;
(vi) eucalyptus – areas for planting eucalyptus; (vii)
perennial agriculture - areas for the plantation of
Paraguay tea; (viii) citrus – areas specifically allotted to producing grapes and oranges; (ix) pasture
– grassland, ultimately used for cattle raising; (x)
waterbodies – bodies of water and artificial lakes
(reservoirs); (xi) farms – small properties, not for
farming and without rural installations; (xii) builtup areas – an area comprising elaborated properties
and their respective rural surroundings; (xiii) urban
area – an assemblage of lots with buildings of low
standard; (xv) Roads/access routes – comprising areas for public use (roads, streets, etc.).
RESULTS
The area occupied by the Lajeado Tunas
watershed (around 650 ha), with a perimeter of 10.6
km, represented only 2.5% of the total area of Frederico Westphalen county. It was mostly situated in
a region occupied by small rural properties characterized as family concerns, which, as such, were
strongly exploited as regards natural resources. Orientation was east-to-west, and the main watercourse
was around 5 km in extent. The calculated drainage
density was 22.3 m/ha.
The watershed itself, comprising an extension of 14.5 km, was drained by a main perennial
watercourse composed of 14 springs, three located
in the urban perimeter, and the remainder in the rural zone.
The greater part of the watershed was located in the rural zone. The smaller part, which was in
18
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 18
09/10/2012 13:43:53
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
the urban zone, presented a paved federal highway, (545.69 ha), distributed among 54 small rural fambut only 238 m of which encroached upon water- ily properties, entirely or partially inserted into
shed limits. Unpaved roads, 22.67 km all told, and the watershed. Annual cultures consist of planting
characterized as earth roads, also included routes corn and soybean, and to a lesser extent, beans and
of access to rural properties. We took the drain- tobacco. Other activities, such as olericulture and
age density as a base to obtain the density of roads, fruit culture are also undertaken in some properties,
which was also high (35 m/ha) in the watershed.
but only for family consumption. Animal breeding
The surface of the watershed presented a is basically restricted to dairy cattle and pigs.
variation of 200 m in height, between the quotas
The extension of agriculture diagnosed by
400 to 600 m above sea level, the greater part of GPS mapping methodology occupied 57.63 % of
which (more than 80%) being situated between 450 the area and corresponded to annual cultures, includand 550 m. The two extremes referred to the highest ing areas of perennial cultures and horticulture, as
and lowest altitudes, corresponding to 13.3% and can be seen in Figure 2. According to field mapping
4.1%, respectively, of the whole area.
(GPS approach) of this class, this percentage was reThe biggest part of watershed relief
duced to 31.56%.
(92.77%) consisted of low declivity areas (0 – 13%),
Although eucalyptus, citrus and perennial
classified as flat, and slightly or moderately wavy.
agriculture were distinguished from annual culWavy relief (13 to 20%) occurred in less than 5%
tures, their areas were little representative, and ocof the whole. On the other hand slopes between 20
cupy only 4.19 ha, 1.87 ha and 2.71 ha, respectively.
and 45% were found in 15.57 ha of the whole area,
Other classes lacking in the satellite image mapwhereas those above 45%, considered mountainous
to cliff-like, were not registered. The average de- ping, were identified through GPS approach (Figure 3): (i) roads/access routes (1.07%); (ii) built-up
clivity was estimated at 6.95%.
Although satellite images interpretation areas (2.97%); and, (iii) farms (2.17%). Urban area
allowed us to classify the study area in five main occupied only 16% of the watershed.
According to GPS mapping approach, pasland use classes, a larger number of classes were
tures
occupied
105.2 ha, and natural vegetation
diagnosed only through the GPS mapping methodFigure
1
–
Localization
of
the
Lajeado
Tunas
watershed,
Frederico
Westphalen
– RS,
Brazil.according to image
around 86 ha. On the other
hand,
ology (Table 1).
Land use classes
Natural cover
Anthropic cover
Forest
Secondary forest
Groves
Swamp
Annual agriculture
Eucalyptus
Perennial agriculture
Citrus
Pasture
Waterbodies
Farms
Built-up areas
Urban areas
Roads/access routes
Total
The area of the watershed situated in the
rural zone corresponded to 84% of the landscape
LandSat
Area (ha)
Area (%)
86.31
13.29
374.41
57.63
82.53
0.09
12.70
0.01
106.29
16.36
649.63
100.00
GPS
Area (ha)
Area (%)
156.20
24.04
14.11
2.17
5.61
0.86
0.20
0.03
205.00
31.56
4.19
0.64
1.87
0.29
2.71
0.42
105.20
16.19
5.41
0.83
14.10
2.17
19.28
2.97
108.80
16.75
6.95
1.07
649.63
100.00
classification approach, pastures occupied 81.89 ha,
and natural vegetation was divided in four classes:
19
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 19
09/10/2012 13:43:53
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
forest (24.04%), secondary forest (2.17%), groves
(0.86%) and swamps (0.03%).
classification, this class was not identified due to
the waterbodies being smaller in size than the pixel
Figure 2 – Chart of land use mapping using LandSat TM5 image classification approach of the Lajeado Tunas
watershed, Frederico Westphalen – RS.
Figure 2 – Chart of land use mapping using LandSat TM5 image classification approach of the Lajeado Tunas
watershed, Frederico Westphalen – RS.
Figure 3 – Chart of land use mapping using GPS field mapping approach of the Lajeado Tunas watershed, Frederico
Westphalen
RS. of land use mapping using GPS field mapping approach of the Lajeado Tunas watershed, Frederico
Figure 3 ––Chart
Westphalen
RS. ‘waterbodies’ corresponded to an
The– class
area of 5.41 ha in field mapping approach. In image
of the LandSat image employed in the study (pixel
= 30 x 30 m).
20
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 20
09/10/2012 13:43:53
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
DISCUSSION
The Lajeado Tunas watershed, classified as
of the third order, can be considered a small unit,
with high drainage density (4) and thus, with favorable conditions for constraining local intervening factors. This high drainage density means that
infiltration is more difficult, with higher surface
drainage, and consequently, greater hewing out of
permanent channels, due to the hydrological deportment of rocks (2).
The quantification of roads, in relation to
the entire area occupied by the watershed, facilitates diagnosing their density. Roads, on one hand,
present a positive contribution when considering
accessibility among properties. But, on the other
hand, they expose natural areas to human presence
through easy access, thereby compromising their
preservation, both through favoring the entrance
of toxic substances, as from the facility in collecting plants and the capture or running over of wild
animals (10).
The watershed also presents low average
altitude and hypsometric amplitude, factors which
influence the amount of radiation received and,
consequently, evapotranspiration, temperature
and rainfall. According to Tonello et al. (2009), the
greater the altitude, the less the amount of solar
energy that the environment receives, thus resulting in less energy availability. In this sense, the
amount of available energy in the watershed can
be considered high.
Most of the watershed is considered as appropriate for agriculture, provided that simple steps
for controlling erosion are taken. We considered
those areas with an accentuated slope as apt for developing annual cultures. However, due to the considerably high susceptibility to erosion in this type
of relief, the implantation of this type of culture is
conditioned to the implementation of intensive soil
conservation techniques. The few areas that present
restriction to agriculture due to this high susceptibility, offer adequate conditions for the establishment of permanent cultures such as perennial agriculture and citrus.
Since declivity is intimately related to the
distribution of water in a watershed (20), the average slope presented by the watershed plays a sig-
nificant role in the distribution of water between
surface and subterranean drainage, thereby functioning positively in the natural conservation of
the drainage system as a whole. Nevertheless, in
the present case, signs of erosion in the watershed
were observed. This was characterized by ravines
in farming areas and gullies along the roads, mainly
where there is higher declivity.
As regards land use classification in the
study area, image classification was limited, due
to low spatial resolution, thereby precluding identification with the same precision as that of some
classes mapped with GPS approach. Nonetheless,
the classification of this type of image can be an
excellent tool when used for larger study areas.
The results obtained from the land use classification permit inferring that the matrix of land
use is agriculture, represented by the corn, soybean
and tobacco cultivation. These cultures are undertaken with no heed to conservation procedures, thus
possibly giving rise to a high loss of soil by erosion.
The divergence among the percentages
obtained for the class ‘agriculture’ in the different methodologies adopted, is possibly related to
the period in which the LandSat image classification was obtained, viz., October, as this coincides
with a critical period, in which the lowest indices of
vegetal cover occur, and when there is a similarity
between the coloration of agropastoral cultures and
natural vegetation, whereby the spectral response
makes identification difficult, especially the case of
small forest fragments and secondary forests, which
end up being incorporated into the local farming
matrix. Besides this, in the GPS approach we could
separate annual plantations from the perennial agriculture, eucalyptus and citrus classes.
We believe that roads/access routes, builtup areas, farms, secondary forest, groves, eucalyptus, and swamps, as identified through GPS mapping approach, as well as small forest fragments,
were incorporated as agricultural areas in the interpretation of the satellite image. Thus, the difference
between the two methodologies of land use classification was significantly increased regarding to the
differentiation among distinct land use classes.
It is important to point out that high resolution images are more indicated for small study
areas, since they permit the correct differentiation
21
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 21
09/10/2012 13:43:54
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
of various land use classes. However, as the acquisition of this type of image is very costly (1 ha costs
around R$10.00 for Quickbird satellite images: spatial resolution = 0.60 m), this can compromise the
feasibility of the projects with the required characteristics. Selection of the most adequate image is
a preponderant factor in a research project, since
there are images available in internet free of charge,
as is the case of LandSat images.
GPS mapping approach makes a precise
and correct diagnosis, and is also indicated in the
study of small areas, due to the intense field work
involved. For larger study areas, satellite images
are once again recommended, in view of the costbenefit factor and the rapid task execution, since the
difference in results is more significant, regarding
to the number of categories in the same class, than
in relation to the differentiation between natural and
anthropic areas.
Pastures occupy the third largest area, possibly due to the economic importance of dairy-cattle
breeding for the region. It is importante to note that
pastures, when well-managed, is a form of maintaining the surface of the soil covered throughout
the year. This practice reduces the speed of surface
drainage, contrary to agricultural activities, which
leave the soil exposed during its preparation prior
to planting (10). As a rule, animal breeding in the
region is developed extensively, with pasture of low
productivity. According to field observations, we
visualize badly-managed compacted areas, having
all the available forage used. The results of these
actions let the soil exposed and without protection
against the erosive action of rain and wind, and significantly diminishing infiltration and directly affecting the drainage of springs and watercourses.
The difference between the values observed in satellite-image classification and GPS
mapping approach is explained by the presence of
small areas with pasture, as well as pastures close
to or inserted into agricultural areas that possess a
similar spectral response, and thus, are not differentiated in satellite-image classification.
Field mapping differentiated vegetation
in forest, secondary forest and groves. Forest, that
originally occupied all the study area, are mainly
located next to springs, accompanying river courses
and in areas of high declivity. We considered forest
as of fundamental importance in the erosion control
and to replenish phreatic water. Accelerated erosive
processes prejudice both the environment and society through diminishing the fertility of the soil, and
affecting plant growth. They also diminish the capacity of soil water retention, as in near and remote
areas, through the drainage of water and sediments,
local damage, negative changes in the environment
related to floods, the fill-in of rivers, lakes and reservoirs, the contamination of bodies of water, etc..
In such cases, natural vegetation is a potential aid in
minimizing these processes (6).
Nevertheless, the area of native forest
shows that the watershed represents the conservation status equivalent to the region where it is located. Based on LandSat image classification, Tonial et al., (2005) encountered approximately 16%
of forest areas in the five water basins located in
the northeastern region of the state of Rio Grande
do Sul, where the present study area is located. On
the other hand, Cemin et al. (2009) found a higher
coverage (51.96%) of natural vegetation, in a water
basin located close to the same study area.
APPs present a large degree of deforestation,
as a result of the urban expansion. Thereabouts, the
execution of environmental projects should be intensified, as a way of preserving areas where springs
occur. We believe this class needs special attention
due to the negative impact which can be associated
with areas covered by solid material, thereby hindering various physical and biological processes, such
as the absorption of rainwater, which normally occur
between the soil and the atmosphere. Furthermore,
the production of residues and the conversion of areas with natural vegetation into lots constitute two
serious recurring problems arising from urbanization
(11). Urban expansion should be redirected to locations with more favorable physical conditions, avoiding negative environmental impacts, and so maintain
the quality of hydric resources.
We do not identify small watercourses in
the image classification due to its scale of 1:50.000,
and the pixels size.
CONCLUSIONS
The watershed is considered appropriate for agro-pastural activities, through being on
22
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 22
09/10/2012 13:43:54
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
a plain, and possesses high drainage efficiency,
thereby favoring surface drainage and minimizing
the aftermath of erosive processes.
Agriculture is the landscape matrix, and
thus constitutes the main threat to the environmental quality of the watershed. Farming areas present
a lack of adequate management, and require urgent
conservation actions, as a means of mitigating the
impacts arising from the intense exploitation of
natural resources.
Forest recomposition in the study area is
imperative, mainly in areas of permanent protection, with the aim of maintaining the ecological
functions associated with natural ecosystems, especially the control of erosion and aid in replenishing
phreatic water.
The methodologies used for diagnosing the
distribution of land use mapping differed, mainly as
regards the identification of the different land use
classes. Although GPS mapping approach identified a larger number of categories of land use, more
time was dedicated to undertaking the task, thereby
conditioning the application of this method to small
areas. Satellite images of mid-spatial resolution
proved to be most indicated in the study of larger areas, due to the adequate relationship cost-benefits.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
We thank the Universidade Regional Integrada do Alto Uruguai e das Missões – URI – Campus de Frederico Westphalen, and the Laboratory of
Geoprocessing for undertaking this work.
RESUMO
Este trabalho analisa o uso da terra e da estrutura da paisagem da sub-bacia hidrográfica do
Lajeado Tunas, Frederico Westphalen, RS, Brasil.
Sistemas de Informação Geográfica (SIG), imagens
de Sensoriamento Remoto e Coordenadas de Global
Positioning System (GPS) foram usadas para caracterizar a paisagem e para gerar dois mapas cobertura da terra, que foram posteriormente comparados
para avaliar as metodologias utilizadas. A sub-bacia
do Lajeado possui cerca de 650 ha, e os resultados
sugerem que o relevo possui declive suave (6,95%),
estando orientado de leste a oeste. Devido ao ter-
reno ser ligeiramente plano, a sub-bacia possui
condições favoráveis para atividades agropastoris, no entanto, práticas conservacionistas são necessárias a fim de controlar a erosão e proteger os
recursos hídricos. O mapeamento dos usos da terra
mostrou que a região é predominantemente ocupada por usos antrópicos, que desempenham efeitos
negativos para a qualidade ambiental e a conservação da biodiversidade. Embora tenha sido usado
um conjunto simples de ferramentas de SIG para
analisar a paisagem focal, esses métodos auxiliaram o entendimento de características da paisagem
estruturalmente importantes no contexto regional,
e os resultados obtidos mostraram-se interessantes
para entender quais ações de conservação devem
ser usadas para melhorar a manutenção da biodiversidade local ou regional, para garantir a longo prazo
a manutenção dos ecossistemas agrícolas, e que, em
futuras análises, a compreensão de como fauna e
flora locais respondem às características da paisagem regional são os pontos-chave para garantir a
manutenção da biodiversidade.
Palavras-chave: Planejamento Ambiental, Estrutura da Paisagem, Manejo Sustentável, Sistemas de
Informação Geográfica (SIG)
REFERENCES
1 - CLARK LABS. IDRISI kilimanjaro software
student user’s guide. Worcester: Clark University. 2003.
2 - CEMIN, G.; PERICO, E.; REMPEL, C. Composição e configuração da paisagem da sub-bacia do arroio jacaré, Vale do Taquari, RS, com ênfase nas áreas de florestas. Rev. Árvore, Viçosa,
v. 33, n. 4, p. 705-711. 2009.
3 - CHRISTOFOLETTI, A. Morfologia de bacias de
drenagem. Not. Geomorfol. v. 18, p.130-132, 1978.
4 - DEPARTAMENTO NACIONAL DE ÁGUAS
E ENERGIA ELÉTRICA – ESTAÇÃO
ECOLÓGICA DE SÃO CARLOS. Bacia experimental rio Jacaré-Guaçu. São Carlos: EESCUSP, 1980. 114 p.
3 - EASTMANN, J. R. Idrisi for Windows: introdução
e exercícios tutoriais. (Trad.) HASENACK, H.;
WEBER, E. Porto Alegre: UFRGS – Centro de
Recursos Idrisi. 1998. 240p.
4 - FAHRIG, L. Effects of habitat fragmentation on
23
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 23
09/10/2012 13:43:54
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
biodiversity. Annu. Rev. Ecol. Evol. Syst, Palo
Alto, v. 34, p. 487-515. 2003.
6 - GUERRA; A. J. T.; MENDONÇA, J. K. S.
Erosão dos solos e a questão ambiental. In:
VITTE, A. C.; GUERRA, A. J. T. (Orgs). Reflexões sobre a geografia física no Brasil. Rio
de Janeiro: Bertrand Brasil, 2004. 280p.
7 - INSTITUTO BRASILEIRO DE GEOGRAFIA
E ESTATÍSTICA. Diretoria de Serviço Geográfico do Exército Brasileiro. Folha SG.22-Y-C-II3MI-2885/3 – Frederico Westphalen. 1979.
8 - INSTITUTO NACIONAL DE METEOROLOGIA. Normais Climatológicas do Brasil 19611990. Versão revista e ampliada. Org.: RAMOS,
A. M.; SANTOS, L. A. R.; FORTES, L. T. G.
Brasília, DF: INMET, 2009. 465p.
9 - MAPINFO PROFESSIONAL. Guia do Usuário.
Troy: MapInfo Corporation. 1998. 591p.
10 - MISSIO, E.; SANTOS, J.E; PIRES, J.S.R.;
MARKOSKI, P.R.; TONIAL, T.M.. Caracterização, diagnóstico e zoneamento ambiental da
paisagem do município de Frederico Westphalen, RS. In: : SANTOS J.E.; CAVALHEIRO,
F.; PIRES, J.S.R.; HENKE-OLIVEIRA, C.;
PIRES, A.M.Z.C.R. (Org.). Faces da polissemia
da paisagem: ecologia, planejamento e percepção. São Carlos: RIMA, 2004. v. 1, p. 383-404.
11 - NUNES, J. O. R.; SANTANA-NETO, J. L. A
produção do espaço urbano e o destino dos resíduos sólidos. Caderno Prudentino de Geografia,
Presidente Prudente, v. 1, n. 24, p. 60-73, 2002.
12 - PISSARRA, T. C. T., POLITANO, W., FERRAUDO, A. S. Avaliação de características
morfométricas na relação solo-superfície da Bacia Hidrográfica do Córrego Rico, Jaboticabal
(SP). Rev. Bras. Ciênc. Solo, Viçosa, v. 28, n. 2,
p. 297-305. 2004.
13 - RAMALHO-FILHO, A.; BEEK, K.J. Sistema de
avaliação da aptidão agrícola das terras. 3. ed.
rev. Rio de Janeiro: EMBRAPA/CNPS. 1995. 65p.
14 - RIBEIRO, M. C.; MARTENSEN, A. C.;
METZGER, J. P.; TABARELLI, M.; SCARANO, F.; FORTIN, M. J. The Brazilian Atlantic
Forest: a shrinking biodiversity hotspot. In:
ZACHOS, F. E.; HABEL, J. C (Org.). Biodiver-
sity hotspots. Berlin and Heidelberg: SpringerVerlag. 2011.
15 - ROCHA, J. V.; Sistema de informações geográficas no contexto do planejamento integrado de
bacias hidrográficas. In: ORTEGA, E. (Org.).
Engenharia ecológica e agricultura sustentável.
Campinas: [s.n.], 2003. cap. 20, p. 1-13.
16 - SILVA, J.M.C., CASTELETI, C.H.M. Status
of the biodiversity of the Atlantic Forest of Brazil. In: GALINDO-LEAL, C., CÂMARA, I.G.
(Orgs.). The Atlantic Forest of South America:
biodiversity status, threats, and outlook. Washington: CABS and Island Press, p. 43–59. 2003.
17 - SOS MATA ATLÂNTICA, INSTITUTO NACIONAL DE PESQUISAS ESPACIAIS. Atlas
dos remanescentes florestais e ecossistemas
associados no domínio da Mata Atlântica. São
Paulo. 2000. 156p.
18 - STRAHLER, A. N. Dynamic basis of geomorphology. Bull. Geol. Soc. Am, v. 63, p. 923-938. 1952.
19 - STRECK, E. V.; KAMPF, N.; DALMOLIN, R. S.
D.; KLAMT, E.; NASCIMENTO, P. C.; SCHNEIDER, P. Solos do Rio Grande do Sul. Porto Alegre:
EMATER/RS, UFRGS, 2002. 107p.
20 - TEODORO, V. L. I.; TEIXEIRA, D.; COSTA,
D. J. L.; FULLER, B. B. O conceito de bacia hidrográfica e a importância da caracterização morfométrica para o entendimento da dinâmica ambiental local. Ver. Uniara, Araraquara, n. 20, 2007.
21 - TONELLO, K.C.; DIAS, H. C. T.; SOUZA, A.
L.; RIBEIRO, C. A. A. S.; FIRME, D. J.; LEITE,
F. P. Diagnóstico hidroambiental da bacia hidrográfica da Cachoeira das Pombas, município
de Guanhães, MG. Brasil. Ambi-Agua, Taubaté,
v. 4, n. 1, p. 156-168. 2009.
22 - TONIAL, T. M.; MISSIO, E.; SANTOS, J. E.
dos; HENKE-OLIVEIRA, C.; HOLZSCHUH,
M. L.; ZANG, N. Diagnóstico ambiental de unidades da paisagem da região Noroeste do Estado
do Rio Grande do Sul no período de 1984 a 1999.
Rev. Bras. Cartografia, Presidente Prudente, v.
57, n. 3, p. 213-225, 2005.
23 - TUCCI, C.E.M. Hidrologia: ciência e aplicação. Porto Alegre, RS. Porto Alegre: UFRGS/
Edusp/ABRH, 2001. 943p.
24
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 24
09/10/2012 13:43:54
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Structure of avian guilds in a bird fragment-corridor community in Lavras county, Minas Gerais, Brazil
Bruno Senna Corrêa - CEFET-MG - Campus IX Nepomuceno - Av. Monsenhor - Luiz de Gonzaga,
103 - Centro, Nepomuceno, MG, CEP: 37250-000. (bruno.senna@gmail.com)
Júlio Neil Cassa Louzada - UFLA – Caixa Postal 37 CEP 37200-000, Lavras, MG Campus Universitário, DBio
Setor Ecologia. (jlouzada@dbi.ufla.br)
Aloysio Souza Moura - Centro Universitário de Lavras “UNILAVRAS”, Caixa Postal 197, CEP 37200-000, Lavras, MG.
(thraupidaelo@yahoo.com.br)
ABSTRACT
Analysis was centered on avian guild structure of a community of birds in a forest
fragment|corridor|farming matrix complex in the Cerrado, in Lavras county, Minas
Gerais, Brazil (21o14’45’’S/44o59’51’’W). Samples were collected from eight semidecidual
forest fragments of 1,0 to 12,1 ha, connected by 5 hedgerow corridors bordered by an
adjacent agricultural matrix. The hypothesis to be tested was whether the distribution
of frequency, diversity and composition of the guilds was similar among the fragments,
ecological corridors and matrix. 176 bird species belonging to 44 families were recorded.
The main guilds recorded were insectivore, omnivore and granivore. The environments
sampled proved to be statistically dissimilar as to guild distribution and composition.
Composition can be altered by the various landscape components. As a whole, insectivore (68 species) and omnivore (53 species) guilds were predominant. Nevertheless,
the average number of species in both was higher in the matrix and corridors, than in
forest fragments. The latter, through functioning more as an efficient way of facilitating
the movement of generalist species can mask the reduction in regional species richness.
Key words: birds, forest fragments, avian guilds.
INTRODUCTION
Forest fragmentation, a historical process
in the Cerrado biome, increased in the 20th century due to agricultural expansion in the Brazilian
center-west. Among the outcomes of the consequential reduction in habitat, a decline in fauna and flora
diversity could be observed. Even though there still
are natural forest fragments in the Cerrado, it is not
known whether the influence of ecological processes
is similar to those observed in forest environments of
the Atlantic Rain Forest and the Amazon Forest. The
impact on tropical ecosystems originating from the
fragmentation process has led to alterations in various parameters which, in turn, have given rise to the
disappearance of insectivore guilds.(13). Notably, the
decline in these guilds in small forest fragments is
more strongly related to the capacity for dispersion
by way of anthropic matrices than to the low availability of food resources (29).
Research related to forest fragmentation
involves the theory of isle biogeography and metapopulation dynamics (19). The former defines a
diminishing in isle surface or fragments as being
associated to an exponential decrease in the number
of species, and the reduction in interspecies relationships (17). The formation of metapopulations is
favored by habitat fragmentation, with each species
occurring in a fragment, even though these populations can also occur in continuous habitats. The
theory of metapopulations has supplanted that of
isle biogeography through its potential to explain
the dynamics of populations in fragmented areas.
25
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 25
09/10/2012 13:43:54
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Forest mosaics or fragmentation can cause
profound impacts on species that require large areas
for survival. These, known as interior species, tend
to quickly disappear in deforested or impacted areas.
Meanwhile, under these circumstances, other species adapted to margin or ECOTONE conditions become dominant. Interior species can be maintained
through adequate management, to so guarantee immigration from larger contiguous areas (17). From
studies dealing with fragmented environments, it can
be inferred that parameters, such as area (3), format
and isolation, exert an influence on the distribution
of the flora and the movement of wild fauna (28).
Other ecological aspects of vegetal structures, such as succession stage, vertical stratification
and heterogeneity, comprise important parameters
in the determination of environmental avian guild
OBJECTIVE
In the present work, the response of the different avian guilds to the elements of a fragmented
agricultural landscape was evaluated. The hypothesis to be tested was that the distribution of avian
guild frequency, diversity and composition between
forest fragments, ecological corridors and matrix
remains unchanged.
METHODOLOGY
Study site
The corridor-fragment studied is located in Lavras county, the Alto Rio Grande
region, in the south of Minas Gerais State
(21º17’15.1”S/44°58’59.3”W) (Figure 1).
M2
M1
M3
M5
M4
Environments
Áreas
(ha)
Physiognomy
Successional
stage
Fragment
diversity (21).
Piratelli & Pereira (2002) emphasized
Florest
F1
7,19
Semid seas for
Secondary
F2
11,84 avian
Semidguilds,
seas for
the importance
of studying
asSecondary
a source
F3
1,03
Semid seas for
Secondary
7,36
Semid seas for
Secondary
of relevantF4F5 data on community
trophic
as
7,80
Semid
seas for structures,
Secondary
F6
12,40
Semid seas for
Secondary
F7
2,25
Semid seas for
Secondary
well as abiotic
parameters.
AsSemidregards
small
F8
1,25
seas for
SecondaryfragCorridors
C1
0,2
Semidthe
seas for quality
Secondary
ments, even
though
connected,
of the
C2
0,28
Semid seas for
Secondary
C3
0,44
Semid seas for
Secondary
habitat may
be poor, and,
the
association
C4
0,12 with
Semid
seas for
Secondary of a
C5
0,72
Semid seas for
Secondary
Matrix
reduced area
with
anthropic
disturbance
in
the surM1
71,0
Anthropized field
Secondary
M2
27,0
Agríc cultivation
Secondary
24,0
Cerrado
Secondary
roundings,M3
viz., fire, agricultural
defensives,
invadM4
28,0
Cerrado
Secondary
M5
93,0
Anthropized field
Secondary
ing vegetal
species,
etc.,
the
occurrence
of
popula51,16
Total fragments
1,76
Total corridors
243,0
Total matrix
tions could
become
unfeasible,
or there might even
295,92
Total
be the exclusion of certain ecological groups (18).
Points shown
Sampling
area (m2)
Altitude
Coordinates
The study site is located around 6 km from
965 m
21 17’28’’S/44 59’13’’W
8
2513 m
Lavras,
onm the slopes
of the21 Serra
do Carrapato. In
971 m
17’43’’S/44 59’40’’W
8
2513
977 m
21 17’51’’S/44 59’13’’W
8
2513 m
973 m
21 18’08’’S/44 59’48’’W
8
2513 m
all,
there
eight
(F), 59’16’’W
interlinked by a
977 mfragments
21 18’13’’S/44
8
2513are
m
996 m
21 19’01’’S/44 59’47’’W
8
2513 m
990
m
21
19’01’’S/44
59’47’’W
8
2513
m
vegetal
corridor 1044
(C)m composed
of a main axis and
21 19’13’’S/44 59’32’’W
8
2513 m
four
branches
(Figure),
in which
seven
960 m
21 17’39’’S/44
59’10’’W of the frag8
628 m
985 m
21 17’38’’S/44 59’24’’W
8
628 m
996 m
21 17’58’’S/44 59’41’’W
8
628 m
ments
present
an interior
river
course, within an ag991 m
21 18’17’’S/44 59’29’’W
8
628 m
1002 m
21 18’43’’S/44 59’35’’W
8
628 m
ricultural
matrix
(old
regional
farming properties).
985 m
21 17’46’’S/44 59’23’’W
8
10053 m
980 m
21 17’33’’S/44 59’28’’W
8
10053 m
The
total
of 997
them properties
is 51,1624
ha, vary21 17’50’’S/44
59’43’’W
8
10053area
m
934 m
21 18’33’’S/44 59’53’’W
8
10053 m
1022 m
8
10053 m
O 21 18’49’’S/44 59’19’’W
O
ing
from
1,0302
ha
(21
17’51’’S/44
59’13’’W)
to
64
20104 m
40
3140 m
O
O
40
50265
m
12,40 ha
(21 19’01’’S/44 59’47’’W). The corridors
144
73509 m
dealt with in the present study are defined as lin2
O
O
2
O
O
2
O
O
2
O
O
2
O
O
2
O
O
2
O
O
2
O
O
2
O
O
2
O
O
2
O
O
2
O
O
2
O
O
2
O
O
2
O
O
2
O
O
2
O
O
2
O
O
2
2
2
2
26
R=
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 26
rb– rw___
N(N – 1)/4
09/10/2012 13:43:54
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
eal vegetal structures of various origins, of reduced
width (between 3 and 6 meters), which can be connected to various-sized fragments (6).
In the area studied, it was possible to
identify: a) a farming matrix (M), comprising
annual cultures, i.e., corn, soybean and beans,
among others, planted pasture (Brachiaria spp.)
for raising cattle, and
M2 natural farmland. Through
dealing with a fragmented area, the matrix was
defined as any farming area, without any form
of forest formation, such as forest fragments or
vegetal corridors, since, M1
from the beginning of
M3
th
the 20 century, these phytophysiognomies have
been gradually substituted by open areas, due to
the regional expansion of agriculture; b) corridors
of regenerating (30 years) arboreal vegetation
occurring in hollows; c) portions of mosaic type
M5
habitat, consisting of secondary stage cerrado
M4
vegetation in the broad sense, secondary stage
man-formed galleries and patches of secondary
stage semideciduous forest (6).
The climate of the region can be defined as
of the Köppen Cwa type, with an average annual
rainfall of 1.529,7 mm, and an average annual temperature of 19,4°C (5). The minimum altitude is 920
meters and the maximum 1.180 meters.
Environments
Fragment
Florest
F1
F2
F3
F4
F5
F6
F7
F8
Corridors
C1
C2
C3
C4
C5
Matrix
M1
M2
M3
M4
M5
Total fragments
Total corridors
Total matrix
Total
to a total of 132 days (924 hours) of field work.
Work began at 5:30 a.m. and finished around 9:30
a.m. The visits took place twice a week, at twilight (4:00 p.m. to 7:00 p.m.). One and the same
point was visited only once a day. The identification of species and the nomenclature used was
according to basic references on the birds encountered in the Comitê Brasileiro de Registros
Ornitológicos (2011).
One of the parameters used for studying
bird communities in closed environments is the
composition of avian guilds (24). Trophic category
analysis was applied to understanding bird community composition patterns within the system fragme
nt|corridor|matrix.
For guild characterization, information on
the foraging form was used, whence, according to
Pimm (1991), guilds could be defined as: Carnivores, Frugivores, Granivores, Insectivores, Nectarivores, Omnivores and Piscivores.
In order to discern the differences in interenvironment guild composition, data was submitted to NMDS (nonmetric multi-dimensional scaling) analysis. Accordingly, the program is applied
to calculating similarity among samples, by cartesian grouping of the more similar points, as to
Áreas
(ha)
Physiognomy
Successional
stage
Points shown
Sampling
area (m2)
Altitude
Coordinates
7,19
11,84
1,03
7,36
7,80
12,40
2,25
1,25
Semid seas for
Semid seas for
Semid seas for
Semid seas for
Semid seas for
Semid seas for
Semid seas for
Semid seas for
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
2513 m2
2513 m2
2513 m2
2513 m2
2513 m2
2513 m2
2513 m2
2513 m2
965 m
971 m
977 m
973 m
977 m
996 m
990 m
1044 m
21O17’28’’S/44O59’13’’W
21O17’43’’S/44O59’40’’W
21O17’51’’S/44O59’13’’W
21O18’08’’S/44O59’48’’W
21O18’13’’S/44O59’16’’W
21O19’01’’S/44O59’47’’W
21O19’01’’S/44O59’47’’W
21O19’13’’S/44O59’32’’W
0,2
0,28
0,44
0,12
0,72
Semid seas for
Semid seas for
Semid seas for
Semid seas for
Semid seas for
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
8
8
8
8
8
628 m2
628 m2
628 m2
628 m2
628 m2
960 m
985 m
996 m
991 m
1002 m
21O17’39’’S/44O59’10’’W
21O17’38’’S/44O59’24’’W
21O17’58’’S/44O59’41’’W
21O18’17’’S/44O59’29’’W
21O18’43’’S/44O59’35’’W
71,0
27,0
24,0
28,0
93,0
51,16
1,76
243,0
295,92
Anthropized field
Agríc cultivation
Cerrado
Cerrado
Anthropized field
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
8
8
8
8
8
64
40
40
144
10053 m2
10053 m2
10053 m2
10053 m2
10053 m2
20104 m2
3140 m2
50265 m2
73509 m2
985 m
980 m
997 m
934 m
1022 m
21O17’46’’S/44O59’23’’W
21O17’33’’S/44O59’28’’W
21O17’50’’S/44O59’43’’W
21O18’33’’S/44O59’53’’W
21O18’49’’S/44O59’19’’W
guild composition and abundance (7). This method
Sampling Planning
The Point (32) Sampling Method, with was basically used to represent differences in guild
10 minutes per point, was used for qualitative and composition in fragment, corridor and matrix environments. The Bray-Cutis similarity index was
R = rb– rw___
quantitative surveying.
used for analysis.
N(N – 1)/4
Observations were carried out three times
One-way ANOSIM testing was used to
a week, between February and December, 2005,
27
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 27
09/10/2012 13:43:54
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
8
8
8
8
8
628 m2
628 m2
628 m2
628 m2
628 m2
71,0
27,0
24,0
28,0
93,0
1,16
1,76
43,0
95,92
Anthropized field
Agríc cultivation
Cerrado
Cerrado
Anthropized field
Secondary
8
10053 m2
960 m
985 m
996 m
991 m
1002 m
21O17’39’’S/44O59’10’’W
21O17’38’’S/44O59’24’’W
21O17’58’’S/44O59’41’’W
21O18’17’’S/44O59’29’’W
21O18’43’’S/44O59’35’’W
985 m
21O17’46’’S/44O59’23’’W
21O17’33’’S/44O59’28’’W
21O17’50’’S/44O59’43’’W
21O18’33’’S/44O59’53’’W
21O18’49’’S/44O59’19’’W
Secondary
8
10053 m
980 m
BrazilianSecondary
Journal of Ecology
ISSN
1516-5868
997 m
8
10053 m
2
2
Secondary
Secondary
8
8
64
40
40
144
10053 m2
10053 m2
20104 m2
3140 m2
50265 m2
73509 m2
934 m
1022 m
statistically verify the differences among groups
formed by NMDS. This is a nonparametric test
which, based on Bray-Curtis similarity (7), furnishes a way of testing whether there is a significant
difference between two or more groups, according
to the formula:
R=
rb– rw___
N(N – 1)/4
0.12
omnivores.
-0.24
0.06
-0.16
-0.08
0.12
-0.06
Coordinate 2
Semid seas for
Semid seas for
Semid seas for
Semid seas for
Semid seas for
0.08
0.16
0.24
0.32
0.4
0.06
-0.12
-0.24
-0.16
-0.08
-0.18
Coordinate 2
0,2
0,28
0,44
0,12
0,72
0.08
0.16
0.24
0.32
0.4
-0.06
-0.24
-0.12
-0.3
-0.18
-0.36
rb average of all the distances among the groups
r w average of all the distances within the groups
N: samples
-0.24
-0.3
Coordinate 1
-0.36
Figure 2. NMDS testing
of inter-environment guilds
(species diversity) (Symbols: + = fragment; o =
The SIMPER (Analysis of similarity of percentages) test was used for examining the inter-environment contribution of each group, according to
Bray-Curtis dissimilarity, and to determine the contribution of each to intra- environment similarity (7).
Coordinate 1
corridor; ▲ = matrix).
Figure 2. NMDS testing of inter-environment guilds
(species diversity) (Symbols: + = fragment; o =
corridor; ▲ = matrix).
0.36
RESULTS
0.24
Coordinate 2
0.36
0.18
0.3
0.12
0.24
0.06
0.18
Coordinate 2
176 bird species belonging to 44 families
were registered. The main guilds were comprised
of insectivores, omnivores and granivores
.
The insectivore guild presented the highest species richness with 68 species (38,0%) in
fragment environments. Insectivore species richness was similar to that of omnivores in corridor
environments (18 species each {10%}). As to the
matrix environment, there was a reduction in insectivore species richness (21 species) in relation
to omnivore (23 species). Behavior of the omnivore guild was the contrary to that of insectivores. There was a gradual rise in omnivore species richness matrixwise. In general, granivore
species richness was inferior (22 species), followed by nectarivores (12 species), carnivores (11
species), frugivores (10 species) and piscivores (3
species). Distribution in the matrix was different
from that of the other environments. In fragments
and corridors distribution was more grouped
(Figures 2 and 3). In axis 1, the omnivore guild
contributed to the overall appearance of the fragment-corridor-matrix grid. In axis 2, there were
differences in distribution among fragments, corridors and matrix. Once again, the greater contribution towards these differences came from the
0.3
-0.5
-0.4
-0.3
-0.2
-0.1
0.12
-0.06
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.06
-0.12
-0.5
-0.4
-0.3
-0.2
-0.18
-0.1
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
-0.06
Coordinat e 1
-0.12
Figure 3. NMDS testing of inter-environment
guilds (number of
-0.18
individuals) (Symbols: + = fragment; o = corridor; ▲ =
matrix).
Coordinat e 1
Analysis of similarity (ANOSIM) detected
significant differences among the inter-environment
individuals) (Symbols: + = fragment; o = corridor; ▲ =
guilds studied, both by species (r = 0.67, P=0.0001,
average matrix).
dissimilarity =27.4), and individuals (r
= 0.53; P<0.0001, average dissimilarity =34.2).
Significant differences of guilds among the
components of the system were obvious: Fragment
and Corridor by species (r = 0.46, P<0.012, average
dissimilarity=23.84); by individuals (r = 0.26, P<0.05,
average dissimilarity=26.02); Fragment and Matrix
by species (r = 0.70, P<0.001, average dissimilarity
=29.83); by individuals (r = 0.76, P<0.008, average
Figure 3. NMDS testing of inter-environment guilds (number of
28
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 28
09/10/2012 13:43:54
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
dissimilarity=42.13); Corridor and Matrix by species
(r = 0.91, P<0.007, average dissimilarity=29.81); by
individuals (r = 0.66, P<0.008, average dissimilarity
= 35.81). The aim was to evaluate the importance of
the guilds (Table 2).
among the three cited environments, with higher
average abundance in corridors (106) than in matrices
(93.6) and fragments (76.3) (Table 4).
Species
Interactions
Fragment x Corridor
Fragment x Matrix
Corridor x Matrix
R
0.46
P
0.011
Average
dissimilarity
22.84
0.70
0.001
29.83
0.91
0.007
29.81
R
P
0.26
0.0448
0.76
0.0008
0.66
0.0079
Individuals
Average dissimilarity
26.02
42.13
35.81
On separating the 3 environments
DISCUSSION
evaluated, viz., fragments, corridors and matrices,
SIMPER species analysis showed that the
Among the environments studied, the maAverage
Average
Average
insectivore guild presented the most expressive
trix abundance
was clearly
dissimilar
to fragments
and corabundance
abundance in
in
result, 10.98 (40.44% accumulated). The average
as regards aviancorridors
guild structure,
frequency
in matrices
fragments
Guilds
Contribution
% Accumulated ridors,
abundance
of insectivore 10.98
species was
greater
Species
Individuals
Insectivores
40.44 in
27.8 The guilds
14 greatest relative
13.6 imand diversity.
with
Average
Average
dissimilarity
fragments
(27.8)
than
in
corridors
(14)
and
matrices
Omnivores
4.13
55.67
13.2
portance15.4
in the matrix
were
the insectivore19.2
and omInteractions
R secondP most abundant
dissimilarity
R
P
(13.6).
Omnivores,
Frugivores as the 3.91
70.09
2.25
0.6
nivore, thus corroborating studies on
avian 7.8
guilds in
0.46
0.011
22.84
26.02
Fragment
x Corridor
0.26
0.0448
guild,
contributed
(15.23% accumulated).
Granivores with 4.1363.01
81.18
7.63
7.8The greater part
12.8of the
tropical environments
(23,9).
0.70
0.001
29.83
42.13
Fragment
x Matrix
0.76
0.0008
Average
omnivore abundance
higher insectivores
Carnivores
2.68 was a little 91.06
2.25 registered
1.4
6.4for the
presented preference
0.91
0.007
29.81
35.81
Corridor
x
Matrix
0.66
0.0079
in the matrix
(19.2) than in2.02
fragments (15.4)
Nectarivores
98.5and
6
matrix. 6.25
In tropical forests,8.2
the high percentage
of
100
0
0
0.8
corridorsPiscivores
(13.2) (Table 3). 0.40
insectivore bird species is common (9;26).
Guilds
Guilds
Insectivores
Omnivores
Granivores
Frugivores
Nectarivores
Granivores
Insetivores
Carnivores
Carnivores
Nectarivores
Frugivores
Piscivores
Piscivores
Omnivores
Average
Average
Average
Average
Average
Average
abundance
abundance in
abundance in
%
abundance
abundance in matrices
abundance
corridors
fragments
Contribution
% Accumulated
Contribution
Accumulated in27.8
fragments in 14
corridors
in13.6
matrices
10.98
40.44
13.19
9.83
3.91
3.31
3.01
3.29
2.68
2.09
2.02
1.69
0.40 0.09
4.13
39.35
68.68
70.09
78.57
81.18
88.40
91.06
94.66
98.5
99.72
100 100
55.67
SIMPER analysis by individuals presented
different results from those by species. The omnivore
guild contributed with 13.19 (39.3% accumulated)
towards distinction the 3 environments (fragments,
%
corridors
and
matrices)
evaluated.
Average
omnivore
Guilds
Contribution Accumulated
abundance
was
higher
in
matrices
(191)
than in
Omnivores
13.19
39.35
corridors (107) and fragments
(73.8). Granivores
Granivores
9.83
68.68
contributed with 9.83 (29.33%) towards distinction
Nectarivores
Insetivores
Carnivores
Frugivores
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd
Piscivores
29
3.31
3.29
2.09
1.69
0.09
78.57
88.40
94.66
99.72
100
73.8
76.3
2.25
21
7.63
40.5
2.25
12.1
6.25
6.88
0 0
15.4
107
106
0.6
43.4
7.8
50.2
1.4
4.2
8.2
5
0 0
13.2
191
93.6
7.8
21
12.8
23
6.4
22.6
6
16
0.8 1
19.2
Among insectivore guilds, most were Passeriformes (72,4%), with a predominance of species
from the families Tyrannidae (21,7%) and FurnariAverage
Average
idaeAverage
(18,8%). With the
exception of insectivores
abundance
abundance
abundance
and omnivores, the matrix environment is normally
in fragments
corridors
in matrices
associated
to places in
which
offer little attraction
to
73.8
107
birds in fragmented landscapes (12). There 191
was a
76.3in the relative importance
106
93.6
reduction
of insectivore
21
40.5
12.1
6.88
0
43.4
50.2
4.2
5
0
21
2329
22.6
16
09/10/2012
1
13:43:55
Granivores
3.01
81.18
Carnivores
2.68
91.06
Nectarivores
2.02
98.5
Piscivores
0.40
100
0
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Guilds
Omnivores
Granivores
Nectarivores
Insetivores
Carnivores
Frugivores
Piscivores
Contribution
13.19
9.83
3.31
3.29
2.09
1.69
0.09
%
Accumulated
39.35
68.68
78.57
88.40
94.66
99.72
100
and omnivore guilds, in corridor environments.
Corridors, besides contributing towards reducing
the isolation of these and other guilds, makes the
conservation of diversity in farming areas possible
(1). The use of corridors, by way of perches, shelters
and food resources (33), facilitates the slightly more
efficient distribution of forest bird guilds (11, 14, 16)
Generally speaking, forest fragments presented low insectivore diversity, possibly related to
variations in their structure (4). According to Ribon et al. (2003) and Develey & Metzger (2005), as
habitat-specialist bird guilds are more sensitive to
alterations in landscape elements, such as fragmentation, this could possibly account for local extinction. These aspects are thus relevant for enlightenment on the use of the most appropriate landscape
elements for each guild.
.
As regards matrix environments, normally,
omnivore guilds are the most relatively important,
followed by granivores. In the present case, omnivore guilds were the most abundant (15.23%). This
guild was mainly formed by Passeriformes (75,4%),
predominantly by species of the family Thraupidae
(24,5%). The greater omnivore density in relation
to granivores presumes that alterations in a landscape are capable of inducing structural changes
in the environment, which would reflect on local
bird-guild abundance. Corroborating Willis (1976),
the increase in omnivores is expected in small environments, since omnivorousness would have a buffer effect against fluctuations in the available food
supply thereabouts. Habitat structure is a relevant
factor in the composition of bird-guild communities
in tropical environments (30). MacArthur & Whitmore (1979) noted that, depending on its size, guild
7.63
7.8
12.8
2.25
1.4
6.4
6.25
8.2
6
0
0.8
Average
abundance
in fragments
73.8
76.3
21
40.5
12.1
6.88
0
Average
abundance
in corridors
107
106
43.4
50.2
4.2
5
0
Average
abundance
in matrices
191
93.6
21
23
22.6
16
1
diversity in a forest fragment can endure distance
from a source and the prevailing habitat structure.
As regards the fragment environment, granivore guilds were relatively the most important,
followed by the omnivores. Marini (2001) also registered the highest diversity of granivores in small
forest patches of the cerrado. On the contrary, in the
corridor environment, the omnivore guild presented
the highest relative importance, followed by the granivores. In the highly man-formed environments,
omnivore guilds were on the increase (23). In the
matrix environments, granivore guilds presented
the highest relative importance, followed by the omnivores. A guild distribution pattern in relation to
the three environments sampled became apparent.
This pattern indicated that guilds that are the most
adaptable to an environment, and to establishing
therein, are those capable of movement among landscape elements (31) (Figure 4). All the environments
sampled appeared to undergo direct influence from
the matrix. Through being reduced environments (1
to 12 ha), fragments functioned as islands, with the
available resources limited to some, less sensitive,
groups. Apparently, certain factors, such as original
habitat loss and a reduction in remnants (2), are limiting factors to the presence of certain groups.
.
Guild distribution in the environments under study seemed to be linked to bird community
composition and the physical structure of the vegetal
mosaic. As to individuals, omnivore and granivore
guilds were apparently predominant in corridors and
matrices. The low frugivore density could be related
to seasonal variation in the offer of fruits, and the dependency on fruits and insects (15). Semi-dependent
insectivore guilds were observed in several frag-
30
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 30
09/10/2012 13:43:55
vores
vores
vores
2.09
94.66
12.1
4.2
22.6
1.69
99.72
6.88
5 Average
16 Average
Average
0.09
100
0%
0 abundance 1 abundance
abundance
Guilds
Contribution Accumulated in fragments in corridors
in matrices
Omnivores
13.19
39.35
73.8
107
191
Granivores
9.83
68.68
76.3
106
93.6 Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Brazilian
Nectarivores
3.31
78.57
21
43.4
21
Insetivores
3.29
88.40
40.5
50.2
23
granívoros. Os ambientes amostrados são
ments and corridors.
The 94.66
capacity of dispersion
of 4.2 onívoros, 22.6
Carnivores
2.09
12.1
Frugivores
1.69 favored by
99.72
6.88and avail- 5 estatisticamente
16
dissimilares para a distribuição e
these groups was
the structure
Piscivores
0.09
100
0
0
1
ability of landscape elements.
.
composição das guildas. A composição das guildas
é alterada pelos diferentes componentes da paisagem. Houve predomínio das guildas de insetívoros
(68 espécies) e de onívoros (53 espécies), de maneira
geral. Contudo, a média de espécies da guilda de
onívoros e granívoros foi maior na matriz e nos corredores que nos fragmentos. Os corredores ecológicos funcionam de maneira eficiente para o deslocamento de espécies generalistas, fato que pode
mascarar a redução da riqueza de espécies na área.
Palavras chave: aves, fragmentos florestais, guildas alimentares.
REFERENCES
Figure 4. Relative abundance of bird guilds in the three
environments.
CONCLUSION
The response of the various avian guilds to
the elements of a fragmented agricultural landscape
showed the importance of insectivores in the separation of the three environments evaluated, viz., fragments, corridors and matrices. On considering species
and individual analysis, it was noted that the distribution of frequency was not the same, the distribution of
diversity remained the same, and avian guild composition was not maintained among the three.
RESUMO
Foi analisada a estrutura de guildas alimentares na comunidade de aves num sistema
fragmento-corredor-matriz em ambiente de Cerrado, no município de Lavras, Minas Gerais
(21o14’45’’S/44o59’51’’W). Foram amostrados oito
(8) fragmentos de floresta estacional semidecidual de 1,0 a 12,1 ha, conectados por 5 corredores
ecológicos delimitados por uma matriz agrícola
adjacente. A hipótese a ser testada é se a distribuição da freqüência, diversidade e composição das
guildas alimentares é similar entre os fragmentos,
corredores ecológicos e matriz. Foram registradas
176 espécies de aves, pertencentes a 44 famílias.
As principais guildas registradas foram insetívoros,
1- ARAÚJO GABRIEL, V de. Uso de cercas vivas por aves em uma paisagem fragmentada de
mata atlântica semidecídua. 2005. 77 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Ciências Biológicas) - Universidade Estadual Paulista “Júlio de Mesquita
Filho”, Campus de Rio Claro. 2005.
2- BENNET, A. Habitat fragmentation. In: ATTIWILL, P.; WILSON, B. (Org.). Ecology an Australian perspective. Oxford: Oxford University,
2003. p. 440-456.
3- BIERREGAARD JUNIOR, R.O.; STOUFFER,
P.C. Understory birds and dynamic habitat
mosaics in Amazonian rainforest. In: LAURANCE, W. F.; BIERREGAARD JUNIOR, R. O.
(Org.). Tropical forest remnants: ecology, management, and consevation of fragmented communities. Chicago: University of Chicago, 1997.
p 138-155.
4- BLAKE, J. G.; LOISELLE, B. A.. Variation in
resource abundance affects capture rates of
birds in 3 lowland habitats in Costa Rica. Auk,
Albuquerque, v. 108, n. 1, p. 114-130, 1991.
5- BRASIL. Ministério da agricultura e reforma
agrária. Departamento Nacional de Meteorologia. Normas climatológicas: 1961-1990. Brasília: Editora da Universidade de Brasília, 1992.
132 p.
6- CASTRO, G. C. Análise da estrutura, diversidade
florística e variações espaciais do componente
arbóreo de corredores de vegetação na região do
Alto Rio Grande, MG. 2004. 83 f. Dissertação
(Mestrado em Engenharia Florestal) – Universi-
31
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 31
09/10/2012 13:43:57
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
dade Federal de Lavras, Brasil. 2004.
7- CLARKE, K. R. Non-parametric multivariate
analysis of changes in community structure.
Australian Journal of Ecology, Canberra, v. 18,
n. 1, p. 117-143, 1993.
8- COMITÊ BRASILEIRO DE REGISTROS ORNITOLÓGICOS. Listas das aves do Brasil.
2011. Versão 24/02/2005. Disponível em: <http://
www.cbro.org.br>. Acesso em: [02 abril. 2011].
9- DARIO, F. R. Influência de corredor florestal
entre fragmentos da mata atlântica utilizando-se
a avifauna como indicador ecológico. 1999. 172
f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Ciências) – Escola
Superior de Agricultura “Luiz de Queiroz”, Universidade de São Paulo. Brasil. 1999.
10-DEVELEY, P. F.; METZGER, J. P. Birds in
Atlantic forest landscapes: effects of forest
cover and configuration. In: LAURANCE, W;
PERES, C. A. (Org.). Emerging threats to tropical forests. Chicago: University of Chicago,
2005. p. 269-289.
11-ESTRADA, A.; COATES-ESTRADA, R.;
MERITT JUNIOR, D. A. Anthropogenic landscape changes and avian diversity at Los Tuxtlas, Mexico. Biodiversity and Conservation,
London, v. 6, n. 1, p. 19-43, 1997.
12-ESTRADA, A.; CAMMARANO, P.; COATESESTRADA, R. Bird species richness in vegetation fences and in strips residual rain forest vegetation at Los Tuxtlas, Mexico. Biodiversity and
Conservation, London, v. 9, n. 10, p. 1399-1416,
2000.
13-FORD, H. A.; BARRET, G.; SAUNDERS, D.;
RECHER, H. Why have birds in the woodlands
of Southern Australia declined? Biological Conservation, Cambridge, v. 97, n. 1, p. 71-88, 2001.
14-GIMENES, M. R.; ANJOS, L. Efeitos da fragmentação florestal sobre as comunidades de
aves. Acta Scientiarum Biological Sciences,
Maringá, v. 25, n. 2, p. 391-402, 2003.
15-GOMES, V. S. M.; SILVA, W. R. Spatial variation in understory frugivorous birds in an Atlantic Forest fragment of southeastern Brazil. Revista Brasileira de Ornitologia, Ararajuba, Rio
de Janeiro, v. 10, n. 2, p. 219-225, 2002.
16-HADDAD, N.; BOWNE, D. R.; CUNNINGHAM, A.; DANIELSON, B. J.; LEVEY, D. J.;
SARGENT, S.; SPIRA, T. Corridor use by diverse taxa. Ecology, Amsterdam, v. 84, n. 3, p.
609-615, 2003.
17-HANSKI, I.; GILPIN, M.E. Metapopulation dynamics: brief history and conceptual domain. In:
HANSKI, I.; GILPIN, M.E. (Org.). Metapopulation dynamics: empirical and theoretical investigations. London: Academic, 1991. p. 3-16.
18-JANSEN, D.H. The eternal external threat. In:
SOULÉ, M.E (Org.). Conservation biology: the
science of scarcity and diversity. Dordrecht:
Sinauer Associates, 1986. p. 286-303.
19-KORMAN, V. Proposta de integração das glebas do Parque Estadual de Vassununga, Santa
Rita do Passa Quatro, SP. 2003. 131 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Ecologia de Agroecossistemas) – Escola Superior de Agricultura “Luiz de
Queiroz”, Universidade de São Paulo, Piracicaba. Brasil. 2003.
20-MAC ARTHUR, R. H.; WHITMORE, R. C.
Passerine community composition and diversity in man-altered environments. Morgantown,
West Virginia, n. 7, v. 1, p. 1-12, 1979.
21-MARINI, M. A. Efeitos da fragmentação florestal sobre as aves de Minas Gerais. In: SANTOSALVES, M. A.; SILVA, J. M. C.; SLUYS, M.;
BERGALLO, H. G.; ROCHA, C. F. D. (Org.). A
ornitologia no Brasil: pesquisa atual e perspectivas. Rio de Janeiro: UERJ, 2000. p. 41-54.
22-MARINI, M. A. Effects of forest fragmentation
on birds of the cerrado region, Brazil. Bird Conservation International, Cambridge, n. 1, v. 11,
p. 11-23, 2001.
23-MOTTA JÚNIOR, J.C. Estrutura trófica e composição das avifaunas de três habitats terrestres
na região central do Estado de São Paulo. Revista Brasileira de Ornitologia, Ararajuba, Rio
de Janeiro, v. 1, n. 6, p. 65-71, 1990.
24-PIMM, S.L. The balance of nature?: ecological
issues in the conservation of species and communities. Chicago: University of Chicago, 1991.
448 p.
25-PIRATELLI, A.; PEREIRA, M.R. Dieta de aves
na região leste de Mato Grosso do Sul, Brasil.
Revista Brasileira de Ornitologia, Ararajuba,
Rio de Janeiro, v. 10, n. 2, p. 131-139, 2002.
26-POZZA, D.D. Composição da avifauna da Estação Ecológica de São Carlos (Brotas-SP) e
reserva ambiental da fazenda Santa Cecília (Patrocínio Paulista-SP), São Carlos-SP. 2002. 89 f.
Dissertação (Mestrado em Ecologia e Recursos
Naturais) - Universidade Federal de São Carlos,
São Carlos. 2002.
32
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 32
09/10/2012 13:43:57
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
27-RIBON, R.; SIMON, J. E.; MATTOS, G. T.
Bird extinctions in Atlantic Forest Fragments of
Viçosa Region, Southeastern Brazil. Conservation Biology, Malden, v. 17, n. 6, p. 1827-1839,
2003.
28-SAUNDERS, D. A.; HOBBS, R. J. Nature conservation 2: the role of corridors. Chipping Norton: Surrey Beatty & Sons Pty, 1991. 442 p.
29-SEKERCIOGLU, C. H.; EHRLICH, P.; DAILY,
G. C.; AYGEN, D.; GOEHRING, D.; SANDI,
R. F. Disappearance of insectivorous birds from
tropical forest fragments. PNAS, Oklahoma
City, v. 99, n. 1, p. 263-267, 2002.
30 -TERBORGH, J. Habitat selection in Amazonian
birds. In: CODY, M.L. (Org.). Habitat selection
in birds. New York: Academic, 1985. p. 311-338.
31-UEZU, A.; METZGER, J. P.; VIELLIARD, J. M.
E. Effects on structural and functional connec-
tivity and patch size on the abundance of seven
Atlantic Forest bird species. Biological Conservation, Cambridge, v. 123, n. 4, p. 507-519, 2005.
32-VIELLIARD, J; SILVA, W. R. Nova metodologia de levantamento quantitativo e primeiros
resultados no interior do Estado de São Paulo.
In: ENCONTRO NACIONAL DE ANILHADORES DE AVES, 4, 1989, Recife. Anais... Recife: UFRPe, 1989. p. 117-151.
33-WEGNER, J. F.; MERRIAM, G. Movements by
birds and small mammals between a wood and
adjoining farmland habitats. Journal of Applied
Ecology, Oxford, v. 16, n. 1, p. 349-357, 1979.
34-WILLIS, E. O. Effects of a cold wave on an Amazonia avifauna in the upper Paraguay Drainage, western Mato Grosso, and suggestions on
oscine-suboscine relationships. Acta Amazonia,
Manaus, v. 6, n. 3, p. 379-394, 1976.
33
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 33
09/10/2012 13:43:57
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
34
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 34
09/10/2012 13:43:57
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Emergence and growth of Ateleia glazioveana Baill. seedlings in direct sowing in an early secondary succession stage
Ana Claudia Escaio - Universidade Regional do Noroeste do Estado do Rio Grande do Sul, Depto. de Biologia e Química, bolsista PET/SESu/MEC (acescaio@gmail.com)
Geodeli Adelita Penz Corrêa - Universidade Regional do Noroeste do Estado do Rio Grande do Sul, bolsista PET/SESu/MEC, Depto. de Biologia e Química (geodelli@yahoo.com.br)
Jonas Darci Noronha de Lima - Universidade Regional do Noroeste do Estado do Rio Grande do Sul,
Depto. de Biologia e Química (jonasnoronha@yahoo.com.br)
* Geraldo Ceni Coelho – Universidade Federal da Fronteira Sul (cenicoelho@gmail.com)
ABSTRACT
Ateleia glazioveana Baill. (Fabaceae), a pioneer tree species from south and southeastern
Brazil, reaches a high population density in Seasonal Forests. The aim was to analyze the
emergence, growth and survival of A. glazioveana seedlings under natural conditions.
The experiment was installed in an eleven-year-old post-agricultural site, with herbaceous vegetation in an early stage of secondary succession. The plots measured 2 x 3 m,
with four random replications in four blocks. The experimental design was factorial 2 x 2
x 2, in two different conditions of vegetation management (with and without the removal
of herbaceous and shrubby plants), two levels of fertilizer (with and without the addition
of 33 g/m 2 of NPK 4:20:12), and with and without seed sowing. Each plot received 200
seeds, i.e., 33 seeds/m2. Dates of emergence and survival were recorded at the second,
fifth and twelfth months. Growth data (height and diameter) were obtained after 12
months. Spontaneous emergence was nil. Emergence from direct sowing reached a total
of 48 (1.5%) seedlings after two months, and 77 (2.4%) after 12 months, from which 56
survived ,viz. 5,833 per hectare. Although the removal of vegetation had no effect on
seedling height and survival, diameters were increased. Moreover, differences with the
addition of fertilizer were insignificant. The average height was 11.96 cm (± 4.08). Direct sowing was viable. Even so, frost damage after the winter of 2010 was general, thus
indicating the possibility of microclimate limitations to recruitment.
Key words: secondary succession, Forest restoration, Semideciduous Seasonal Forest.
INTRODUCTION
Although pre-colonial cover by Subtropical
Semideciduous Forest was 1,000,000 km2, including
Brazil, Argentina and Paraguay, nowadays this has
been reduced to only 6% of the original area (4). The
remnants present high reduction and fragmentation,
with an expressive degree of isolation (23).
Forest fragmentation leads to significant
modifications in the composition, structure and dy-
namics of local communities and populations, with
a corresponding reduction in species habitat and
ecological niche (19). Forest restoration could be
helpful in reducing wild ecosystem fragmentation,
promoting the improvement of degraded areas, and
recovering environmental services. Seedling planting with a combination of tree species from different successional groups, is a frequently used method
for restoring forest cover (16,15, 24). Notwithstanding, direct sowing and spontaneous regeneration are
35
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 35
09/10/2012 13:43:57
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
promising alternatives for minimizing costs, and
making restoration feasible from a socioeconomic
point of view (10). Direct sowing is particularly
recommended for both pioneer and early secondary
species, and for sites without vegetal cover. It is also
recommended for late successional species in secondary forest enrichment (15).
Secondary succession is the transformation, over time, of the community structure, following a local disturbance (13). The first species
to colonize a given site are denominated pioneers.
Pioneers are capable of facilitating, hindering, or
simply playing a neutral role, in the settlement and
growth of other species (9).
Plant population renewal or recruitment
presents a series of limitations. These limiting
factors can be divided into three groups, namely
source and fecundity, dispersion and establishment.
The source and fecundity refers to limitations in
seed production by adult plants. Such limitations
could be related to climate variation (lack or excess
of rain, late frosts, etc.) or biotic factors (lack of
pollinators and flowers, or fruit predation). Moreover, seed availability, besides being variable year
to year, is also affected by landscape structure and
the size of neighboring, wild remnant vegetation.
Dispersion efficiency depends on the available dispersion agents and propagule quality (8). A. glazioveana is wind-dispersed, so that the force, amount
and direction of the winds are all determinant for
dispersion efficiency.
Establishment factors refer to seedling survival and development. Losses throughout the process could be due to predation, competition or the
inadaptability of seedlings to local ecological conditions. In the case of early succession stages in abandoned cropland (old-field succession), competition
with herbs and climbing plants could be the most
limiting factor for woody species (5). Herbaceous
vegetation withdrawal or topsoil removal could
improve the germination rates and early growth of
woody species (25,12).
Ateleia glazioveana Baill. (Fabaceae), a
pioneer tree species in Seasonal Subtropical Forest
and secondary forest formations in south and southeastern Brazil, Argentina (Misiones) and Paraguay,
is outstanding by its high-capacity to occupy sites
with adverse conditions. The fruit is an orbicular, sa-
maroid, indehiscent legume with only one seed that
reaches maturity between May and August. Dispersion is anemochoric (6). The species, through association with nitrogen fixative bacteria, provides an
excellent green manure. The foliage in dry matter
can reach 3.5 to 4.9 % of nitrogen (1). This species,
dominant in the first stages of forest succession, remains as a canopy component in the late succession
stages and frequently forms spontaneous monospecific stands denominated ‘timbozais’ in the vernacular (2). Thus, the presence and regeneration of A.
glazioveana can play a key role in nutrient cycling
processes and the recruitment of other species.
The aim was to evaluate spontaneous and
induced recruitment through the direct sowing of
A. glazioveana seeds under various management
conditions. The experiment was carried out in an
11-year-old post-agricultural site with herbaceous
vegetation in an early stage of secondary succession. The spontaneous emergence of other tree species was also quantified.
METHODOLOGY
Study site
The experiment was carried out in a forest remnant named ‘Mato do Silva’, in Chiapetta,
State of Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil (27° 55’ 02” S
and 53° 53’ 18” W). The climate is SL PU perhumid
subtropical, with an average annual temperature of
19 ºC, and annual rainfall of 1,800 mm (17). The
altitude ranges between 400 and 472 m above mean
sea level. The forest remnant comprises 240 ha of
late successional semi-deciduous seasonal forest,
and around 50 ha of areas of secondary herbaceous
or secondary forest vegetation (2).
The area of the experiment was an abandoned cropland, which after 11 years has become
dominated by Poaceae such as Saccharum villosum
Steud. (dominant), Schizachyrium microstachyum
(Ham.) Roseng. et al., Leersia hexandra Sw., and
Calamagrostis viridiflavescens Steud. Sparse individuals of various woody species also occur, especially Schinus terebinthifolius Raddi and Aegiphila
brachiata Vell. The topographic level ranges between 402 and 403 m above mean sea level (Figure
1). The late successional Semi-deciduous Seasonal
Forest begins 100 meters from the 408 m quota.
36
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 36
09/10/2012 13:43:57
The experiment was carried out in a forest remnant named ‘Mato do Silva’, in Chiapetta county, State of Rio
Grande do Sul, Brazil (27° 55' 02” S and 53° 53' 18" W). The climate is SL PU perhumid subtropical, with an average
annual temperature of 19 ºC, and annual rainfall of 1,800 mm (17). The altitude ranges between 400 and 472 m above
mean sea level. The forest remnant comprises 240 ha of late successional semi-deciduous seasonal forest, and around 50
ha of areas of secondary herbaceous or secondary forest vegetation (2).
The area of the experiment was an abandoned cropland, which after 11 years has become dominated by
Poaceae such as Saccharum villosum Steud. (dominant), Schizachyrium microstachyum (Ham.) Roseng. et al., Leersia
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
hexandra Sw., and Calamagrostis viridiflavescens Steud. Sparse individuals of various woody species also occur,
Seed germination capacity, determined in
a greenhouse in the IRDeR- Instituto Regional de
Desenvolvimento Rural (UNIJUÍ), at ambient temperature and in a PLANTMAX ® substrate (a mixture of vermiculite and Pinus residues), was 55%.
Statistical Analysis
Figure 1. Topographic diagram in a northeast-southwest direction between the Inhacorá River, on the left, and the
Considering as experimental factors vegbeginning of secondary forest dominated by A. glazioveana, on the right. The arrow indicates the location of the
experiment,
the quotas 402 and 403 m
above sea level.in a northeast-southwest
Figurebetween
1. Topographic
diagram
etation removal and the addition of fertilizer, analydirection between the Inhacorá3 River, on the left, and the
sis of seedling emergence with direct sowing was
beginning of secondary forest dominated by A. glazioby one-factor ANOVA, whereas comparative analyveana, on the right. The arrow indicates the location of
sis of maximum height and diameter was by twothe experiment, between the quotas 402 and 403 m above
factor ANOVA. Seeing that emergence without seed
sea level.
sowing under the prescribed conditions was zero,
Table 1. Soil physiochemical profile in an old-field with
these experiments were excluded from the analysis.
Physicochemical soil data were provided by UNIJUÍ Soil Laboratory (Table 1).
especially Schinus terebinthifolius Raddi and Aegiphila brachiata Vell. The topographic level ranges between 402 and
403 m above mean sea level (Figure 1). The late successional Semi-deciduous Seasonal Forest begins 100 meters from
the 408 m quota. Physicochemical soil data were provided by UNIJUÍ Soil Laboratory (Table 1).
secondary vegetation, Mato do Silva, Chiapetta-RS, Brazil, 2009.
Table 1. Soil physiochemical profile in an old-field with secondary vegetation, Mato do Silva, Chiapetta-RS, Brazil,
2009.
pH
P
K
S
Cu
Zn
Mn
Ca
Mg
Al
CEC
H + Al (pH = 7.0)
V%
M%
O.M.
(%)
71.0
0.0
4.0
RESULTS
Emergence only occurred in treatments with
sowing (Table 2), thus spontaneous emergence was nil.
After one year, there was no significant difexperimental protocol
ference among treatments as regards emergence or
Experimental protocol
Seeds of A. glazioveana, gathered between July and September, 2009, were first cleaned and then stored at room
the number of remnant seedlings. The highest emertemperature in sealed
recipients.of
It was
by casting was in October,
2009, in plots measuring
2 x 3 m. Data on
Seeds
A.Ssowing
glazioveana,
gathered
between
gence rate occurred in the first 60 days, reaching 48
emergence, survival and growth were obtained between December, 2009 and October, 2010. The experimental design
July
and
2009,
were
firstmanagement,
cleaned
was
factorial
2 x 2 xSeptember,
2, under two adverse different
conditions
of vegetation
viz., withand
and without the
seedlings. After one year, 77 seedlings had emerged
removal of herbaceous and shrubby plants, with and without the addition of fertilizer, and with and without seed
then stored at room temperature in sealed recipisowing.
(Figure 2), corresponding to a density of 8,021 seedThe fertilizer
used was
33 g/m of NPK
200Two hundred
corresponding to 33
per m , were sowed
ents.
It was
sowing
by4:20:12.
casting
was seeds,
in October,
2009,
in each plot.
lings per ha.
in plots
measuring
2replications
x 3 m.distributed
Dataat random,
on emergence,
surEach treatment
consisted of four
one per block. The blocks
were located in
Table 2. Survivor seedlings (% of seeds) of
transverse strips in relation to the slope of the site. The northward-sloping inclination of the site was 2%.
vivalEmergence
and growth
were obtained between December,
and survival were recorded after 60 days (December, 2009), 150 days (March, 2010) and one year
Ateleia
glazioveana
obtained through direct sowing,
(October, 2010). After one year, the maximum height and the diameter of the basal portion of the stem were measured
2009 and October, 2010. The experimental design
with ruler and pachymeter.
Mato do Silva, Chiapetta-RS, 2009-2010. There was
Table 2. Survivor seedlings (% of seeds) of Ateleia glazioveana obtained through direct sowing, Mato do Silva,
germination capacity,
IRDeR-different
Instituto Regional de
Desenvolvimento
was Seed
factorial
2 xdetermined
2 x in2,a greenhouse
underin thetwo
conno difference
atwasany
timeatamong
Rural (UNIJUÍ), at ambient temperature and in a PLANTMAX ® substrate (a mixture of vermiculite and Pinus
Chiapetta-RS,
2009-2010. There
no difference
any time amongtreatments
treatments (P > 0,05).(P > 0,05).
ditions of vegetation management, viz., with and
residues), was 55%.
R
RF
NR
NRF
Total
without the removal of herbaceous and shrubby
December, 2009
2.1
1.4
0.9
1.6
1.5
statistical Analysis
plants, with and without the addition of fertilizer,
March, 2010
0.9
1.4
4.6
0.4
1.8
Considering as experimental factors vegetation removal and the addition of fertilizer, analysis of seedling
and with
and
without
seed
sowing.
October, 2010
0.5
1.4
4.9
0.3
1.8
emergence
with direct
sowing
was by one-factor
ANOVA,
whereas comparative analysis of maximum height and
diameter was by two-factor ANOVA. Seeing that emergence without seed sowing under2the prescribed conditions was
of vegetation without fertilizer, RF = removal of vegetation with fertilizer, NR = without both vegetation
The fertilizer used was 33 g/m of NPK RR= removal
zero, these experiments were excluded from the analysis.
= removal of vegetation without fertilizer, RF = reremoval
and
fertilizer,
NRF = without vegetation removal, but with the addition of fertilizer
4:20:12. Two hundred seeds, corresponding to 33 moval of vegetation
with fertilizer, NR = without both
RESULTS
2
per m , were sowed in each plot.
vegetation removal and fertilizer, NRF = without vegetaBetween 150 days and one year, 21 seedlings (36% of the total emergence) had disappeared, the remaining 56
As eEmergence only occurred in treatments with sowing (Table 2), thus spontaneous emergence was nil.
removal, but with the addition of fertilizer
Each treatment consisted of four replica- thustion
After one year, there was no significant difference among treatments as regards emergence or the number
of corresponding to a density of 5,833 seedlings per hectare.
remnant seedlings. The highest emergence rate occurred in the first 60 days, reaching 48 seedlings. After one year, 77
tions distributed at random, one per block. The
As to average height, no difference was observed among treatments, the overall average height reaching11.96
seedlings had emerged (Figure 2), corresponding to a density of 8,021 seedlings per ha.
Between 150 days and one year, 21 seedblocks were located in transverse
strips
in
relation
cm
(
±
4.08).
4
of the
totalin treatments
emergence)
disappeared,
to the slope of the site. The northward-sloping incli- lings
The (36%
average diameter
of seedlings
with vegetationhad
removal
was higher than those without
the
remaining
56
thus
corresponding
to
a
density
of
removal.
There
was
no
significant
difference
with
the
addition
of
fertilizer
(Table
3
and
Figure
3).
nation of the site was 2%.
th
On
the
60
day,
three
seedlings
of
other
species
were
observed,
two
of
Eugenia
uniflora
L.
and one of
Emergence and survival were recorded 5,833 seedlings per hectare.
Allophylus edulis (A. St.-Hil.) Niederl. One E. uniflora seedling disappeared between 150 days and one year.
As to average height, no difference was obafter 60 days (December, 2009), 150 days (March,
In October, 2010, all the seedlings presented signs of frost damage, which caused loss of the shoot apex and
among treatments, the overall average height
2010) and one year (October, 2010). After one year, theserved
absence of lateral bud expansion.
reaching11.96
cm (± 4.08).
the maximum height and the diameter of the basal
The average diameter of seedlings in treatportion of the stem were measured with ruler and
ments
with
vegetation removal was higher than those
pachymeter.
mg/dm³
5.9
4.2
73.0
4.3
8.3
cmolc/dm³
4.9
2
54.1
7.0
2.9
0.0
4.2
14.6
2
37
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 37
09/10/2012 13:43:57
Table 2. Survivor seedlings (% of seeds) of Ateleia glazioveana obtained through direct sowing, Mato do Silva,
Chiapetta-RS, 2009-2010. There was no difference at any time among treatments (P > 0,05).
R
RF
NR
NRF
Total
December, 2009
2.1
1.4
0.9
1.6
1.5
October, 2010
0.5
1.4
4.9
0.3
Brazilian
Journal
ISSN
1516-5868
March, 2010
0.9 of Ecology
1.4
4.6
0.4
1.8
1.8
without removal. There was no significant difference
DISCUSSION
removal and fertilizer, NRF = without vegetation removal, but with the addition of fertilizer
with the addition of fertilizer (Table 3 and Figure 3).
Between 150 days and one year,
21 seedlings (36% of the total emergence) had disappeared, the remaining 56
On the 60th day, three seedlings of other
Seedling emergence only occurred in treatthus corresponding to a density of 5,833 seedlings per hectare.
As to average
no difference wastwo
observed
treatments, theuniflora
overall average height
species
wereheight,
observed,
ofamong
Eugenia
L. reaching11.96
ments that received seeds. The absence of spontanecm (± 4.08).
and The
one
of Allophylus edulis (A. St.-Hil.) Niederl. ous emergence could be explained by insufficient
average diameter of seedlings in treatments with vegetation removal was higher than those without
removal.
no significantseedling
difference with thedisappeared
addition of fertilizer (Table
3 and Figure 3).
One There
E. was
uniflora
between
150 seed dispersion or high predation prior to initiating
On the 60 day, three seedlings of other species were observed, two of Eugenia uniflora L. and one of
days and
one
year.
Allophylus
edulis (A.
St.-Hil.)
Niederl. One E. uniflora seedling disappeared between 150 days and one year. the experiment. Furthermore, data on sowed plots
In October, 2010, all the seedlings presented signs of frost damage, which caused loss of the shoot apex and
In October, 2010, all the seedlings present- showed that emergence continued after 150 days
the absence of lateral bud expansion.
ed signs of frost damage, which caused loss of the (after April, 2010), a sure indication that the winshoot apex and the absence of lateral bud expansion. ter of that year was not severe enough to hinder the
R = removal of vegetation without fertilizer, RF = removal of vegetation with fertilizer, NR = without both vegetation
th
course of seedling emergence.
Curiously, although local seed rain was apparently insufficient, the production of seeds was
high during 2009 and A. glazioveana is abundant
in the vicinity, reaching dominance above the quota
405 m. a. s. L., 70 m from the experiment (7).
The addition of fertilizer caused no increase in seedling growth during the first year. As
a rule, pioneer tree species respond to fertilization
with an increase in growth, whereas late succesFigure 2. As a sum of all treatments, accumulated emergence (dashed line) and survival (solid line) of A. glazioveana
Table
3. Two-factor
ANOVA
results for
theall
variable
‘diameter’; comparison
among treatments R,
RF (with vegetation
Figure
2.
As
a
sum
of
treatments,
accumulated
emersional species respond either weakly or insignifiseedlings in direct sowing, Mato do Silva, Chiapetta, State of Rio Grande do Sul, 2009-2010.
removal) and NR, NRF (without vegetation removal). * indicates P < 0.05.
gence (dashed line) and survival (solid line) of A. glaziocantly (21). To several species, with direct sowing,
Source of Variation
Df
Mean square
F
P
5 Mato
veana seedlings in direct sowing,
do Silva, ChiaInteraction
1
1.19
0.834
0.368
both in greenhouse (3), and in the field (14), the
petta, State of Rio Grande do Sul, 2009-2010.
Vegetation removal
1
6.25 *
4.375
0.045 *
addition of fertilizers or organic soil increases
Fertilizer added
1
0.358
0.251
0.620
seedling growth.
Table
ANOVA
results for the variable
Residual 3. Two-factor
30
1.43
The removal of vegetation induced an in‘diameter’; comparison among treatments R, RF (with
vegetation removal) and NR, NRF (without vegetation
crease in stem diameter, since the presence of herTable 3. Two-factor ANOVA results for the variable ‘diameter’; comparison among treatments R, RF (with vegetation
removal).
*
indicates
P
<
0.05.
baceous plants can reduce light intensity, a possible
removal) and NR, NRF (without vegetation removal). * indicates P < 0.05.
cause of thinner stems. In spite of such low-lightSource of Variation
Df
Mean square
F
P
Interaction
1
1.19
0.834
0.368
intensity conditions are capable of inducing an inVegetation removal
1
6.25 *
4.375
0.045 *
crease in height, damage to the shoot apex caused by
Fertilizer added
1
0.358
0.251
0.620
the frosts of 2010 supposedly prevented differences
Residual
30
1.43
among treatments.
Shoot-apex damage, which suggests sensitivity to frost in the seedling stage, could have been
a limiting factor to species settlement. The experiment was located 150 meters from, and less than
one meter above, the Inhacorá River, thus favorable
to the occurrence of subzero temperatures, since
cold air tends to move to lower topographic levels
(20). The species is considered only moderately tolerant to cold, whereby it presents growth limitations
Figure
3. Stem basal
diameter (mm)
of A. glazioveana
seedlings
after oneof
year A.
of direct
sowing in Mato do Silva,
Figure
3. Stem
basal
diameter
(mm)
glazioveana
subjected to heavy frosts during experimental
Chiapetta county, State of Rio Grande do Sul, 2010. Treatments R and RF are with vegetation removal, treatmentswhen
NR
seedlings after one year of direct sowing in Mato do
and NRF, without. The gray columns indicate the addition of fertilizer (33 g/m of NPK 4:20:12). Vertical bars indicate
planting
(6). Furthermore, as wind intensity can be
standard
error.
Silva,
Chiapetta, State of Rio Grande do Sul, 2010. Treatlow in the bottom of valleys, seed dispersion is less
6
ments R and RF are with vegetation
removal, treatments
and consequently recruitment reduced.
NR and NRF, without. The gray columns indicate the ad2
dition of fertilizer (33 g/m of NPK 4:20:12). Vertical bars
Seedling height after one year of experiindicate standard error.
mentation can be considered low when compared
2
38
Figure 3. Stem basal diameter (mm) of A. glazioveana seedlings after one year of direct sowing in Mato do Silva,
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 38
09/10/2012 13:43:58
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
with other experimental studies with direct sowing.
For example: Soares & Rodrigues (2008) recorded a
wide variation in the heights of Fabaceae tree species
sowed in abandoned cropland, of 30 cm for Bowdichia virgilioides Kunth to 3 m for Acacia polyphylla
DC, after 13 months; Mattei & Rosenthal (2002) registered heights between 29 and 66 cm for Peltophorum dubium (Spreng.) Taub., in secondary forest
enrichment through direct sowing, after 18 months;
Engel & Parrotta (2001) observed heights ranging
from 20 cm (Ceiba speciosa [A. St.-Hil] Ravenna) to
170 cm for Schizolobium parahyba (Vell.),Blake, after two years of direct sowing in Botucatu, São Paulo;
Camargo et al. (2002),noted heights ranging between
38 and 85 cm for Caryocar villosum Aubl., and 20
and 45 cm for Parkia multijuga Benth. in Amazonia,
after one year of direct sowing; and finally, Ferreira
et al. (2007) reported heights ranging from 200 to
250 cm after 15 months of direct sowing for Trema
micrantha (L.) Blüme, Senna multijuga (L. C. Rich)
Irwin & Barneby, S. macranthera (Collad.) Irwin &
Barneby, and Solanum mauritianum Scopoli.
Data indicate that the regeneration of A.
glazioveana through direct sowing is viable, even
without vegetation removal. On the other hand, the
occurrence of severe frosts car hamper species survival and recruitment. Direct sowing, though being
a low-cost restoration method, requires a longer period of monitoring, in order to check whether plants
can reach sufficient densities, to so establish a viable forest structure.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
To Ilsi Boldrini (UFRGS) for helping with
taxonomic identification. To Jorge Schirmer (IRDeR/UNIJUÍ) for assistance in the determination of
seed germination capacity. To Andressa Felipin for
the English revision.
RESUMO
Emergência e crescimento de plântulas
de Ateleia glazioveana Baill. em semeadura direta
em um estágio sucessional inicial. Ateleia glazioveana (Fabaceae) é uma espécie arbórea pioneira
que ocorre no Sul e Sudeste do Brasil, alcançando
grandes densidades populacionais na Floresta Es-
tacional. O objetivo deste trabalho foi analisar a
emergência, crescimento e sobrevivência de plântulas de A. glazioveana em condições naturais. O ensaio foi instalado em uma área agrícola abandonada
por 11 anos, com vegetação herbácea em fase inicial
de sucessão secundária. As parcelas tinham 2 x 3
m, com 4 repetições, em 4 blocos casualizados. O
desenho experimental foi um fatorial de 2 x 2 x 2,
com duas diferentes condições de manejo da vegetação (com e sem remoção da vegetação herbácea
e arbustiva), dois níveis de fertilização (adição de
33 g/m 2 de NPK 4:20:12 e sem adição de fertilizante) e com ou sem adição de sementes. As parcelas com semeadura receberam 200 sementes, o
que corresponde a 33 sementes/m 2. O registro de
dados de emergência e sobrevivência foi feito aos
dois, cinco e 12 meses. Os dados de crescimento
(diâmetro do colo e altura) foram obtidos após 12
meses. A emergência espontânea de A. glazioveana
foi nula. A emergência produzida pela semeadura
direta atingiu um total de 48 (1,5%) plântulas após
dois meses e 77 (2,4%) plântulas após 12 meses.
Destas, 56 plântulas sobreviveram após 12 meses,
o que corresponde 5.883 plântulas por hectare. Os
tratamentos não diferiram quanto à altura e sobrevivência, entretanto os tratamentos submetidos à
retirada da vegetação apresentaram plântulas com
maior diâmetro do colo. A adição de fertilizante não
gerou diferenças significativas. A altura média das
plântulas após 12 meses foi de 11,96 cm (± 4,08).
A semeadura direta se mostrou viável, porém todas
as mudas apresentaram danos causados pela geada
após o inverno de 2010, indicando limitações microclimáticas ao recrutamento.
Palavras chave: sucessão secundária, restauração
florestal, Floresta Estacional Semidecidual.
REFERENCES
1- BAGGIO, A. J. Timbó: uma alternativa para a
produção perene de adubo verde. Circular Técnica 68 (EMBRAPA Florestas), Curitiba, p. 1-8,
2002.
2- BENVENUTI-FERREIRA, G.; COELHO, G. C.
Floristics and structure of the tree component
in a Seasonal Forest remnant, Chiapetta, Rio
Grande do Sul State, Brazil. Revista Brasileira
39
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 39
09/10/2012 13:43:58
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
de Biociências, Porto Alegre, v. 7, n. 4, p. 344353, 2009.
3- BRAGA, A J.; GRIFFITH, J. J.; PAIVA, H. N.;
SILVA, F. C.; CORTE, V. B.; MEIRA-NETO,
J. A. A. Enriquecimento do sistema solo-serapilheira com espécies arbóreas aptas para recuperação de áreas degradadas. Revista Árvore,
Viçosa, v. 31, n. 6, p. 1145-1154, 2007.
4- BURKART, R. & FERNÁNDEZ, J. G. 2002.
Introducción. In: BURKART, R., CINTO, J.
P., CHÉBEZ, J. C., FERNÁNDEZ, J. G. &
RIEGELHAUPT, E. (Eds.) La Selva Misionera
– opciones para su conservación y uso sustentable. Buenos Aires: FUCEMA. p. 11-16.
5- CAMARGO, J. L. C.; FERRAZ, I. D. K.; IMAKAWA, A. M. Rehabilitation of degraded areas
of Central Amazonia using direct sowing of forest tree seeds. Restoration Ecology, Malden, v.
10, n. 4, p. 636-644, 2002.
6- CARVALHO, P. E. R., 1994. Espécies florestais
brasileiras: recomendações silviculturais, potencialidades e uso da madeira. EMBRAPACNPF: Brasília, 1994, 640 p.
7- COELHO, G. C.; RIGO, M. S.; LIBARDONI,
J. B.; OLIVEIRA, R.; BENVENUTI-FERREIRA, G. Understory structure in two successional stages of a Semi-deciduous Seasonal
Forest remnant of Southern Brazil. Biota Neotropica, Campinas, vol. 11, n. 3, p. 63-74, 2011.
8- CLARK, J. S., BECKAGE, B., CAMILL, P.,
CLEVELAND, B., HILLERISLAMBERS, J.,
LICHTER, J., MCLACHLAN, J., MOHAN, J.,
& WYCKOFF, P. Interpreting recruitment limitation in forests. American Journal of Botany,
Columbus, v. 86, n. 1, p. 1–16, 1999.
9- CONNELL, J. H.; SLATYER, R. O. Mechanisms of succession in natural communities and
their role in community stability and organization. The American Naturalist, Chicago, v. 111,
n. 982, p. 1119-1144, 1977.
10-ENGEL, V. L.; PARROTTA, J. A. An evaluation
of direct seeding for reforestation of degraded
lands in central São Paulo state, Brazil. Forest
Ecology and Management, Amsterdam, v. 152,
n. 1/3, p. 169-181, 2001.
11- FERREIRA, R. A.; DAVIDE, A. C.; BEARZOTI, E.; MOTTA, M. S. Semeadura direta com
espécies arbóreas para recuperação de ecossiste-
mas florestais. Cerne, Lavras, v. 13, n. 3, p. 271279, 2007.
12-GEEVES, G., SEMPLE, B., JOHNSTON, D.,
JOHNSTON, A., HUGHES, J., KOEN, T.,
YOUNG, J. Improving the reliability of direct
seeding for revegetation in the Central West of
New South Wales. Ecological Management &
Restoration, Carlton, v. 9, n. 1, p. 68-71, 2008.
13-GOTELLI, N. J. 2009. Ecologia. 4ª ed. Londrina, Ed. Planta.
14-HÜLLER, A.; COELHO, G. C.; MENEGHELLO, G. E.; PESKE, S. T. Semeadura direta
de Schinus terebinthifolius Raddi e Citharexylum solanaceum Chamisso na recuperação de
áreas degradadas no Bioma Mata Atlântica. In:
VIII CONGRESSO NACIONAL DE RECUPERAÇÃO DE ÁREAS DEGRADADAS, 2010,
Guarapari. Anais... Guarapari: SOBRADE,
2010, CD-ROM.
15-KAGEYAMA, P. Y.; GANDARA, F. B. 2000.
Recuperação de áreas ciliares. In RODRIGUES,
R. R.; LEITÃO FILHO, H. F. (Eds.). Mata ciliares: uma abordagem multidisciplinar. EDUSP/
FAPESP, São Paulo, p. 249-269.
16-KNOWLES, O. H.; PARROTTA, J. A. Amazonian forest restoration: an innovative system for
native species selection based on phenological
data and field performance indices. Commonwealth Forestry Review, Oxford, v. 74, n. 3, p.
230-243, 1995.
17-MALUF, J. R. T. Nova classificação climática do
Estado do Rio Grande do Sul. Revista Brasileira
de Agrometeorologia, Santa Maria, v. 8, n. 1, p.
141-150, 2000.
18-MATTEI, V. L.; ROSENTHAL, M. D. Semeadura direta de canafístula (Peltophorum dubium
(Spreng.) Taub.) no enriquecimento de capoeiras. Revista Árvore, Viçosa, v.26, n. 6, p.649654, 2002.
19-ODUM, E. P. Ecologia. 1ª Ed., Rio de Janeiro:
Guanabara Koogan, 1988. 434 p.
20-OMETTO, J. C. Bioclimatologia vegetal. São
Paulo: Ceres, 1981. 425 p.
21-RESENDE, A. V.; FURTINI NETO, A. E.;
CURI, N. Mineral nutrition and fertilization of
native tree species in Brazil: research progress
and suggestions for management. Journal of
Sustainable Forestry, New Haven, v. 20, n. 2, p.
40
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 40
09/10/2012 13:43:58
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
45-81, 2005.
22-SOARES, P. G.; RODRIGUES, R. R. Semeadura direta de leguminosas florestais: efeito da
inoculação com rizóbio na emergência de plântulas e crescimento inicial no campo. Scientia
Forestalis, Piracicaba, v. 36, n. 78, p. 115-121,
2008.
23-SCHENKEL, V.; GASS, S. L. B.; LUCCHESE,
O. A.; COELHO, G. C. 2003. Levantamento de
cobertura florestal no noroeste rio-grandense: o
diagnóstico das APP’s a partir de microbacias
hidrográficas. In: LUCCHESE, O. A.; COELHO, G. C. (Eds.). Reflorestamento e Recupe-
ração Ambiental: Biodiversidade e Culturas - a
gestão ambiental em foco. Ijuí: Editora da UNIJUÍ, p. 192-201.
24-SHONO, K.; DAVIES, S. J.; CHUA, Y. K. Performance of 45 native tree species on degraded lands
in Singapore. Journal of Tropical Forest Science,
Kuala Lumpur, v. 19, n. 1, p. 25–34, 2007.
25-STEVENSON, B. A.; SMALE, M. C. Seed bed
treatment effects on vegetation and seedling establishment in a New Zealand pasture one year
after seeding with native woody species. Ecological Management & Restoration, Carlton, v.
6, n. 2, p. 124-131, 2005.
41
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 41
09/10/2012 13:43:58
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
42
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 42
09/10/2012 13:43:58
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Plant richness in exotic tree plantations in Rio Grande municipality, Rio Grande do Sul State, Brazil
Quenie Januário, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande, Instituto de Ciências Biológicas
Caroline Igansi Duarte, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande, Instituto de Ciências Biológicas
Geraldo Ceni Coelho, Universidade Federal da Fronteira Sul, (cenicoelho@gmail.com)
Ubiratã Soares Jacobi *, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande, Instituto de Ciências Biológicas,
(dmbbira@furg.br)
ABSTRACT
The aim was to investigate vegetal richness inside two exotic tree-species plantations, as
well as to analyze the influence of light and litter. One of the areas was a 30 ha plantation
of Eucalytus tereticornis Sm. and E. robusta Sm., and the other a 3 ha plantation of Pinus
elliottii Engelm. In each, twenty-five 5x10 m plots were marked out, so as to investigate
the structure of the vegetal community. The presence of tree, bush, epiphyte, climbing and herb species was registered. 25 samples of litter from each area were collected
by way of square frames measuring 625 cm². Light intensity was measured in all the
plots. Spatial richness and the distribution of species were correlated with the distance
from the plantation-edge, litter-disposal and light-intensity. Richness was measured and
analyzed according to the number of species. The area of Eucalyptus spp. presented 18
species and that of P. elliottii 14. Tillandsia aeranthos Desf. ex Steud., the most frequent
species in both areas, was registered in all the plots. In the P. elliottii plantation, richness diminished with the increase in distance from the edge and with the reduction in
light-intensity. In both study-areas, the number of species decreased in accordance with
the increase of litter. Concomitantly, richness presented a higher correlation with light
intensity. The data indicate the need for monitoring and amplifying the intensity of light
as a strategy for regenerating vegetal communities.
Key-words: richness, invasive tree species; exotic-species monoculture; Pinus; Eucalyptus.
INTRODUCTION
The coastal regions of Rio Grande do Sul
State, Brazil, through comprising a varied assortment of environments, such as swamps, salt marshes,
dunes and prairies, facilitate the formation of distinct
vegetal configurations with high plant diversity, herbaceous plants and trees amongst others (15). Recent
anthropic activities have caused negative impacts
and disturbance. Exotic tree and rice cultivation,
cattle raising and real estate expansion are among
the human activities accountable for degradation in
the southern Rio Grande do Sul coastal region (6, 4).
The introduction of exotic-tree species is one of the
greatest threats to local biodiversity, through the introduction of pathogens, competition, allelopathy and
the formation of physical barriers (19).
Exotic species are defined as those that occur
outside the natural and historically known limits, as a
result of accidental or intentional human dispersion.
Invasive species are those which, once having been
introduced and adapted to the new environment, begin spontaneous reproduction and occupy the space
of native species, thereby inducing modifications in
43
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 43
09/10/2012 13:43:58
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
ecological processes, reaching to dominance (26).
Biological contamination is pointed out as being the
second main cause of extinction worldwide, surpassed only by fragmentation and habitat loss (19).
Pinus species, natives of the Northern
Hemisphere, are among those with the highest
invasive potential worldwide. Around the 1950’s,
they were introduced into Brazil for pulp production, their culture being largely stimulated by tax
incentives. Pinus spp. is cultivated in the coastal
region of Rio Grande do Sul State for resin production. It is anemophilous and wind-dispersed,
with a dispersal range of 25 km. The more than
90% seedling emergence facilitates its adaptation
to any ecosystem. Furthermore, it is highly fire resistant. The slow degradation and accumulation of
pine needles in layers more than 20 cm deep acidifies the soil (19, 25).
The genus Eucalyptus, native of Oceania,
was introduced into Brazil at the end of the nineteenth century. Eucalyptus species were widely
used for railroad sleepers, fence posts, lamp posts,
the drainage of bogs and marshes, and as windbreaks. Besides the fast growth rate, their extensive
cultivation was much favored by their innate capacity for adaptation to various soil types and fertility
levels (13). Since the 1970’s, they have been used
for pulp production, recently with the inclusion of
genetically modified species. In 2000, Eucalytpus
cultivation occupied an area of 3.0 million hectares
of the 4.8 million dedicated to forestry in Brazil (1).
Whereas some authors advocate the importance of planting exotic trees in the regeneration
of native vegetation (8, 20, 23), little research has
been carried out to measure the impact of Pinus or
Eucalyptus homogeneous plantations on local biodiversity (26, 16, 21), with a complete lack along the
Southern Brazilian coastal region.
The aim was to describe the richness and
structure of the plant communities inside two exotic
plantations, one of Pinus elliottii Engelm. and the
other of Eucalyptus tereticornis Sm. and E. robusta
Sm. The correlations among litter accumulation, light
intensity and plant spatial patterns were also analyzed.
METHODOLOGY
Rio Grande municipality, Rio Grande do Sul State.
According to the Köppen system, the climate is Cfa
humid subtropical. The average temperatures are:
annual 17.9 °C., in the hottest month 23.3 °C; and
in the coldest month 12.7 °C. The average annual
rainfall is 1,252 mm, and relative humidity around
80%. The predominant wind direction in all seasons
is northeast (18).
Plantations were with 2x3m spacing and
with no commercial exploitation. The study took
place between April, 2008 and November, 2009.
The nearly 25-year-old P. elliottii plantation, within an area of three ha, was located in
the campus of the Rio Grande Federal University
(FURG), 2 meters above sea level, at the coordinates 32º 04’ 58.67” S and 52º 09’21.10”W. The adjacent areas were meadows, urban areas, and other
Pinus and Eucalyptus cultivations.
The nearly 30-year-old Eucalyptus spp.
plantation, comprising two species, E. tereticornis
and E. robusta, was located in an area of 35 ha in the
6th Industrial District of Rio Grande, within the coordinates 32º 07’ 40.54”S and 52º 08’21.60” W, 19
meters above sea level. The adjacent areas consisted
of meadows, woody fields, swamps, and a sandbank
forest inside a conservation area.
Richness was measured and analyzed
through species quantification. Frequency and
the number of species were estimated using the
fixed-plot method (14). Five demarked areas of
5x50m were each divided into five plots, to a total
of 25 plots of 50 m 2 and 1250 m 2 of total sampled
area in the two sites. Within each spot, two plots
of 1 x 1 m were delimited for herbaceous sinusia sampling. The demarked areas were placed
so that the first were situated on the border and
those subsequent towards the interior (Figure 1).
For herbaceous sinusia, plants smaller than 30
cm high were recorded. For tree sampling, plants
with DBH (diameter breast height) ≥ 5.0 cm at a
height of 1.30 m above ground level were included. All epiphytic plants observed in the plots were
recorded, this including hemi-epiphytic species.
Terrestrial plants that use others as support were
included as climbing plants, together with woody
lianas (10). The sample was evaluated through the
sample sufficiency curve.
The sites are located on the coastal plains of
44
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 44
09/10/2012 13:43:58
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Border
Border
Figure 1 – Distribution of plots in the plantations, ‘b’
is the sampling spot used for herbs, and ‘a’ the spot for
other sinusiae.
Table 1 - Absolute (FA) and relative (FR) frequency of the species recorded in the Eucalyptus spp. plantation.
Other
observed Lifeinside
the FAplantaSpecies species
(Family)
form Origin
FR
Eucalyptus spp. (Myrtaceae)
AR
EX
100
26,32
tions,
but not encountered in the plots,
were100regisTillandsia aeranthos Desf. ex Steud. (Bromeliaceae)
E
N
26,32
(Raddi) Kuhlm. (Poaceae)
N
76
20
tered Axonopus
to sofissifolius
complement
the floristicH survey.
Microgramma vacciniifolia (Langsd. & Fisch.) Copel. (Polypodiaceae)
E
N
40
10,53
Species
were
identified according
Eleocharis
bicolor Chapm.
(Cyperaceae)
H
N
12to the
3,16
Ficus cestrifolia Schott ex Spreng. (Moraceae)
Eh
N
12
3,16
literature,
and
by
consulting
herbaria
(HURG),
exSmilax campestris Griseb. (Smilacaceae)
T
N
12
3,16
MyrsineDigital
parvifolia A.DC. Data
(Primulaceae)Bank of the
AR/ABBrazilian
N
8 Flora
2,11
perts, the
Pycreus polystachyos (Rottb.) P.Beauv. (Cyperaceae)
H
N
4
1,05
Species
Checklist,
theN New
Dichanthelium sabulorum
(Lam.) Gould Flora
& C.A. ClarkBrasiliensis,
(Poaceae)
H
4 York
1,05
Pleopeltis pleopeltifolia (Raddi) Alston (Polypodiaceae)
E
N
4
1,05
Botanical
Garden, and the Missouri
Botanical
GarCentella asiatica (L.) Urb. (Apiaceae)
H
C
4
1,05
Citharexylum
(Spreng.) Moldenke of
(Verbenaceae)
AR/AB family
N
1,05
4
den.
Themontevidense
delimitation
taxa at the
level
is
Lithrea brasiliensis Marchand (Anacardiaceae)
AB
N
-
-
Hydrocotyle bonariensis Lam. (Araliaceae)
H
N
-
-
E
N
according to the proposition for the Angiosperm
Phylogeny Group III (3).
Litter was estimated by way of 25 samples obtained by a square iron frame with 25 cm
sides. Samples were dried in a stove at 70 ºC, and
weighed with a precision balance (15). Light intensity (expressed as µ mol s -1 m-2) was estimated
with a LI-COR Radiation Sensor in each sampling spot.
The Spearman rank correlation was determined for analyzing relationships between richness,
litter and light intensity.
RESULTS
In the Eucalyptus plantation, there were
18 species belonging to 15 families (Table 1), two
species each from Cyperaceae, Poaceae and Polypodiaceae, and only one each from the others. Sixteen (88%) species were native, one exotic and one
cosmopolitan (Table 1).
Senecio brasiliensis
(Spreng.) Less. (Asteraceae)
H
N frequency
- of the species recorded in the Eucalyptus spp. plantation.
Table
1 - Absolute
(FA) and relative
(FR)
Rhipsalis teres (Vell.) Steud. (Cactaceae)
N
SpeciesAR/AB
(Family)
-
-
-
-
Life form
Origin
FA
FR
Eucalyptus spp. (Myrtaceae)
AR
EX
100
26,32
Tillandsia aeranthos Desf. ex Steud. (Bromeliaceae)
E
N
100
26,32
Axonopus fissifolius (Raddi) Kuhlm. (Poaceae)
H
N
76
20
Microgramma vacciniifolia (Langsd. & Fisch.) Copel. (Polypodiaceae)
E
N
40
10,53
Eleocharis bicolor Chapm. (Cyperaceae)
H
N
12
3,16
Ficus cestrifolia Schott ex Spreng. (Moraceae)
Eh
N
12
3,16
Smilax campestris Griseb. (Smilacaceae)
T
N
12
3,16
Myrsine parvifolia A.DC. (Primulaceae)
AR/AB
N
8
2,11
Pycreus polystachyos (Rottb.) P.Beauv. (Cyperaceae)
H
N
4
1,05
Dichanthelium sabulorum (Lam.) Gould & C.A. Clark (Poaceae)
H
N
4
1,05
Pleopeltis pleopeltifolia (Raddi) Alston (Polypodiaceae)
E
N
4
1,05
Centella asiatica (L.) Urb. (Apiaceae)
H
C
4
1,05
Citharexylum montevidense (Spreng.) Moldenke (Verbenaceae)
AR/AB
N
4
1,05
Lithrea brasiliensis Marchand (Anacardiaceae)
AB
N
-
-
Hydrocotyle bonariensis Lam. (Araliaceae)
H
N
-
-
Senecio brasiliensis (Spreng.) Less. (Asteraceae)
H
N
-
-
Rhipsalis teres (Vell.) Steud. (Cactaceae)
E
N
-
-
Daphnopsis racemosa Griseb. (Thymelaeaceae)
AR/AB
N
-
-
Daphnopsis racemosa Griseb. (Thymelaeaceae)
AB= tree; AR= shrub; E= epiphyte; H= herb; T= climbings; N= native; C= cosmopolitan; Ex= exotic; Eh = hemiepiphyte; - = species
observed out the sampling plots.
AB= tree; AR= shrub; E= epiphyte; H= herb; T= climbings; N= native; C= cosmopolitan; Ex= exotic; Eh = hemiepiphyte; - = species
observed out the sampling plots.
45
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 45
09/10/2012 13:43:58
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
In the Eucalyptus site, the lowest values
for accumulated litter were in the edge plots and
the highest in the intermediate (Figure 3), whereas
species richness was inversely proportional to litter
levels (Figure 3 on left), with r = -0.60.
For P. elliottii, there were 14 species belonging to 12 families (Table 2), among which 11
(79%) were native and 3 (21%) exotic. There were
two species each from Fabaceae and Myrtaceae,
and only one each from the other 10 (Table 2).
Table 2 - Absolute (FA) and relative (FR) frequency of the species recorded in the Pinus elliottii plantation.
Species (Family)
Life form Origin
FA
FR
Table 2 - Absolute (FA) and relative (FR) frequency of the species recorded in the Pinu
Pinus elliottii Engelm. (Pinaceae)
AB
EX
100
32,47
Tillandsia aeranthos Desf. ex Steud. (Bromeliaceae)
E
Species (Family)
N
100
Pinus elliottii Engelm. (Pinaceae)
32,47
Life form
Origin
AB
EX
E
N
Axonopus fissifolius (Raddi) Kuhlm. (Poaceae)
H
N ex Steud.
40(Bromeliaceae)
12,99
Tillandsia aeranthos
Desf.
Acacia longifolia (Andrews) Willd. (Fabaceae)
AR/AB
EX
16 (Poaceae)
5,18
Axonopus
fissifolius (Raddi)
Kuhlm.
H
N
Schinus terebinthifolius Raddi (Anacardiaceae)
Acacia longifolia
(Andrews)
Willd.
AB
N
16 (Fabaceae)
5,19
AR/AB
EX
Ipomoea cairica (L.) Sweet (Convolvulaceae)
Schinus terebinthifolius
T
N Raddi (Anacardiaceae)
12
3,90
AB
N
Desmodium adscendens (Sw.) DC. (Fabaceae)
Hydrocotyle bonariensis Lam. (Araliaceae)
Ipomoea cairica (L.) Sweet (Convolvulaceae)
T
N
Desmodium adscendens (Sw.) DC. (Fabaceae)
H
N
Hydrocotyle bonariensis Lam. (Araliaceae)
H
N
H
N
H
N
8
2,60
H
N
4
1,30
Rumohra adiantiformis (G.Forst.) Ching (Dryopteridaceae)
H
N
4
1,30
Rumohra adiantiformis (G.Forst.) Ching (Dryopteridaceae)
Sida rhombifolia L. (Malvaceae)
H rhombifolia
N L. (Malvaceae)
4
1,30
Sida
Syzygium cumini (L.) Skeels (Myrtaceae)
AR/AB
EX Skeels (Myrtaceae)
4
1,30
Syzygium
cumini (L.)
H
N
AR/AB
EX
Sapium glandulosum (L.) Morong (Euphorbiaceae)
Sapium glandulosum
(L.)
AB
N Morong (Euphorbiaceae)
-
AB
N
Myrsine parvifolia A.DC. (Primulaceae)
Myrsine
parvifolia N
A.DC. (Primulaceae)
AR/AB
-
AR/AB
N
AB
N
Eugenia uniflora L. (Myrtaceae)
Eugenia uniflora L. (Myrtaceae)
AB
N
-
-
AB= tree; AR= shrub; E= epiphyte; H= herb; T= climbing; N= native; C= cosmopolitan; Ex= exotic; Eh = h
AB= tree; AR= shrub; E= epiphyte; H= herb; T= climbing; N= observed
native; C=out
cosmopolitan;
Ex= exotic; Eh = hemiepiphyte; - = species
the sampling plots.
observed out the sampling plots.
The two sites contained four species in Table 3 – Richness and sinusia in the sampling plots
common: Tillandsia aeranthos, Hydrocotyle bonar- on each site
Table 3 – Richness and sinusia in the sampling plots on each site.
iensis, Myrsine parvifolia, Axonopus fissifolius.
Sinusia
Eucalyptus
Pinus
Table species
3 – Richness
andrecorded
sinusia inin
thethe
sampling
plots on each site.
Seven woody
were
two sites,
Herbs
5 (38%)
5 (46%)
Sinusia
Eucalyptus
four in the P. elliottii
(Table 2) and
another three in Pinus
Trees
2 (15%)
2 (18%)
the Eucalytptus (Table
Herbs 1).
5 (38%)
5 (46%)
Shrubs
1 (8%)
2 (18%)
Tillandsia aeranthos was present in all the
Trees
2 (15%)
2 (18%)
Epiphytes
4 (34%)
1 (9%)
plots in both sites. Axonopus fissifolius was the secShrubs
1 (8%)
2 (18%)Climbing
1
(8%)
1 (9%)
ond most common species (Table 1 and 2).
Epiphytes only plots,
4 (34%)
13
11
On considering
the Eucalyp- 1 (9%) Total
Climbing
(8%) 11 species, 1 (9%)
tus and Pinus sites
presented 131 and
46
S p e c ie s
S p e c ie s
Litter accumulation in the Pinus site was
11
higher than in the Eucalyptus, and was inversely
12
14
proportional
to the distance from the edge (Figure
12
10
3). 10Furthermore, species richness was inversely
8
8
proportional
to accumulated litter (Figure 3 on the
12
6
6
right), 10with r = -0.87.
4
4
In the Eucalyptus site, the lowest light in2
8
2
0
tensity
was registered in the intermediate plots.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26
0
6
There was
a significantPlotscorrelation of richness with1
4
light intensity
(r = 0.90) (Figure 4 on the left).
S p e c ie s
S p e c ie s
respectively. All the
represented in
Totalsinusiae were 13
both areas, with the predominance of herbs (Table
3). Although epiphytes comprised the second richest sinusia in the Eucalyptus site, only one was observed in the Pinus.
14
Whereas12 in the Eucaplyptus site sample sufficiency analysis10indicated stabilization in the seven8
teenth spot (Figure
2), in the Pinus the absence of a
6
clear stabilization (Figure 2) could be related to dif4
ferences in richness
between edge and interior plots.
2
3
4
5
6
7
2
2
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26
Plots
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26
Plots
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 46
09/10/2012 13:43:58
8
9 10 11
Epiphytes
Epiphytes
Climbing
Climbing
4 (34%)
4 (34%)
1 (9%)
1 (9%)
1 (8%)
1 (8%)
1 (9%)
1 (9%)
TotalTotal
13 13
1111
14
14
12
12
10
10
6
12 12
10 10
8 8
8
S p ec ies
S p e c ie s
8
S p e c ie s
S p ec ie s
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
6 6
6
4
4
2
2
4 4
2 2
0
1
0
8 11
9 12
10 11
2 3 1 4 2 53 64 75 86 97 10
13 12
14 13
15 14
16 15
17 16
18 1719 18201921202221232224232524 2625 26
0 0
14 15
15 16
16 17
17 18
18 19 20 21
1 12 23 34 45 56 6 7 7 8 8 9 9 10101111 1212 1313 14
21 22
22 23
23 24
24 25
25 2626
Plots Plots
lots
PPlots
Figure 2 – Cumulative curve of species per spot in a monoculture Eucalyptus area (on the left) and a Pinus area (on
the right).
30 30
1200
1200
25 25
1000
1000
S Species
pecies
20 20
800
800
1200 1200
600
600
L itter
L itter
30
30
15 15
25
25
10 10
20
20
5 5
15
15
0 0
1 1
10
10
5
5
0
0
1
1000 1000
400
400
S pecies
S pecies
800 800
200
200
L itter
L itter
30
30
5000
25
25
4500
4000
15
15
25 25
10
10
20 20
3 3
4 4
5 5
66
P lots
P lots
3500
3500
1500
3000
3000
1000
2500
2500
500
2000
0 2000
55
15 15
600 600
00
2 2
3500
5000
5000
3000
4500
4500
2500
4000
4000
2000
20
20
30 30
400 400
00
10 10
200 200
5 5
0
0 0
0
11
22
33
44
22
pecies
ies
SS pec
itter
LLitter
SSpec
pecies
ies
L Litter
itter
1500
1500
1000
1000
5
lots
PPlots
500
500
00
2
2 3
3 4
4 5
5 6
6
2 2
3 3 plantation
44
5 5(on the left) and in the
Figure 3 -1 Relationship
between
accumulated
litter and richness in 1the1 Eucalyptus
P lotsP lots
P
lots
P
lots
30
80
30
300
3030 (on the right).
300
Pinus
pecies
SSpecies
200
200
300
300
15
2515 25
150
150
250
250
10
2010 20
100
100
200
200
5 5
15
15
50
50
150
150
0 0
10
10
11
5
5
0
0100
100
0
22
33
44
55
50 50
Plots
Plots
0
0
1
1 2
2 3
3
4
4
5
25
25
lightht
lig
20
20
30 30
15
15
S pecies
S pecies 25 25
10
10
lig ht
lig ht
20 20
55
15 15
00
10 10
0
5
Plots
Plots
70
SS pecies
pec ies
60
508080
lig
light
ht
µ m o l s ˉ¹ m ˉ²
µ m o l s ˉ¹ m ˉ²
µ m o l s ˉ¹ m ˉ²
20
3020 30
o l s ˉ¹ m ˉ²
µ m o l s ˉ¹ m ˉ²µµ m
m o l s ˉ¹ m ˉ²
250
250
µ m o l s ˉ¹ m ˉ²
2525
407070
306060
205050
104040
11
22
5 5
33
4
SSpec
ies
pecies
lig
light
ht
0 3030
5
2020
1010
Plots
Plots
0 0
00
1 1
2 2
33
44
55
Plots
Plots
Figure 4 – Correlation between light intensity (triangles) and richness (squares) in the Eucalyptus site (on the left) and
in the Pinus site (on the right).
In the Pinus site, light intensity was closely
related to distance from the border. This pattern was
accompanied by a significant correlation of richness with light intensity (r=0.97) (Figure 4 on right).
DISCUSSION
In spite of difficulties related to differences in method, the richness observed in our study
could be considered low for both the Eucalyptus and
Pinus sites, when compared to other inventories in
the same or other regions. It should be emphasized
that, at the most, no more than one sinusia had been
studied in those other inventories.
In native coastal ecosystems, plant richness
is normally high, much more so than that noted in the
present report. On recording the presence of 78 vascular plant species (including three endangered ones)
in the Lagoa Verde Environmental Protection Area,
Rio Grande municipality, Batista et al. (2007) used
this to emphasize the extreme human disturbance in
the area. Marangoni (2003) recorded 29 vascular spe-
47
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 47
09/10/2012 13:43:59
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
cies in a site in the Lagoa dos Patos estuary. Porto
& Dillenburg (1986) registered 151 vascular plants in
two forest formations, one in a swamp and the other
in sandy soil, located in the Taim Ecological Station. Kindel (2002) reported 158 vascular plants in
a swampy forest in Torres municipality, Rio Grande
do Sul State. In the Lagoa do Peixe National Park,
Záchia (2006) recorded 100 plant species and Dorneles & Waechter (2004) 21 tree species.
Neri et al. (2005) recorded 47 species in a
Eucalyptus site in the Brazilian Cerrado. The authors
stressed that such low diversity, when compared to Cerrado diversity in general, could be attributed to shading.
In another similar study in the Cerrado,
Saporetti et al. (2003) encountered 39 woody species. The authors, on pointing out that Eucalypti
hinder the arrival of zoochoric and wind-dispersed
native species, proposed Eucalyptus girdling and
the permanence of dead trees to serve as perches.
Floristic studies of Pinus monocultures are
few, in spite of species of this genus pointedly possessing high invasive potential and causing local diversity loss (26, 19). Even so, Andrae et al. (2005) reported understory establishment of 121 woody-plant
species under 25-30-year-old pines in plantations in
the Central Region of Rio Grande do Sul State.
Generally speaking, scientific papers refer
to Pinus, Eucalytus and other exotic tree species
plantations as ‘planted forest’, ‘commercial planted
forest’ (23) or ‘reforestation’ (2). Notwithstanding,
a forest is a complex ecosystem, in which, not only
one or two, but several species of plants, animals,
fungi, protists and bacteria are involved.
Some studies indicate examples of Pinus
and Eucalyptus as facilitating native forest regeneration (23). Nonetheless, the commercial management of such areas implies the use of agrochemicals
to control plants, animals, fungi and bacteria, thereby hampering their complete development, whence
the origin of the so-called “green deserts”. The
above mentioned studies were actually developed
in non-commercial or abandoned areas of exotic
tree plantations, thus where agrochemicals are no
longer used, and where fallen trees generate gaps,
thereby inducing native plant species development,
beginning at the edges. According to light availability, native plant regeneration could further expand
to the interior, thus characterizing true restoration.
Nonetheless, even in noncommercial areas,
the absence of patches of native forest, in regions
with extensive Pinus and Eucalyptus plantations,
could be a hinderance to native forest regeneration,
since this requires seeds and propagules originating
from other areas.
In the Pinus site, it was noted that the lowest
plant richness was correlated to the highest litter accumulation, which, in turn, increased from the edges
towards the interior. On the other hand, plant richness was positively correlated to light intensity. The
scenario was similar in the Eucalyptus plantation. As
plant richness was more highly correlated with light
intensity than with litter accumulation and distance
from the border, it can be deduced that a reduction
in richness is strongly linked to the prevailing shade.
However, the complementary contribution of litter to
the decrease in richness cannot be discarded.
Although some authors point to the possibility of regeneration in homogeneous stands of exotic
species through shading (2, 16, 21), this would be
impossible in old plantations with trees of 30-meters
or more in height. Hinderance would be especially
stronger for tree species, when considering the observed predominance of herbs and epiphytes. In the
Eucalyptus area only one tree species presented individuals with DBH ≥ 5.0 cm at 1.3 m above ground
level, and in the Pinus, only one exotic woody species
(A. longifolia) was observed, whence it is impossible
to demonstrate regeneration in a plant community.
Considering the importance of biodiversity
conservation, the adequate management of exotictree-species plantations, focusing native plant community restoration, requires top priority. This could
be achieved through techniques that increase light
intensity, such as tree girdling, as also proposed by
previous authors (22).
However, the lower diversity found in exotic species monoculture may be due to other factors, such as allelopathy, a phenomenon in which
substances released by the leaves and branches of
tree species may hinder the development of other
surrounding plants (9).
In Canada, Newmaster et al. (2006) proposed
reforestation with native conifers, as the first step towards rehabilitating conifer forests that had been converted to agriculture and then abandoned. However, in
Brazil, Pinus may interfere in plant diversity, since its
48
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 48
09/10/2012 13:43:59
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
own regeneration is stimulated in detriment of native
plants, insofar as light availability increases (5). On the
other hand, abandoned non-commercial plantations
that present well-developed understories, could serve
as a source of seeds or seedlings for environmental
restoration projects, an issue that needs further evaluation in the Atlantic Rain Forest Biome.
CONCLUSION
Plant richness, reduced inside Eucalyptus
and Pinus plantations, when compared to wild environments in the coastal ecoregion, is directly correlated to light intensity and inversely correlated to
litter accumulation inside the plantations.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
To Adriano Jacobi and Andressa Felipin for
the English revision.
RESUMO
Este estudo teve como objetivo investigar a
riqueza vegetal no interior de dois plantios de espécies
arbóreas exóticas, analisando também as influências
da luz e serrapilheira. Uma das áreas foi um plantio
de Eucalytus tereticornis Sm. e E. robusta Sm., com
30 ha. A outra área foi um plantio de Pinus elliottii
Engelm. com três ha. Em cada área foram demarcadas
25 parcelas de 5 x 10 m para investigar a estrutura da
comunidade vegetal. Registrou-se a presença de espécies arbóreas, arbustivas, epifíticas, trepadeiras e herbáceas. Foram coletadas 25 amostras de serrapilheira
de cada área com o auxílio de uma moldura quadrada
com 625 cm². A intensidade de luz foi medida em
todas as parcelas. A riqueza e a distribuição espacial
das espécies foram correlacionadas com a distância
da borda, a deposição da serrapilheira e a intensidade
de luz. A riqueza foi mensurada e analisada através
da quantidade de espécies. A área de Eucalyptus spp.
apresentou 18 espécies e a área de P. elliottii 14 espécies. Tillandsia aeranthos Desf. ex Steud. foi a espécie
mais freqüente em ambas as áreas, sendo registrada
em todas as parcelas. Na plantação de P. elliottii a
riqueza diminuiu com o aumento da distância da borda e com a redução da intensidade de luz. O número
de espécies diminui de acordo com o aumento de ser-
rapilheira nas duas áreas. Em ambas as áreas a riqueza
apresentou maior correlação com a intensidade luminosa. Os dados indicam a necessidade de monitorar e
ampliar a intensidade luminosa como estratégia para a
regeneração das comunidades vegetais.
Palavras-chave: riqueza, espécies arbóreas invasivas; monocultura de espécies exóticas; Pinus; Eucalyptus.
REFERENCES
1-ALMEIDA, A. C.; SOARES, J. V. Comparação
entre uso de água em plantações de Eucalyptus
grandis e floresta ombrófila densa (Mata Atlântica) na costa leste do Brasil. Revista Árvore,
Viçosa, v. 27, n 2, p. 159-170, 2003.
2-ANDRAE, F. H.; PALUMBO, R.; MARCHIORI,
J. N. C.; DURLO, M. A. O sub-bosque de reflorestamentos de pinus em sítio degradados da
região da floresta estacional decidual do Rio
Grande do Sul. Ciência Florestal, Santa Maria,
v. 15, n 1, p. 43-63, 2005.
3-APG III. An update of the Angiosperm Phylogeny
Group classification for the orders and families of
flowering plants: APG III. Botanical Journal of the
Linnean Society, London, v. 141, p. 105-121, 2009.
4-BATISTA, T. L.; CANTEIRO, R. C. A.; DORNELES, L. P. P.; COLARES, I. G. Levantamento florístico das comunidades vegetais na Área
de Proteção Ambiental da Lagoa Verde, Rio
Grande, RS. Revista Brasileira de Biociências,
Porto Alegre, v. 5, supl. 2, p. 225-227, 2007.
5-BECHARA, F. C., REIS. A. Recomendações de
manejo para a substituição de Pinus pela restauração das restingas do Parque Florestal do Rio
Vermelho. In: TRES, D. R.; REIS, A. Perspectivas sistêmicas para a conservação e restauração
ambiental: do pontual ao contexto. 1. ed. - Itajaí:
Herbário Barbosa Rodrigues, 2009, p. 165-170.
6-BURGER, M. I. Situação e Ações Prioritárias
para a Conservação de Banhados e Áreas Úmidas da Zona Costeira. Porto Alegre: Fundação
Zoobotânica do RS, 2000. 60 p.
7-DORNELES, L. P. P.; WAECHTER, J. L. Fitossociologia do componente arbóreo na floresta turfosa do parque Nacional da Lagoa do Peixe, Rio
Grande do Sul, Brasil. Acta Botanica Brasilica,
Feira de Santana, v. 18, n 4, p. 815–824, 2004.
49
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 49
09/10/2012 13:43:59
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
8-FEYERA, S.; BECK, E.; LÜTTGE, U. Exotic
trees as nurse-trees for the regeneration of natural tropical forests. Trees-Structure and function, Berlim, v. 16, n. 4-5, p.245–249, 2002.
9-JACOBI, U. S.; FERREIRA, A. G. Efeitos alelopáticos de Mimosa bimucronata (DC) sobre
espécies cultivadas. Pesquisa Agropecuária
Brasileira, Brasília, v. 26, n. 7, p. 935-43, 1991.
10-KINDEL, A. Diversidade e estratégias de dispersão de plantas vasculares da floresta paludosa do Faxinal, Torres, RS. 2002. 102 f. Tese
(Doutorado em Botânica) – Instituto de Biociências, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do
Sul, Porto Alegre, 2002.
11-KLEINPAUL, I. S.; SCHUMACHER, M. V.;
BRUN, E. J.; BRUN, F. G. K.; KLEEINPAUL,
J. J. Suficiência amostral para coletas de serrapilheira acumulada sobre o solo em Pinus elliottii
Engelm, Eucalyptus sp. e floresta estacional decidual. Revista Árvore, Viçosa, v. 29, n. 6, p.965972, 2005.
12-MARANGONI, J. C. Caracterização da paisagem de uma área de preservação: Estudo de caso
da Lagoinha (Rio Grande, RS). Atlântica, Rio
Grande, v. 25, n. 2, p.163-169, 2003.
13-MATTEI, V. L. & LONGHI S. J. Avaliação da
Regeneração Natural de Eucalyptus paniculata
Smith. Ciência Florestal, Santa Maria, v. 11, n.
1, p.55-65, 2001.
14-MUELLER-DOMBOIS, D.; ELLENBERG, H.
Aims and Methods of Vegetation Ecology. New
York: Wiley, 1974. 547 p.
15-MÜLLER, S. C.; WAECHTER, J. L. Estrutura
sinusial dos componentes herbáceo e arbustivo
de uma floresta costeira subtropical. Revista
Brasileira de Botânica, São Paulo, v. 24, n. 4, p
395-406, 2001.
16-NERI, A. V.; CAMPOS, E. P.; DUARTE, T. G.;
NETO, J. A. A. M.; SILVA, A. F.; VALENTE,
G. E. Regeneração de espécies nativas lenhosas
sob plantio de Eucalyptus em área de Cerrado
na Floresta Nacional de Paraopeba, MG, Brasil.
Acta Botanica Brasilica, Feira de Santana, v. 19,
n. 2, p. 369-376, 2005.
17-NEWMASTER, S.G.; BELL, F.W.; ROOSENBOOM, C.R.; COLE, H.A.; TOWILL, W.D. Restoration of floral diversity through plantations on
abandoned agricultural land. Canadian Journal
of Forest Research, v. 36, p. 1218–1235, 2006.
18-PORTO, M. L.; DILLENBURG, L. R. Fisionomia e Composição Florística de uma Mata de
Restinga da Estação Ecológica do Taim, Brasil.
Ciência e Cultura, v. 38, n. 7, p. 1228-1236, 1986.
19-REIS, A.; ROGALSKI, J. M.; TRÊS, D. R.;
SIMINSKI, A.; HMELJEVSKI, K.; BOURCHEID, K.; SCARIOT, E.; WIESBAUER, M.
B.; SANTA ANNA, C. Novos Aspectos na Restauração de Áreas Degradadas. Florianópolis:
UFSC, 2006. 106 p.
20-SAPORETTI, A. W.; NETO, J. A. A. M.; ALMADO, R. Fitossociologia de Sub-bosque de
Cerrado em Talhão de Eucalyptus grandis W.
Hill ex Maiden no Município de Bom Despacho
– MG. Revista Árvore, Viçosa, v. 27, n. 6, p. 905910, 2003.
21-SIMÕES-JESUS, M. F.; CASTELLANI, T. T.
Avaliação do potencial facilitador de Eucalyptus sp. na restinga da Praia da Joaquina, Ilha de
Santa Catarina, SC. Biotemas, Florianópolis, v.
20, n. 3, p. 27-35, 2007.
22-TRES, D. R.; REIS, A. Perspectivas sistêmicas
para a conservação e restauração ambiental:
do pontual ao contexto. 1. ed. - Itajaí: Herbário
Barbosa Rodrigues, 2009. 374 p.
23-VIANI, R.A.G.; DURIGAN, G.; MELO, A.C.G.
A regeneração natural sob plantações florestais:
desertos verdes ou redutos de Biodiversidade?
Ciência Florestal, Santa Maria, v. 20, n. 3, p.
533-552, 2010.
24-ZACHIA, R. A. Diferenciação de Componentes
Herbáceos e Arbustivos em Florestas do Parque
Nacional da Lagoa do Peixe, Tavares – Rio
Grande do Sul. 2006. 164 f. Tese (Doutorado
em Botânica), Instituto de Biociências, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Porto
Alegre. 2006.
25-ZANCHETTA, A. D.; PINHEIRO, L. S. Análise
biofísica dos processos envolvidos na invasão
biológica de sementes de Pinus elliottii na Estação Ecológica de Itirapina – SP e Alternativas de
Manejo. Climatologia e Estudos da Paisagem,
Rio Claro, v. 2, n. 1, p. 72, 2007.
26-ZILLER, S. R.; GALVÃO, F. A Degradação da
estepe gramíneo-lenhosa no Paraná por contaminação biológica de Pinus elliottii e P. taeda. Revista Floresta, Curitiba, v. 32, n. 1, p. 41-44, 2002.
50
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 50
09/10/2012 13:43:59
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
The Influence of feeding tree spatial distribution and fruit
abundance in the location of sleeping trees in the common
marmoset, Callitrix jacchus (Primates: Callitrichidae).
Gustavo André Fernandes Silveira - Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte.
(email:gustavoandrefs@yahoo.com.br)
Carla Soraia Soares de Castro - Universidade Federal da Paraíba, Campus IV, Rio Tinto, Departamento
de Engenharia e Meio Ambiente (email: carlasoraia@ccae.ufpb.br)
ABSTRACT
Security against predators, the proximity of food sources and cohesion within the group
are factors which can have an influence on the localization of sleeping trees in primates.
The aim was to investigate the influence of spatial distribution of gum and fruit trees,
and the abundance of fruit in the localization of sleeping trees in the common marmoset.
Two groups of marmosets living in the Parque das Natal, Rio Grande do Norte State
were studied. Instantaneous scan sampling was used to register, at 5 minute intervals,
their position on maps of the area, and to identify the localization of sleeping trees.
Frequency of use of the same trees was also recorded. The species of trees used for fruit
consumption, the extraction of gum and for sleeping were identified. Phenological data
were collected monthly to determine the periods of fruit abundance. Sleeping trees were
randomly distributed, without any apparent relationship to the aggregated distribution of
gum and fruit trees. 38, Nonetheless, the abundance of fruit seemed to be an important
factor in the use of space and in the localization of sleeping trees. Both, the presence of
potential predators and the nonconsecutive use of sleeping trees, seem to indicate protection against predators as being another important factor in the localization of sleeping
trees in the study-area.
Key words: common marmoset; sleeping trees; food sources; predators
INTRODUCTION
Arboreal primates typically sleep in
trees. They use either the forks of branches, holes
in the trunk (38, 43) the surface of leaves (23, 47,
5), nests they themselves build (26) or even bird´s
nests (29) in the process.
Predator risk has been defined as the main
determinant in the location of sleeping trees (15, 25,
22, 1, 17, 7, 3, 37). Nevertheless, other variables,
such as the proximity of food and water resources,
ranging patterns and territoriality aspects, security from falls, physical comfort, hygiene, parasite
avoidance, group cohesion, resource availability
and thermoregulation, are also important (16, 20,
44, 4, 23, 1, 3, 27, 14, 5).
Some species of primates (e.g. Ateles geoffroyi (11), Colobus guereza (46), Hylobates pileatus
(36), Saguinus fuscicollis and S. mystax (40), Trachypithecus leucocephalus (28) prefer to sleep close
to available food resources. The strategy to wake
up close to food, decrease the time and energy spent
in foraging. Apparently, in the case of these species,
this factor is more important than sleeping in safety
against predators.
The common marmoset (Callitrix jacchus) is a primate species endemic to the Brazilian northeast. Although its distribution was
51
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 51
09/10/2012 13:43:59
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
originally restricted to this part, introduced
populations can now be found in other regions
of Brazil (43). It is now found in Atlantic Forest fragments, in the Caatinga (21), and in mangrove swamps (32). Through its adaptability to
various environments, by living in the Atlantic Forest, this species inhabits one of the most
threatened biomes in the world. This biome has
been extensively transformed into a fragmented
landscape (35), through convertion to alternative
land usage, such as agriculture and pasture (45).
Incidentally, several studies of small fragments
of this forest have reported on the proximity
of trees that serve for sleeping to feeding trees
(1,8).
OBJECTIVES
Under this perspective, the aim was to investigate the influence of gum and fruit tree spatial
distribution, and fruit abundance in the location of
sleeping trees.
METHODOLOGY
Study area
The study took place in a conservation
area, in the Parque Estadual das Dunas (PED), in
northeast Brazil (5° 48’ S – 35° 12’ W). PED comprises a 1.175 ha fragment of the Atlantic Forest,
7 ha of which corresponding to a public area (24).
There are large trees, extensive plant cover, a vast
and continuous canopy, and high epiphyte density.
With an idea to conservation, access is restricted to
research and educational trails, with daily, though
partial, monitoring.
The public area, with many exotic plants
and gaps, harbors around a thousand tree species.
There is also a touristic infrastructure for receiving more than 2.000 people daily. Each year, about
65.000 visitors find entertainment in the structure
of the park itself, walking trails and picnicking, or
simply by enjoying nature.
There are records of the presence of boa constrictors (Boa constrictor), black vultures (Coragyps
atratus), turkey vultures (Cathartes aura), roadside
hawks (Buteo magnirostris), great black hawks (Buteogallus urubutinga), white-tailed kites (Elanus leu-
curus), and the southern carcara (Polyborus plancus)
(24), all liable Callithrix jacchus predators.
Data collection
From January to December, 2007, two
groups of common marmosets (A and L) came under observation. Both inhabited the public area,
and only used the forest area sporadically. In the
former, there are trees conducing to fruit and gum
consumption, and sleeping. Both groups were accustomed to the presence of researchers, and had
already undergone capture and individual identification in previous years.
Instantaneous scan sampling (2), at 5-minute intervals, was chosen for recording the location
of the marmosets on area maps containing alphanumeric system 20x20m quadrants, and for identifying the location of sleeping trees. These data also
constituted the base for calculating the home range
of each group, obtained as a sum of the quadrants
visited. Frequency-of-use of sleeping trees was recorded, to so determine the proportion of use, by
plant species.
The tree species turned to use for fruit
consumption, gum extraction and sleeping, were
identified taxonomically by on-the-spot floristic studies (18). Phenological data were collected
monthly to determine the peak periods of fruit
abundance. Fruiting was quantified using the
semi-quantitative method (19), whence five classes
of abundance are inferred, 0) absence of fruit; 1)
1-25% of fruit; 2) 26-50% of fruit; 3) 51-75% of
fruit; and 4) 76-100% of fruit (19). Sleeping trees
were identified, and measurements taken of height
and diameter at breast height.
The distance from the nearest neighbor
(R) was used to define spatial patterns of gum and
fruit tree, and sleeping tree distribution. R=1 indicates random distribution; R>1 uniform distribution, and R<1 aggregated distribution (12). The frequencies of monthly marmoset visits recorded for
each quadrant in the home range were compared
through one-way ANOVA (5%) and Tukey testing
(5%). Spearman correlation analysis was used to
investigate the relationship between frequency of
use for sleeping and tree-height, frequency of use
for sleeping and diameter of sleeping trees, and
sleeping-tree height and diameter.
52
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 52
09/10/2012 13:43:59
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
RESULTS
Eight different trees belonging to five species
were used for sleeping. Coccoloba sp. (Polygonaceae); Bowdichia virgilioides HBK, (Fabaceae); Cassia
apoucoita Aubl. (Leg. Caesalpinoideae) and Pouteria
grandiflora (Sapotaceae) were used by group L, and
Coccoloba sp.; Buchenavia capitata (Combretaceae)
and Pouteria grandiflora by group A. Diameters at
breast height (DBH) ranged from 28.3 to 236.82 cm,
and heights from 12 to 24 m (Table I).
No significant correlations were found between DBH and height of sleeping trees (r=0,02; p=0,95
N=16 ), DBH and frequency of use of sleeping trees (r=0,09; p=0,82; N=16), and height and frequency of use
of sleeping trees (r=0,59; p=0,12; N=16), whereby the
inference of other variables influencing choice.
Gum trees were located between 10 and
42 meters from sleeping trees, whereas fruit trees
were between 8 and 27 meters away. Of the eight
trees used by groups for sleeping, two were located
at the edge of the main forest (n=3) and six in the
Table I – Identification of species, height and location of sleeping trees by groups of common marmosets.
Species
Nº Height Records of use
Location
as sleeping trees
(n)
Coccoloba sp.
1
12 m
3
Public area
Coccoloba sp.
2
14 m
5
Public area
Bowdichia virgilioides
3
17,5 m
4
Public area
Bowdichia
virgilioides of species, height and 4location
24 of
m sleeping trees6 by groups Public
area marmosets.
Table I – Identification
of common
Species Aubl.
of use
Location
Edge of
remnant
Cassia apoucoita
5
20Nºm Height Records
1
as
sleeping
trees
Coccoloba sp.
6
18 m
3
Public area
(n)
Buchenavia
capitata
Eichl.
7
17
m
2
Edge of
remnant
Coccoloba sp.
1
12 m
3
Public
area
Pouteria grandiflora
8
22
m
5
Public
area
Coccoloba sp.
2
14 m
5
Public area
Bowdichia virgilioides
3
17,5 m
4
Public area
For sleeping purposes, Group L showed a public area (n=26) between 20 and 80 meters from
Bowdichia virgilioides
4
24 m
6
Public area
preference (50)% for Bowdichia virigiloides,, where- the main forest edge (Table I). Sources of fruit, gum
remnant
Cassia apoucoita Aubl. Fruiting
5
20 m
Family
Species
Group 1 LocationEdge
of offruit
as Group A preferred (75%) Coccoloba sp.. Although and sleeping trees were
distributed over the 0.94 ha
trees
Coccoloba sp.
6
18 m
3
Public area
re-use of sleeping
trees
was detected February
on severaltooccaand 1.3 ha + 0.7 (+ stanCecropiaceae
Cecropia
adenopus
March7 + 0.417(+mstandard
L deviation)
Buchenavia
capitata Eichl.
2 PA/F Edge of remnant
sions, this did
not occur on consecutive days.
dard deviation) areas, corresponding to the home
Campomanesia
Pouteria grandiflora
22 m
March and April 8
L/A 5 PA/F Public area
Myrtaceae
dichotoma
Table 2– Fruiting periods and location of trees used by groups L and A for fruit consumption.
Myrtaceae
Hexaclamys itatiaiae
January, February and March
L/R
PA/F
Where PA
= Public area and F = February
Forest and March
Poligonaceae
Coccoloba sp.
L/A
PA/F
Boraginaceae
January Fruiting
A
Family Cordia superba
Species
Rhamnaceae
Zizyphus joazeiro
December and January
A
January,February
February,
Cecropiaceae
Cecropia adenopus
to March and
A
Myrtaceae
Sizygium jambolanum
Campomanesia April
March and April
Myrtaceae
Anacardium
November,
December,
dichotoma
L/A
Anacardiaceae
occidentale
January
Myrtaceae
Hexaclamys itatiaiae
January, February and March
December,
January
Poligonaceae
February
and Marchand A
Anacardiaceae
MangiferaCoccoloba
indica sp.
Boraginaceae Cordia superba FebruaryJanuary
MyrtaceaeRhamnaceae
Eugenia malaccensis
Zizyphus joazeiroDecember
December and January A
Myrtaceae
Sizygium jambolanum
Anacardiaceae
Anacardium
occidentale
Anacardiaceae
Mangifera indica
Myrtaceae
Eugenia malaccensis
January, February, March and
April
November,
December,
January
December,
January
and
February
December
PA
Group
PA/F
L
PA
L/A
PA
L/R
L/APA
A
A PA
PA/F
PA/F
PA
PA/F
A
PA
L/A
PA
A
PA
A
PA
Location of fruit
trees
PA/F
PA/F
53
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 53
09/10/2012 13:43:59
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
ranges of groups A and L, respectively.
The fruit consumed by both groups came
from ten tree-species with overlapping fruiting periods (Table II). There were significant differences
in the frequency of monthly visits to the various
quadrants, mainly as regards group A (F=3.48 df=
4; p=0.01). Visits were significantly higher in January, February and March, when a higher number of
fruiting species was recorded. Most visited quadrants were those containing fruiting trees, with overlapping where at least one sleeping site was located.
Trees for fruit consumption and gum extraction were
distributed in the aggregate (R A=0.78 and RL=0.71),
and sleeping trees randomly (R A=1.27 and RL= 1.23).
Despite the presence of marmoset predators, no actual predation was recorded in the study
area. Nonetheless, marmosets were vigilant on a
number of occasions. Upon perceiving a great black
hawk (Buteogallus urubitinga) in flight, they vocally warned other members of the group, before
hiding behind branches and foliage.
DISCUSSION
In the present study, gum and fruit trees
were distributed in the aggregate and sleeping trees
randomly. Aggregate distribution signifies the individual tendency to stay together at particular sites
in the environment, whereas in random distribution, there is the likelihood of individual disposition
at any point whatsoever (13). On the other hand,
distances between gum, sleeping and fruit trees
were short, to so facilitate marmoset locomotion to
neighboring areas when searching for food, thereby
reducing overall travel costs. A similar pattern has
already been noted in several primates, such as Ateles geoffroyi (11), Saguinus mystax and Saguinus
fuscicollis (23) and Callithrix jacchus (33).
The home range of primates from the Callitrix genus varies from 0.5 to 5 ha, with C. jacchus
presenting the smallest ever recorded. The home
range in this case is closely related to the distribution pattern of gum and fruit trees (38).The aggregate-type pattern of both justifies the establishment
of two small territories wherever they occur. Above
all, even though C. jacchus requires a minimum
area to survive, the adequate availability of gum
trees is essential (39).
Differences in visit-frequency to quadrants
in the home range, clearly shows the influence of
fruit abundance on space-use patterns and sleepingtree location. The strong influence of gum trees and
fruit abundance on the use of space, is especially
manifest in groups of marmosets living in forest
remnants or orchards (9)
Common marmosets may sleep in trees
with or without dense foliage or epiphyte cover (1,
33), high up in palm trees (30), or much lower in the
canopy (8, 33). The sleeping trees used by marmosets in the PED area were robust, with DBH ranging
between 28,3 and 236,82 cm, and heights ranging
from 12 to 22 m. They slept in the forks of branches,
where group members aggregated in a ball-like formation. This behavior probably serves to confuse
possible predators through taking on the appearance
of either a much larger animal or even a termite nest
(16). According to an early study, the sleeping trees
used by Callitrix flaviceps varied in height from 8 to
more than 20 m. Through being densely overgrown
with climbers, they were relatively isolated from the
surrounding vegetation, thus offering safe sleepingquarters for the group members huddled together in
a large ball (17).
There are many potential marmoset predators in the PED. A study of an area where predators had been eradicated demonstrated that sleeping
trees were located in the sites of highest feedingtree concentration (33). Regardless of its structure,
the authors considered that the key variable defining sleeping-site location was the availability and
location of immediate food sources. In the present
study the availability of food, especially fruits, was
more important than the location of their sources.
Although there are no records of common
marmoset predation in PED, their response to potential aerial predators, such as the black hawk (Buteogallus urubutinga), presupposes that marmosets
are capable of recognizing the characteristic flight
profile of falconiforms, with the consequential and
immediate reaction through avoidance. This response to potential aerial predators has been recorded in Callitrix jacchus (29), and C. flaviceps (17).
The loud alarm call sometimes elicits a response
from other group members, while in the act of taking cover and remaining completely motionless. On
taking cover at relatively low levels in the forest, the
54
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 54
09/10/2012 13:43:59
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
animals normally move to the underside of the supporting branch by way of a rapid lateral movement.
Other studies have recorded a collared forest-falcon
(Micrastur semitorquatus) predating an adult marmoset (1), a roadside hawk (Rupornis magnirostris)
predating an infant (29), and an unsuccessful attempt on a group (8).
Earlier studies identified aspects related to
the structure and location of sleeping trees in areas
where predators were present. Totally hidden by a
dense entangled mass of lianas, climbers and epiphytes (1, 43, 6,17), and located at the edge of the
forest, bordering open fields (42, 41), they were distributed throughout the home range, and remained
without use for several successive nights (41). This
is in accordance with the present findings, in that the
sleeping trees used by both groups in PED were close
to the forest edge and not used on consecutive days.
Sleeping tree location is crucial for survival
where predation risk is high, albeit less so, where
predators are extinct (33). In the latter case, dailyfood acquisition, rather than predators, would be the
limiting factor. In the case of PED, and in spite of
the importance of fruit abundance in space-usage
and sleeping-tree location, the local presence of
predators, and the non-consecutive use of sleeping
trees, point to protection as an important factor in
the location of sleeping trees among marmosets.
Differences in these results and those obtained in earlier studies (31, 8, 34, 33) reveal diversity in the strategies adopted by the common marmoset to selectively locate sleeping trees under the
prevailing circumstances.
CONCLUSION
This study offers important contributions
to an understanding of the prevailing strategies
among primates, when selectively locating sleeping
trees. Location, as employed by two groups of marmosets in the Parque das Dunas, was not influenced
by the distribution pattern of gum and fruit trees,
but by fruit abundance and the presence of potential predators, thereby showing the relationship between the strategy adopted and the type of pressure
encountered. Finally, the understanding of resource
distribution and sleeping tree location, perceptibly
furnishes relevant factors towards the conservation
of primates, in that their correct management could
contribute to primate population viability.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
We are grateful to Mary Savage Praxedes
and Alexandre Gusmão, managers of the Parque
Estadual das Dunas, for permission to carry out this
study in the Conservation area, as well as to the Instituto de Defesa do Meio Ambiente do Rio Grande
do Norte (IDEMA) for financial support.
RESUMO
A segurança contra os predadores, a proximidade das fontes de alimento e a coesão do grupo
são fatores que podem influenciar a localização de
árvores de dormir em primatas. Este estudo objetivou
investigar a influência da distribuição de árvores de
goma e de frutos e a abundância de frutos na localização das árvores de dormir dos sagüis. Dois grupos
de sagüis que vivem no Parque Estadual das Dunas,
em Natal, RN, foram estudados. A varredura instantânea de amostragem foi utilizada para registrar
a cada 5 min a localização dos sagüis nos mapas da
área e para identificar a localização das árvores para
dormir. A freqüência de uso de árvores para dormir
foi registrada. As espécies das árvores utilizadas para
o consumo de frutas, extração de goma e dormitório
foram identificadas, e os dados fenológicos foram
coletados mensalmente para determinar os períodos
de abundância de frutos. As árvores de dormir estavam distribuídas aleatoriamente, aparentemente não
possuindo relação com a distribuição agregada das
árvores de goma e de frutos. No entanto, a abundância de frutos se apresentou como um fator importante
na utilização do espaço e na localização das árvores
para dormir. A presença de pontenciais predadores
do sagüi, e o uso não-consecutivo de árvores de dormir apontam a proteção contra os predadores como
um outro fator importante na localização das árvores
de dormir na área do estudo.
REFERENCES
1- ALONSO, C.; LANGGUTH, A.. Ecologia e comportamento de Callithrix jacchus (Primates:
Callithrichidae) numa ilha de floresta Atlântica.
55
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 55
09/10/2012 13:43:59
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Revista Nordestina de Biologia, v. 6, n. 2, p.
105–137, 1989.
2- ALTMANN, J. Observational study of behavior:
Sampling methods. Behaviour, v. 49, n. 3/4, p.
227-267, 1974.
3- ANDERSON, J. R. Sleep, sleeping sites, and
sleep-related activities: awakening to their significance. Am. J. Primatol. v. 46, p. 63–75, 1998.
4- AQUINO, R.; ENCARNACIÓN, F. Characteristics and use of sleeping sites in Aotus (Cebidae:
Primates) in the Amazon lowlands of Peru. Am.
J. Primatol. v. 11, p. 319–331, 1986.
5- BITETTI, M.S.; VIDAL, E.M.; BALDOVINO,
M.C. & BENESOVSKY, V. Sleeping site preferences in tufted capuchin monkeys (Cebus apella
nigritus). Am. J. Primatol. v. 50, p. 257-274,
2000.
6- CABRAL, M. C. C. Uso da área domiciliar de
um grupo de Callithrix jacchus (Callithrichidae, Primates) na Estação Ecológica do Tapacurá- Pernambuco, Brazil. BSc thesis, Federal
Rural University of Pernambuco, Brazil, 1989.
7- CAINE, N.G.; POTTER, M.P.; MAYER, K.E.
Sleeping site selection by captive tamarins (Saguinus labiatus). Ethology v. 90, p. 63–71, 1992.
8- CAMAROTTI, F. L. M.; MONTEIRO DA
CRUZ, M. A. O. Fatores ecológicos e comportamentais implicados na seleção e uso dos locais
de pernoite de grupos de Callithrix jacchus em
ambiente natural, p. 27–42, 1997. In: SOUZA,
M.B.C.; MENEZES, A.A. L. (Eds). A Primatologia no Brazil 6. Natal, Editora da Universidade
Federal do Rio Grande do Norte.
9- CASTRO, C. S. S. Tamanho da área de vida e
padrão de uso do espaço em grupos de sagüis,
Callithrix jacchus, Linaeus, 1758 (Primates,
Callitrichidae). Revista Brasileira de Zoologia,
Curitiba-PR, v. 20, n. 1, p. 91-96, 2003.
10- CASTRO, C. S. S.; ARAÚJO, A. Diet and Feeding behavior of marmoset, Callithrix jacchus.
Brazilian Journal of Ecology v. 10, p. 16-21,
2007.
11- CHAPMAN, C. A.; CHAPMAN, L. J.;
MCLAUGHLIN, R. L. Multiple central place
foraging by spider monkeys: travel consequences of using many sleeping sites. Oecologia v. 79,
p. 506–511, 1989.
12- CLARK, P. J.; EVANS, F. C. Distance
to Nearest Neighbor as a Measure of Spatial Relationships in Populations. Ecology v. 35, n. 4, p.
445-453, 1954.
13- DALE, M.R.T.; Spatial pattern analysis in plant
ecology. Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press, 1999, p. 326.
14- DAY, R. T.; ELWOOD, R. W. Sleeping site selection by the golden-handed tamarin Saguinus
midas midas: The role of predation risk, proximity to feeding sites, and territorial defence.
Ethology v. 105, p. 1035-1051, 1999.
15- DAWSON, G.A. Behavioral ecology of the Panamanian tamarin, Saguinus oedipus. Unpubl.
Ph.D. dissertation, Michigan State Univ., East
Lansing, 1976.
16- DAWSON, G.A. The use of time and space by
the Panamanian tamarin Saguinus oedipus. Folia Primatol. v. 31, p. 253-284, 1979.
17- FERRARI, S. F.; LOPES-FERRARI, M.A.
Predator avoidance behaviour in the buffy-headed marmoset, Callithrix flaviceps. Primates v.
31, p. 323–338, 1990.
18- FREIRE, M. S. B. Levantamento Florístico do
Parque Estadual Dunas de Natal. Acta Botânica Brasilica v. 4, n. 2, p. 131-142, 1990.
19- FOURNIER, L.A. Un método cuantitativo para
la medición de características fenológicas en árboles. Turrialba v. 24, p. 422-423, 1974.
20- HAUSFATER, G.; MAEDE, B. J. Alternation
of sleeping groves by yellow baboons (Papio
cynocephalus) as a strategy for parasites avoidance. Primates v. 23, p. 287–297, 1982.
21- HERSHKOVITZ, P. Living New World monkeys (Platyrrhini) with an introduction to Primates. Chicago, University of Chicago Press,
1977, p. 117.
22- HEYMANN, E.W. A field observation of predation on a moustached tamarin (Saguinus mystax)
by an anaconda. Int. J. Primatol. v. 8, p. 193-195,
1987.
23- HEYMANN, E.W. Sleeping habits of tamarins,
Saguis mystax and Saguinus fuscicollis (Mammalia; Primates: Callitrichidae in north-eastern
Peru. J. Zool. Lond. v. 237, p. 211–226, 1995.
24- IDEC/IDEMA, Plano de manejo: Parque Estadual Dunas do Natal, 1989. - Available online at: http.//www.idema.rn.gov.br [Acessed:
08/02/2010]
56
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 56
09/10/2012 13:44:00
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
25- IZAWA, K. A field study of the ecology and
behavior of the black-mantle tamarin (Saguinus
nigricollis). Primates v. 19, p. 241-274, 1978.
26- JONES, C.; JONES C.A.; JONES JR, J.K.
& WILSON, D.E. Pan troglodytes. Mammalian
Species v. 529, p. 1-9, 1996.
27- KAPELLER, P. M. Nests, tree holes, and the
evolution of primate life histories. Am. J. Primatol. v. 46, p. 7–33, 1998.
28- LI, D., ZHOU, Q., TANG X., HUANG H.,
HUANG C., Sleeping site use of the whiteheaded langur Trachypithecus leucocephalus: The role of predation risk, territorial defense, and proximity to feeding sites Current
Zoology(formerly Acta Zoologica Sinica), v. 57,
n. 3, p. 260 – 268, 2011.
29- LYRA-NEVES, R.M.; OLIVEIRA, M.A.B.;
TELINO-JÚNIOR; W.R. & DOS SANTOS,
E. M. . Comportamentos Interespecíficos entre
Callithrix jacchus (Linnaeus) (Primates, Callitrichidae) e algumas aves de Mata Atlântica, Pernambuco, Brasil. Revista Brasileira de Zoologia
v. 24, n. 3, p. 709-716, 2007.
30- MENEZES, M.O.T. The Use of Date Palms
(Phoenix sp.) as Resting and Sleeping Sites by
Callithrix jacchus in Northeastern Brazil. Neotropical Primates v. 12, n. 2, p. 53-55, 2004.
31- MENDES PONTES, A. R. Influência dos fatores ambientais e comportamentais na dinâmica de um grupo selvagem de Callithrix jacchus
(Callitrichidae, Primate) na mata de Dois Irmãos, Recife, Pernambuco, Brazil. BSc thesis,
Federal University of Pernambuco, Brazil, 1989.
32- MENDES PONTES, A.R.; MONTEIRO DA
CRUZ, M. A. O. Home range, intergroup transfers and reproductive status of common marmosets Callithrix jacchus in a forest fragment in
Northeastern Brazil. Primates v. 36, p. 335-347,
1995.
33- MENDES PONTES, A.R.M.; LIRA
SOARES, M. Sleeping sites of common marmosets (Callithrix jacchus) in defaunated urban
forest fragments: a strategy to maximize food
intake. J. Zool. London. v. 266, p. 55-63, 2005.
34- MONTEIRO DA CRUZ, M. A. O. Dinâmica reprodutiva de uma população de sagüis-do-nordeste (Callithrix jacchus) na Estação Ecológica
de Tapacurá. PhD thesis, University of São Pau-
lo, 1998.
35- MORI, S. A. Eastern, extra-Amazonian Brazil.
p. 428–454, 1989. in Campbell, D. G. & Hammond, H. D. (Eds). Floristic inventory of tropical countries: the status of plant systematics,
collections, and vegetation, plus recommendations for the future. New York Botanical Garden, New York.
36- PHOONJAMPA, R., KOENIG, A., BORRIES
C., GALE, G.A., SAVIN,T. Selection of Sleeping Trees in Pileated Gibbons (Hylobates pileatus). American Journal of Primatology, v. 72, p.
617–625, 2010.
37- REICHARD, U. Sleeping sites, sleeping places,
and the presleep behaviour of gibbons. Am. J.
Primatol. v. 46, p. 35–62, 1998.
38- RYLANDS, A.B.; FARIA, D.S. Habitats, feeding, and home range size in the genus Callithrix,
p. 262-272, 1993. In: RYLANDS, A.B. (Ed).
Marmosets and Tamarins (Systematics, Behaviour, and Ecology). New York, Oxford Univ.
Press, p. 396.
39- SCANLON, C. E.; CHALMERS, N. R.; MONTEIRO DA CRUZ, M. A. O. Home range use
and the explotation of gum in the marmoset Callithrix jacchus jacchus. Intern. J. Primatol, v. 10,
p. 123-136, 1989.
40- SMITH A.C., KNOGGE C., HUCK M., LÖTTKER P., BUCHANAN-SMITH H.M. Long-term
patterns of sleeping site use in wild saddleback
Saguinus fuscicollis and mustached tamarins S.
mystax: effects of foraging, thermoregulation,
predation, and resource defense constraints.
American Journal of Physical Anthropology v.
134, p. 340–353, 2007.
41- SNOWDON, C. T.; SOINI, P. The tamarins genus. In Ecology and behaviour of Neotropical
Primates: p. 246–248, 1988. In: MITTERMEIER, R. A., RYLANDS, A. B., COIMBRA-FILHO, A. F. ; FONSECA, G. A. B. (Eds).Washington, DC:WorldWildlife Fund.
42- SOINI, P. The pygmymarmoset, genus Cebuella.In Ecology and behaviour of Neotropical Primates: p. 79–129, 1988 In: (Eds).Washington,
DC:WorldWildlife Fund.
43- STEVENSON, M.F.; A.B. RYLANDS. The marmosets, genus Callithrix, p. 131-211, 1988. In: MITTERMEIER, R. A., RYLANDS, A. B., COIM-
57
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 57
09/10/2012 13:44:00
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
BRA-FILHO, A. F.; FONSECA, G. A. B. (Eds).
Ecology and Behavior of Neotropical Primates.
Washington, D.C., World Wildlife Fund, p. 610.
44- TILSON, R. L.; TENAZA, R. R. Interspecific
spacing between gibbons (Hylobates klossii)
and langurs (Presbytis potenziani) on Siberut
island, Indonesia. Am. J. Primatol. v. 2, p. 355–
361, 1982.
45- VIANA, V. M.; TABANEZ, A. J.; BATISTA, J.
L. Dynamics and restoration of forest fragments
in the Brazilian Atlantic moist forest. p. 351–365,
1997. in Laurance, W. F. & Bierregaard, R. O. Jr
(Eds). Tropical forest remnants: ecology, management, and conservation of fragmented communities. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
46- VON HIPPEL, F.A. Use of sleeping trees by
black and white colobus monkeys Colobus guereza in the Kekamega forest, Kenya. American
Journal of Primatology v. 45, p. 281–290, 1998.
47- ZHANG, S.Y. Sleeping habits of brown capuchin monkeys (Cebus apella) in French Guiana.
Am. J. Primatol. v. 36, p. 327-335, 1995.
58
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 58
09/10/2012 13:44:00
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Environmental impacts caused by roads and trails in the
Altomontana Private Reserve, Itamonte, Minas Gerais.
Ana Cristina Magalhães de França - Universidade Federal de Lavras, Departamento de Biologia/Setor de
Ecologia (e-mail: anafranca.bio@gmail.com)
Felipe Santana Machado - Universidade Federal de Lavras, Departamento de Ciências Florestais (e-mail:
epilefsama@hotmail.com)
Rosângela Alves Tristão Borém - Universidade Federal de Lavras, Departamento de Biologia/Setor de
Ecologia (e-mail: tristao@dbi.ufla.br)
Luís Antônio Coimbra Borges - Universidade Federal de Lavras, Departamento de Ciências Florestais (email: luis.borges@dcf.ufla.br)
ABSTRACT
The adequate planning and management of highways contribute to reducing environmental impacts. In conservation units, the evaluation of possible environmental impacts
caused by roads has facilitated the adoption of preventive action, with a view to avoiding
biodiversity loss. In this sense, impacts caused by roads and trails in the Altomontana
Private Reserve, Itamonte, Minas Gerais State, Brazil, were assessed, as a means of obtaining information for improving road and trail management in the unit, as well as mitigating those impacts that generate local environmental degradation. Internal roadways
of the property were scoured, and points along the altitude gradient marked. A grading
impact array was used for standardizing observations. Marks of 0 to 3 were attributed
to characterizing the intensity of impacts, with positive or negative signs added, according to the type of impact. Among the observed environmental impacts caused by roads,
erosion, the most outstanding variable, occurred at all altitudes, with discarded waste as
runner up. All told, local vegetation appeared to be well-conserved, with the variation in
altitude favoring the formation of various physiognomies, thereby constituting an appropriate environment for developing local community activities as part of environmental
education programs.
Key words: Environmental impact assessment; roads; conservation unit.
INTRODUCTION
The divulgation of environmental damage
by organizations dedicated to the protection of the
environment has contributed decisively towards
consolidating the Evaluation of Environmental Impacts (EEI), as a tool for registering data applied to
measuring the consequences arising from anthropic
activities in natural ecosystems, and as a forerunner of means for taking the necessary steps towards
maintaining the quality of the environment (22).
Following the United Nations Conference on the
Environment, in 1972, there have been modifications in the policies for development and economic
intervention, which are no longer exclusively orientated by economic-financial parameters. From there
on, environmental and socio-economic questions
have also been inserted (9), thereby leading to the
publication of literature specialized in evaluation
and reports on environmental impacts (25, 23, 17).
59
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 59
09/10/2012 13:44:00
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Around this time, the EEI turned up in
Brazil, as a prerequisite for financial research by
international organizations (24). Subsequently, this
was inserted into the National Policy for the Environment (NPE), regulated according to the Federal
Law 6.938/81. This later became obligatory on licensing processes involving polluting activities or
those modifying the natural environment (22). The
advance in the protection of Brazilian ecosystems
continued with the Federal Law 9.605|98. Law of
Environmental Crimes (5), and the Federal Law
9.985|00, which instituted the National System of
Nature Conservation Units (6) thereby establishing
criteria and norms for the creation, implantation and
management of Conservation Units (CU). Among
these, and within the group Sustainable Use, the
Private Reserve of Natural Patrimony (PRNP) is a
private area which aims at perpetually conserving
biodiversity, and, according to article 21, permits
scientific research, as well as tourism, recreation
and educational visits.
The evaluation of impacts caused by roads
is a recent line of research, and over the past few
years, studies have been developed with the aim of
acquiring knowledge on the possible effects on ecosystems (4, 8, 15, 18, 7). According to Gumier-Costa
& Sperber (200), some of these have emphasized the
impact of routes inside CUs, when considering that
trails and roads possibly induce the isolation and
fragmentation of environments, besides animal-hits
when crossing. The impacts pointed out by Forman
& Alexander (1998) include difficulty in dispersion
by native plants, the introduction of exotic species,
noise, changes in the levels of lighting, the attraction and repulsion of fauna, problems with drainage,
erosion, atmospheric pollution through the emission
of gases from fuel combustion, and the increase of
dust in the air. The evaluation of environmental
impacts caused by roads in CUs would effectively
contribute towards the improvement of management planning, thereby facilitating the adoption of
preventive and corrective action.
The aim was to assay and analyze environmental impacts caused by roads and trails inside
the Altomontana PRNP, in Itamonte, Minas Gerais
State, Brazil. As this unit is in the initial creation
phase, this study will contribute with relevant information towards the elaboration of management
planning. The specific aims were: a) describe environmental impacts caused by roads; b) analyze and
systematize data referring to road impacts, to so improve CU management; and c) propose mitigating
solutions for degraded areas.
METHODOLOGY
Study Area
The study took place in the Altomontana
PRNP, in Itamonte county, Minas Gerais State
(22º21’51”S and 44º48’29”W). The steep altitude
gradient varies from 1.450 to 2.400 meters. An inner road gives access to water slides, where the altitude reaches 2.140 meters. Close to the buildings at
the entrance of the unit, trails lead away to the waterfalls. The total CU area is 672 hectares, comprising a mosaic of phytophysiognomies, that of semi
deciduous seasonal forest being the most representative (sensu 27). The climate is of the Köppen Cwb
type, and mesothermic, with dry winters and mild,
rainy summers. The average annual temperature
varies from 17.4ºC to 19.8ºC. The dry season extends from May to September, with the driest period
occurring in June and July, and the rainiest during
December and January (21). The PRNP, a private
property inserted within the Area of Environmental
Protection (AEP) of the Serra da Mantiqueira, contains a large area with remnant Atlantic Rain Forest.
Sampling
The inner roads (main and adjacent, as
well as trails) were scoured and points marked at
the extremities and along the altitude gradient,
by means of GPS Garmin GPSMAP® 76Csx apparatus. Collected data was systematized in an
impact grading matrix, adapted from Leopold
et al. (1971), for standardizing observations and
analyzing impacts. Impacts were characterized
and analyzed by way of spot road-width measurements and respective intervention on roadside
vegetation. The height of the embankment was
evaluated in accordance with the roadside-presence of developed and adult native tree species,
and vegetal soil cover. Visual and risk characterization of the occurrence of impacts, such as fire,
erosion and waste, as well as other anthropic activities, were also investigated. The impacts were
quantitatively classified as to magnitude; points
60
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 60
09/10/2012 13:44:00
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
from zero to three were attributed for characterization, and qualitatively as to intrinsic value, to
which were added positive and negative signs, according to the type of impact. Summation indicated the most impacted sights. Employees were
interviewed as to outstanding natural events prior
to the study period, with visual documentation
(photographs) of the impact.
RESULTS
Impacts caused by anthropic activity, such
as visits, animal raising, the traffic of vehicles, and
the points of erosion arising from these activities,
were the most marked negative environmental impacts encountered along the road crossing the
property. Vegetal conservation and soil cover
were the most relevant positive aspects, these
acquiring the highest marks. Environmental impacts analyzed on the inner road of the CU appear
in Table 1. According to summation, the most
impacted environment was located at point 1,
close to the entrance of the PRNP. As informed,
the largest area of erosion (Point 1), acquired its
present form due to a land-slide that occurred in
2005, thereby starting the formation of a roadside ravine, at the moment 30 meters wide at the
northern end, and with a 13-meter-wide crater in
the south (Figures 1A and 1B). Points of erosion
were also noted at higher altitudes, this type of
visual impact being the most remarkable. In some
spots of the road, the incorrect drainage of rainwater has given rise to large natural ruts, thereby
indicating the formation of fresh points of erosion
(Figure 1C). Artificial ditches for better rain-water drainage were also seen.
Although small areas of erosion were noted
in points 2 and 3, generally speaking, final summation of positive and negative impacts indicated
adequate conservation of the stretch of road, roadside vegetation and height of embankments. A large
clump of bamboo was noted at a higher level
(Point 4). Its origin is unknown, and further studies
are required, as it was impossible to relate it to the
presence of a road (Figure 1D).
The highest negative impact caused by
anthropic activities along the road was in point 6,
where an artificial clearing had been made for the
installation of a telecommunication antenna. At
this point, besides complete soil exposure, there
was a considerable amount of remnant material.
At the highest point, 2.140 meters (Point 7), vestiges of unauthorized camping were found, clear
evidence of area vulnerability. This included signs
of a bonfire (Figure 3), non-biodegradable packaging, and the opening of a trail in the vegetation. Old scrawls on the rocks were noted as a main
negative visual impact (Figure 3).
Table 1: Environmental impacts on the road inside the Altomontana PRNP, Itamonte/MG.
Sampling points
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Altitude (m)
1.533
1.560
1.645
1.800
1.960
2.130
2.140
Erosion
-3
-1
-1
-1
0
-1*
0
Fire
0
0
0
0*
0
0
-2*
Waste
-1
-1
0
0
0
-3
-3*
Anthropic activity
-2
-1
-1
0
0
-3
-1*
Preservation of
+1
+2
+2
+1
+3
+1
+2*
vegetation
Height of canopyt
+3
+2
+1
+1
+3
0
0
Soil vegetation cover
+1
+2
+2
0
+3
0
+3
Visual impact
-3
-1
+2
-1
+3
-3
+2
Total impact at the
-4
+2
+5
0
+12
-9
+1
point
Extent of roadside
10,20
9,50
6,50
8,00
7,70
**
**
vegetation (m)
Road-width (m)
5,40
5,30
4,30
5,00
4,40
**
**
Legend:
Types of impact: [-] Negative impact; [+] Positive impact
Intensity of the impact: [0] None; [1] Low; [2] Medium; [3] High
*Vulnerable;
**Artificial clearing
Summation
-7
-2
-8
-8
+12
+10
+11
-1
+7
41,90
24,40
61
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 61
09/10/2012 13:44:00
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Apart from the main road, there are two
trails, the Trail to the Waterfall (Points 10, 11 and
12) and to the Forest of the Elves (Points 14,15 and
16). Both were scoured for signs of impacts (Table
2). The main vestiges found were the residues of
a bonfire, discarded non-biodegraded objects and
small points of erosion. Around the higher-placed
waterfall, the visual impact was great, due to stone
arches built by the former proprietor (Figure 4B).
This did not occur at the better conserved, lowerplaced waterfall. Positive points were the presence of alcoves appropriate for leisure, with wellinstalled grills. Nonetheless, the wrongly placed
bonfire residues close to the waterfall was a clear
indication of the need for dedicating more attention
to visitor orientation on the best use of the area. All
62
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 62
09/10/2012 13:44:00
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
along the trail, the well-preserved vegetation (Figures 4C and 4D) with enclosing canopy, and the
appearance of pioneer plants along the edges, were
clear indications of initial regeneration processes
(Figure 4A). Nowhere on the trails or around the
waterfalls were there garbage cans for the selective
collection of waste.
8
9
10
11
In point 9, 1.563 meters high, there is an
8-meter-wide road, adjacent to the main one and
leading to an abandoned building. The road is
around 800 meters long, and has been out of use for
more than 5 years. It is in the regeneration stage,
with the beginning of soil coverage by creepers.
Sampling points
12
13
Altitude (m)
2.110 1.563 1.490 1.465
Erosion
0
-3
0
-1
Fire
0*
0
0
0
Waste
0
-2
0
0
Anthropic activity
0
-2
0
0
Preservation of
+3
+3
+3
+3
vegetation
Height of canopy
+1
+3
+3
+3
Vegetation soil cover
+3
+3
+3
+2
Visual impact
+1
-2
+3
-1
Point total impact
+8
0
+12
+6
5,80
4,50
4,40
2,80
Extent of roadside
vegetation (m)
Road-width (m)
3,00
4,00
2,40
2,00
Legend:
Types of impact: [-] Negative impact; [+] Positive impact
Impact Intensity: [0] None; [1] Low; [2] Medium; [3] High
*Vulnerable;
**Artificial clearing
14
15
16
Summation
1.455
0
-3
-3
-3
+3
1.475
-2
0
-2
-3
+1
1.490
0
0
0
0
+3
1.445
-1
0
0
-3
+1
1.435
-1
0
0
-3
+1
+3
+2
-2
-3
2,00
0
0
-2
-8
**
+3
+3
+1
+10
3,00
0
+1
-2
-4
6,00
0
+1
-2
-4
6,00
+16
+18
-6
+17
34,50
2,00
**
3,00
6,00
6,00
28,40
-8
-3
-7
-17
+21
63
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 63
09/10/2012 13:44:00
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Several points of erosion were also observed, with
heights varying between 1,80 and 3 meters on the
northern edge. In some points inclined trees and
marked root exposure were apparent (Figure 4E).
The vegetation in this area is well-preserved with
an estimated 15-meter canopy (Figure 4F). The
negative points for visual impact were the occurrence of non-biodegraded waste, mainly around
the abandoned building. Tires, cans of oil and several types of plastic packaging were also found.
No indicative signs or indications of strategic planning, to facilitate animal crossing or avoid accidents with the local fauna, were observed in any of
the points evaluated.
DISCUSSION
The most impacted areas are located at either
end of the main road, the outstanding points being the
presence of erosion, discarded material and the remains of fire. This could be related to the permanence
of people, seeing that the road is used only for passage
between the lower part and the gliding ramps. One factor that may have contributed to the advance of erosion
on the main road could be the recent entrance of heavy
vehicles, for the installation of telecommunication antennas. This occurred before the present assaying. The
crater cause by the landslide in 2005 presented visible
signs of instability. Moreover, before this, the road was
10 meters wide, whereas now it is only 5,40m. Small
landslides were noted and it is interesting to point out
the possibility of the crater increasing in size, since
vegetation is not in the process of regeneration. The
slope of the land could be the main cause of erosion,
thus corroborating Oliveira et al., (2010a), and Antonangelo & Fenner (2005), who pointed out declivity
as being one of the generating factors of erosion. Further studies are required, with specific methodologies
on declivity and erosion, to evaluate local vulnerability and instability.
Concrete gutters were built along the road
to improve rainwater drainage. However, their inef-
64
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 64
09/10/2012 13:44:01
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
ficiency was apparent, seeing that incorrect drainage was the means of accelerating erosion in some
points. Surface drainage of rainwater is a preponderant factor in the formation of erosive processes,
according to WEPP (Water Erosion Prediction
Project), and as cited by Machado et al. (2003) and
Garcia (2001). The adoption of preventive measures
and the subsequent monitoring are attitudes which
are simple, efficient and financially cheaper, when
compared to corrective measures (20) Certain measures can be taken, such as the recuperation and
contention of canopy, the maintenance of adequate
gutters, planting seedlings of native plants where
erosion is in an advanced stage (20), programs of
environmental education, supervision in areas of
easy access, and studies on the influence of vehicle
traffic on vertebrate communities, as suggested by
Bager & Rosa (2010), who proposed specific studies and the use of an index for implanting mitigating
measures against wild-fauna hits.
The presence of discarded non-biodegraded
material, such as tires, oil cans, glass bottles and plastic packaging, was observed in isolated points. Even
though it was impossible to estimate the time this
material has been in the area, their very presence is
a sign of vulnerability. The withdrawal of this material is indispensable, since these residues are prejudicial, both visually and to the native fauna. Although
roads are necessary structures for the flow of material and people, their very existence can negatively
affect the fauna (4, 7, 15, 26). Some studies, besides
outlining the high diversity and abundance of biota,
demonstrate their fragility in the face of anthropic
impacts caused in their environment. Thus, it can be
perceived that the Altomontana PRNP does not present the necessary structure or the required preventive
measures against the loss of biodiversity through the
ingestion of residues, the isolation of subpopulations,
or road-hits, whence the need for undertaking appropriate studies in this field.
The presence of well-preserved vegetation,
the various phytophysiognomies encountered on
the altitudinal gradient and the wide expanse of the
CU, go well towards affirming that the PRNP had
reached a high level of environmental heterogeneity and complexity. Similar situations have been the
focus of a series of studies, such as by August (1983)
and Vera Y Conde & Rocha (2006). Heterogeneity
in any environment is represented by the vertical
stratum developed. Apart from the characteristics
of woody plants, the presence of epiphytes is considered a positive factor as it concerns environmental heterogeneity. According to Gatti (2000), they
are extremely important as indicators of the maintenance of biological diversity and the interactive
equilibrium among species, since their successful
establishment and diversity is highly dependent on
environmental conditions (13). Through their sensitivity to anthropic impacts, their role as indicators
of environmental quality is further enhanced. Thus,
the presence of epiphytic plants was a clear indication of preservation along roads and trails.
.
The presence of a bamboo grove at a fixed
altitude caused a visual impact. As it extended over
the areas of other properties, always at the same
variations in altitude, its origin can probably be associated to a natural occurrence. Even so, additional
more detailed studies are required to better understand the occurrence.
As the management plan for the CU is in the
elaboration phase, and together with the results of
this evaluation of impacts, the proposal is to charge
an entrance fee for recreational visits and access to
water slides, as a form of maintaining the roads and
trails on the property, since, through being a CU of
sustainable use, the use of areas for recreation and
environmental education is permitted. Nevertheless, it is recommended that the entrance of visitors
be limited, and selective garbage cans installed in
the entrance of the reserve, in the areas of recreation
at the waterfalls, and alongside water slides.
The elaboration of environmental education programs should also become an alternative for
the better enlightenment of visitors, as to the preservation of the area.
CONCLUSION
Among the various environmental impacts
caused by the road, erosion at all altitudes is extremely prominent, with the presence of discarded waste
as a close runner up. The vegetation on the edges of
trails and roads was found to be well-preserved, thus
comprising a propitious environment for the development of insertion activities among the local community, as part of programs on environmental edu-
65
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 65
09/10/2012 13:44:01
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
cation. The most impacted strips are the extremities
of roads and trails, where preventive supervision is
required. The proposal is the adoption of a series of
measures, such as the control of visitor entrance, the
creation of educational activities on environmental
conservation for PRPN-user enlightenment, the supervision of critical points, the restoration of unstable
points of erosion with native plants, signs at various
points on the road, with emphasis on the existence of
fauna, and the need to reduce speed, as administrative tools to better conserve the area.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Thanks are extended to the owners of the
Altomontana PRPN for logistic support and accompaniment throughout the work
.
RESUMO
Planejamento e gestão adequada de estradas
contribuem para a redução dos impactos ambientais.
Em Unidades de Conservação, a avaliação de possíveis
impactos ambientais causados pelas estradas permite a
adoção de ações preventivas, visando evitar a perda de
biodiversidade. Nesse intuito, foi realizado um levantamento de impactos causados pelas estradas e trilhas
da RPPN Altomontana, Itamonte (MG/Brasil), objetivando fornecer informações para um melhor manejo
das estradas e trilhas da unidade de conservação, bem
como mitigar impactos que geraram degradação ambiental da área. As extensões das estradas internas da
propriedade foram percorridas, sendo marcados pontos nos extremos e ao longo do gradiente altitudinal.
Uma matriz de gradação de impactos foi utilizada
para padronizar as observações. Foram atribuídas notas de zero a três para caracterizar a intensidade dos
impactos, acrescidos dos sinais positivo e negativo
conforme o tipo de impacto. Dentre os impactos ambientais observados causados pelas estradas, a erosão
foi a variável de maior destaque, ocorrendo em todas
as faixas de altitude da propriedade, seguida da presença de lixo descartado. De modo geral, a vegetação
da área encontra-se bem conservada e a variação de
altitude favorece a formação de diferentes fitofisionomias, sendo um ambiente propício ao desenvolvimento
de atividades de inserção da comunidade local em programas de educação ambiental.
Palavras-chave: avaliação de impacto ambiental,
estradas, Unidade de conservação.
REFERENCES
1- ANTONANGELO, A., FENNER, P. T. Identificação dos riscos de erosão em estradas de uso
florestal através do critério do fator topográfico
LS. Energia na Agricultura, Botucatu, v. 20, n.
3, p. 1-20, 2005.
2- AUGUST, P. V. The role of habitat complexity
and heterogeneity in structuring tropical mammal communities. Ecology, New York, v. 64, n.
6, p. 1495-1507, 1983.
3- BAGER, A., ROSA, C. A. Priority ranking of
Road sites for mitigating wildlife roadkill. Biota
Neotropica, São Paulo, v. 10, n. 4, p. 149-153,
2010.
4- BENÍTEZ-LÓPEZ, A., ALKEMADE, R., PITA,
A. V. The impacts of roads and other infrastructure on mammal and bird populations: a metaanalysis. Biological Conservation, v. 143. p.
1307-1316, 2010.
5- BRASIL, 1998. Lei Federal 9.605 de 12 de fevereiro de 1998. Lei de crimes Ambientais. Disponível em <http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil/
Leis/L9605.htm> acessado em 10 maio 2011.
6- BRASIL, 2000. Lei Federal 9.985 de 18 de julho
de 2000. Sistema Nacional de Unidades de Conservação. Disponível em <http://www.planalto.
gov.br/ccivil_03/Leis/L9985.htm> acessado em
10 maio 2011.
7- CLEVENGER, A.P., CHRUSZCZ, B. & GUNSON, K. E. Spatial patterns and factors influencing small vertebrate fauna road-kill aggregations. Biological Conservation, v. 109, p. 15-26,
2003.
8- CORREA, C. M. C., CRUZ, J, Erosão real e estimada através da Rusle em estradas florestais, em
relevo ondulado a fortemente ondulado. Revista
Árvore, Viçosa, v. 34, n. 4, p. 587-595, 2010.
9- FERREIRA, R. M. A. Avaliação de Impacto
Ambiental e a Legislação Brasileira. Informe
Agropecuário, Belo Horizonte, v. 21, n. 202,
p.5-11, 2000.
10-FORMAN, R. T. T., ALEXANDER, L .E. Roads
and their major ecological effects. Annual Review
of Ecology and Systematics, v. 29, p. 207-231, 1998.
66
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 66
09/10/2012 13:44:01
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
11-GARCIA, A. R. Uso do modelo WEPP (Water
Erosion Prediction Project) modificado para
estimar taxas de erosão em estradas florestais.
2001. 96 f. Tese (Doutorado em Ciência Florestal) – Universidade Federal de Viçosa, Viçosa.
2001.
12-GATTI, A. L. S. O componente epifítico vascular da Reserva Natural de Salto Morato,
Guaraqueçaba, PR. 2000. 93f. Dissertação
(Mestrado em Botânica) - Universidade Federal
do Paraná, Curitiba, PR. 2000.
13-GIONGO, C., WAECHTER, J. L. Composição
florística e estrutura comunitária de epifíticos
vasculares em uma floresta de galeria na Depressão Central do Rio Grande do Sul. Revista
Brasileira de Botânica, São Paulo, v. 27, n. 3, p.
563-572, 2004.
14-GUMIER-COSTA, F., SPERBER, C. F. Atropelamentos de vertebrados na Floresta Nacional de
Carajás, Pará, Brasil. Acta Amazonica, Manaus,
v. 39, n. 2, p. 459- 466, 2009.
15-HELS, T., BUCHWALD, E. The effect of road
kills on amphibian population. Biological Conservation, v. 99, p.331-340, 2001.
16-LEOPOLD, L. B.; CLARKE, F. S.; HANSHAW,
B. B.; BALSEY-JR,T. A. Procedure for evaluating environmental impact. Washington: U. S.
Geological Survey, 1971. 13p.
17-MACHADO, C. C., GARCIA, A. R., SILVA, E.,
FONTES, A. M. Comparação de taxas de erosão
em estradas florestais estimadas pelo modelo
WEPP (Water Erosion Prediction Project) modificado em relação a medições experimentais. Revista Árvore, Viçosa, v. 27, n. 3, p. 295-300, 2003.
18-MARCELINO, F. A. Avaliação dos sistemas de
redes viárias florestais em função dos custos e
riscos de erosão. 2007. 129 f. Tese (Doutorado
em Agronomia) – Universidade Estadual Paulista, Botucatu. 2007.
19-OLIVEIRA, F. P., SILVA, M. L. N., AVANZI, J.
C., CURI, N., LEITE, F. P. Avaliação das perdas
do solo em estradas florestais não pavimentadas
no Vale do Rio Doce, Minas Gerais. Scientia
Forestalis, Piracicaba, v. 38, n. 87, p. 331-339,
2010[a].
20-OLIVEIRA, A. H., SILVA, M. L. N., AVANZI,
J. C., SILVA, M. A., CURI, N. Erosão hídrica
em estradas florestais: causas e controle. Revista de Geografia, Recife, v. 27, n. 2, p. 126-140,
2010[b].
21-PANE, E. Estudo Hidrológico, Hidrogeológico e
Geofísico no município de Itamonte - MG. 2001.
84 f. Dissertação (Mestrado) – Universidade Estadual de Campinas, Campinas, SP. 2001.
22-PEREIRA, J. A. A.; BORÉM, R. S. T.,
SANT’ANA, C. M. Análise e avaliação de impactos ambientais. Lavras: UFLA/FAEPE,
2001, 147p.
23-RODRIGUES, G. S., CAMPANHOLA, C. Sistema integrado de avaliação de impacto ambiental
aplicado a atividades do Novo Rural. Pesquisa
Agropecuária Brasileira, Brasília, v. 38, n. 4, p.
445-451, 2003.
24-ROHDE, M. G. Estudos de impacto ambiental:
a situação brasileira. In: VERDUM, R., MEDEIROS, R. M. V. [org.] RIMA, Relatório de
Impacto Ambiental: Legislação, elaboração e
resultados. 3ªed. ampl. Porto Alegre: Ed. Universidade/UFRGS, 1995, p. 20-36.
25-SILVEIRA NETO, S., MONTEIRO, R. C., ZUCCHI, R. A., MORAES, R. C. B. Uso de análise
faunística de insetos na avaliação de impactos
ambientais. Scientia Agricola, Piracicaba, v. 52,
n.1, p. 9-15, 1995.
26-TROMBULAK, S. C., FRISSELL, C. A. Review
of ecological effects of roads on terrestrial and
aquatic communities. Conservation Biology,
v.14, n. 1, p.18-30, 2000.
27-VELOSO, H. P., RANGEL-FILHO, A. L. R.,
LIMA, J. C. A. Classificação da vegetação
brasileira, adaptada a um sistema universal.
Rio de Janeiro: Fundação Instituto Brasileiro de
Geografia e Estatísitica – IBGE. 1991, 124p.
28-VERA Y CONDE, C. F., ROCHA, C. F. D. Habitat disturbance and small mammal richness and
diversity in an Atlantic Rainforest area in Southeastern Brazil. Brazilian Journal of Biology,
São Carlos, v. 66, n. 4, p. 983-990, 2006.
67
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 67
09/10/2012 13:44:01
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
68
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 68
09/10/2012 13:44:01
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
FlorIstic and spatial distribution of Orchidaceae species in
the Serra do Mucambo, Conceição do Coité, Bahia, Brazil
*Denis Nunes de Carvalho, Centro Universitário Jorge Amado (email: denisnunis-@hotmail.com)
Cássio van den Berg, Universidade Estadual de Feira de Santana (email: vcassio@gmail.com)
Camila Magalhães Pigozzo, Centro Universitário Jorge Amado (email: camilapigozzo@yahoo.com.br)
ABSTRACT
The aim of the present study was to evaluate the Orchidaceae family in the Serra do
Mucambo, Conceição do Coité, Bahia and to describe the local population distribution
patterns, as well as discuss local factors that influenced species distribution. Sixteen
species in 14 genera were found. The genera Trichocentrum and Vanilla presented the
highest number of species, with two each. All species displayed aggregated distribution.
The highest abundance and species richness were found at higher altitudes. Availability
of resources is possibly the main factor influencing species distribution.
Key-words: resources, elevation, abundance
IntroduCTION
The Orchidaceae family contains around
850 genera and 20,000 species, amongst which, 235
genera and 2,419 species have been registered in
Brazil (6). Distribution of the family is cosmopolitan, Pantropical, and probably the second largest
among the angiosperms (5), with the main centers
of diversity in the tropical regions of America and
Asia (9). Besides taxonomic representability, the
family is valued by the ornamental potential of the
flowers (16).
The use of the flowers for ornamentation
purposes represents one of the threats to orchid species diversity, through removal from their natural
habitats. Another ominous factor is the constant destruction of habitats through the advance of agriculture (16, 22). Thus, extinction could also be a consequence of the reduction in area of occupancy, since
only larger areas sustain large populations. (18)
In a plant community, plants are aggregated according to the various intra and interspecific
associations throughout their natural distribution
(14). Besides anthropic alterations, which incur
vegetal impacts, there are also natural alterations
arising from differences in the soil, and variations
in humidity and altitude, which contribute to floristically characterizing certain areas of the mountain range (34). Altitude, a possible relevant factor,
can induce a soil and climate grid, an important
aspect in the repartition of the various floristic
aggregates, thereby contributing to the different
vegetation patterns in the landscape (24, 10). The
distribution of the different ecological substrata
and refuges is related to the degree of local shade
or illumination, whence the selective process of
appropriate environments for the development of
certain types of vegetation in detriment of others
(10). Through humidity, as well as the presence of
a substratum, being limiting factors in the distribution of epiphytic orchids (7), epiphyte diversity
can be used as an ecological indicator of the quality and conservation of humid forests (22).
On the whole, in Bahia, botanical studies
in the field are concentrated in the Chapada Diamantina (3, 4, 12, 19, 20, 32, 36, 40, 37), with only
a few studies having been undertaken in the centerwestern part of the state (15). Further on, the find-
69
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 69
09/10/2012 13:44:01
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
ings will be commented on, since a list of citations
without contents would not be informative. Studies
on Orchidaceae spatial distribution are still scarce,
especially in northeast Brazil.
On considering the work done on orchid
spatial distribution, the importance of the family,
the threats to its diversity, the scarcity of studies
of northeast Bahia, and the need for a better understanding of the factors that influence the distribution of these species, the aim of the present
study was to undertake a floristic survey of orchid
species in the Serra do Mucambo, thereby identifying the spatial distribution of populations and
investigating factors defining their occurrence and
distribution.
METODOLOGY
Characterization of the study area – Conceição do Coité is located in the northeastern part of
Bahia State (11°31’ S and 39°19’ W). The study area
was at the highest point of the municipality, at an
altitude of 575 meters. The surroundings and some
parts of the Serra have already been deforested for
sisal (Agave sisalana Perrine) hemp production and
cattle raising.
The climate is semiarid, with temperatures
ranging from 16.1 to 33ºC, and an average rainfall of 500 to 800 mm. Vegetation is mixed, with
elements from the arboreal Caatinga and arborealbushy Caatinga, and with the presence of palm
trees (Arecaceae) of the species Syagrus coronata
(Mart.) Becc.
Collection of data – 20 fixed and noncontiguous quadrats measuring 10×10m, in total
2.000m², were marked out according to methodology developed by Almeida et al., (2007), but with
modifications, with random distribution at various altitudes, an irregular number at each, along
a sloping gradient of 449 to 575m, with no fixed
difference between. Elevation and coordinates
were obtained with a GPS Garmin eTrex Vista
HCx, Personal Navigator. The fertile orchids in
each quadrant were collected, pressed, identified
and quantified. The amount of available resources
was also measured, taking into account, trees, lianas, soil and palm trees. Rock, as a source, was
eliminated. Trees and lianas were measured as to
the percentage of cover, and soil, as to the available area. Palm trees were counted. The total of
available resources was obtained by substituting
scarce, abundant and very abundant by the numbers 2, 3 and 4, respectively, and with the summation of values attributed to soil, trees and lianas,
and the number of palm trees. As regards epiphyte
species, even individuals that had accidentally
fallen, and were still alive on the soil and remained
fixed to dry branches, were included. Collections
took place from January to December, 2010, thus
twelve in total. Specimens were deposited in the
herbarium of the Universidade Estadual de Feira
de Santana (HUEFS).
Analysis of data – species identification
was from specialized literature by Pabst & Dungs
(1975, 1977). When necessary, the material was
compared to specimens from the collection of
HUEFS. Species binomials were standardized in
accordance with the World Check List of Selected
Plant Families, the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew
(http://apps.kew.org/wcsp/qsearch.do).
The Morisita index (27) was used for identifying species distribution patterns. Absolute taxon
frequency was calculated by the formula described
by Maracajá et al.(2003):
where FAt is the absolute taxon frequency,
Pt the number of plots where the taxa occurred, and
P the number of sampled plots.
Analysis of correlations between the
amount of resources and orchid frequency was performed to evaluate the influence of resource availability. Cluster analysis of qualitative and quantitative data with the UPGMA method in the PCORD
4.0 software, using the Sorensen Index for qualitative, and the Morisita-Horn Index for quantitative,
was used to evaluate whether more similar quadrants, in terms of resources, would be more similar as to floristic composition. Correlation analysis
with SPSS for Windows was to evaluate the relationships between abundance and richness among
species at different altitudes.
.
70
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 70
09/10/2012 13:44:01
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Results
patterns, respectively.
Individuals of G. barbata, C. micranthum and
Sampling involved 821 individuals belong- Notylia sp. represented 67% of those sampled (Table.
ing to 14 genera and 16 species (Table 1). On con- 1), whereas individuals of O. maculata, V. palmarum
sidering the two habits, epiphytes were found to be and T. cebolleta together represented 22%, and the reevaluate
whether There
more similar
terms of resources,
would
more similar
as to most
floristic
composition.
maining
10bespecies
11%. The
abundant
species
thetomost
common.
were quadrants,
only fiveinterrestrial
Correlation
analysis
with SPSS for Windows was to evaluate the
relationships
between
abundance
and1).richness among
were
also the most
frequent
(Table
species
and one
facultative.
species Average
at differentabundance
altitudes. among quadrants was
Groups of qualitative (Figure 2) and quanti.
41.5, with standard deviation of ± 44.56 individu- tative (Figure 3) similarity were formed in the same
als each. Richness varied from 1 to 10 species per quadrants in both dendrograms. Whereas the first
RESULTS
group was formed by quadrants without the presence
quadrant; the most frequent was two species each.
Formatado:
Sampling involved 821 individuals belonging to 14 genera and 16 species (Table 1). On considering the two habits,
epiphytes were found to be the most common. There were only five terrestrial species and one facultative.
Average abundance among quadrants was 41.5, with standard deviation of ± 44.56 individuals each. Richness varied
from 1 to 10 species per quadrant; the most frequent was two species each.
Table 1. List of the species from the family Orchidaceae found
in the Serra do Mucambo, Conceição do Coité, Bahia, Brazil.
Legend: N. IND = number of individuals sampled, MI= Morisita
Index, AF= absolute frequency, Epi. = epiphyte, Ter.= terrestrial,
Fa.Epi= facultative epiphyte. Species
Campylocentrum micranthum (Lindl.) Rolfe
Catasetum luridum Lindl.
Cyrtopodium saintlegerianum Rchb.f.
Eltroplectris triloba (Lindl.) Pabst
Encyclia oncidioides (Lindl.) Schltr.
Gomesa barbata (Lindl.) M.W.Chase & N.H.Williams
Notylia sp.
Oeceoclades maculata (Lindl.) Lindl.
Pelexia trachyglossa (Kraenzl.) Pabst.
Polystachya concreta (Jacq.) Garay& H. R. Sweet
Prescottia sp.
Sarcoglottis sp.
Trichocentrum cebolleta (Jacq.) M. W. Chase & N. H. Williams
Trichocentrum pumilum (Jacq.) M. W. Chase & N. H. Williams
.
Formatado:
N.
IND.
M.I
A.F.
%
191
27
5
4
17
272
109
74
13
2
1
14
51
3
22,5
4,2
3,3
3,3
4,9
33,6
27,8
9,3
4,2
2
1
4,5
8,8
0,9
55
35
10
15
20
60
45
55
15
5
5
20
60
15
Vanilla bahiana Hoehne
10
4,9
10
Vanilla palmarum (Salzm ex. Lindl.) Lindl.
60
14
30
Habit
Voucher
Epi.
Epi.
Epi.
Ter.
Epi.
Epi.
Epi.
Ter.
Ter.
Epi.
Ter.
Ter.
Epi.
Epi.
Epi.
Fa.
Epi.
HUEFS 166693
HUEFS 166683
HUEFS 166689
HUEFS 166686
HUEFS 166694
HUEFS 166680
HUEFS 166678
HUEFS 166679
HUEFS 166688
HUEFS 166685
Formatado:
HUEFS 166692
HUEFS 166690
HUEFS 166682
of C.
luridum,
in thethan
second,
this G.
species
was
present
No
inall
allthe
thequadrants,
quadrants,
Nospecies
species occurred
occurred in
andand
only four
occurred
in more
half, viz.,
barbata
and
T.
all,relative
together
with S. among
coronata,
the only
phorophyte
only
four occurred
in more
than half,and
viz.,
barbata(55%).in In
cebolleta
(60%), and
C. micranthum
O.G.
maculata
abundance
the total
of individuals
studied,
G.
barbata
32.3%,
C.
micranthum
22.3%,
O.
maculata
8.8%,
T.
cebolleta
2.3%,
and
the
remaining
10
was also
and T. cebolleta (60%), and C. micranthum and O. to be used by this species. This phorophytespecies
11.7% were
noteworthy.
maculata
(55%).
In relative abundance among the total the only one on which V. palmarum and C. saintlegeAlthough
the quadrants
at higher
altitudes
presented arianum
significantly
higher abundance
of to
individuals
(r = 0.547;
occurred.
According
the Sorensen
Index,
of individuals
studied,
G. barbata
32.3%,
C. micranp
<
0.05),
no
significant
correlation
between
species
richness
and
elevation
could
be
found
(r
=
0.419;
p
>
0.05).
thum 22.3%, O. maculata 8.8%, T. cebolleta 2.3%, and the most similar quadrants were P6 and P7 (Figure.
Most of the species presented aggregated distribution (14 species), and only two, T. pumilum and Prescottia
2), with 100% similarity in floristic composition, folthe remaining
10 species 11.7% were noteworthy.
sp., presented random and uniform patterns, respectively.
Although the quadrants at higher altitudes lowed by P1 and P20 with more than 90%. As regards
Individuals of G. barbata, C. micranthum and Notylia sp. represented 67% of those sampled (Table. 1),
presented a significantly higher abundance of indi- qualitative-quantitative similarity, and as indicated
whereas individuals of O. maculata, V. palmarum and T. cebolleta together represented 22%, and the remaining 10
viduals (r = 0.547; p < 0.05), no significant correla- by the Morisita-Hom Index, the most similar quadspecies 11%. The most abundant species were also the most frequent (Table 1).
tion between species richness and elevation could rants were P3, P6 and P7, with 100% similarity.
and orchid abundance (r = 0.223;
beGroups
found of
(r =qualitative
0.419; p (Figure
> 0.05).2) and quantitative (Figure 3) similarityResource
were formed in the same quadrants in both
p>
0.05),theand
resource
orchid-species
richness
Most Whereas
of the species
presented
aggregated
dendrograms.
the first group
was formed
by quadrants
without
presence
of C.and
luridum,
in the second,
this
= - 0.317;topbe
> 0.05)
were
not correlated.
distribution
species),
and only
two,
T. pumilum
species was (14
present
in all, together
with
S. coronata,
the only(rphorophyte
used by
this species.
This phorophyte
and Prescottia sp., presented random and uniform
71
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 71
09/10/2012 13:44:01
was also the only one on which V. palmarum and C. saintlegerianum occurred. According to the Sorensen Index, the
most similar quadrants were P6 and P7 (Figure. 2), with 100% similarity in floristic composition, followed by P1 and
P20 with more than 90%. As regards qualitative-quantitative similarity, and as indicated by the Morisita-Hom Index,
the most similar quadrants were P3, P6 and P7, with 100% similarity.
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
was
also the
oneabundance
on which V.
C. saintlegerianum
occurred.
According
to the(r Sorensen
the
Resource
andonly
orchid
(r =palmarum
0.,223; p and
> 0.,05),
and resource and
orchid-species
richness
= - 0.,317;Index,
p > 0.,05)
most
quadrants were P6 and P7 (Figure. 2), with 100% similarity in floristic composition, followed by P1 and
weresimilar
not correlated.
saintlegerianum, O. maculata, P. concreta, T.
cebolleta, Trichocentrum pumilum and V. bahiana
were not correlated.
have been registered by Batista and Bianchetti
(2003) among species occurring in the Brazilian
Federal District. T. pumilum is also encountered
in areas of the ‘Cerrado’ in São Paulo (16).
Campylocentrum micranthum, O. maculata, P
concreta and T. pumilum have been registered in the
Serra de São José, Minas Gerais State (2) as well as
Figure 2. Floristic similarity dendogram, by the UPGMA method and using the Sorensen Index, based on data on the
in riverine forests in Rio Grande do Sul State (39).
presence
or absence
Orchidaceae in quadrants
in the Serra
do Mucambo, Conceição
Coité,UPGMA
Bahia, Brazil.
Figure
2.ofFloristic
similarity
dendogram,
bydothe
Species richness observed in the present
method and using the Sorensen Index, based on data on
study can be considered small when compared to
the
presence
or
absence
of
Orchidaceae
in
quadrants
in
the
Figure 2. Floristic similarity dendogram, by the UPGMA method and using the Sorensen Index, based on data on the
Serra
doofMucambo,
Conceição
Coité,
Bahia,
presence
or absence
Orchidaceae in quadrants
in the Serra dodo
Mucambo,
Conceição
do Coité,Brazil.
Bahia, Brazil.
that in plant corridors in the Cerrado, where 100
species were registered (9), and the 226 species
registered in the Parque Nacional do Itatiaia, in
the Serra da Mantiqueira (5). Nonetheless, many
studies presented richness values close to those
encountered herein, such as the 25 species found
in an area undergoing regeneration in the Montane
Figure 3. Floristic similarity dendogram by the UPGMA method and using the Morisita-Index, based on data onDense Ombrophilous Forest (34), or the nine, even
Orchidaceae species abundance in quadrants on the Serra do Mucambo, Conceição do Coité, Bahia, Brazil.
10, species found in vegetal isles in parts of the
Morro do Pai Inácio Plateau, also in Bahia (1, 20).
Figure 3. Floristic similarity dendogram by the UPGMA method and using the Morisita-Index, based on data on Indeed, although Orchidaceae species richness
Figure 3. Floristic similarity dendogram by the UPGMA
Orchidaceae species abundance in quadrants on the Serra do Mucambo, Conceição do Coité, Bahia, Brazil.
is high in humid and montane regions, it is much
method and using the Morisita-Index, based on data on
Orchidaceae species abundance in quadrants on the Serra
lower in dry and seasonal areas.
do Mucambo, Conceição do Coité, Bahia, Brazil.
Cyrtopodium
saintlegerianum
was
registered as a rare species in dry forests, O.
DiscussION
maculata as common in both dry and humid forests,
T. cebolleta occasional in dry forests, T. pumulum
Most of the sampled orchids are widely rare in dry forests, P. concreta occasional in dry
distributed geographically, some of them even forests, and V. bahiana occasional in both dry and
occurring in other countries, as well as in various humid forests (8).
biomes, such as restingas, rocky outcrops, mountain
The species O. maculata was very frequent
forests, ecotone areas, semideciduous forests and in shady or well-illuminated spots in areas with
dense ombrophilous forests.
bushy and arboreal vegetation. The high frequency
The species C. micranthum, C. luridum, E. indices of this species have been associated to
triloba, O. maculata, P. concreta and V. bahiana are efficient reproductive organisms, such as autogamy
to be found in the ‘restingas’ of Espírito Santo State and anemochorous dispersion (40). O. maculata and
(23). Campylocentrum micranthum also occurs in E. triloba were encountered in sheltered spots inside
the same ecosystem in the state of São Paulo (28) closed formations and in open areas (23), thereby
as well as in rocky ground in Mucugê, Bahia State corroborating their occurrence in both ‘restinga’ as
(3). The species E. oncidioides, V. bahiana and P. well as dry forests, as was the case in the present
concreta are incidental in the ecotonal area between study. This indicates the capacity of these species
the Atlantic Rain Forest and the ‘Cerrado’ in São to inhabit areas with various grades of luminosity.
Paulo (22). Vanilla palmarum occurs in remnants of Species that occur in the lower and upper part of
the Atlantic Rain Forest in the south of Bahia (21).
trunks possibly prefer or tolerate more humid and
Gomesa barbata occurs in semiarid shadier environments (39).
regions in Pernambuco State (38). Cyrtopodium
Rogalski and Zanin (2002) noted the
P20 with more than 90%. As regards qualitative-quantitative similarity, and as indicated by the Morisita-Hom Index,
the most similar quadrants were P3, P6 and P7, with 100% similarity.
Resource and orchid abundance (r = 0.,223; p > 0.,05), and resource and orchid-species richness (r = - 0.,317; p > 0.,05)
Formatado: Inglês (Estados Unidos)
Formatado: Inglês (Estados Unidos)
Formatado: Inglês (Estados Unidos)
Formatado: Inglês (Estados Unidos)
72
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 72
09/10/2012 13:44:02
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
existence of two groups, those that required less
luminosity and more humidity, and those that
tolerate higher luminosity and less humidity. Some
species, such as E. oncidioides, were more present
in tree canopies than in the lower part of the trunks
where vegetation was more closed and large-sized.
The species C. luridum, V. palmarum, and C.
saintlegerianum always occurred associated with S.
coronata, in quadrants with more open vegetation
and higher solar radiation. Species requirements
limit their distribution. A possible motive for this
association could be the substratum conditions that
this phorophyte offers, this favoring the growth
and maintenance of symbiontic mycorrhizic fungi,
and self maintenance as a microecosystem with
the adequate luminosity and humidity for the
development of these species. It was confirmed
that, as cover becomes more open, other species
begin to appear, especially those which are more
tolerant to luminosity (23). Gonçalves & Waechter
(2002) attributed high diaspore production and
resistance against isolation to the outstanding
capacity for colonizing and high abundance of
vascular epiphytes. Lower species richness could
be related to environments with microclimatic
instability (higher solar radiation and wind
exposure), and to the lower exposal of phorophytes
to epiphyte diaspores (13). In other words, where
there are more aged phorophytes, species richness
is generally higher in the regions closer to the
climax. Higher abundance, density and diversity
is expected in canopy epiphytic orchids in mature
forest fragments (35).
Cavatti (2007) related distribution of the
terrestrial species Epidendrum sp. to the abundance
of litter in the soil. This factor could also be related
to the distribution of other terrestrial orchid species.
In the ‘Caatinga’, the production of litter is not high,
as it is in other ecosystems. Even so, in the present
study, some areas notably accumulated a large
amount of substratum in the soil, appropriate for
the establishment of terrestrial species, such as E.
triloba, P. trachyglossa, Prescottia sp., Sarcoglottis
sp. and O. maculata .
Although no relationship between elevation
and species richness was found, there was a positive
relationship between elevation and abundance.
Jacquemyn (2005) encountered higher diversity
between 400 and 800 meters, presumably due to
the presence of an altitudinal distribution zone
with many overlapping species. The high diversity
between 500 and 2,000 meters is supposedly a result
of high habitat diversity (41). In the present study, no
relationship was found between habitat availability
(resources) and species richness abundance.
High richness and diversity can be
characterized as effected by climate (25).
Temperature can be a limiting factor, whereas
climate changes can contribute to changes in
distribution and abundance in orchid populations
(17). Thus, less richness and abundance in
quadrants where temperature and humidity have
been modified by human action, can be expected,
as is the case of those near the edges in lower areas,
where there is less humidity, and variations in the
temperature, besides being greater during the day,
are seasonal. This interference of the edge-effect
was aggregated to the grid of elevation-liable
humidity. Possibly, these two factors are directly
linked with less abundance at lower placed areas
undergoing the edge effect.
As observed by Pereira and Ribeiro
(2004), members of Orchidaceae maintained
aggregate distribution in three areas in the process
of regeneration, as also occurred with young
and old individuals of the species Mesadenella
cuspidata (Lindl.) Garay (14). Thus, the present
study confirms a tendency which has already been
observed in orchids. The aggregation of these
populations could be due to the incidence of light,
or characteristics of the substratum, such as trunk
texture and specificity in arboreal species (35).
Some phorophytes harbored numerous epiphytes in
a few quadrants, whereas others harbored very few.
Among the factors that exert an influence
on orchid spatial distribution, two are of extreme
importance, viz., seed dispersion and an adequate
substratum for germination and growth. Seed
dispersion is a critical process in plant life, since
these need to arrive at adequate substrata (31)
in forest areas, protected from wind dispersal,
and where young seedlings are always capable of
germinating and growing close to the mother plant,
thereby forming groups. This is especially the case
of terrestrial orchids that form large groups on the
soil. Furthermore, infection and colonization of the
73
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 73
09/10/2012 13:44:02
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
habitat by compatible micorrhizic fungi is obligatory
for supplying the necessary carbohydrates for
seedling germination, initial growth, and nutrition
on the substratum (11). Thus, only seeds which have
fallen onto the adequate substratum are viable.
Even though Orchidaceae populations,
on the whole, give evidence of being sensitive
to human environmental interference, it cannot
be said that this is the only factor influencing
the distribution of individuals. Environmental
alterations in the Serra do Mucambo still need to
be studied, through the monitoring of other local
populations and communities.
Resumo
O presente estudo objetivou inventariar
a família Orchidaceae na Serra do Mucambo,
Conceição do Coité, Bahia e descrever a
distribuição das populações na área, discutindo os
fatores que influencia na distribuição das espécies.
Foram encontradas 16 espécies e 14 gêneros. Os
gêneros com maior número de espécies foram
Trichocentrum e Vanilla, com duas espécies cada.
As espécies distribuíram-se de forma agregada.
As maiores abundâncias e riqueza específica
foram encontradas nas maiores elevações. A
disponibilidade de recursos pode ser o fator que
influencia na distribuição destas espécies.
Palavras-chave: recursos, elevação, abundância
ReferENCES
1- ALMEIDA, A.;FELIX,W. J. P.; ANDRADE, L.
A.; FELIX, L. P. A família Orchidaceae em inselbergs da Paraíba, Nordeste do Brasil. Revista
Brasileira de Biociências, Porto Alegre, v. 5, n.
2, p. 753-755, 2007.
2- ALVES, R. J. V.; KOLBEK, J. Summit vascular
flora of Serra de São José, Minas Gerais, Brasil.
Check List, v. 5, n. 1, p. 35-73, 2009.
3- AZEVEDO, C. O.;VAN DEN BERG, C. Análise
comparativa de áreas de campo rupestre da
Cadeia do Espinhaço (Bahia e Minas Gerais,
Brasil) baseadas em espécies de Orchidaceae.
Sitientibus série ciências biológicas,Feira de
Santana, v.7, n. 3, p. 199-210, 2007.
4- BASTOS, C. J. P.; YANO, O.;VILAS BOAS-
BASTOS, S. B. Briófitas de campos rupestres
da Chapada Diamantina, Estado da Bahia, Brasil. Revista brasileira de Botânica, São Paulo,
v.23, n.4, p. 359-370, 2000.
5- BARBAREMA, F. F. V. A. Orchidaceae no
Parque Nacional do Itatiaia, sudeste do Brasil: listagem e estudos taxonômicos na tribo
Laeliinae. 2010. 149 f. (Tese de mestrado em
botânica) - Instituto de Pesquisas Jardim Botânico do Rio de Janeiro Escola Nacional de Botânica Tropical Programa de Pós-graduação Stricto
Sensu, Rio de Janeiro, 2010.
6- BARROS, F.; VILHOS, F.; RODRIGUES, V.
T.; BARBAREMA, F. F. V. A.; FRAGA, C. N.
Orchidaceae in Lista de Espécies da Flora do
Brasil. Jardim Botânico do Rio de Janeiro. 2010.
- BATAGHIN, F. A.; BARROS, F. PIRES, J. S. R..
Distribuição da comunidade de epífitas vasculares em sítios com diferentes graus de perturbação na Floresta Nacional do Ipanema, São Paula,
Brasil. Revista brasileira de Botânica, São Paulo, v. 33, n. 3, p. 501-512, 2010
8- BATISTA, J. A. N.; BIANCHETTI, A. B. Lista
atualizada das Orchidaceae do Distrito Federal.
Acta Botânica Brasilica, Feira de Santana, n. 17,
v. 2, p. 183-201, 2003.
9- BATISTA, J. A. N.; BIANCHETTI, L. B.;
PELLIZZARO, K. F. Orchidaceae na Reserva
Ecológica do Guará, DF, Brasil. Acta Botânica
Brasilica,Feira de Santana, v. 19, n. 2, p. 221232, 2005.
10-BISPO, P. C.; VALERIANO, M. M.; KUPLICH,
T. M. Relação entre as variáveis morfométricas extraídas de dados SRTM (Shuttle Radar
Topography Mission) e a vegetação do Parque
Nacional de Brasília. Acta Botânica Brasílica,
Feira de Santana,v. 204 n. 1, p. 96-103, 2010.
11-BOLDRINI, R. F.; SANTOS, W. O.; CRUZ Z.
M. A.; RAMOS, A. C. Bases de associação micorrízica orquidóide. Natureza on Line, Santa
Tereza, v. 8, n. 3, p. 140-145, 2010.
12-BORBA, E. L.; FUNCH, R. R.; RIBEIRO, P. L.;
SMIDT, E, C.; SILVA-PEREIRA, V. Demografia variedade morfológica e genética e conservação de Cattleya tenuis (Orchidaceae), espécie
ameaçada de extinção na Chapada Diamantina,
Sitientibus série ciências Biológicas,Feira de
Santana, v. 7, n. 3, p. 211-222, 2007.
74
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 74
09/10/2012 13:44:02
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
13-BORGO, M.; SILVA, S. M. Epífitos vasculares
em fragmentos de Floresta Ombrófila Mista,
Curitiba, Paraná, Brasil. Revista brasileira de
Botânica, São Paulo, v. 26, n. 3, p. 391-401, 2003.
14-BUDKE, J. C.et al. Distribuição espacial de
Mesadenella cuspidata (Lindl.) Garay (Orchidaceae) em uma floresta ribeirinha em Santa
Maria, RS, Brasil, Acta Botanica Brasilica,Feira
de Santana, v. 18, n. 1, p. 31- 35. 2004.
15-CARDOSO, D. B. O. S.; FRANÇA, F.; NOVAIS, J. S.; FERREIRA, M. H. S.; SANTOS, R.
M.; CARNEIRO, V. M. S.; GONÇALVES J. M.
Composição florística e análise fitogeográfica
de uma floresta semiadecídua na Bahia, Brasil,
Rodriguesia, Rio de Janeiro, v. 60, n. 4, p. 10551076, 2009.
16-CARDOSO, J. C.; ISRAEL, M. Levantamento
de espécies de Orchidaceae em Águas de Sta.
Bárbara (SP) e seu cultivo. Horticultura brasileira, Brasília, v. 23, n.2, p. 169-173, 2005.
17-CAREY, P. D. Changes in the distribution and
abundance of Himantoglossum hircinum (L.)
Sprengel (Orchidaceae) over the last 100 years.
Watsonia,New York, v. 22, p. 353-364, 1999.
18-CAVATTI, F. S.; BOINA C. D.; GONÇALVES,
J. O. VOLTOLINI, J. C.; MOTTA, L. B.; CARDOSO, M. F. D.; FONSECA, R. M. Distribuição
de Epidedrum sp. (Orchidaceae) em formações
de ilhas de restinga do Parque Estadual Paulo
César Vinha, Guarapiri, Es. Anais do VIII Congresso ecologia do Brasil, Caxambu, 2007.
19-CERQUEIRA, C.; FUNCH, L. S.; BORBA, E.
L. Fenologia de Syngonanthus mucugensis Giulsubsp. mucugensis e S. curralensis Moldenke
(Euricaulaceae), nos municípios de Mucugê e
Morro do Chapéu, Chapada Diamantina, BA,
Brasil.Acta Botânica Brasilica, Feira de Santana, v. 22, n. 4, p. 962-969, 2008.
20-CONCEIÇÃO, A. A.; GIULIETTI, A. M.;
MEIRELES, S. T. Ilhas de vegetação em afloramentos quatzito-arenito no Morro do Pai Inácio,
Chapada Diamantina, Bahia, Brasil. Acta Botanica Brasilica, Feira de Santana, v. 21, n. 2, p.
255-347. 2007.
21-COSTA, L. C. B.; ROCHA, E. A.; SILVA, L. A.
M.; JARDIM, J. G.; SILVA, D. C.; GAIAO, L.
O.; MOREIRA, R. C. T.. Levantamento preliminar de espécies vegetais com potencial econômi-
co no Parque Municipal de Boa Esperança, Ilhéus, Bahia, Brasil. Acta Farm. Bonaerense, v.
25, n. 2, p. 184-191, 2006.
22-FERREIRA, A. W. C. ; LIMA, M. I. S. ; PANSARIN, E. R. Orchidaceae da região central de
São Paulo, Brasil. Robriguésia, Rio de Janeiro,
v. 61, n. 2, p. 243-259. 2010.
23-FRAGA, C. N.; PEIXOTO, A. L. Florística e ecologia das Orchidaceae do Espírito Santo. Rodriguésia, Rio de Janeiro, v. 55. n. 84, p. 5-20, 2004.
24-GOMES, A. P. S.; RODAL, M. J. N.; MELO,
A. L. Florística e fitogeografia da vegetação arbustiva subcaducifólia da Chapada de São José,
Buíque, PE, Brasil. Acta Botanica Brasilica,Feira
de Santana, v. 20, n. 1, p. 37-48, 2006.
25-GONÇALVES, C. N.; WAECHTER, J. L. Epífitos vasculares sobre espécimes de Ficus orgamensis isolados no norte da planície costeira
do Rio Grande do Sul: padrões de abundância e
distribuição. Acta Botanica Brasílica, Feira de
Santana,v. 16, n. 4, p. 429-441, 2002.
26-JAQUEMYN, H.; MICHENEAU, C.; PAILLER,
T.. Elevational gradients of species diversity,
breeding system and floral traits of orchid species on Reunion Island. Jounal of Biogeography,
v. 32, p. 1751-1761, 2005.
27-KREBS, C. J. Ecological Methodology. Harper
Collins, New York. 1989, 620p.
28-MANIA, L. F.; MONTEIRO, R. Florística e ecologia de epífitas vasculares em um fragmento de
floresta de restinga, Ubatuba, SP, Brasil. Rodriguesia, Rio de Janeiro, v. 61, n. 4, p. 705-713,
2010
29-MARACAJA, P. B.; BASTISTA, C. H. F.; SOUSA A. H.; VASCONCELOS, W. E. Levantamento florístico e fitossociológico do estrato arbustivo-arbóreo de dois ambientes na Vila Santa
Catarina, Serra do Mel, RN. Revista de Biologia
e Ciências da Terra, v. 3, n. 2, 2003.
30-MORAES, C. P.; DOMINGUES, E.; PREZZI,
L. E.; SOUZA LEAL, T.; ZAMBOM, R. I.;
BRESCANSIN, R. L.; RAMOS, P. A. B. Florsitica e fitossociologia da família Orchidaceae
no Centro de Educação Ambiental “Francisco
Mendes, município de Mogi Guaçu, SP, Brasil.
Scientia plena, v. 6, n. 1, p. 1-5, 2010.
31-MURREN, C. J.; ELLISON, A. M. Seed dispersal characteristics of Brassavola nodosa (Orchi-
75
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 75
09/10/2012 13:44:02
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
daceae). American Journal of Botany, v. 85, n. 5,
p. 675-680, 1998.
32-NEVES, S. P. S.; CONCEIÇAO, A. A. Campo
rupestre recém-queimado na Chapada Diamantina, Bahia, Brasil: plantas de rebrota e sementes, com espécies endêmicas na rocha. Acta Botanica Brasilica, Feira de Santana,v. 24, n. 3, p.
697-707, 2010.
33-PABST, G. F. J.; DUNGS, F. Orchidaceae brasiliensis. Hildesheim Brucke V1 & V2. 1975-1977,
1.408 p.
34-PANSARIN, E. R.; PANSARIN, L. M. A família Orchidaceae na Serra do Japi, São Paulo,
Brasil. Rodriguésia, Rio de Janeiro, v. 59, n. 1,
p. 99-111, 2008.
35-PEREIRA, U. Z.; RIBEIRO, L. Caracterização
da comunidade de Orchidaceae em fragmentos
em Floresta Ombrófila Densa Montana em diferentes estágios de regeneração em Santa Tereza,
Espírito Santo, Brasil. Natureza on Line, Santa
Tereza, v. 2, n. 2, p. 52-60, 2006.
36-QUEIROZ, L. P.; SENA, T. S. N.; COSTA, M.
J. S. L. Flora vascular da Serra da Jibóia, Santa
Terezinha, Bahia: campo rupestre. Sientitibus
série ciências biologicas, Feira de Santana, n.
15, p. 27- 40, 1996.
37-RIBEIRO, P. L.; BORBA, E. L.; TOSCANO-
DE-BRITO, A. L. V. O gênero Bulbophylum
Thouars (ORCHIDACEAE) na Chapada Diamantina, Bahia, Brasil. Revista Brasileira de
Botânica, São Paulo, v. 28, n. 3, p. 423-439,
2005.
38-RODAL, M. J. N.; NASCIMENTO L. M. N.
Levantamento florístico da floresta serrana da
reserva biológica de Serra Negra, Macrorregião
de Itapiraca, Pernambuco, Brasil. Acta Botanica
Brasilica, Feira de Santana, v. 16, n. 4, p. 481500, 2002.
39-ROGALSKI, J. M.; ZANIN, E. M. Composição
florística de epífitos vasculares no estreito de
Augusto César, Floresta Estacional Decidual
do Rio Urugiai, RS, Brasil. Revista Brasileira
de Botânica, São Paulo, v. 26, n. 4, p. 551-556,
2003.
40-WATANABE, M. T. C.; ROQUE, N.; RAPINI,
A. Apocynaceae sensu strictum no Parque Municipal de Mucugê, Bahia, Brasil, incluindo a
publicação válida de dois nomes de Mandevilla
Lindl. Iheringa, Porto Alegre, v, 64, n. 1, p. 6375, 2009.
41-WOLF, J. H. D.; FLAMENCO, A. Patterns in
species richness and distribution of vascular
epiphytes in Chiapas, Mexico.Journal of Biogeography, v. 30, p. 1689-1707, 2003.
76
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 76
09/10/2012 13:44:02
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Fluctuating Asymmetry in three Basileuterus (Passeriformes, Parulidae) species in a semideciduous forest
fragment in the Brazilian Cerrado
Vanessa Fonseca Gonçalves - Universidade Federal de Uberlândia, Instituto de Biologia, Programa de
Pós-graduação em Ecologia e Conservação de Recursos Naturais (email: vanessinha_fg@hotmail.com)
Celine de Melo - Universidade Federal de Uberlândia, Instituto de Biologia (email: celine@inbio.ufu.br)
ABSTRACT
Habitat fragmentation in small remnants may compromise aptitude in some bird species. Fluctuating Asymmetry (FA) is the morphological alteration of bilateral characters
caused by genetic or environmental stress, this can be used in environmental biomonitoring studies and programs. The objectives were to define FA levels of tarsus and wing
in three species of genus Basileuteurus (B. hypoleucus, B. flaveolus and B. leucophrys),
and to verify the hypothesis of FA being more pronounced in birds that inhabit fragment
edges than those inside. The highest FA values in wing were found in B. flaveolus and
B. hypoleucus, and for tarsus in B. hypoleucus. Basileuterus leucophrys was the least
assymetric for both characters. FA values were different, both among the three Basileuterus species and between environments, thereby indicating that the characteristics of
the environment in which the species concentrates its activities appear to be the most
important factor in determining character stability.
Key words: morphometry; avifauna; forest fragment
INTRODUCTION
Habitat fragmentation is a process in which
a large and continuous patch of vegetation is split
into two or more isolated fragments that function
as islands surrounded by nonforested habitats (24).
Various techniques have been used for monitoring
the effects of habitat fragmentation on biota.
One of these is Fluctuating asymmetry
(FA) analysis. This deals with random differences
between the two sides of characters with bilateral
symmetry (23, 8). FA has proved to be one of the
most used indices when describing phenotypic
variations caused, not only by disturbances of an
environmental nature, such as susceptibility to
habitat degradation, parasites, or disease, but also
genetic factors, as a result of genic disharmony
caused by endogamy, heterozygosity or recombination (15, 8, 11).
Bird fluctuating symmetry has been proposed as a tool in the studies of the conservation
of natural and forest fragment populations. In Passeriformes of Atlantic Rain Forest, the highest FA
levels occurred in the more fragmented areas when
compared to the continuous, thereby demonstrating
that wing FA levels are higher in smaller areas (2).
In Passeriformes in Minas Gerais State, symmetric fluctuation in coracoids, ulnae, tarsi and femurs
was a clear indication that intense regional deforestation affected populations (1).
FA is a practical and trustworthy conservation index, due to the facility in obtaining data and
superiority in relation to other indices (2). On considering the susceptibility of asymmetry levels to
individual localization, higher in populations whose
activities are more concentrated on the edges (20),
the differentiated use of the environment by species
furnishes data for studies of environmental quality.
77
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 77
09/10/2012 13:44:02
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
In the Cerrado, three species of the genus
Basileuterus (B. hypoleucus, B. flaveolus and B. leucophrys) are potentially apt for testing this model.
They are sympatric and essentially forest species,
with spatial niche partitioning as a result of competition exclusion (12). Birds of the genus Basileuterus
(Passeriformes, Parulidae) are insectivores, with differentiated usage of the environment (19).
OBJECTIVES
To determine fluctuating asymmetry levels in three species of Basileuterus, viz., Basileuterus hypoleucus, Basileuterus flaveolus, and Basileuterus leucophrys), and to verify the hypothesis of
FA being more accentuated in individuals inhabiting regions closer to the fragment forest edge than
those inside.
METHODOLOGY
Study site:
Captures occurred from November, 2007
to June, 2008, and from August, 2008 to October,
2008 in fragment of semideciduous forest fragment
(37 hectares) in the Glória Experimental Farm,
Uberlândia, Minas Gerais (18º57’06.31”S and
48º12’17.12”W). According to Köppen classification, the climate is megathermic, with rainy summers and dry winters (17)
Collection:
Mist nets (12,0m x 3,0m and 6,0m x 2,5m)
were placed at the edge of and inside the dry and
flooded interior of a forest fragment. After being
ringed (CEMAVE/ICMBio), the captured birds
were then weighed with manual dynamometers (30
g and 60 g).The length of each wing and tarsus was
sequentially measured twice with a manual calliper
kingtools (0,1mm precision) in the following order:
left wing, left tarsus, right wing, right tarsus. The
animals were released immediately after the measurements. The arithmetic mean of the measurements of each character was determined later.
According to Straube and Bianconi (2008),
the capture effort was calculated by the simple multiplication of the area of each net by the time of exposure, plus the number of nets. The total effort was
the sum of daily samplings.
Statistic analysis
Fluctuating asymmetry (FA) was evaluated
separately for the wing and tarsus of each species,
following calculations defined by Palmer and Strobeck (1986) for the wings and tarsi separately: [ | R
– L | / (R + L / 2) ], where: R= average of the right-side
measurement for each individual, and L=average of
the left-side measurement for each individual.
According to Palmer & Strobeck (1986),
it is necessary to distinguish FA from other types
of asymmetry, such as directional asymmetry and
antisymmetry. For this, t-tests were used to verify
that the difference in the mean measures of the
right and the left (D - E) was significantly equal to
zero and the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test was used
to examine the normality of the (D - E) distribution. When the average of the measure of the right
and left sides was equal to zero and normally distributed, the occurrence of directional asymmetry
and antisymmetry was discarded, respectively.
The dependence of FA on the size of the original
measure was tested for each sample using a Pearson correlation between the |FA| and the average of
the measure on the right side (13).
Kruskal-Wallis was used to verify the interspecific differences in the FA values for wings
and tarsi and Mann-Whitney was used to compare
the differences between FA values for birds captured in the edge and inside. The species with the
most pronounced FA was also that which presented
the highest FA value for wing and tarsus.
RESULTS
Twenty two individuals of the genus
Basileuterus were captured, of which five were B.
hypoleucus, seven B. flaveolus and ten B. leucophrys, in 80.199,3 hours.m 2.
The distribution by wings and tarsi was not
normal. According to Babbit et al. (2006), there can
be a slight deviation in the distribution of data frequency, without impeding the occurrence of fluctuating asymmetry.
Directional asymmetry was discarded, or
rather, the data presented averages equal to zero for
both the wings (t = 0,462; df = 21; p = 0,150) and tarsi
(t = 0,246; df = 21; p = 0,220). FA values for wing did
not correlate with the average of the original mea-
78
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 78
09/10/2012 13:44:02
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
AF média
surements (rs = -0,327; gl = 22; p > 0,05), as neither
did tarsus FA values (rs = -0,036; gl = 22; p > 0,05).
There were differences between interspecific FA levels for wing (H= 1,728; p= 0,004; N= 22)
and tarsus (H= 6,271; p= 0,009; N= 22). The highest FA values for wing were found in B. flaveolus
(AF= 0,0142 + 0,0135) and B. hypoleucus (0,0130 +
0,0122), and for tarsi in B. hypoleucus (AF= 0,0573
+ 0,0728). Basileuterus leucophrys was the least
0,14asymmetric for both characters (Figure 1).
0,12
AF média 0,14
0,10
0,12
0,08
0,10
0,06
0,08
0,04
0,06
0,02
0,04
0,00
0,02
B. hypoleucus
asa
tarso
B. leucophrys
B. flaveolus
Espécies
0,00
B. hypoleucus
B. leucophrys
B. flaveolus
Espécies
AF média
AF média 0,14
0,12
0,10
0,08
0,06
0,04
0,02
0,00
AF média
Figure 1: Fluctuating asymmetry (FA) (average± stan0.07
dard
error) in the wings and tarsi of Basileuterus hyinterior
0.06
poleucus,
B. leucophrys and B. flaveolus, captured
in
borda
AF média
0.07
0.05
semideciduous forest in the Gloria Experimental Farm,
0.06
0.04
Uberlândia,
MG.
0.05
0.03
AF média 0,14
0.02
0.04
Of the
22 individuals captured, one B. hypo0.03
0.01
asa
leucus
and four
0,10
0.02 B. flaveolus were caught in the edges
0
tarso
asa
tarso
0.01
of fragment,
whereas
B. leucophrys
individuals were
0,08
Carácter
0
from 0,06
the inside.
Although there was a significant
asa
tarso
difference
between edge and interior,
for FA levels
0,04
Carácter
for wing
0,02 (U= 35; p= 0,025; N= 22), this was not the
B. hypoleucus
B. leucophrys
B. flaveolus
case for
40; p= 0,41; N= 22) (Figure 2). FA
0,00 tarsi (U=
Espécies
B. hypoleucus
B. leucophrys
B. flaveolus
for wing was
higher in species
captured on
the edge
Espécies
(AF= 0,0194 + 0,0161), and lower in individuals from
the inside (AF= 0,0075 + 0,0063).
0,12
0.07
0.06
0.05
0.04
0.03
0.02
0.01
0
interior
AF média
0.07
borda
0.06
0.05
0.04
0.03
0.02
0.01
asa
0
tarso
Carácter
asa
tarso
Carácter
Figure 2: Fluctuating asymmetry (FA) (AF) (average±
standard error) in individuals from three species of
Basileuterus captured in Semideciduous Forest in the
Gloria Experimental Farm, Uberlândia, MG.
DISCUSSION
The interspecific difference between fluctuating asymmetry (FA) values for wings and tarsi
in the individuals implies that the differentiated use
of characters is a factor that exerts an influence on
FA levels (2). According to Balmford et al. (1993),
the FA of a character depends on its functional importance, whereby the possible appearance of different values between characters and species. Furthermore, FA specificity for a character (13, 14) is
asa
liable to generate variations among characters in the
tarso
same individual, and even among characters related
to morphological structure development (7).
Basileuterus hypoleucus and Basileuterus
flaveolus presented the highest wing FA levels,
which is probably associated to the expressive allocation of time for flight in these species (4).
Tarsi in Basileuterus hypoleucus were more
asymmetric. The use, by this bird, of various strata
interior
(19),
and its greater movement inside forest fragborda
ments, possibly more frequently expose wings and
tarsi to the prevailing environmental conditions,
with the consequentially high FA levels (12, 2).
Basileuterus flaveolus and B. hypoleucus,
asa
through being capable of foraging on forest edges
tarso
where the microenvironment is different from the
inside, and levels of light, temperature and wind
higher (16), undergo environmental stress which
would influence FA values. According to Van Valen
(1962) and Lomônaco & Germanos (2001), FA has
become the most used index for describing phenotypic variations caused by environmental noise.
In their studies, Evans and Marshall (1996)
presented a correlation between fitness and asymmeinterior
try,borda
in which FA increases with environmental and
genetic stress. A possible mechanism of the relationship between FA and stress is that organisms require
more energy to compensate stress, thereby resulting
in less expenditure with reproduction and growth
(10), or, in other words, stress reduces the available
energy for the development of character precision
(21). Thus, higher levels of habitat disturbance could
increase population asymmetry levels prior to a decrease in survival becoming apparent (9).
79
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 79
09/10/2012 13:44:02
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Species that presented higher FA levels,
such as B. hypoleucus and B. flaveolus, could represent groups which are more sensitive to disturbance in the process of character development (2).
The effects of genetic and environmental stress are
cumulative. Hence, organisms under genetic stress
are useful as biological indicators of environmental
stress quantified through FA, and can thus be efficiently employed in biomonitoring programs (5, 15).
Basileuterus leucophrys is more exigent
as regards the microhabitat, and so, in this study,
was only captured inside the forest, and thus presented the lowest wing and tarsus FA values. The
interior of a forest fragment is more isolated from
edge-effects ((16), thus anthropic disturbance has
less influence on the development of character stability (20). Furthermore, FA levels are often higher
among individuals undergoing environmental stress
and located in ecologically marginal habitats (22).
CONCLUSION
Fluctuations in asymmetry values varied
among the three species of Basileuterus, and between environments (interior and edge), this being
more so in B. hypoleucus and B. flaveolus species,
which use the edge for foraging, and less so in B.
leucophrys species, which were captured only inside the forest fragment. Thus, the characteristics of
the environment in which the species concentrates
its activities appear to be the predominating factor
in determining character stability, whence the usefulness of FA in the relative diagnosis of impacts
arising from forest fragmentation.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
Thanks are extended to Professors Dr. Oswaldo Marçal Júnior and Dr. Cecília Lomônaco for
the corrections and criticisms, and to my collegues
Eurípedes Luciano da Silva Júnior, Péricles Rocha
da Silva and Giâncarlo Ângelo Ferreira for the help
in collecting data.
RESUMO
A fragmentação do habitat em pequenos
remanescentes pode comprometer a aptidão de
algumas espécies de aves. A assimetria flutuante
(AF) é uma alteração morfológica em caracteres
bilaterais causada por estresse genético ou ambiental, que pode ser utilizada em estudos e programas de biomonitoramento ambiental. Os objetivos deste trabalho foram: determinar os níveis de
AF de asas e tarsos em três espécies de Basileuterus (B. hypoleucus, B. flaveolus e B. leucophrys)
e testar a hipótese da AF ser mais acentuada em
aves que habitam regiões mais próximas da borda
do fragmento daquelas restritas ao interior de um
remanescente florestal. Os maiores valores de AF
para asa foram encontrados em B. flaveolus e B.
hypoleucus, e para tarso foi em B. hypoleucus.
Basileuterus leucophrys foi o menos assimétrico
para ambos os caracteres. Os valores de AF foram
diferentes entre as três espécies de Basileuterus e
entre os ambientes indicando que a característica
do ambiente no qual a espécie concentra suas atividades parece ser o fator mais importante na determinação da estabilidade do carácter.
Palavras chave: morfometria; avifauna; fragmento
florestal
REFERENCES
1- ALMEIDA, R. C. V. Assimetria flutuante em
esqueletos de aves Passeriformes do Estado de
Minas Gerais: aspectos metodológicos e implicações sobre a utilização de coleções osteológicas como objeto de estudos de variação temporal de comunidades. 2003. 59 f Dissertação
(Mestrado em Zoologia de Vertebrados) - Pontifícia Universidade Católica de Minas Gerais,
Belo Horizonte. 2003.
2- ANCIÃES, M.; MARINI, M. Â. Assimetria
flutuante em Passeriformes da Mata Atlântica.
In: ALVES, M. A. S., SILVA; J. M. C., VAN
SLUYS; M., BERGALLO, H. G.; ROCHA; C.
F. D. (Orgs). A ornitologia no Brasil: pesquisa
atual e perspectivas. Rio de Janeiro: Editora da
Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, 2000.
3- BABBITT, G. A.; KILTIE, R.; BOLKER, B. Are
Fluctuating Asymmetry Studies Adequately Sampled? Implications of a New Model for Size Distribution. The American Naturalist, v. 167, 2006.
4-BALMFORD, A.; JONES, I. L.; THOMAS, A.
L. R. On avian asymmetry: evidence of natu-
80
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 80
09/10/2012 13:44:02
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
ral selection for symmetrical tails and wings in
birds. Proceedings of the Royal Society, v. 252,
p. 245-251, 1993.
5- CLARKE, G.M. Fluctuating asymmetry: a technique for measuring developmental stress of genetic and environmental origin. Acta Zoologica
Fennica 191:31-35. 1992.
6- EVANS, A.S.; MARSHALL, M. Developmental
instability in Brassica campestris (Cruciferae):
fluctuatin asymmetry of foliar and floral traits.
Journal Evolution of Biology 9:717-736. 1996.
7- KLINGENBERG, C. P.; MACINTYRE, G. S.
Geometric morphometrics of developmental
instabilitity: analyzing patterns of fluctuanting
asymmetry with procrustes methods. Evolution,
v. 52, p. 1363-1375, 1998.
8- LEARY, R.F.; ALLENDORF, F.W. Fluctuating
asymmetry as indicator of e stress: implications
for conservation biology. Trends in Ecology &
Evolution 4:214-217. 1989
9- LENS, L., DONGEN, S.V.; MATTHYSEN, E.
Fluctuating asymmetry as an early warningsystem in the critically endangered Taita Thrush.
Conservervation. Biology 16:479-487. 2002.
10-LEUNG, B.; FORBES, M. R.; HOULE, D. Fluctuating asymmetry as a bioindicator of stress:
comparing efficacy of analyses involving multiple traits. The American Naturalist, v. 155, n. 1,
p. 101-115, 1999.
11-LOMÔNACO, C.; GERMANOS, E. Variações
fenotípicas em Musca domestica L. (Diptera:
Muscidae) em resposta à competição larval por
alimento. Neotropical Entomology, v. 30, n. 2, p.
223-231, junho 2001.
12-MARINI, M. A.; CAVALCANTI, R. B. Habitat
and foraging substrate use of three Basileuterus
warblers from Central Brazil. Ornitologia Neotropical, v. 4, n. 2, p. 69-76, 1993.
13-Palmer, A. R.; Strobeck, C., Fluctuating
asymmetry: measurement, analysis, patterns.
Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, p.
391-421. 1986.
14-PARSONS, P.A. Fluctuating asymmetry: an epigenetic measure of stress. Biological Review, v.
65, p. 131-145, 1990.
15-PARSONS, P.A. Fluctuating asymmetry: a biological monitor of environmental and genomic
stress. Heredity 68:361-364. 1992.
16-PRIMACK, R. B.; RODRIGUES, E. Biologia
da conservação. Londrina: Editora Planta, 2001.
327 p.
17-ROSA, R.; LIMA, S. C.; ASSUNÇÃO, W. L.
Abordagem preliminar das condições climáticas
de Uberlândia (MG). Sociedade & Natureza, p.
91-108, 1991.
18-STRAUBE, F. C.; BIANCONI, G. V. Sobre a
grandeza e a unidade utilizada para estimular
esforço de captura com utilização de redes de
neblina. Chiroptera Neotropical, v. 8, p. 150152, 2008.
19-SICK, H. Ornitologia brasileira. Rio de Janeiro:
Editora Nova Fronteira, 1997. 912 p.
20-SIIKAMÄKI, P.; LAMMI, A. Fluctuating
asymmetry in central and marginal populations
of Lychnis viscaria in relation to genetic and
environmental factors. Evolution, v. 52, p. 1285
1292, 1998.
21-SOMMER, C. Ecotoxicology and developmental
stability as an in situ monitor of adaptation. Ambio, v.25, p. 374-376, 1996.
22-SOULÉ, M.; BAKER, B. Phenetics of natural
populations IV: The population asymmetry parameter in the butterfly Coenonympha tullia.
Hereditery, v. 23, p. 611-613, 1968.
23-VAN VALEN, L. A study of fluctuating asymmetry. Evolution, v. 16, p. 125-142, 1962.
24-WILCOVE, D.S., McLELLAN, C.H.; DOBSON, A.P. Habitat fragmentation in the temperate zone. Conservantion Biology, p. 237-256.
1986.
25-ZAR, J.H. Biostatistical analysis. New Jersey:
Prentice Hall, 1984. 947 p.
81
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 81
09/10/2012 13:44:03
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
82
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 82
09/10/2012 13:44:03
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Vascular plant diversity and substratum parameters
as indicators of ecologically based degraded-area
recuperation
Maria Luiza Porto - Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Departamento de Ecologia (e-mail: mlporto@ecologia.ufrgs.br).
Marisa Azzolini † - Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Departamento de Plantas de Lavoura, in
memoriam
Cíntia Silva Beauvalet - Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Departamento de Ecologia, bolsista
IC/PIBIC.
Telmo Focht - Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Bolsista recém-doutor - CNPq - Departamento
de Ecologia (email: tefocht@gmail.com)
ABSTRACT
In order to be characterized as restoration on an ecological basis, the recovery of a degraded area should increase natural biodiversity. The aim was to establish experiments
that reveal the processes involved in the advance of spontaneous vegetation in areas
degraded by coal mining. Plant species were first planted for primary coverage of a
substratum formed by a coal refuse deposit already covered by regional B-horizon soil,
the two pioneer species, Cynodon dactylon (L.) Pers. and Indigofera campestris Bong.
ex Benth, being those chosen. Spontaneous plant species diversity was monitored by
three abundance and cover surveys. The experiment consisted of two plots, one for each
species, divided into 9 sub-plots. From April, 2009 to February, 2011, C. dactylon cover
dropped from around 40 to 5%, thereby facilitating the establishment of a higher number
of local spontaneous plants. In each survey, I. campestris covered around 80% of the
soil. Shannon index between the two species differed significantly (f=0.0141, α=0.05).
According to substratum fertility analysis, both at the beginning and the end of the experiments, fertility in organic material increased throughout, with a reduction in acidity
at the end of the experiment. Although both species retained substratum, I. campestris
contributed towards its more pronounced fertilization, whereas C. dactylon facilitated
natural succession and diversity. Hence the latter is more adequate for restoration.
Key words: recovery on an ecological basis: degraded area recuperation; species diversity; mining areas; coal
INTRODUCTION
The criteria applied in recuperation processes, besides being variable, will initially depend
on the characteristics of the degraded area. Independently, recuperation, at least over long-term,
should re-establish ecological interactions, thereby
facilitating the increase of local biodiversity. Only
after these prerequisites have been fulfilled, will it
be possible to affirm that recovery, on an ecological
basis, has begun.
As also stated by Ser (2004), the recovery
of an area on an ecological basis consists of reestablishing the dynamics of ecosystem processes,
83
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 83
09/10/2012 13:44:03
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
through actions and procedures based on natural
principles, and for ecological restoration in itself,
and not simply for detaining certain processes of
substratum loss by the use of any form of vegetal
cover. The principle of recovery on an ecological
basis will make it possible to reach a state of equilibrium, even though only close to that prior to the
disturbance. In order to accomplish this, it is very
important that, at the very beginning, vegetal cover
of the areas to be restored be preferentially adopted
from native species (13). Nonetheless, there are occasions in which the environment to be restored is
so adverse to local species, that the use of exotic species, or even a mixture of these with domesticated
exotic plants, and on the prior condition of their not
presenting characteristics of invaders (7), is more
appropriate, as a means of modifying the environment, in such a way as to facilitate the posterior establishment of native species (5, 3, 1), thereby giving continuity to the succession process. However,
simply promoting vegetal cover, without necessarily taking into account ecological processes, could
be considered as only recovering with vegetation or
simply recuperation.
Connell and Slatyer (1977) presented three
mechanisms, viz., facilitation, tolerance and inhibition, for explaining the process of vegetal succession. In the first, facilitation is defined as the
modification of an environment by pioneer species,
in such a way that this would facilitate the establishment of species characteristic of a more advanced
stage in succession. Through tolerance, there is
initial modification, but without affecting the recruitment of species of posterior succession stages.
Finally, through inhibition, pioneer species modify
the environment with such intensity, that this becomes only little or less adequate for any species of
subsequent succession stages. Of the three mechanisms, that which would be more detectable is facilitation, especially in the initial stages of a succession. Even though it is not always possible to detect
whether any one of the mechanisms is functioning
alone in a succession, or even whether this is possible, probably all the three play their respective role
throughout the succession process (9).
With these mechanisms in mind, over long
term, restoration should not only re-establish those
ecological interactions which facilitate succession
and system efficacy, but also induce local biodiversity (13, 12).
In this study, vegetal species diversity is
considered, as a possible indicator of the initial
phases of the ecological-based recovery process of
degraded areas, according to Connell and Slatyer
(1977) criteria, as to the first mechanism (facilitation), and Reis et al., (2003) criteria as to biodiversity inducement. Thus, the establishment of new
species follows a dynamically sequential and natural process of substitution and entrance of organisms, as outlined by Rogalski et al., (2005), until
reaching an equilibrium phase, in accordance to local and regional environmental conditions (climatic
and geomorphological).
The different types of interaction among
living organisms, as, for example, predation, herbivority, pathogeny, mutualism and decomposition, at the different trophic levels, are prerequisites for characterizing an ecological restoration
process (11), through inducing natural processes,
such as vegetal succession, by the establishment
of facilitating pioneer species in the processes of
species entrance and substitution in the system (1).
The processes unleashed in this first sequential
phase will facilitate the entrance of spontaneous
species from the native fauna, thus increasing diversity in vegetal species, to be followed by those
of the associated fauna (14).
Nonetheless, success in a recuperation process carried out on an ecological basis, also depends
on the initial conditions of the abiotic component
of an ecosystem. An important point which should
be considered – and contemplated – is soil retention
against possible erosion. During the process of soil
degradation, with the accompanying modifications
in structure, and chemical and biological composition, organic-matter loss, as the main consequence,
tends to retard the natural restoration process. One
way of incrementing available organic matter is by
transposing soil from neighboring areas, thereby recomposing fertility with mineral and organic nutrients and ionic exchange capacity, as well as part of
the biota of this compartment of the ecosystem (13,
19). Furthermore, the seed bank and other propagules present in the transported soil can increase the
diversity of colonizing species in the new environment (19).
84
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 84
09/10/2012 13:44:03
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
By the aforementioned motives, substratum
fertility at two moments (initial and final), as well
as the loss of this substratum through surface drainage during the period of observation, were chosen
as additional indicators of the process.
In the phenomenon studied here, a descriptive approach on a temporal scale was chosen,
starting from a completely bare substratum (time
zero), although, through dealing with inedited
knowledge and an emergent topic for subtropical
areas in the south of Brazil, there were limits to
a deeper statistical approach. In the present case,
deeper statistical analysis would require having
accompanied the process over several years, with
direct dependence on environmental dynamics.
Nonetheless, in spite of the short period of observation (32 months), clear tendencies of the established processes towards recovery on an ecological
basis, were observed.
OBJECTIVE
The aim was to obtain experimental data
on the initial processes which lead to the recovery
of degraded areas on an ecological basis, having as
the substratum, refuse from the processes of washing and beneficiating mineral coal in Treviso county, southern Santa Catarina State.
METHODOLOGY
The area chosen for field experiments corresponds to the taluses built by Mineradora Metropolitana, Treviso, SC, for the recuperation of areas
of mineral coal deposits, whose geographic coordinates are 28º29’02.33”S and 49º27’33.53”W.
Refuse from washing and beneficiating deposited
coal, and accumulated at the base of each talus, has
been covered by B horizon soil from the region.
These taluses are encountered in an environment
of the Atlantic Forest. They are located on various
platforms placed around the heap of refuse, each
platform measuring around 2000 m in length (Figure 1). The experiments were begun at the moment
zero (control), in bare substratum, and consisted
of setting up two plots on the taluses (Figure 2) for
recovery experiments.
Area for setting
Áreaupde
theimplantação
recovery
plots (bare
substratum)
Figure 1. Delimitation of the refuse deposit and location
of the study area on the deposit.
Initially, two species, C. dactylon and I.
campestris. were implanted, one each, into two
plots, each measuring 10 m x 20 m (Figure 2B).
Planting took place on May 6th, 2008. Stolons were
planted at a distance of 0.40m between rows and
0.20m between each plant (Figure 2A), in substratum without any correction of acidity or the addition
of any type of manure. It is important to point out
that the substratum used in this area for covering refuse had been taken from local B horizon soil, with
low organic matter and nutrient rates, especially of
nitrogen (Table 1).
The collection of substratum compound
samples was by boring till a depth of 20cm. This
was done in each of the two plots in the beginning
(zero moment – control), on May 6th, 2008, and at
the end (32 months) of the experiment. This substratum was analyzed for fertility, according to the
method described by Tedesco et al., (1995). Soil
pH was defined with a potentiometer in a soil-water suspension, at a proportion of 1:1. The organic
matter rate was defined by humid digestion, using
potassium dicromate and sulfuric acid. The micronutrients were obtained according to the methods
described in Cqfs - Comissão de Química e Fertilidade do Solo (2004).
Due to high seedling mortality, in September it became necessary to plant more seedlings
in both plots. In order to evaluate the amount of
sediments through artificial drainage, 0.5 m x 5 m
troughs were installed in both plots (Figure 2A).
As a form of comparing the efficiency of
each species in substratum coverage and inducing
colonization by new species, after the seedlings of
both species had reached an adequate growth, sur-
1
85
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 85
09/10/2012 13:44:03
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
veys of abundance and cover, according to BraunBlanquet (1979), but modified, were carried out in
April and October, 2009 and February, 2011, in 9
sub-plots measuring 0.5m x 0.5m (0.25m²), with
systematic selection procedures for localizing
planted pioneer species in each plot (Figure 2B).
Species diversity was estimated according to the
Shannon index (1948) in both planted plots. As a
complement, the t test was applied for estimating
the significance of results between the two species.
Both the significance test and diversity index were
obtained with PAST software (10).
Area for setting
Áreaupde
theimplantação
recovery
plots (bare
substratum)
Area for setting
RESULTS
Área
upde
theimplantação
recovery
plots (bare
The substratum substratum)
analyzed corresponded to
material used for covering refuse from coal mining
(B horizon of local soil). Thus, generally speaking,
fertility was very low and acidity high (pH = 4.5).
The initial degree of organic matter was almost zero
(0,3%). Nonetheless, an increase in organic matter
and a drop in acidity were noted following planting and the subsequent advance in revegetation.
The same could be observed through the increase
in ions that are important for vegetal development
and growth, and the decrease in the concentration
of some heavy metals and aluminum, whereby the
inference that the species planted are capable of
contributing to the phytoremediation process, i.e.,
the absorption of toxic ions by tolerant plants.
Table 1. Physical and chemical characteristics of the
substratum (B horizon local soil) used for covering
carboniferous refuse in the area of implanting recovery plots, obtained in the beginning and at the
end of experiments.
Rates
Dec - 2008
Feb – 2011
Talus/bare
Cynodon
indigofera
Substratum fertility
area
dactylon
campestris
Clay (%)
15
13
13
pH
4.5
4.7
4.8
SMP Index
4.7
4.7
4.8
4.5
2.1
1.7
Phosphorus (mg dm-3)
127
142
153
Potassium (mg dm-3)
Organic matter (%)
0.3
1.9
2.6
8.3
3.0
2.7
Changeable aluminum (cmolc dm-3)
0.7
2.4
3.6
Changeable calcium (cmolc.dm-3)
0.9
1.9
2.8
Changeable magnesium (cmolc dm-3)
19.4
19.4
17.3
Aluminum + Hydrogen (cmolc.dm-3)
21.4
24.1
24.1
Cation change capacity (CCC) (cmolcdm-3)
CCC saturation as bases (%)
9
19
28
CCC saturation as Al (%)
80.9
38.9
28.3
Correlations Ca/Mg
0.8
1.3
1.3
Correlations Ca/K
2.1
7
9
Correlations Mg/K
2.8
5
7
84
45
31
Súlfur (mg dm-3)
2.6
1.8
1.4
Zinc (mg dm-3)
14.0
1.2
0.8
Copper (mg dm-3)
0.3
0.6
0.6
Boron (mg dm-3)
22
25
28
Manganese (mg dm-3)
Substratum analysis by the Soil Laboratory of the Faculty of Agronomy/UFRGS – a member of the Oficial
Network Soil Analysis Laboratories (ROLAS) – in accordance with Tedesco et al. (1995) and Cqfs Comissão de Química e Fertilidade do Solo (2004).
Figure 2. General view of the plots at the time of planting in May, 2008, with surface drainage gutter (A) and
the scheme of experimental delimitation in plots and
sub-plots (B).
Substratum analysis by the Soil Laboratory of
the Faculty of Agronomy/UFRGS – a member of the
Oficial Network Soil Analysis Laboratories (ROLAS)
1
– in accordance with Tedesco et al., (1995) and Cqfs
-Comissão de Química e Fertilidade do Solo (2004).
The species I. campestris afforded a quicker and more uniform recoverture of the area, leading to a reduction in drainage in the respective plot,
when compared to that with C. dactylon. Nonetheless, as I. campestris is more sensitive to frosts than
C. dactylon, from July on, it was noted that drainage
86
2
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 86
09/10/2012 13:44:03
Rates
Rates
Dec
- 2008
Feb
– 2011
Dec
- 2008
Feb
– 2011
Talus/bare
Cynodon
indigofera
Talus/bare
Cynodon
indigofera
Substratum
fertility
Substratum
fertility
area
dactylon
area
dactylon
campestris
Brazilian Journal of Ecology campestris
ISSN
1516-5868
Clay
(%)
1515
1313
1313
Clay
(%)
pHsimilar
4.54.5 the same 4.7
4.84.8 cover
pH
4.7
was
in both plots (Figure 3).
winter. Over
period,
I. campestris
SMP
Index
4.74.7
4.74.7
4.84.8
SMP
Index
-3
The (mg
peaks
in) -3)sediment production oc- dropped4.5
from
decomposi2.12.1but as plant1.7
Phosphorus
dmdm
4.5 88 to 69%,
1.7
Phosphorus
(mg
-3 -3
)
127
142
153
Potassium
(mg
dm
curred
in March
tion in this
species is quicker
dactylon,
127
142 than in C.153
Potassium
(mgfor
dmthe) plot with C. dactylon, and
matter
0.30.3
1.91.9 it was already
2.62.6possible
Organic
matter
(%) I. campestris, even though
in Organic
April
for
that(%)
with
in the collection
in October,
-3 -3
) )
8.38.3
3.03.0
2.72.7
Changeable
aluminum
(cmol
Changeable
aluminum
(cmol
c dm
c dm
-3and
there
was no acalcium
peak
in
rainfall
to note an
increase of 82.4
to
compared
) -3) drainage. This
0.70.7
3.63.6
Changeable
(cmol
2.412 species, as
Changeable
calcium
(cmol
c.dm
c.dm
-3 -3
) up
1.91.9 in the plots
2.82.8
Changeable
magnesium
(cmol
probably
occurred
through
digging
to April.0.9
In
of C. dac) the soil to
0.9February, 2011,
Changeable
magnesium
(cmol
c dm
c dm
-3 -3
) ) decumbens
19.4
19.4
Aluminum
Hydrogen
(cmol
19.4
19.4
17.320% of
Aluminum
+ Hydrogen
(cmol
c.dm
c.dm
remove
plants+ of
the species
(Urochloa
tylon and
I. campestris,
there was 4717.3
and
-3 -3
)
21.4
24.1
24.1
Cation
change
capacity
(CCC)
(cmol
dm
)
21.4
24.1
24.1
Cation
change
capacity
(CCC)
(cmol
cdm
c
Stapf,
synonym
Brachiaria
decumbens - Poaceae), uncovered
richness
was 1828and
CCC
saturation
as as
bases
(%)
9 9soil, species19
CCC
saturation
bases
(%)
19
28 9, and
CCC
saturation
as
Al
(%)
80.9
38.9
28.3
CCC
saturation
as
Al
(%)
80.9
38.9
28.3
an exotic invader that had been used by the mining promoted cover 5 and 70%, respectively. The temCorrelations
Ca/Mg
0.80.8
1.31.3
1.31.3
Correlations
Ca/Mg
company
for revegetation
in the neighborhood of poral sequence
of the process
of recovery
over the
Correlations
Ca/K
2.12.1
77
99
Correlations
Ca/K
theCorrelations
study
area,Mg/K
and
whence had invaded the plots.
two previous
2.82.8 years can 5be5 seen in Figure
7 74.
Correlations
Mg/K
-3 -3
) )
84
4545 between October,
3131 2009
Súlfur
(mg
dmdm
Súlfur
(mg
On
an
average,
the production of sediAs84can be observed,
-3 -3
) )
2.62.6
1.81.8
1.41.4
Zinc
(mg
dmdm
Zinc
(mg
ments
during
the
period analyzed was 43.5 and and February,
2011, cover
in the C. dactylon
plot
-3 -3
) )
14.0
1.21.2
0.80.8
Copper
(mg
dmdm
14.0
Copper
(mg
-3 -3 in the plots with I. campestris
43.8
kg
per
hectare
dropped
from
20
to
5%,
which
presupposes
that
this
0.30.3
0.60.6
0.60.6
Boron
(mg
dmdm) )
Boron
(mg
-3 -3
)
22
25
28
Manganese
(mg
dm
)
22
25
28
Manganese
(mg
dm
and C. dactylon, respectively, thereby demonstrat- species was being dislocated by the rest in the sucSubstratum
analysis
byby
thethe
Soil
Laboratory
of of
thethe
Faculty
of of
Agronomy/UFRGS
– a– in
member
thetheOficial
Substratum
analysis
Soil
Laboratory
Faculty
Agronomy/UFRGS
a member
of
Oficial
ing
that, when
growth
has
been
completely
estabcession
advance, whereas
the I. of
campestris
plot,
Network
(ROLAS)
with
et etal.al.
(1995)
and
Network
SoilAnalysis
Analysis
Laboratories
(ROLAS)–by
–in inaccordance
accordance
withTedesco
Tedesco
(1995)70%
andCqfs
Cqfs- lished,
theSoil
potential
forLaboratories
sediment
retainment
cover
practically
remained
around
throughComissão
dede
Química
e Fertilidade
dodo
Solo
(2004).
Comissão
Química
e Fertilidade
Solo
(2004).
both
is similar,
when
growth
has been
completely
out the period. Bare substratum remained around
established. Nevertheless, these numbers do not 20%. Shannon diversity indices for C. dactylon and
represent total sediment loss during the period, I. campestris plots were in April, 2009 1.263 and
since some rainfall-events were discarded from 1.192, in October, 2009 0.791 and 1.260, and in Febanalysis, due to gutter overflowing, thus annulling ruary, 2011 1.594 and 1.227, respectively (Table 2).
correct volume readings on these occasions.
These results point to the greater contribution by C.
Figure 3. Data on the production of sediments in the plots for implanted recovery in the area of the coal deposit. rf = rainfall.
In April, 2009, there was 40 and 25% of
uncovered soil, and species richness was 31 and
8 in the plots of C. dactylon and I. campestris,
respectively (Table 2), whereas in October, 2009,
uncovered soil was 44 and 25%, and species richness 19 and 12 (Table 2). In April, I. campestris
soil coverture was around 25%, and C. dactylon
around 40%. From April to October, 2009, although mantle cover rose from 5 to 35% in the
area with C.dactylon, there was a drop of 31 to
19 species, and in cover from 40 to 20%, through
the aerial part of many species dying during the
dactylon in furthering vegetal diversity throughout
the period evaluated.
Table 2. Number of spontaneous vegetal species
(Richness) in each of the recovery systems, and the
respective Shannon Diversity indices (H’).
22
Period of data collection
Recovery
plots
C. dactylon
I. campestris
2009, April
Shannon
Species
Diversity
richness
H’
31
1.263
8
1.192
2009, October
Shannon
Species
Diversity
richness
H’
19
0.791
12
1.260
2011, February
Shannon
Species
Diversity
richness
H’
18
1.594
9
1.227
87
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 87
09/10/2012 13:44:03
Shannon
Diversity
H’
C. dactylon
31
1.263
I. Brazilian
campestris
8
Journal of Ecology ISSN 1.192
1516-5868
Recovery
plots
Species
richness
Species
richness
19
12
Shannon
Diversity
H’
0.791
1.260
Species
richness
18
9
Shannon
Diversity
H’
1.594
1.227
Figure 4. Advance of the vegetation in the plots where C. dactylon and I. campestris were planted.
As to the substratum, on analyzing nutrients,
it was noted that, over the period December, 2008 to
February, 2011, there was an increase in organic matter of 0.3% to 1.9% in the plot with C. dactylon and to
2.6% in that with I. campestris (Table 1). There was
also a tendency for a reduction in acidity, especially
in the I. campestris, plot, on comparing with zero moment. As to surface sediment drainage, on an average,
the production of sediment from April to October was
similar in both species, with 43.5 kg for the C. dactylon plot and 43.8 kg for that with I. campestris.
DISCUSSION
When considering the recovery of areas
on an ecological basis, the species C dactylon was
chosen for testing in the role of pioneer for establishing a sequential process, followed by accompaniment of diversity in other species throughout
the process, as important elements in the recovery
of areas impacted by the exploitation of coal. Efficiency was compared with that of another species of the family Fabaceae, i.e., I. campestris,
3
88
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 88
09/10/2012 13:44:03
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
which also possesses the characteristics of pioneer
plant and substratum restorer. The empirical and
theoretic fundamentals of the initial phase of an
ecological model for coal-refuse impacted area recovery have already been defined (1). No matter
how drastic the local degradation conditions, the
recovery of an area should not be understood as a
simplified process, with the sole aim of recovering
the area, or simply making it green.
When considering the serious physical
and chemical limitations of areas impacted by coal
mining, as revealed through substratum analyses, their recovery requires ample planning. The
choice of appropriate vegetal species should be in
accordance with criteria which facilitate the establishment of recovery on an ecological basis. Thus,
further attention should be directed towards evaluating the capacity of the different vegetal species
to colonize these environments and induce rapid
soil coverture. This would consist of the contribution towards a reduction in surface and sub-surface
drainage, and the fixing of toxic metallic elements,
with an eye to phytoremediation, thence leading
to an increase in local fauna and floral diversity
(1,13). Thus, the species C. dactylon, was included
in the experiments, through presenting the characteristics of tolerance to degraded terrains, as well
as facilitating the entrance of new species into the
community, even though it is a domesticated exotic species (17), whence its use is debatable (6). The
species I. campestris was used as a pioneer, since,
through being a Fabaceae, it possesses nitrobacterium nodules. This is an essential characteristic for
substratum nitrogen enrichment, thereby, according to the degree of cover, reducing loss.
The results obtained for sediment surface
drainage indicated their higher retention in the plot
planted with I. campestris, which is characterized
by lower native and spontaneous species diversity,
when compared with the C. dactylon plot, thus
placing in evidence that one vegetal species alone
would hardly possess all the necessary characteristics for recovery in ecological terms. Hence, for
recovery to play a complete role, it is necessary
to understand the interactions between the species
and the dynamics of succession, with a view to an
increase in environmental diversity and local ecological complexity.
On the other hand, knowledge of the requirements for maintaining an ecosystem is not
enough, but also comprehension of the methods and
techniques which accelerate recovery processes in
degraded areas, is essential. Among these, knowledge of facilitating species (5, 13, 9), nucleater species (13, 8), or ‘nurse plants’, that enhance recovery
processes on an ecological basis, is essential, since
these can also play a role in the natural advance of
one type of vegetation over another, in a dynamic
process of flower succession. These qualities, as observed in the experiment with C. dactylon, presuppose that this plant, even though a domesticated exotic species, is capable of exerting a facilitating role
in natural sequential processes, since its substitution
by other native species is possible. These characteristics contributed to higher spontaneous vegetal species richness in the plots with C. dactylon, than in
those with I. campestris, as can be seen from results.
Furthermore, C. dactylon, besides being heavy-metal
tolerant and fast-growing in contaminated terrains
(1), is capable of detaining substratum loss and partial fertilization, as was observed here.
The continuation of this work would make
it possible to glean further invaluable information
on the contribution of the vegetal species here used,
when considering further sequential phases in vegetal coverture in association with bushy and arboreal
species. Thus, the dynamics of the recovery process
for degraded areas, applied on an ecological basis
in a region where the original landscape matrix was
Atlantic Forest, would be more comprehensible.
CONCLUSION
On comparing the outcome in plots of C.
dactylon and I. campestris, after 32 months of planting on a bare substratum, it can be concluded that
C. dactylon contributed more to an increase in native spontaneous species diversity and was more involved in the natural succession process, through its
role in facilitating recovery on an ecological basis.
It can also be concluded that, besides substratum chemical indictors revealing a higher contribution for fertilization on the I. campestris plot,
there was no significant difference in surface sediment drainage between the two, a clear indication of
the same capacity for substratum retainance.
89
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 89
09/10/2012 13:44:03
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
RESUMO
A recuperação de uma área degradada deve
aumentar a biodiversidade natural para caracterizarse como restauração em bases ecológicas. Este estudo visou estabelecer experimentos que revelem os
processos de avanço de vegetação espontânea em
áreas degradadas pela exploração do carvão mineral.
Inicialmente foram plantadas espécies para a cobertura primária deste substrato, formado por rejeitos de
carvão, cobertos pelo horizonte B de solos regionais.
A diversidade de espécies vegetais espontâneas foi
monitorada em três levantamentos de abundância e
cobertura, após o plantio das espécies com características de pioneira Cynodon dactylon (L.) Pers. e Indigofera campestris Bong. ex Benth. O experimento
consistiu de uma parcela com 9 sub-parcelas para
cada espécie. De abril de 2009 a fevereiro de 2011,
a cobertura de C. dactylon reduziu-se de cerca de
40% para 5%, facilitando o estabelecimento de um
maior número de espécies espontâneas nesta parcela.
I. campestris cobriu cerca de 80% do solo em cada
levantamento. O índice de Shannon diferiu significativamente entre as parcelas com as duas espécies
(f=0,0141, α=0,05) no período avaliado. Análises de
fertilidade do substrato foram feitas no inicio e no
fim dos experimentos e demonstraram que a fertilidade teve acréscimo de matéria orgânica, e redução
de acidez no final do experimento. Conclui-se que
ambas as espécies retém substrato, mas I. campestris
contribui para uma maior fertilização do substrato
e C. dactylon facilita a sucessão natural e a diversidade, sendo esta adequada à restauração.
Palavras chave: recuperação em bases ecológicas,
recuperação de áreas degradadas, diversidade em
espécies áreas de mineração, carvão.
REFERENCES
1- AZZOLINI, M. Restauração ecológica de áreas
impactadas por cinzas de carvão mineral: contribuição da mamona (Ricinus communis L.) e
respostas da espécie a metais pesados. 2008.
181 f. Tese (Doutorado em Botânica) - Instituto
de Biociências, Universidade Federal do Rio
Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre. 2008. Disponível
em: <http://hdl.handle.net/10183/17470>.
2- BRAUN-BLANQUET, J. Fitosociología. Ma-
drid: H. Blume, 1979. 820 p.
3- CALLAWAY, R. M.; WALKER, L. R. Competition and facilitation: a synthetic approach to interactions in plant communities. Ecology v. 78,
n. 7, p. 1958-1965, 1997.
4- Cqfs - Comissão de Química e Fertilidade do
Solo. Manual de Adubação e de Calagem para os
Estados do Rio Grande do Sul e de Santa Catarina. Porto Alegre: Sociedade Brasileira de Ciência do Solo/Núcleo Regional Sul, 2004. 394p.
5- CONNELL, J. H.; SLATYER, R. O. Mechanisms of sucession in natural communities and
their role in community stability and organization. The American Naturalist v. 111, n. 982,
p.1119-1144, 1977.
6- D’ANTONIO, C.; MEYERSON, L. A. Exotic
plant species as problems and solutions in ecological restoration: a synthesis. Restoration
Ecology v. 10, p. 703-713, 2002.
7- EWEL, J. J.; PUTZ, F. E. A place for alien species
in ecosystem restoration. Frontiers of Ecology
and Environment v. 2, n. 7, p. 354-360, 2004.
8- FORNECK, E. D. Estrutura e dinâmica da expansão florestal em mosaico natural de floresta-savana no morro Santana, Porto Alegre, RS, Brasil.
2007. 85 f. Tese (Doutorado em Ecologia) - Instituto de Biociências, Universidade Federal do Rio
Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre. 2007. Disponível
em: <http://hdl.handle.net/10183/29983>.
9- GUREVITCH, J.; SCHEINER, S. M.; FOX, G.
A. Ecologia Vegetal. Porto Alegre: Artmed, 2ª
ed., 2009. 592 p.
10- HAMMER, Ø.; HARPER, D. A. T.; RYAN,
P. D. 2001. PAST - Palaeontological Statistics.
Disponível em: <http://www.uv.es/~pardomv/
pe/2001_1/past/pastprog/past.pdf>. Acesso em:
20 de abril de 2011.
11- KARDOL, P.; WARDLE, D. A. How understanding aboveground–belowground linkages
can assist restoration ecology. Trends in Ecology
and Evolution v. 25, n. 11, p. 670-679, 2010.
12- PALMER, M. A., FALK, D. A., ZEDLER, J.
B. Ecological theory and restoration ecology.
In: FALK, D. A., PALMER, M. A., ZEDLER, J.
B. (Org.). Foundations of Restoration Ecology.
Washington: Island Press, 2006. p 1-10.
13- PODGAISKI, L. R.; RODRIGUES, G. G. Leaflitter decomposition of pioneer plants and detri-
90
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 90
09/10/2012 13:44:03
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
tivore macrofaunal assemblages on coal ash disposal sites in southern Brazil. European Journal
of Soil Biology, v. 46, p. 394-400, 2010.
14- PORTO, M. L.; AZZOLINI, RODRIGUES, G.
G.; M.; ZOCCHE, J. J.; FOCHT, T.; FLORES,
M. da S.; FRANCISCO, P. B.; MARTINHAGO,
K.; COSTA, K. M.; BEAUVALET, C. S. Uso
de indicadores biológicos para avaliação do
sucesso de restauração ecológica. Disponível
em: <http://www.seb-ecologia.org.br/2009/resumos_ixceb/192.pdf>.
15- REIS, A.; BECHARA, F. C., ESPÍNDOLA, M.
B. de, VIEIRA, N. K., SOUZA, L. L. de. Restauração de áreas degradadas: a nucleação como
base para incrementar os processos sucessionais. Natureza e Conservação v. 1, n. 1, p. 28-36,
2003.
16- ROGALSKI, J. M.; BERKENBROCK, I. S.;
REIS, A.; REIS, M. S. Sucessão e diversidade
como fundamentos básicos na restauração am-
biental. In: SIMPÓSIO NACIONAL E CONGRESSO LATINO-AMERICANO DE RECUPERAÇÃO DE ÁREAS DEGRADADAS, 6.,
Curitiba. Anais..., Curitiba, 2005. p. 433-439.
17- Ser. 2004. Society for Ecological Restoration.
Disponível em <http://www.ser.org/content/ecological_restoration_primer.asp>. Acesso em 30
de setembro de 2011.
18- SHANNON, C. E. A mathematical theory of
communication". Bell System Technical Journal
v. 27, p. 379-423, 1948.
18- TEDESCO, M. J.; VOLKWEISS, S. J.;
BOHNEN, H. Análise de solo, plantas e outros
materiais. Porto Alegre: UFRGS, Faculdade de
Agronomia, Departamento de Solos. Boletim
Técnico, n. 5. 174p, 1995.
19- VÉCRIN, M. P.; MULLER, S. Top-soil translocation as a technique in the re-creation of species-rich meadows. Applied Vegetation Science
v. 6, p. 271-278, 2003.
91
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 91
09/10/2012 13:44:04
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
92
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 92
09/10/2012 13:44:04
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Floration phenology of a Bromeliaceae community of an EPA
in the restinga of Maricá (RJ, Brasil) as compared to other
habitats of the southeastern Brazilian Atlantic Rain Forest
OF AN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AREA (EPA)
Camila V. Suizani¹ (camilavsu@hotmail.com)
Heloísa A. de L. Carvalho¹ (heloisa.alc@gmail.com)
Ana Tereza A. Rodarte¹ (atrodarte@gmail.com)
Cristine Benevides¹ (crisbenevides@yahoo.com.br)
¹Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro/Museu Nacional - Departamento de Botânica,
Lab. De Biologia Reprodutiva de Angiospermas.
ABSTRACT
A study was made of a community of Bromiliaceae in the EPA of a restinga in Maricá,
Rio de Janeiro State, Brazil. The collected data revealed the intensity (2010-2011) and
activity (2004-2011) of flowering phenology. Tests of the correlation between flowering
and environmental factors, such as temperature, rainfall, relative humidity of the air and
insolation, were applied, besides comparisons between these periods of the phenophase
for the same species in other habitats of the Brazilian southern Atlantic Rain Forest.
Aechmea nudicaulis (L.) Griseb., Billbergia amoena (Lodd.) Lindl., Neoregelia cruenta
(Graham) L.B. Sm., Tillandsia gardneri Lindl., Tillandsia stricta Sol. ex Sims. and Vriesea neoglutinosa Mez., presented sequential flowering, with the peaks concentrated in
the restinga rainy season. The abiotic factors tested revealed no statistically significant
correlation with the periods of flowering in the majority of the species, with the exception of T. stricta and B. amoena. In the first, there was a significant positive correlation
with medium and minimum temperatures, and the second, with the relative humidity of
the air. Through bibliographic surveys, thereby comparing other habitats, three of the six
species presented notable variations in the period and duration of flowering. There were
also variations in floral visitor guilds, almost exclusively represented by hummingbirds
in forested areas, but also including insects (bees and butterflies) in the area of the restinga. It was concluded that abiotic and intrinsic factors, such as phylogenetic constraints,
are not the main determinants in the flowering periods of some bromeliads, thereby
presupposing that abiotic factors, such as pollination could be more significant.
Key words: Bromeliaceae, phenology, sequential flowering, restinga, phylogenetic constraints
INTRODUCTION
Even though phenological studies of Bromeliaceae have been included in those involving the
Atlantic Rain Forest (15, 12, 14), caatinga (19), upland
swamps (23), Amazon Forest (17) and rocky ground
(21), these are scarce for the restinga (15, 3, 6).
Humming birds have been shown to be
the main pollen vectors for around 85% of the Bromeliaceae species investigated (24). Many authors
have indicated that sequential flowering is common
among sympatric bromeliads of the same floral syndrome. This could arise from pollinator competitive
activity, as a selective force, thereby giving rise to
93
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 93
09/10/2012 13:44:04
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
divergence in species flowering peaks in the same
locality throughout the evolutive process (3, 12, 14).
It has been said of the family Bromeliaceae, that rainy and dry season periodicity has a
strong influence on the flowering pattern (5), with
peak predominance in the rainy season, as registered in the Atlantic Rain Forest (12, 14) and the
Caatinga (19). However, in upland swampy environments, bromeliad community behavior has
proven to be otherwise, with the peak occurring
predominantly in the dry season (23). Differences
in the beginning and extension of the flowering
period of the same species, although in different
localities, could indicate that environmental factors are more important for phenology in tropical
areas than intrinsic factors, such as phylogenetic
constraint and evolutive history (11, 12).
OBJECTIVES
The aim was to characterize the flowering
phenology of a bromeliad community in the EPA
(Environmental Protection Area) of a restinga in
Maricá, Rio de Janeiro State, Brazil, by investigating the occurrence of species sequential flowering,
as well as the correlation between environmental
factors, such as rainfall, temperature, relative humidity and insolation, with the flowering periods registered. Furthermore, attention was given
to comparing the periods of flowering and floral
visitors of these species in different ecosystems
of the Brazilian southeastern Atlantic Rain Forest,
through the use of the available bibliographic records. The intention was to contribute towards clarifying the question of which factors exert a greater
influence on Bromilaceae phenology, intrinsic, i.e.,
phylogenetic relations or group evolutive history, or
environmental, i.e., rainfall, temperature, photoperiod, relative humidity, pollinator availability and
competitiveness.
METHODOLOGY
The study was carried out in an EPA in
the restinga of Maricá, Rio de Janeiro State (22°52'
to 22°54’S and 42°48' to 42°54’W), along a transect (320m) on an inner sandy cordon, parallel to
the beach, and passing through two vegetal forma-
tions, an open bushy (shrublike) and closed bushy
(22) areas, both not liable to flooding. According to Köeppen (1948) classification, the climate
of the region is Aw tropical rainy, with the rains
concentrated in the summer, and reduced in the
winter. According to data from INMET (National
Institute of Metereology), the average temperature during the year of studies ( from May, 2010 to
April, 2011) was 23,5°C, with a maximum average
of 34,4°C and minimum 16,1°C. The total annual
rainfall was 1.251,6 mm, with 65,6% occurring
from October, 2010 to April, 2011.
Fortnightly one-or-two-day field visits
took place between May, 2010 and April, 2011,
during one year of observation. Considering each
florescence as a single individual, bromeliads in
flower and up to 1 meter on each side of the transect were marked. Records of each of the six bromeliad populations studied were of the absence or
presence of the flowering phenophase (activity –
4). The intensity of the event was estimated by the
number of individuals in flower, taking into consideration the three classes, low, medium and high,
in accordance with the minimum and maximum
number of individuals in flower (9 with modifications). Floral visitors were observed with the naked
eye at various distances from the plant, during 5 to
15 minutes each visit, in sessions between 6 a.m.
and 7 p.m. Visitors were identified only at the genus or family level.
Monthly rainfall (mm), maximum, minimum and average temperatures (ºC), relative humidity of the air (%), and total monthly insolation
(hours) were taken into account, when checking
correlations with the intensity of flowering of each
species. The two latter parameters refer to historic
averages for Maricá between 1986 and 2008 (Station n. 83089). The Spearmen correlation test, considering p<0,01, and with the STATISTICA version
7 program, was applied for testing the correlations
of average temperature and rainfall, taking into account 1 and 2 months prior to the event (7).
Use was made of data collected during the
study, as well as data on flowering phenological
activity in bromeliads collected between 2004 and
2010 by Rodarte (2008 – and unpublished data), in
the same area and for the same species, for testing
flowering period regularity. Bibliographic references
94
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 94
09/10/2012 13:44:04
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
ing the years 2005, 2007 and 2010. In accordance
with the data on flowering intensity, obtained for
the years 2010|2011, although the bromeliads of
the Maricá restinga presented sequential flowering peaks (Table 2), these were concentrated from
the end of the rainy season during transition to the
sub-dry (January to May). During the study period, there was a long period (July to December), in
which Bromeliaceae species intensity and activity
were low, with no register of flowering in October and November, 2010 (Table 2; Figure 1). The
intensity of flowering (Figure 1) presented no significant correlation with the factors total rainfall,
average, minimum and maximum temperature,
relative humidity of the air, and total insolation
for most of the species, except for T. stricta, whose
peak of flowering was positively and significantly
correlated with the average (Spearman coefficient
= 0,76, for p=0,0039) and minimum (Spearman coefficient = 0,74, for p=0,0054) temperatures, and
B. amoena with the relative humidity of the air
(Spearman coefficient = 0,83, for p=0,0008).
containing data on the species in question (15, 12, 14)
were also consulted, in order to compare flowering
periods and bromeliad floral visitors in the restinga
with other habitats in the Atlantic Rain Forest in the
Brazilian southeast. After analyzing the areas of the
reference studies, the following habitats of the Atlantic Rain Forest were considered: 1) granitic outcrops
at sea level, known as rocky shores (15); 2) upland
plains at over 1.400 m, this including two habitats
proposed by Marques and Lemos Filho (2008), viz.,
altitudinal mesic and stoney xeric; 3) forest mesic between 1.200 and 1.300 m; and 4) mixed ombrophilous forest, an ecotonal zone between Araucaria forest and the forest environment itself (12).
RESULTS
The bromeliad community studied included all the species found in the transect, viz.,
Aechmea nudicaulis (n= 260), Billbergia amoena
(n= 20) and Neoregelia cruenta (n= 61), of the subfamily Bromelioideae, and Tillandsia gardneri, T.
Table 1. Records of the flowering phenophase in six bromeliad species of the EPA in the restinga of Maricá,
RJ, during the period January, 2004 to April, 2011.
Espécies
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
J F MA MJ J A S O N D J F MA MJ J A S O N D J F MA MJ J A S O N D J F MA MJ J A S O N D J F MA MJ J A S O N D J F MA MJ J A S O N D J F MA MJ J A S O N D J F MA
A. nudicaulis Espécies
• • • •
• 2004
• ••
B. amoena
• J• F• M A M J J A S
• •
N. cruentaA. nudicaulis• • • •• •• • •
B. amoena
• ••
T. gardneri
• • •
N. cruenta
• • • ••
T. stricta T. gardneri• • •
• • •
V. neoglutinosa
T. stricta • • • • •• •• •• • • • • •
V. neoglutinosa
2007
• • • • • • • 2005 • • • • • • • • •2006
• • • •• • •
• • • • •• • • •
• • • •
• •• •
•• •
• • • •• •• •• • • • • • • • • •• •• • • • • • • • • • • • •
• •• •
•• •
• •
• • •
• • •
• ••
• • •
• •• •
• • •
• •
• •
• • • ••• •• • • • • • • • •• •• •• •• • • • • • • •• •• •• •
• • • • •• •• ••
• 2008
• • •• •
• • •
• •• •• •• • • • • •
• • •
• ••
• •
•• •
•• •
• •
• • • • •2009
• • • • • • • • • • 2010
• • • • • • • 2011
••
• ••
• • •
• •• •• • ••• •• •• • • • • • • • • • • • •• •• • • • • •
• ••
• • •
•
•
• • •
•• •
•
• • •
• •
•• •• • • • •
• •• • • • •
• • •• •
O N D J F MA MJ J A S O N D J F MA MJ J A S O N D J F MA MJ J A S O N D J F MA MJ J A S O N D J F MA MJ J A S O N D J F MA MJ J A S O N D J F MA
• •• • ••• •• •• • • •
• • • •
• •• • •
• • • • •• • • • •• • • • •• • • • •• • • • •• • • • •
• • • •
• • • •
• •• • • • •• •
• • • • •• • •
•• • • •
••
•
• • •
•
•
• ••
• •• • •
• •• • •
Table
Flowering
intensity
five bromeliad
species
EPAofinMaricá,
the restinga
Maricá,
(May,
2010
Table 2.2.Flowering
intensity
in five in
bromeliad
species of the
EPA inof
thethe
restinga
RJ (May,of
2010
to April,RJ
2011)
Intensities
Table 2. Flowering intensity in five bromeliad species of the EPA in the restinga of Maricá, RJ (May, 2010 to April, 2011) Intensities
to
April, 2011)
Intensities - High
Low
Medium
High
- Low
Medium
- Low
Medium
High
MM
JJ
JJ
A
SS
OO
N N
D D J
J F
FM
M
A
A
Vriesea
neoglutinosa
Vriesea
neoglutinosa
Tillandsia
stricta
Tillandsia
stricta
Aechmea nudicaulis
Aechmea nudicaulis
Billbergia amoena
Billbergia amoena
Neoregelia
Neoregelia
Estação subseca
Estação chuvosa
Estação
subseca
Sub-dry
season
Afloramentos
Sub-dry
season
Estação
chuvosa
Rainy
season
Restinga
Campos de
(todas as estações)
(estação quente e chuvosa)
Mésico
Floresta
Rainy season
species studied, there
stricta. (n= 54) and Vriesea neoglutinosa
(n= 25), florestal OmbrófilaInmistathree of the six
Referências
altitude
graníticos
Afloramentos
Floresta
Restinga
Campos de
Mésico
(nível do mar)
(nível doSince
mar)
(altitute
> 1.400m)
(altitude 1.200m)
900m)
was (altitude
appreciable
variation in the
period and duraof the Aechmea
subfamily
Tillandsioideae.
2004,
speReferências
nudicaulis
jan - dez
nov - fev
nov - dez mista
altitude
graníticos
florestal
Ombrófila
tion of flowering, which very often took place in
cies annual flowering
periods
relatively
(nível do mar)
(nívelhave
do mar) been
(altitute
> 1.400m) (altitude 1.200m) (altitude 900m)
ACHADO & SEM IR (2006), M ARQUES & LEM OS FILHO (2007)
Billbergia amoena
abr - jun
mar - mai
abrnov
- mai- dez
Aechmea nudicaulis
jan - dez
nov - fev
different
seasons, Mwhen
compared to occurrence in
regular,
varying(todas
from
short
to
long
(Table
1).
The
as estações)
(estação quente e chuvosa)
(estação quente e chuvosa)
habitats
in the
Atlantic Rain Forest (Table 3).
exception
was T. gardneri,
which presented a su- mar -other
fev - mai
M ACHADO & SEM IR (2006), M ARQUES & LEM OS FILHO (2007)
Billbergia Neoregelia
amoena cruenta abr - jun
mai
abr - mai
(estação fria e seca)
(estação fria e seca)
The rainy
(October to March) and dry (April to Seppra-annual pattern,
through failing to flower dur- (transição)
M ACHADO & SEM IR (2006), M ARQUES & LEM OS FILHO (2007)
(estação quente e chuvosa)
M ACHADO & SEM IR (2006), M ARQUES & LEM OS FILHO (2007)
(estação fria e seca)
(transição)
(estação fria e seca)
* Não foram encontradas referências
(transição)
Tillandsia gardneri
jul - ago
Neoregelia cruenta
fev - mai
fev -(estação
mai fria e seca)
MARQUES & LEM OS FILHO (2007)
* Não foram encontradas referências
(transição)
(transição)
Tillandsia stricta
Tillandsia gardneri
dez - mar
mai - set
ago - set
(estação
jul
- agoquente e chuvosa)
(estação
e seca)
fev - fria
mai
(estação estação fria e seca)
(estação fria e seca)
Vriesea neoglutinosa
Tillandsia stricta
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 95
ago - mar
jan - mar
(transição e estação
(estação quente e chuvosa)
dez -quente
mar e chuvosa)
(estação quente e chuvosa)
M ACHADO & SEM IR (2006), M ARQUES & LEM OS FILHO (2007)
(transição)
95
MARQUES & LEM OS FILHO (2007)
M ARTINELLI (1994)
mai - set
ago - set
(estação fria e seca)
(estação estação fria e seca)
M ACHADO & SEM IR (2006), M ARQUES & LEM OS FILHO (2007)
09/10/2012 13:44:04
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
tember) periods are the same in all the areas stud- ing pattern, by appearing as annual in the uplands
2004 Tillandsia
2005 stricta flowers
2006
2008 in the restinga
2009
ied.Espécies
In the restinga,
be- 2007
and supra-annual
(Table 2010
1 and 2).2011
The
J F MA MJ J A S O N D J F MA MJ J A S O N D J F MA MJ J A S O N D J F MA MJ J A S O N D J F MA MJ J A S O N D J F MA MJ J A S O N D J F MA MJ J A S O N D J F MA
A.
nudicaulis
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
••
tween December and March, hot and rainy months, only species that presented coinciding flowering peB. amoena
•••
••••
••••
•••
•••
•••
•••
•
N. cruenta
whereas
in up-lands
and •mixed
ombrophylous
forriods in •all
Billbergia
•••••
••••
•••
•••
• • the
• • habitats
• • • of
• • occurrence• were
••
•
T. gardneri
•••
••
•
•
ests,
and September,
colder
amoena,
April
T. strictathis occurs
• • • between•May
••
••••
•••
• • •between
•
• • and June in
• • the restinga
• • •and
V. neoglutinosa • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •
•••••••••
••••••••
•••••
••
•••••
months and with less rainfall. Aechmea nudicaulis ombrophyilous forest, and Vriesea neoglutinosa, bealso presents in uplands and mixed ombrophylous tween August and March, in the restinga and rocky
Table 2. flowering
Flowering intensity
five bromeliad
species
of the EPA in the
restinga
of Maricá,
RJ (May,
2010of
to April,
2011) Intensities
forests
periodinfrom
November
to February,
shores
(Table
3). No
records
Neoregelia
cruenta
when
hot and rainyHigh
(Table 3). This period is were encountered in comparative studies.
- Low it is also
Medium
relatively short compared toMthe restinga,
birds
J
JwhereAthe S
O Although
N
Dhumming
J
F (Throchilidae)
M
A
event extends throughout practically the entire year, were observed visiting all the bromeliads that flowVriesea neoglutinosa
with the peak in April and May (Table 2; Figure 1), ered throughout this study, visits by butterflies were
Tillandsia
stricta of transition to the colder and less also recorded (Nymphalidae, Lycaenidae and Pieriwhich
are months
rainy
season.
Apart from differences in the flower- dae) in A. nudicaulis and V. neoglutinosa, as well as
Aechmea
nudicaulis
ing period among the habitats compared (Table 3), bees, viz., Euglossa sp.and Xylocopa sp. in A. nudiBillbergia amoena
T. gardneri also presented differences in the flower- caulis, and Euglossa sp. and Trigona sp. in N. cruenta.
Neoregelia
Table 3: Flowering periods of six bromeliad species in various habitats in the Brazilian southeast Atlantic Rain
Estação subseca
Estação chuvosa
Forest
Sub-dry season
Restinga
(nível do mar)
jan - dez
Aechmea nudicaulis
Campos de
Mésico
Floresta
graníticos
altitude
florestal
Ombrófila mista
Referências
(altitude 900m)
nov - dez
M ACHADO & SEM IR (2006), M ARQUES & LEM OS FILHO (2007)
(nível do mar)
(altitute > 1.400m) (altitude 1.200m)
nov - fev
(todas as estações)
Billbergia amoena
Rainy season
Afloramentos
(estação quente e chuvosa)
(estação quente e chuvosa)
abr - jun
mar - mai
abr - mai
(estação fria e seca)
(transição)
(estação fria e seca)
Neoregelia cruenta
M ACHADO & SEM IR (2006), M ARQUES & LEM OS FILHO (2007)
fev - mai
* Não foram encontradas referências
(transição)
Tillandsia gardneri
jul - ago
fev - mai
(estação fria e seca)
(transição)
Tillandsia stricta
MARQUES & LEM OS FILHO (2007)
dez - mar
mai - set
ago - set
(estação quente e chuvosa)
(estação fria e seca)
(estação estação fria e seca)
Vriesea neoglutinosa
ago - mar
jan - mar
(transição e estação
(estação quente e chuvosa)
M ACHADO & SEM IR (2006), M ARQUES & LEM OS FILHO (2007)
M ARTINELLI (1994)
quente e chuvosa)
Temperatura (ºC)
Temperatura máxima
30
20
10
0
Umidade relativa
do ar (%)
100
80
60
40
20
0
C.
Temperatura mínima
40
B.
96
Temperatura média
100
mai
jun
jul
ago
set
Insolação
out nov dez
jan
Umidade relativa do ar
fev mar abr
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
Insolação (horas/mês)
Precipitação
Precipitação (mm)
A.
Aechmea nudicaulis
50
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 96
0
09/10/2012 13:44:04
Insolação
Umidade relati
do ar (%)
100
C.
Umidade relativa do ar
300
250
200
150
100
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN50
1516-5868
0
lação (horas/mês)
100
80
60
40
20
0
Aechmea nudicaulis
50
0
10
D.
Billbergia amoena
5
0
30
E.
Nº de indivíduos em flor
F.
tillandsia stricta
20
10
0
60
neoregelia cruenta
40
20
0
10
G.
vriesea neoglutinosa
5
H.
0
150
Comunidade
100
50
0
mai
jun
jul
ago
set
DISCUSSION
On comparing various habitats in the Atlantic Rain Forest, all in the southeast of Brazil,
bromeliad species flowering phenology was found
to be considerably variable. Kochmer and Handel
(1986) attribute the regulation of flowering in temperate regions mainly to intrinsic factors, which they
denominate phylogenetic constraints, and affirm that
competition by pollinators would be responsible for
only small and temporary adjustments during flowering periods. From the present study, it was possible
out
nov
dez
jan
fev
mar
abr
to indicate that, in tropical areas, these constraints
are possibly less important in determining phenological patterns than local selective pressure.
In all the bibliographies used for comparative studies (15, 12, 14), the six species studied
presented ornithophylic characteristics, such as exposed inflorescences, with attractive bracts tubular
and inodorous flowers with contrasting colors and
daily anthesis (7), with records of hummingbirds as
their main pollen vectors. Sequential and continuous flowering of species with the same floral syndrome has been pointed out as being an important
97
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 97
09/10/2012 13:44:04
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
strategy in the maintenance of pollinators throughout the year, thereby maximizing the reproduction
of these vegetal species (2, 12, 14). Nonetheless, the
records of bromeliad flowering in the Maricá restinga have shown a period of the year with very low
intensity, or even the total absence of floral activity, with the consequential lack of available nectar
for hummingbirds. Notably, bromeliad species represented around 60% of the ornithophyles within
the study area (18). In other words, they represent
the main resource for these birds. Notwithstanding, there are records of low throchili diversity, with
only Amazilia fimbriata Elliot and Eupetomena
macroura Gmelin as floral visitors in the Maricá
(13) and Jurubatiba (8) restingas. Possibly this diversification in the guild of bromeliad pollinators,
this including insects, in the restinga, may have favored the successful reproducibility of these plants.
In the Marica restinga, by presenting a
high fruit|flower ratio (around 90%), A. nudicaulis
is not self-compatible (Suizani, unpublished data).
In other words, fruit production depends on the
pollinator. This could be the consequence of the
large number of visits by at least four species of
butterflies and two species of bees supplanting the
number of visits by hummingbirds. Schmid et al.
(2011) reported that both bees and hummingbirds
are responsible for the pollination of A. nudicaulis
in an area of the restinga in Santa Catarina State.
Besides hummingbirds, Almeida et al. (2004) also
registered bees as the most frequent visitors (93,3%)
of Tillandsia stricta in the Jurubatiba restinga. Apparently, hummingbirds were the only, or at least
always the most frequent, floral visitors of the species studied in other habitats of the Atlantic Rain
Forest (15, 12, 14). These data presuppose that, in
the restinga environment, the pollination of some
bromeliad species tends to be more generalist. As
the restingas are geologically recent and their fauna mainly composed of species that have migrated
from adjacent, humid forests (3), possibly more generalist pollination systems selectively arose, thus
guaranteeing more successful reproducibility, as it
is improbable that specialized pollinators migrated
together with specific vegetal species (1). Thus, it
is presupposed that pollinator competition was possibly different in the two areas, thereby giving rise
to flowering period variation.
CONCLUSIONS
Divergence in flowering periods between
the areas compared, and the rare cases of significant correlations between flowering and factors,
such as temperature, rainfall, photoperiod and relative humidity of the air in the restinga, indicate that
phylogenetic constraints and abiotic environmental
factors are possibly not the main determinants of
this phenophase in some bromeliad species. This
presupposes that biotic factors, as variations in the
pollinating scenario, could possibly be related to
variations in the distribution and extent of flowering periods in species of this family, whose occurrence includes restinga and forest areas.
RESUMO
O estudo foi feito na APA da restinga de
Maricá, RJ, Brasil, em uma comunidade de Bromeliaceae. Os dados coletados focaram a intensidade
(2010-2011) e atividade (2004-2011) da fenologia
da floração. Foram aplicados testes de correlação
entre floração e os fatores ambientais temperatura,
precipitação, umidade relativa do ar e insolação,
além de comparações entre os períodos dessa fenofase para as mesmas espécies em outros habitats
da Mata Atlântica do sudeste brasileiro. Aechmea
nudicaulis (L.) Griseb., Billbergia amoena (Lodd.)
Lindl., Neoregelia cruenta (Graham) L.B. Sm., Tillandsia gardneri Lindl., Tillandsia stricta Sol. ex
Sims. e Vriesea neoglutinosa Mez. apresentaram
floração sequencial, com picos concentrados na estação chuvosa da restinga. Os fatores abióticos testados não mostraram correlação estatística significativa com os períodos de floração da maioria das
espécies. As exceções foram T. stricta e B. amoena,
onde a primeira apresentou correlação positiva significativa com a temperatura média e mínima, e a
segunda com a umidade relativa do ar. Três das
seis espécies apresentaram variações notáveis no
período e duração da floração quando comparadas
a outros habitats, através dos levantamentos bibliográficos. Também foram observadas variações
na guilda de visitantes florais, quase que exclusivamente representada por beija-flores em áreas de
mata, mas incluindo insetos (abelhas e borboletas)
em área de restinga. Concluímos que fatores abióti-
98
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 98
09/10/2012 13:44:05
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
cos e intrínsecos (como restrições filogenéticas) não
sejam os principais determinantes nos períodos de
floração de algumas bromélias, sugerindo que fatores abióticos como a polinização possam ser mais
significativos.
Palavras chave: Bromeliaceae, fenologia, floração
sequencial, restinga, restrições filogenéticas
REFERENCES
1 -ALMEIDA, E. M.; STORNI, A.; RITTER, P. D.;
ALVES, M. A. S. Floral visitors of Tillandsia
stricta Sol. (Bromeliaceae) at Restinga of Jurubatiba, Macaé, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Vidalia,
Viçosa, v. 2, n. 1, p. 30-35, 2004.
2 -ARAÚJO, A. C.; FISCHER, E. A.; SAZIMA,
M. Floração sequencial e polinização de três espécies de Vriesea (Bromeliaceae) na região de
Juréia, sudeste do Brasil. Revista Brasileira de
Botânica, São Paulo, v. 17, n. 2, p. 113-118, 1994.
3 - ARAÚJO, D. S. D. Análise florística e fitogeográfica das restingas do estado do Rio de
Janeiro. 2000. 176 f. Tese (Doutorado em Ecologia) - Instituto de Biologia, Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro. 2000.
4 -BENCKE, C. S. C.; MORELLATO, L. P. C.
Comparação de dois métodos de avaliação da
fenologia de plantas, sua interpretação e representação. Revista Brasileira de Botânica, São
Paulo, v. 25, n. 3, p. 269-275. 2002.
5 -BENZING, D. H. Bromeliaceae: Profile of an
adaptive radiation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000. 690 p.
6 -BONATO, R. R.; MURANO, N. D. Aspectos
fenológicos e reprodutivos de Vriesea incurvata
Gaudich (Bromeliaceae). Acta Scientiarum Biological Sciences, Maringá, v. 28, n. 2, p. 95-102, 2006.
7 -FAEGRI, K ; PIJL, L. The principles of pollination ecology. New York: Pergamon Press, 1976.
291 p.
8-FONSECA, L. C. N.; ALVES, M. A. S. Assembleia de plantas utilizada por beija-flores (aves:
Trochilidae) em área de restinga aberta de
Clusia no Parque Nacional da Restinga de Jurubatiba, Sudeste do Brasil. In: CONGRESSO
BRASILEIRO DE ECOLOGIA, 8, 2007, Caxambu – MG. Anais... Caxambu: SEB, 2007.
09-FOURNIER, L. A. Un método cuantitativo para
la medición de características fenológicas en árboles. Turrialba, San José, v. 24, p. 422-423, 1974.
10-KÖEPPEN, W. Climatologia: com um estúdio de
los climas de La tierra. México: Fondo de Cultura Econômica, 1948. 479 p.
11-KOCHMER, J. P.; HANDEL, S. N. Constraints
and competition in the evolution of flowering
phenology. Ecological monographs, Wasshington, v. 56, n. 4, p. 303-325, 1986.
12-MACHADO, C. G; SEMIR, J. Fenologia da Floração e biologia floral de bromeliáceas ornitófilas de uma área da Mata Atlântica do Sudeste
brasileiro. Revista Brasileira de Botânica, São
Paulo, v. 29, n. 1, p. 163-174, 2006.
13-MACIEL, N. C. A fauna da restinga do estado
do Rio de Janeiro: passado, presente e futuro.
Proposta de preservação. In: SIMPÓSIO SOBRE RESTINGAS BRASILEIRAS, 1984, Niterói. Anais... Niterói: CEUFF, 1984. p. 285-304.
14-MARQUES, A. R; LEMOS FILHO, J. P. Fenologia reprodutiva de espécies de bromélias na
Serra da Piedade, MG, Brasil. Acta Botanica
Brasilica, São Paulo, v. 22, n. 2, p. 417-424,
2008.
15-MARTINELLI, G. Reproductive biology of
bromeliaceae in the atlantic rainforest of southeastern Brazil. 1994. 197 f. Tese (Doctorate in
Philosophy) - School of Biological and Medical
Sciences, University of St. Andrews, St. Andrews. 1994.
16-MATALLANA, G.; WENDT, T.; ARAÚJO, D.
S. D.; SCARANO, F. R. High abundance of dioecious plants in a tropical coastal vegetation.
American Journal of Botany, Saint Louis, v. 92,
n. 9, p. 1513-1519, 2005.
17-NARA, A. K.; WERBER, A. C.; Biologia floral
e polinização de Aechmea beeriana (Bromeliaceae) em vegetação de baixio na Amazônia
Central. Acta Amazonica, Manaus, v. 32, n. 4, p.
571-588, 2002.
18-ORMOND, W. T.; PINHEIRO, M. C. B.; LIMA,
H. A.; CORREIA, M. C. R.; PIMENTA, M. L.
Estudo das recompensas florais das plantas da
restinga de Maricá- Itaipuaçu, RJ. I- Nectaríferas. Bradea, Rio de Janeiro, v. 6, n. 21, p. 179195, 1993.
19-PEREIRA, F. R. L.; QUIRINO, Z. G. M. Fenologia e biologia floral de Neoglaziovia variegata
99
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 99
09/10/2012 13:44:05
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
(Bromeliaceae) na caatinga da Paraíba. Rodriguesia, Rio de Janeiro, v. 59, n. 4, p. 835-844, 2008.
20-RODARTE, A. T. A. Caracterização espacial,
temporal e biologia floral das espécies de restinga, com ênfase nos recursos florais. 2008.
685 f. Tese (Doutorado em Ciências Biológicas
– Botânica) - Departamento de Botânica, UFRJ/
Museu Nacional, Rio de Janeiro. 2008.
21-SANTANA, C. S.; MACHADO, C. G. Fenologia
de floração e polinização de espécies ornitófilas
de bromeliáceas em uma área de campo rupestre
da Chapada da Diamantina, BA, Brasil. Revista
Brasileira de Botânica, São Paulo, v. 33, n. 3, p.
469-477, 2010.
22-SCHMID, S.; SCHMID, V. S.; ZILLIKENS, A.;
HARTER-MARQUES, B.; STEINER, J. Bimodal pollination system of the bromeliad Aechmea
nudicaulis involving hummingbird and bees.
Plant Biology, Freiburg, v. 13, p. 41-50, 2011.
23-SIQUEIRA FILHO, J. A.; MACHADO, I. C.
Síndrome de polinização de uma comunidade
de Bromeliaceae e biologia floral de Vriesea
psittacina (Hooker) Lindley (Bromeliaceae) em
Brejo dos Cavalos, Caruaru, Pernambuco. Revista Brasileira de Zoologia, Curitiba, v. 24, p.
277-284, 2007.
24-SNOW, D. W.; SNOW, B. K. Feeding ecology of
hummingbirds un the Serra do Mar, southeastern Brazil. El Hornero, Buenos Aires, v. 12, p.
286-450, 1986.
100
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 100
09/10/2012 13:44:05
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Floral Biology and Pollination Ecology of Chrysobalanus
icaco L. (Chrysobalanaceae) in an Environmental Protection
Area (EPA) within the Restinga of Barra do Rio Mamanguape,
Paraíba, Brazil.
Túlio Freitas Filgueira de Sá- Graduado em Ecologia, Laboratório de Ecologia Vegetal
Departamento de Engenharia e Meio Ambiente – Centro de Ciências Aplicadas e Educação
UFPB (email:tulio_filgueira@hotmail.com)
Evelise Locatelli- Laboratório de Ecologia Vegetal, Departamento de Engenharia e Meio Ambiente,
Centro de Ciências Aplicadas e Educação – UFPB. (email: evelise.locatelli@pq.cnpq.br)
ABSTRACT
(Floral Biology and Pollination Ecology of Chrysobalanus icaco (Chrysobalanaceae)
in an Environmental Protection Area (EPA) within the Restinga of Barra do Rio Mamanguape, Paraíba, Brazil). The aim was to investigate floral biology and pollination
ecology of Chrysobalanus icaco (Chrysobalanaceae) in an EPA of Barra do Rio Mamanguape - Rio Tinto (6º 70’72’’S and 34º 90’21’’W). Data was obtained during the period
July 30th, 2009 to September 30th, 2010. 10 individuals, distributed among dunes in the
study area inside the open restinga, were selected. Chrysobalanus icaco presents continuous flowering, daily anthesis, clear-colored flowers, and a small amount of nectar,
viz., 1-5µl with an average concentration of 20 to 55%. The flowers were visited by 11
insect species, belonging to the orders Hymenoptera, Lepdotera and Coleoptera. The
most common visitors were wasps of the family Crabonidae. The bee Apis mellifera
was also another. Although only 3,3% of fruit formation was obtained in spontaneous
self-pollination treatments (n=1.452), the test control (n=1.064) was more successful with
9,5%. As the species is a generalist, hence visited by various groups of insects, it is important as a resource for the local fauna.
Key words: Restinga; Chrysobalanus icaco; pollination.
INTRODUCTION
The Atlantic Rain Forest biome formerly
consisted of an area of 1.306.000 km², or around
15% of what is now known as, Brazilian territory.
After 500 years of continuous exploitation, less than
4% of the original primary forest, plus 4% of secondary forest, still remain. Apart from this widespread devastation, the forest harbors one of the
most important assemblages of plants and animals
worldwide (45, 44).
Ecologically, the restinga is considered a
mosaic of various vegetal formations belonging to
the Atlantic Rain Forest, located on the Brazilian
coastal plateau (35). According to Suguio & Tessler
(1984), the denomination ‘restinga’, as employed in
the Brazilian literature, has several meanings, and
can be used as much for designating various types of
coastal deposits, as well as other coastal, and even
vegetal, features. According to Azevedo (2005), the
adaptability of the species encountered in coastal
ecosystems demonstrates their importance in the
maintenance of dune relief, which is constantly undergoing modifications, mainly wind induced.
The family Chrysobalanaceae, distributed
throughout tropical and subtropical regions, is comprised of 20 genera and 500 species, form shrublike
to arboreal (29). The species Chrysobalanus icaco
101
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 101
09/10/2012 13:44:05
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
L., a shrub, is essential for fixing dunes in areas of
the restinga. In Brazil, this species is also used in
the treatment of diabetes, its hypoglycemic and diuretic effects having been pharmacologically proven (13, 7, 2).
As, to date, there are few studies of floral
biology and pollination ecology of the Chrysobalanaceae family, and with the aim of obtaining additional information, an investigation of these specific
aspects in Chrysobalanus icaco was undertaken, in
an Environmental Protection Area (EPA) in Barra
do Rio Mamanguape, in Rio Tinto county, Paraíba
State, one of the most important conservation units
in the Brazilian northeast.
.
METHODOLOGY
Study area
The study was carried out in the EPA of
Barra do Rio Mamanguape (6º46’55,814” S and
35º03’46,732’’ W), in Rio Tinto county, Paraíba
State. The EPA perimeter is around 80 km, encompassing a total area of 14.460 ha (34). According to
Köppen, the climate of the region is tropical rainy
(Aw), and the average annual temperature varies between 24ºC and 27ºC. The average annual rainfall
along the north Paraiba coast is around 1.500mm,
with the rains concentrated in the trimester April
to June (28).
Sampling planning
Data were obtained during the period July
30th, 2009 to September 30th, 2010, during monthly visits to a natural population of C. icaco. In the
study area, 10 individuals, 5 to 10 meters, apart
were selected. These were distributed in an area of
dunes in an open part of the restinga at about 50
meters from the beach (6º 70’72’'S and 34º 90’21’'W
Datum SAD-69).
The flowers collected from five individuals
were conserved in alcohol 70% for subsequent analysis and morphometry of floral structures (n=20)
through stereomicroscopy. The average number of
flowers per inflorescence was estimated (n=40),
and the number of open flowers in three randomly
chosen individuals counted. Floral anthesis and resources offered to visitors were verified in the field.
For the former, buds in the pre-anthesis stage were
marked for posterior accompaniment until floral se-
nescence. Stygma receptivity was tested in the field
using H2O2, and with the aid of a magnifying glass
(18). Sugar concentration in the nectar was noted
with the aid of a pocket refractometer (0 - 90% Atago®), and the volume measured with micro-syringes
of 5 µl and 10 µl (Microliter®) from buds which had
been previously bagged during pre-anthesis. In order to check the rate of floral nectar production in
six groups of inflorescences, each group containing
four flowers, use was made of cloth-bagged inflorescences, thereby impeding floral-visitor contact.
At 7 a.m., nectar was extracted from the
first group, at 9:00 a.m., from the second, and so
on, the final extraction from the sixth group beginning at 5:00 p.m. The pollen grains from each anther
were colored with safranine and counted directly
(14) with the aid of a squared laminator and stereomicroscope (16x magnification). Pollinic viability
was estimated using acetic carmine 2% (33). Ten
buds in the pre-anthesis stage from three specimens
were used throughout the whole process. The ovary
wall was cut open to facilitate ovule counting.
For obtaining phenological data, ten individuals were observed by monthly accompaniment
over the period July, 2009 to Sepetember, 2010,
whereby data referring to flowering and fruition
were collected (17). The flowering pattern was classified according to Newstrom et al. (1994). Normality testing of data was through Shapiro – wilk, followed by Pearson linear correlation testing of the
relationship of the flowering and fruition phenophases with precipitation.
During the study period, 85 hours of observation, distributed throughout seven consecutive
days from 5:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., were exclusively
dedicated to recording and observing visitors, as
to visiting time, frequency and duration, and their
behavior towards the flowers. During this period,
visitors were classified as rare (0 to 5% of the visits),
common (6 to 15% of the visits), and very common
(16 to 45% of the visits), as well as effective pollinator (eP) – all those that contacted the stigmatic area
and the anthers -, and occasional pollinators (oP) –
stigmas and anthers only rarely or not contacted - .
The spot of pollen placement on the visitor’s body
was analyzed according to visiting behavior. Some
visitors from each visiting species were collected
and dry-mounted for structure analysis and identifi-
102
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 102
09/10/2012 13:44:05
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
cation, prior to depositing in the Laboratory of Vegetal Ecology – LABEV – of the Federal University
of Paraíba, campus IV.
For defining reproductive strategy,
C.icaco flowers were subjected to experiments involving manual self-pollination, spontaneous pollination, xenogamy, natural pollination and apomixis. Buds, previously randomly selected among
the ten individuals under study, were marked with
a colored tape, to be so identified as test controls.
The exsiccates produced from sample specimens
were deposited in the Laboratory of Vegetal Ecology – LABEV – of the Federal University of Paraíba, campus IV.
RESULTS
Chrysobalanus icaco is a shrublike species, from 1,5 to 3 meters high, and generally placed
2 to 10 meters apart, one from the other.
Flowering occurs throughout the year (27),
the peak of highest concentration of inflorescences
and flowers per individual occurring in the dry season, from September to December, with little rain
(66 mm), and an average temperature of 27°C (Figure 1). Generally speaking, when compared to other
species, C. icaco flowering and fruition is extremely
irregular, with the regular occurrence of individuals
presenting all the different stages at the same time,
thereby generating mutual asynchronism. Whereas
some individuals presented flowers, others, which
had already ceased to flower, had reached the fruit
maturation stage, and some even presented overlapping cycles of flowering-production of fruits-seeds
in one and the same plant.
Rainfall
Flowering
Fruition
Time of extraction of nectar
Group
07:00
09:00
11:00
13:00
15:00
17:00
µl
5,1 ± 5,0
1,5 ± 1,2
2,3 ± 2,2
%
42
1
2,5± 2,0 1,5
± 1,3 1,0 ± 0,7
1,5 ± 1,0
1,0 ±0,7 0,7
±0,5 fruition
Figure
1.µlFournier
Intensity
of the
flowering
and
%
15
15
32
35
42
55
phenophases,
as well
as precipitation, of the ten Chryso2
µl
4,0 ± 3,9 1,3 ± 1,2 1,4 ± 1,2 0,9 ± 0,8 0,7 ± 0,6
32
42
34
55
55
balanus %icaco individuals
during
the period
July,
2009 to
3
µl
4,5 ± 4,2 1,9 ± 1,6 1,3 ± 1,2 1,3 ± 1,1
September,
2010.
%
42
42
55
55
4
5
6
42
55
µl
4,7 ± 4,4
3,3 ± 3,4
%
42
5,4 ± 5,2
%
55
Revista
SEB Ano 14 Final.indd
103
Order|Family
Genus|species
Frequency
Behavior
103
55
µl
The production and development of C. icaco
fruits occurs throughout the year with a peak of release from December to February (Figure 1). As regards size, this attained around 7 mm (N=50) in a
fortnight, thereon varying between 12,8 and 19,6 mm
(DP 2,13, N=44), until reaching maturation, ready for
dispersion, at the end of 45 days, with sizes varying
between 26,8 and 29,3 mm (DP 1,33, N=20).
Data on flowering (p= 0.1026), fruition
(p=0.6722) and precipitation (p=0.41497) were considered normal. There was a significant negative
correlation between flowering and precipitation (r
=-2.1611, p < 0,005), contrary to fruition and precipitation where the correlation was significantly
positive (r = 1.4265, p > 0,005).
C. icaco inflorescences are terminal cymoid. The number of flowers that open every day,
per inflorescence, varied between five and eight (DP
1,41, N=40), there being a certain variation in the
number among individuals. The 7 to 11 mm long (DP
1,4 – N=20) flowers are hermaphroditic and urceolate, whose floral parts are arranged in whorls (cyclic). The 10 mm-long gynoecium, which possesses a
pilose semi-detached ovarium and is unilocular, uniovular and stileto-like, positions the stygma over and
opposed to the stamina. The androecium, formed by
22 four-to-six mm long (DP 1,2, N=20), polystem,
heterodynamic and external stamina, possesses
yellow-colored anthers and a longitudinal opening.
The fruit is berrylike, 5 cm in diameter and red and
orange colored with a soft white pulp.
Anthesis lasts three days. On the first day,
the flowers are light colored and attractive. On the
second and during the morning, the petals, which
have acquired an orange tone, drop off. The opening of the buds is asynchronous, the production of
nectar initiating even before the petals are fully
open. Some flowers already begin to open at around
8:00 a.m. Protogyny occurs in the first two hours
of opening, and when the flower is in the feminine
phase. Spontaneous opening of the anthers begins
gradually and asynchronously from 10 o’clock on,
thereby initiating the bisexual phase of the flower.
At both instants, the petals are attractive and there
is the production of nectar, with average viability
reaching 95% (+ 2,0).
C. icaco flowers begin to produce nectar
at 7:00 a.m., with an average volume of 2,5± 2,0 µl
Substance
09/10/2012 13:44:06
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
per flower. In other words, even before the flower
is totally open, production has already begun, only
dropping off at the end of the afternoon. However,
although the production of nectar takes place in the
first ten hours of anthesis, there is only an increase
in the concentration of sugar towards the end of
the afternoon.
The small amount of nectar produced (1-5
ml) is stored on the nectariferous disc at the filament insertion, and is limited to the first day of
anthesis. In the present case, nectar sugar concentration was 15-55%. The production of nectar of
the last group of flowers tested reached 5,4 ± 5,2
ml, 55% of the total volume of nectar accumulated
(Table 1). The extraction of nectar did not affect
its production. With a constant daily production of
nectar for visitors, the number of these per flower
was naturally higher. Keeping in mind that the
plant is a generalist, the production of nectar was
consequentially higher.
The average production of nectar was
around 1,0 ± 1,5 ml. For extraction at the six times
indicated, there must have been re-absorption, notable through the similar quantities of nectar momentarily available. The first group began with a
concentration of 15%, this reaching 55% towards
the end. In the second group, this began with 32%,
had already reached 42% until 11: a.m., and gradually dropped until 1:00 p.m. Oscillations in production possibly occurred throughout.
The C. icaco flowers were visited by 11 insect species belonging to the orders Hymenoptera
(8), Lepidoptera (2) and Coleoptera (1). The visitors, their behavior and the resource sought appear
in Table 2. The first visits began at 7:00 a.m., even
before the flowers were completely open. The most
common visitor was a species of wasp of the family Crabronidae. When on the flowers, these wasps
were shown to be extremely territorial. After initially flying over the plant, they then alighted on
a flower, even when not completely open, whereupon they introduced the buccal apparatus to suck
out nectar. On passing through the inflorescences,
the ventral part of the abdomen entered in contact
with the anthers and stigma. Although the visit to
each flower lasted around 2-3 seconds, permanence
among the inflorescences themselves depended on
the number of open flowers. The wasps of this family can be considered as the effective pollinators,
since, through seasonal independence, their behavior and frequency was stable throughout the year.
Bees of the species Apis mellifera L. entered in contact with the reproductive structures
when collecting nectar. During the rainy season,
their visiting peak was between 10:00 and 11:00
a.m. in the morning, and 2:00 to 3:00 p.m. in the
afternoon. The duration of each visit was extremely
variable, extending to 9 seconds per flower, during which there were short and continuous flights
among the inflorescences.
.
Table 1. Volume and concentration of nectar in Chrysobalanus icaco, measured by
group of flowers subjected to extraction.
Time of extraction of nectar
Group
1
2
3
4
5
6
07:00
09:00
11:00
13:00
15:00
17:00
µl
2,5± 2,0
1,5 ± 1,3
1,0 ± 0,7
1,5 ± 1,0
1,0 ±0,7
0,7 ±0,5
%
15
15
32
35
42
55
µl
4,0 ± 3,9
1,3 ± 1,2
1,4 ± 1,2
0,9 ± 0,8
0,7 ± 0,6
%
32
42
34
55
55
µl
4,5 ± 4,2
1,9 ± 1,6
1,3 ± 1,2
1,3 ± 1,1
%
42
42
55
55
µl
5,1 ± 5,0
1,5 ± 1,2
2,3 ± 2,2
%
42
42
55
µl
4,7 ± 4,4
3,3 ± 3,4
%
42
55
µl
5,4 ± 5,2
%
55
104
Order|Family
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 104
Genus|species
Frequency
Behavior
09/10/2012
Substance
13:44:07
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Bees of the species Trigona spinipes Fabri- of sexual system among the angiosperms (31).
The concentration of sugar in nectar is also
cius were often observed collecting nectar. In this
case, the bee perforated the chalice, thereby harm- associated with the type of floral visitor (6, 15, 31).
Time of extraction of nectar
ing the flower, since some lepidoptera, which before Flowers visited by bees and wasps present a high conGroup
07:00
09:00
11:00
13:00
15:00
17:00
collected legitimately, began to introduce their ap- centration (13-50%), which was the case of C. icaco in
1
µl
2,5± 2,0 1,5 ± 1,3 1,0 ± 0,7 1,5 ± 1,0 1,0 ±0,7 0,7 ±0,5
the present study, with an even higher concentration
paratus through the hole thus made.
%
15
15
32
35
42
55
(55%)
than
the
interval
established
by Baker (1975).
In the reproductive
experiments
(Table
2
µl
4,0 ± 3,9 1,3 ± 1,2 1,4 ± 1,2 0,9 ± 0,8 0,7 ± 0,6
C.
icaco
visitors
used
nectar
as the main
3), it could be observed that,
whereas
spontaneous
%
32
42
34
55
55
due
to its high conself-pollination treatment
3
µlwas successful in 3,3% 4,5foraging
± 4,2 1,9resource,
± 1,6 1,3possibly
± 1,2 1,3
± 1,1
centration.
Besides
being
the
most
important floof the cases, in the test control
this
reached
9,5%.
%
42
42
55
55
ral reward
pollen
Although the fecundation
4
µlobtained by self-pollina5,1 ±offered
5,0 1,5to
± 1,2
2,3 biotic
± 2,2 vectors (23),
metabolized
by
tion indicated species compatibility,
this was inex- nectar is easily
%
42
42
55all classes of flo4,7 ±requiring
4,4 3,3 ±high
3,4 energetic expressive, due to the5 smallµlnumber of fruits formed ral visitors, without
%
plant for 55
its production (38).
(3,3%). Low fruit productivity
was characterized penditure from the 42
6
µl
5,4
± 5,2could be related
The reduced production of nectar
through reproductive testing.
%
55
Table 2. Visitors to Chrysobalanus icaco flowers. Ep – Effective pollinator, Op – Occasional pollinator,
N – Nectar; P – Pollen. R = rare (till 5% of the visits); C = common (6% to 15% of the visits) and VC = very
common (16% to 45% of the visits).
Order|Family
Genus|species
Hymenoptera/Crabronidae
Hymenoptera/Apidae
Hymenoptera/Apidae
Hymenoptera/Apidae
Hymenoptera/Vespidae
Hymenoptera
Hymenoptera
Hymenoptera/Apidae
Coleoptera/Coccinellidae
Lepidóptera 1
Lepidóptera 2
Morfoespécie I
Centris nitens Lepeletier, 1841
Apis mellifera Linnaeus, 1758
Xylocopa frontalis Olivier, 1789
Polistes canadensis Linnaeus, 1758
Pepsis sp.
Vespa sp.
Trigona spinipes Fabricius, 1793
Não identificado
Não identificada
Não identificada
Frequency
of visits
VC
C
VC
R
R
C
C
VC
R
R
R
Behavior
Ep
Op
Op
Op
Op
Ep
Op
Op
Op
Op
Op
Substance
collected
N
N/P
N/P
N/P
N
N/P
N
N/P
N
N
N
Table 3. Formation of fruits from controlled pollination.
Treatment
Control
Spontaneous autogamy
Manual autogamy
Xenogamy
Apomixis
Total
N. of flowers
N. of Fruits
Success (%)
Tested
1064
1452
43
36
25
2620
Obtained
101
47
0
0
0
148
9,5
3,3
0
0
0
5,9
DISCUSSION
The floral attributes presented by Chrysobalanus icaco, such as diurnal anthesis, a short
corola, light color, low production of nectar (2,5±
2,0 µl), several flowers per inflorescence and sweet
odor, are all associated to the syndrome of entomophily (15). Morphological analysis of the flowers
indicated hermaphroditism, the most common type
to a species strategy, thereby forcing visitors to
carry out the search among several flowers to
satisfy their wants, with the consequential cross
pollination (26,37). The association of low production with high concentration is essential for a
plant to benefit by pollination. Whereas the high
concentration of nectar sugar serves in attracting
pollinators, its constant availability throughout
the day maintains their presence.
105
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 105
09/10/2012 13:44:07
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Various patterns of nectar secretion during anthesis can occur in vegetal species; on the
one side, only one secretion occurs throughout
the entire anthesis, whereas on the other, secretion can continue after each removal by a visitor, with the consequential replacement of volume
(19). This is what occurred with C. icaco, whose
continuous secretion guarantees a constant flow
and larger number of visitors per flower, also the
case of Couepia uiti (Chrysobalanaceae), as noted
by Paulino Neto (2007).
The concentration of nectar in C. icaco
flowers is high and similar to that of other generalist
entomophylous plant-species (8, 24, 29, 35), which
makes this resource a very attractive energy source
for visitors. According to Baker (1975), flowers visited by wasps and bees present high nectar sugar
concentration (16-50%). Furthermore, the increase
in this concentration could be related to changes in
temperature and relative humidity (12). Although
the volume of nectar produced per flower in C. icaco is low, this is compensated by the high concentration of sugar, which, in this case, reached its peak
at the end of the afternoon.
C. icaco presents generalist entomophylous
pollination. The most frequent visitors were wasps
of the family Crabronidae and bees of the species
Apis mellifera and Centris nitens. Flowers adapted
to pollination by bees and wasps are denominated
entomophylous (15, 9, 31).
Wasps of the family Crabronidae, even
though less frequent, are considered legitimate visitors, by their constant pollination throughout the
year, independent of the season, thus different from
the bees Apis mellifera and Centris nitens, which
are seasonal. According to Proctor et al. (1996) and
Heithaus (1979), flowers pollinated by wasps are
open, small and opaque-colored, with a shallow
corola, hence facilitating access to the nectarines,
whereas in flowers where corollas are deep and narrow, access is restricted (1). To date, there are no
studies or citations of floral visits by species of the
family Crabronidae.
Wasps are cited as effective pollinators in
various studies (32, 46, 25, 22, 1).
Flowering in C. icaco is continuous and
abundant, thus offering a high availability of resources for the anthophilous fauna of the area. Plants
with massive flowering, the case of C. icaco, attract
opportunist visitors, capable of quickly responding
to the ephemeral availability of resources (20, 11,
10). Furthermore, according to Augspurger (1980
and 1981), abundant flowering not only attracts a
large number of floral visitors, but also increases
the rate of visits and transportation of pollen among
plants, thus elevating pollination levels.
Chrysobalanus icaco is characterized
by low fruit production (Fruits|Flowers=9,5%
reproductive success). A certain amount of the
formed fruits drop off while still in the green
stage, without reaching maturity, when the fruit
is purple-reddish. As expressed by the average
Fruit|Flower proportion of 42,1% (42), hermaphrodite plants produce an excess of flowers which
do not reach the fruit stage. Hypotheses have been
presented, in the attempt to clarify this pattern of
low fruit production, among which, limitation in
the amount of pollen, number of pollinators, or
amount of maternal nutrients, or even selective
abortion, are outstanding (40, 41). In the species
under study, there appears to be no limitation in
the amount of pollen or pollinators, since the occurrence of flower visits is intense. Furthermore,
the gradual release of pollen grains favors their
availability throughout anthesis.
The reproductive success of spontaneous
self-pollination (3,3%) was less than that under natural conditions (9,5%), or rather, even though selffecundatory, cross pollination in C. icaco places
in evidence the extreme importance of pollinating
agents for the species and its genic flow. In species
of the family Chrysobalanaceae, such as Couepia
uiti (30) and Couepia bracteosa, self-incompatibility was evident (16). Work on the reproductive
system of this family is, as yet, scarce, whereby the
urgent necessity for further pertinent studies.
As regards the pollen|ovulum rate, the
more efficient the transference of pollen, the lower
is the rate (14). In C. icaco, xenogamy is obligatory,
thus the pollen|ovulum rate is very high. Hence, on
analyzing self-pollination test data, the extremely
high dependency on pollinators for accomplishing
reproductive efficiency becomes evident.
Continuous flowering in C. icaco, added to
its floral characteristics, makes this a key species, due
to its ecological role as a source of trophic resources
106
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 106
09/10/2012 13:44:07
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
throughout the year, both for its own pollinators, as
well as other insect species, which, in turn, act in pollinating numerous other plants in the ecosystem.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Thanks are extended to Dr. Celso Feitosa
for the identification of the wasps and bees (UFPB);
to MSc. Maria do Céo R. Pessoa (UFPB) for identification of the vegetal species studied; to the Instituto Chico Mendes de Conservação da Biodiversidade – ICMBio, and to CNPq for the Scientific
Initiation grant for the first author, and for the grant
Productivity in Research for the second.
RESUMO
(Biologia Floral e Ecologia da Polinização de Chrysobalanus icaco (Chrysobalanaceae)
em uma área de Restinga na Área de Proteção
Ambiental (APA) da Barra do Rio Mamanguape,
Paraíba, Brasil). O presente estudo teve como
objetivo investigar a biologia floral e ecologia da
polinização de Chrysobalanus icaco (Chrysobalanaceae) na APA da Barra do Rio Mamanguape Rio Tinto (6º 70’72’'S e 34º 90’21’'W). Os dados
foram obtidos no período de 30 de julho de 2009 a
30 de setembro de 2010. Na área de estudo foram
selecionados 10 indivíduos distribuídos em área de
duna na formação aberta de restinga. Chrysobalanus icaco apresenta uma floração contínua, antese
diurna, flores claras e uma pequena quantidade de
néctar, 1-5ml com concentração média 20 a 55 %.
As flores foram visitadas por 11 espécies de insetos pertencentes às ordens Hymenóptera, Lepdóptera e Coleoptera. Os visitantes mais comuns
foram vespas da família Crabronidae e a abelha
Apis mellifera. Nos tratamento de autopolinização
espontânea (n=1452) obteve-se 3,3% de formação
de frutos, mas no teste controle (n=1064) obteve-se
um maior sucesso com 9,5%. Por ser uma espécie
visitada por vários grupos de insetos, possuindo,
portanto, um sistema de polinização generalista, a
espécie é importante como fonte de recursos para
fauna local.
Palavras chave: Restinga; Chrysobalanus icaco;
polinização.
REFERENCES
1- AGUIAR, C. M. L.; SANTOS G. M. M. Compartilhamento de recursos florais por vespas sociais
(Hymenoptera:Vespidae) e abelhas (Hymenoptera: Apoidea) em uma área de Caatinga. Neotropica Entomology, v. 36, p. 836–842, 2007.
2- AGRA, M. F.; FRANÇA, P. F.; BARBOSAFILHO, J. M. Synopsis of the plants known as
medicinal and poisonous in Northeast of Brazil.
Revista Brasileira de Farmacognosia, v. 17, p.
114- 140, 2007
3- AUGSPURGER, C. K. Mass-flowering of a tropical shrub (Hybanthus prunifolius): influence of
pollination attraction and movement. Evolution,
v. 34, p. 475-488, 1980.
4- AUGSPURGER, C. K. Reproductive synchrony
of a tropical plant: experimental effects of pollinators and seed predators on Hybanthus prunifolius (Violaceae). Ecology, v. 62, p. 775-788,
1981.
5- AZEVEDO, D. V. Propostas de Manejo para a
APA das Dunas de Lagoinha-Paraipaba- Ceará.
2005. 124 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Desenvolvimento e Meio Ambiente). Prodema- Programa Regional de Pós-Graduação em Desenvolvimento e Meio Ambiente, Pró-Reitoria de
Pesquisa e Pós-Graduação, Universidade Federal do Ceará, Ceará, 2005.
6- BAKER, H. G. Sugar concentrations in nectar
fromhummingbird flowers. Biotropica, v. 7, p.
37-41, 1975.
7- BARBOSA-FILHO, J. M. et al. Plants and their
active constituents from South, Central, and
North America with hypoglycemic activity. Revista Brasileira de Farmacognosia, v. 15, p. 392413, 2005.
8- BARBOSA, A. A. A.; SAZIMA, M. Biologia
reprodutiva de plantas herbáceo-arbustivas de
uma área de Campo Sujo de Cerrado. In: SANO,
S. M; ALMEIDA, S. P.; RIBEIRO, J. F (Ed.).
Cerrado: Ecologia e Flora. Brasília: Embrapa
Cerrados, 2007. p. 291-307.
9- BARTH, F. G. Insects and flowers – The biology
of a partnership. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1991. 408 p.
10- BARRET, S. C. H. & SHORE, J. S. Dimorphic incompatibility in Turnera hermannioides
107
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 107
09/10/2012 13:44:07
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Camb. (Turneraceae). Annals of the Missouri
Botanical Garden, 72:259-263, 1985.
11- BAWA, K. S. Evolution of dioecy in flowering
plants. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, v. 11, p. 15-39, 1980.
12- CORBET, S. A. et al. Post-secretory determinants of sugar concentration in nectar. Plant Cell
Environ, v. 2, p. 293-308, 1979.
13- COSTA, O. A. Brazilian plants with hypoglycaemic effects. Leandra, v. 7, p. 63-75, 1977.
14- CRUDEN, R. W. Temporal dioecism; systematic breadth, associated traits, and temporal patters. Botanical Gazzete, v.149, p. 1-15, 1977.
15- FAEGRI, K.; VAN DER PIJL, L. The principles
of pollination ecology. London: PergamoPress,
1979. 244 p.
16- FALCÃO, M. A.; LLERAS, E.; KERR, W. E.
Aspectos fenológicos, ecológicos e de produtividade do pajurá (couepia bracteosa Benth.). Acta
Amazonica, 11(3): 473-482, 1981.
17- FOURNIER, L. A. Un método cuantitativo para
la medición de características fenológicas en arbores. Turrialba, vol. 4, p. 22-423. 1974.
18- GALEN, C.; PLOWRIGH, R. C. Testing the
accuracy of using peroxidase actity to indicate
stigma receptive. Canadian Journal of Botany, v.
65, p. 11-107, 1987.
19- GALETTO, L.; BERNARDELLO, G. Rewards
in flowers. Nectar. In: DAFNI, A.; KEVAN, P.
G.; HUSBAND, B. C. (Eds.). Practical Pollination Biology. Ontario: Cambridge, 2005. p. 261312.
20- GENTRY, H. A. Flowering phenology and diversity in tropical Bignoniaceae. Biotropica, 6:
p. 64-68, 1974.
21- HEITHAUS, E. R. Flower visitation records and
resource overlap of bees and wasps in northest
Costa Rica. Brenesia, v. 16, p. 9-52, 1979.
22- HERMES, M. G.; KÖHLER, A. The flowervisiting social wasps (Hymenptera, Vespidae,
Polistinae) in two areas of Rio Grande do Sul
State, southern Brazil. Revista Brasileira de Entomologia, v. 50, n. 2, p. 268-274, 2006.
23- KEVAN P.G.; BAKER H. G. Insects as flower
visitors and pollinators. Annual Review of Entomology, v. 28, p. 407-453, 1983.
24- MACHADO, A. O.; OLIVEIRA, P. E. Biologia
floral de Casearia grandiflora Camb. (Flacour-
tiaceae). Revista Brasileira de Botânica, v. 23, p.
283-290, 2000.
25- MECCHI, M. R. Comunidade de vespas Aculeata
(Hymenoptera) e suas fontes florais. In: PIVELLO, V. R.; VARANDA, E. M. (Eds.), O cerrado
Pé-de-Gigante: ecología e consevação, Parque Estadual de Vassununga. 2005. p. 255-266.
26- NAVARRO, L. Pollination ecology and effect of
nectar removal in Macleania bullata (Ericaceae).
Biotropica, v. 4, p. 618-625, 1999.
27- NEWSTROM, L. E., FRANKIE, GW. ; BAKER, H. G. A new classification for plant phenology based on flowering patterns in lowland
tropical rain forest trees at La Selva, Costa Rica.
Biotropica vol. 26, p.141-159, 1994.
28 - NIMER, E. Climatologia do Brasil. 2.ed. IBGE,
Departamento de Recursos Naturais e Estudos
Ambientais. Rio de Janeiro, p.422, 1989.
29- OLIVEIRA, P. E.; GIBBS, P. E. Reproductive
biology of woody plants in a cerrado community
of Central Brazil. Flora, v. 195, p. 311-329, 2000.
30- PAULINO-NETO H. F. Pollination and the
breeding system of Couepia uiti (Mart and
Zucc) Benth. (Chrysobalanaceae) in the Pantanal da Nhecolândia. Braz. J. Bot., v. 67, p.715719, 2007.
31- PROCTOR, M.; YEO, P.; LACK, A. The Natural History of Pollination. Portland: Timber
Press, 1996. 479 p.
32- QUIRINO, Z. G. M.; MACHADO, I. C. Biologia da Polinização e da Reprodução de três
Espécies de Combretum Loefl. (Combretaceae).
Revista Brasileira de Botânica, v 24, n2, 181193, 2001.
33- RADFORD, A. E. et al.; Vascular Plant Systematics. New York: Harper & Row Publishers,
1974. 891 p.
34- RODRIGUES, I. A.; ANTUNES, L. R.; RODOVALHO, R. B. Perfis social, econômico
e ecológico da área de influência da APA da
Barra do Rio Mamanguape (PB): bases para a
classificação e seleção de estabelecimentos rurais para gestão ambiental. In: RODRIGUES, G.
S.; BUSCHINELLI, C. C. de A.; RODRIGUES,
I. A.; MARCON NEVES, M. C. (Ed.). Avaliação de impactos ambientais para gestão da APA
da Barra do Rio Mamanguape/PB. Jaguariúna:
Embrapa Meio Ambiente, 2005. p. 39-73.
108
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 108
09/10/2012 13:44:07
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
35- SANTOS, M. J. L. & MACHADO, I. C. Biologia floral e heterostilia em Vismia guianensis
(Aubl.) Choisy (Clusiaceae). Acta Botânica Brasílica 12 (suplemento):451-464, 1998.
36- SCARANO, F. R. Structure, function and florístic relationships of plant communities in
stressful habitats marginal to the Brazilian Atlantic Rainforest. Annals of Botany, v. 90, p.
517-524, 2002.
37- SIGRIST, M. R.; SAZIMA, M. Ruellia brevifolia
(Pohl) Ezcurra (Acanthaceae): fenologia da floração, biologia da polinização e reprodução. Revista Brasileira de Botânica, v. 25, p.35-42, 2002.
38- SIMPSON, B. B.; NEFF, J. L. Floral rewards:
alternatives to pollen and nectar. Annual Missouri Botanical Garden, 68: 301-322, 1983.
39- SOUZA, V. C.; LORENZI, H. Botânica
Sistemática: Guia ilustrado para identificação
das famílias de angiospermas da flora brasileira, baseado em APG II. Ed Instituto Platarum,
Nova Odessa, p.639, 2005
40- STEPHENSON, A. G. Flower and fruit abortion: proximate causes and ultimate functions.
Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, v.
12, p. 253-279, 1981.
41- SUTHERLAND, S. Why hermaphroditic plants
produc many more flowers than fruits: experimental testes with Agave mckelveyana. Evolution, v. 4, n. 4, p. 750-759, 1987.
42- SUTHERLAND, S.; DELPH, L. F. On the importance of male fitness in plants; patterns of
fruit-set. Ecology, v. 65, n. 4, p. 1093-1104, 1984.
43- SUGUIO, K.; TESSLER, M. G. Planícies de
cordões litorâneos quaternários do Brasil: Origem e nomenclatura. In: LACERDA, L. D.;
ARAÚJO, D. S. D.; CERQUEIRA, R.; TURQ,
B. Restingas: Origem, estrutura e processos. Niterói: CEUFF, 1984. p. 15-26.
44- TABARELLI, M., L. P. Pinto, J. M. C. Silva &
C. M. R. Costa. The Atlantic Forest of Brazil:
endangered species and conservation planning.
In: C. Galindo-Leal & I.G. Câmara (eds.). The
Atlantic Forest of South America: biodiversity
status, trends, and outlook. Center for Applied
Biodiversity Science e Island Press, Washington, D.C, p.86-94, 2003.
45- TERBORGH, J. Maintenance of biodiversity in
tropical forests. Biotropica, v. 24, p. 283-292, 1992.
46- VITALI-VEIGA, M. J.; & MACHADO, V. L. L.
Entomofauna Visitante de Gleiditsia triacanthos
L. – Leguminosae durante o seu período de floração. Revista Bioikos, v.15, n.1, p. 29-38, 2001.
109
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 109
09/10/2012 13:44:07
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
110
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 110
09/10/2012 13:44:07
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Analysis of the landscape structure of the Coqueiral Environmental Protected Area, Coqueiral, MG
Carolina Gusmão Souza - Universidade Federal de Lavras, Departamento de Ciências Florestais
(email: carolinagusmaosouza@gmail.com)
Rosângela Alves Tristão Borém - Universidade Federal de Lavras, Departamento de Biologia
(email: tristao@dbi.ufla.br)
Lisiane Zanella - Universidade Federal de Lavras, Departamento de Biologia
(email: lisianezanella@gmail.com)
Luis Marcelo Tavares de Carvalho - Universidade Federal de Lavras, Departamento de Ciências Florestais
(email: passarinho@dcf.ufla.br)
Rafaela Vidal Ambrosio - Universidade Federal de Lavras, Departamento de Biologia
(email: rafavidalambrosio@yahoo.com.br).
ABSTRACT
This study analyzed the landscape structure of the Coqueiral Protected Area, located in
southern Minas Gerais. We aimed to evaluate the landscape structure in the study area,
based on landscape metrics and indicate priority areas for conservation. We use Geographic Information Systems and Remote Sensing tools to construct a land use map from a
HCR SPOT 5 satellite image. Landscape structure analysis was carried out through Fragstats software and used landscape metrics. Results showed pasture class was considered as
the landscape matrix and occupied almost half of the protected area. Landscape structure
analysis showed the landscape is dominated by agropastoral activities. The landscape presented 704 units. Mean patch size area was higher for pasture than semideciduous forest, while semideciduous forest presented higher patch density. Land use classes showed
complex shapes indicating higher edge effects. Pasture had the lower patch isolation. Data
obtained in this study are relevant for decision making and environmental planning of the
Coqueiral Protected Area, allowing suggest priority areas for conservation.
Keywords: Landscape ecology, Landscape metrics, Geographic Information Systems.
INTRODUCTION
Over the past years, there have been profound technological, social, economic, and mainly,
environmental modifications worldwide. Man-made
modifications in the landscape have given rise to
intense habitat fragmentation. The fragmentation
of natural habitats has been defined by Metzger
(1999), as a process of rupture in the spatial continuity of natural areas, thereby representing a serious threat to the maintenance of biological diversity.
The transformation of these continuous areas has
generated a landscape composed of natural vegetal
remnants, split up into various patches that vary in
size, shape, degree of isolation, and types of connectivity and environmental matrix (29).
The fragmentation process in Brazil gained
momentum from 1970 on, with essentially negative
impacts on biodiversity, as confirmed by several
authors, such as Primack & Rodrigues (2001) and
Tabarelli & Gascon (2005). According to Metzger
(2009), with the reduction into small, spaced out
fragments, degradation in the Atlantic Rainforest
biome has reached such a high degree, that, accord-
111
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 111
09/10/2012 13:44:07
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
ing to Tabarelli and Gascon (2005), the consequential alteration in natural ecosystems can be considered as the greatest threat to biodiversity.
As has been shown by several authors, the
deforestation of tropical forests has caused profound
modifications in their respective ecosystems. The
main consequences of fragmentation are increased
edge-effects, habitat loss, alterations in ecological
interactions and reproductive processes of various
species, the isolation of vegetal formations, increased predation and competition, the loss of micro-habitats, the extinction of species, and the loss
in biodiversity (3, 27, 30, 14).
Within this context, landscape ecology could offer a contribution, since, according to
Metzger (2001), the proposal of dealing with anthropic mosaics would be a way of understanding
the occurrent human-induced structural and functional modifications in the landscape, as a whole.
By way of landscape structure analysis
and interpretation, it is possible to compile efficient information for the planning of an area,
thereby making it possible to identify probable
negative impacts, as well as seek solutions compatible with the ecological, socio-economical and
cultural spheres (31).
Information regarding the effects on
landscape structure in tropical communities is
still scarce, accounting for only 14% of published
works (20) Therefore, it is of crucial importance,
not only for developing the appropriate research,
but also to better understand the fundamental
patterns and processes of certain organisms. This
would enable working on a local scale, since each
area presents different landscape characteristics,
whereby the need for ample knowledge on regional ecological relationships, contriving to facilitate
a more efficient action for its gestation and conservation.
In view of this need for understanding landscape structure, as a means of undertaking adequate
measures for biodiversity conservation, the Coqueiral Environment Protection Area (EPA Coqueiral)
was chosen for the study, since, as it deals with an
established conservation unit, there is the required
management structure to make the use, protection,
conservation and monitoring of natural and socioeconomic resources of the area, feasible.
OBJECTIVE
The aim of this study was to analyze landscape structure and fragmentation in the Coqueiral
Environmental Protection Area, as a means of supplying subsidies for the management of natural vegetal
remnants, and to point out priority conservation areas.
METHODOLOGY
Study area
The Environmental Protection Area (EPA)
of Coqueiral is located in Coqueiral county, in the
south of Minas Gerais State. Comprising 6.836,21
hectares in the Rio Grande basin in the micro-region of Lavras, it is partly surrounded by the lake
formed by the Furnas reservoir, and the remainder
by the counties of Boa Esperança, Aguanil, Campo
Belo and Nepomuceno, between the geographic
coordinates 45°19’37,5” and 45°26’16,3” longitude
west and 21°03’52,7” and 21°09’30,8” latitude south
(11). The main productive activities are coffee, cattle raising and small farms.
The Coqueiral EPA, created on May 17th,
2002, occupies around 25% of the area of Coqueiral
county. The income of the approximately 400 families that occupy the area is mainly based on coffee
culture and cattle raising (8). As a large part is covered by shallow soils on a highly irregular relief,
there are many restrictions to agricultural activities
(13), therefore, there is a fundamental need for studies of the suitability and adequacy of land use, when
attempting to conciliate an increase in the income
of the population with environmental conservation.
Study Area mapping
Reconnaissance of the study area was the
first step taken, followed by acquisition of a SPO5
satellite image, with 2,5m spatial resolution, encompassing the whole area of the county. The orthorectified image, acquired with radiometric preprocessing and geometric pattern (SPOTMAP),
served as a base for mapping forest fragments, as
well as land use and occupation.
The three image bands used for visual interpretation, viz., the two visible and the panchromatic of the electromagnetic spectrum, referred to
the green (0,5 to 0,6 μm), red (0,6 to 0,7 μm) and
112
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 112
09/10/2012 13:44:07
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
panchromatic (0,48 to 0,71μm) wave lengths. A ed in the field, accuracy being evaluated by the
Kappa index. Confusion matrices were calculated
false-color composite (RGB-12PAN) was used.
Thematic vector graph maps were obtained by cross tabulation between the plans of matrix
through Geo-referenced Information Processing information of image-derived land use, and data
with SPRING 5.1.5. (5). Visual interpretation was from field sampling, according to the methodolthrough the simultaneous observation of recognition ogy described by Moreira (2003). Kappa index
elements, such as tone, color, texture, shape, size pat- evaluation was with a table adapted from Landis
tern, shade, and the association of available evidence, & Koch (1977) (Table 1).
as described by Marchetti & Garcia (1997). Based on
visual interpretation criteria, real use was mapped Table 1: Value for evaluating the degree of concoraccording to class, as follows: (i) Semidecidual sea- dance, starting from the Kappa index
sonal forest: dense forest formations and gallery
Kappa value
Kappa value
Concordance
forest at the edge of streams, neglected/abandoned
Poor
< 0,20
< 0,20
fields; (ii) Cerrado: cerrado
formations; (iii) CofWeak
0,21 – 0,40
0,21 – 0,40
fee: cultures at the non-productive
Moderate
0,41 – 0,60 stage, i.e., under
0,41 – 0,60
3 years, and over three-years-old;
Good
0,61 – 0,80(iv) Exposed rock:
0,61 – 0,80
Very
good
0,81
–
1,00
0,81
–
1,00
areas with visible rock formation; (v) Pasture: areas
of natural and formed pasture; (vi) Other cultures:
areas with annual cultures in various stages of development; (vii) Other uses: urban areas and those with
Landscape configuration
Variables
Variables
Definition
Definition
improvements; (viii) Reforestation: areas set aside
Landscape configuration, computed from
Total area of the landscape (ha).
Total area of the landscape (ha).
A
A
foraplanting eucalyptus;
and
(ix)
Water bodies:
water toArea
the type
soil
by(class)
means
landscape
indices,
Kappa
value
Concordance
Area (ha) of
the
fragment
ij. Iaijrefers
the
(ha)cover
of
offragment
themap
fragment
ij. and
Iofrefers
j to to
thethe
number
type ofoffragment
fragments
(cli
ij
Poor
<
0,20
bodies, rivers,landscape.
streams and reservoirs.
was calculated with FRAGSTAS 3.3 (18) software.
landscape.
Weak
0,21 – 0,40
true features
of the land
Four
were
used,
viz.,
(m) between
twowere
fragments,
basedmetric
on(m)
theconfigurations
between
distance
two
between
fragments,
the edges
basedarea,
ofontwo
thefragments
distance
aijs The Distance
aijs con- Distance
Moderate
0,41 – 0,60
calculated
from
the
center
of
one
pixel
calculated
to
the
center
from
of
the
another.
center
of
one
pixel
to
the
center
of
another
firmed by field visits. 500,61
points
density, shape andGood
proximity/isolation (28, 6, 33)
– 0,80of each land-useTotal
length
of
the
edge
(m)
in
the
landscape
Total
length
between
of
the
fragments
edge
(m)
type
in
i
the
and
landscape
k.
between
fragment
e
e
ik were sampled using
ik
0,81 –a1,00
class
GPSMAP Garmin
(Tables 2 and 3) Very good
Distance (m) from fragment hijij to the Distance
nearest fragment
(m) fromoffragment
the sameijtype
to the
of nearest
habitat fragment
(class), based
of theo
distance from edge to edge, and computed
distance
fromfrom
cell-center
edge to(pixel)
edge, to
andcell-center
computed(pixel).
from cell-center (pix
Distance between the cells (pixels)
ijrDistance
(located between
within the
thefragment
cells (pixels)
ij) and
ijrthe
(located
centroid
within
thefrag
fra
of the
hijr
hijr
Variables
ij, based on the distance cell center (pixel)
ij,Definition
based
to celloncenter
the distance
(pixel).cell center (pixel) to cell center (pixel)
Totalof
areafragments
of the landscape
A Number
of a(ha).
determined
type
Number
of habitat
of fragments
(class) iofinathe
determined
landscape.
type of habitat (class) i in
nij
nij
Area (ha) of the fragment ij. I refers to the type of fragment (class) and j to the number of fragments in the
aij
Proportion of the landscape occupied
by
Proportion
fragmentsofofthe
a determined
landscape occupied
class (i). by fragments of a determ
Pi
Pi
landscape.
of(m)
thebetween
fragment
ij measured
Perimeter
number
of the
offragment
cellthe(pixel)
measured
surfaces.
by the
pij
pij basedby
Distance
two fragments,
on the
the distance
between
edgesij of
two fragments,
and number of cell (pi
aijs Perimeter
Represents
metric
that
will
Represents
in athemetric
formula
that ofwill
average,
be calculated
average inof the
the formul
area u
xij
xpixel
ij be
calculatedafrom
the center
of one
to thecalculated
center
of another.
standard
deviance,
and coefficient
consideration,
of variation.
standard
Total length of
the edge (m)
in the landscape
between
fragments
type
i and k. deviance, and coefficient of variation.
eik consideration,
Distance
(m) from
fragment
tozthe
nearestNumber
fragment
ofofthecells
same(pixels)
type of habitat
based on
of cells
(pixels)
in ijthe
fragment
ij.
in the(class),
fragment
ij.the
hij Number
z
hij
hijr
nij
Pi
pij
Indicesx
ij
z
distance from edge to edge, and computed from cell-center (pixel) to cell-center (pixel).
Distance between the cells (pixels) ijr (located within the fragment ij) and the centroid of the fragment
ij, based on the distance cell center (pixel) to cell center (pixel).
Number of fragments of a determined type of habitat (class) i in the landscape.
Proportion of the landscape occupied by fragments of a determined class (i).
Perimeter of the fragment ij measured bySign
the number
and of cell (pixel) surfaces.
Sign and
Formula
Formula
Meaning
Represents
a metric that will Indices
be interval
calculated (unit)
in the formula
of average, average ofinterval
the
area (unit)
under
consideration, standard deviance, and coefficient of variation.
Number of cells (pixels) in the fragment ij.
CA>0
(ha)
Class area
(CA)
Class area (CA)
This is a measure of landscape composition.
This is aHigh
mea
CA>0 (ha)
CA values indicate matrix dominance. CA values ind
76CSx receiver, together with a TOPCON GPS
RESULTS
indices were obtained by means of points collect-
This is of
a measure
of landscape
composition.
Higher
classes
land-use.
By occupying
49,19%
of the total
Quantifies the proportional abundance Quantifies
of each type
the
Percentage
of
Percentage
precision receiver,
hiper GGD model.
All the of
Sign and
patch
in
the
landscape.
The
interpretation
patch
of
in
PLAN
the
l
thegeoinformation
landscape
in
the
landscape
in
Indices thus generated
Formula
Meaning
was included
in(unit)
a
occupation
PLAND>0
(%) Land use and
PLAND>0 (%)
interval
is
the
same
as
that
described
for
CA,
but
is
the
expressed
same
as
eachofclass
each class
bank
geographic data. Visual interpretation
hit
It was possible to classify the area into nine
percentages.
percentages.
(PLAND)
(PLAND)
CA>0 (ha)
Class area (CA)
Number of
patchesPercentage
(NP) of
the landscape in
each class
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 113
(PLAND)
NP = nj
CA values This
indicateismatrix
dominance.
a simple
measure of the degreeThis
of division
is a simp
113
fragmentation. Higher NP≥1
values indicate
fragmentation
high
NumberNP≥1
of
= nj abundance of each type of
theNP
proportional
(dimensional)
(dimensional)
fragmentation,
and lower values
landscape
the unio
fra
patches
(NP) Quantifies landscape
patch in the landscape. The interpretation of PLAND
or extinction of fragments of the same class.
or extinction
PLAND>0 (%)
is the same as that described for CA, but expressed in
09/10/2012
percentages.
13:44:08
hijr
nij
Pi
pij
xij
Brazilian Journal
z
Distance between the cells (pixels) ijr (located within the fragment ij) and the centroid of the fragment
ij, based on the distance cell center (pixel) to cell center (pixel).
Number of fragments of a determined type of habitat (class) i in the landscape.
Proportion of the landscape occupied by fragments of a determined class (i).
Perimeter of the fragment ij measured by the number of cell (pixel) surfaces.
Represents a metric that will be calculated in the formula of average, average of the area under
of
Ecology standard
ISSN 1516-5868
consideration,
deviance, and coefficient of variation.
Number of cells (pixels) in the fragment ij.
Table 3: Indices of landscape ecology generated by FRAGSTATS (version 3.3) software for quantifying
landscape structure
Sign and
interval (unit)
Meaning
Class area (CA)
CA>0 (ha)
This is a measure of landscape composition. Higher
CA values indicate matrix dominance.
Percentage of
the landscape in
each class
(PLAND)
PLAND>0 (%)
Quantifies the proportional abundance of each type of
patch in the landscape. The interpretation of PLAND
is the same as that described for CA, but expressed in
percentages.
NP≥1
(dimensional)
This is a simple measure of the degree of division or
fragmentation. Higher values indicate higher
landscape fragmentation, and lower values the union
or extinction of fragments of the same class.
Patch density
(PD)
PD>0
(number per 100
ha)
Represents the number of fragments of the class in
100 hectares of landscape. The interpretation of PD is
the same as that described for NP.
Largest patch
index (LPI)
0<LPI<100
(%)
The highest value favors dispersers, pollinators and
propagule dispersion, supplying smaller fragments.
Average area
fragmentation
(AREA_MN)
AREA_MN>0
(ha)
Indicates the degree of fragmentation according to the
number of fragments and the total area occupied by a
certain class.
Index of
distance
average
shape from
(SHAPE_MN)
the nearest
SHAPE_MN≥1
(adimensional)
Lower values indicate a simple type
ENN_MN≥0
fragmentation,
thus beneficial for conservation.
Indices
Number of
patches (NP)
Average
neighbor
Average
distance
from
(ENN_MN)
the nearest
neighbor
(ENN_MN)
Formula
NP = nj
ENN_MN≥0
(m)
(m)
of
Lower values indicate fragment aggre
Lower values indicate fragment aggregation.
area (Figure 1), pasture was the predominant. Of the
others, 28,95% of the area was covered by native
vegetation (semidecidual seasonal forest and cerrado), 11,35% dedicated to coffee culture, 0,6% by
other forms of culture, and 0,9% to reforestation,
6.836,21 ha, in total (Table 4).
A small part of the EPA corresponds to water bodies, representing 5.67% of the total area. Of
this, 5% is part of the Furnas lake inside the reserve
limits, with 52.37% of preserved secondary forest.
The Kappa accuracy index obtained in this
classification was 95.75%.
Analysis of landscape structure
Through evaluating landscape indices, it
can be seen that the four classes; pasture, coffeeClasses
land-use
culture, other cultures
and of
reforestation
occupy an
Coffee
area of
4273.13
ha
(CA),
corresponding
to 62.49%
Cerrado
Water
bodies
(PLAND) of the total area (Table 5). The landscape
Semidecidual Seasonal Forest
percentage
index (LPI) shows that, whereas the
Other Cultures
Other Uses
class Pasture
‘pasture’ occupies the largest fragment, i.e.,
Reforesting
114Exposed Rock
Coffee
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 114
Cerrado
Classes of land-use
Percentage
11,35%
1,52%
5,67%
27,46%
0,6%
Figure 1: Map of land-use
0,75%and occupation of the Coqueiral EPA, 2010
49,19%
0,9%
2,56%
Percentage
11,35%
09/10/2012 13:44:09
1,52%
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Table 4: Percentage of distribution in land-use in the Coqueiral EPA
Classes of land-use
asonal Forest
Classes of land-use
Coffee
Classes of land-use
Coffee
Cerrado
Cerrado
Water bodies Water bodies
Semidecidual Semidecidual
Seasonal Forest
Seasonal
Other CulturesOther Cultures
Other Uses
Other Uses
Pasture
Reforesting Pasture
Exposed RockReforesting
Forest
Exposed Rock
Percentage
Percentage
11,35%
11,35%
1,52%
1,52%
5,67%
5,67%
27,46%
27,46%
0,6%
0,6%
0,75%
0,75%
49,19%
49,19%
0,9%
2,56%
0,9%
2,56%
Table 5: Landscape indices for the classes, land use and occupation
Classes
asses
asonal Forest
CA (ha) NP PD LPI(%) AREA_MN SHAPE_MN ENN_MN
Water bodies
387,56 26
0
2,95
14,91
1,00
545,77
Pasture
3378,96 130 1,01
25,99
16,15
21,02
CA (ha) NPClasses
PD LPI(%) 17,99
AREA_MN
CA (ha)
NPSHAPE_MN
PD LPI(%)
ENN_MN
ARE
Semidecidual Seasonal Forest
1844,01 265 2,06
2,45
6,96
6,11
38,24
387,56bodies
26 50,870 102 2,95
14,91
Other culturesWater
0
0 387,56
0 26
1,84 0 1,00
280,782,95 545,77
3378,96
Pasture 130 776,17
1,01 83 17,99
25,99
1,0116,15
17,99 21,02
Coffee
0
0 3378,96
9,35 130
2,26
184,20
Other uses 1844,01
52,46 Forest
25
0
0 1844,01
2,1 265
1,88
489,122,45 38,24
Semidecidual
265Seasonal
2,06
2,45
6,96
2,06 6,11
Reforestation
67,13 26
0
0
2,58
2,37
398,8
Other
50,87cultures
102
0
0
50,87 0 102
0 1,84
0 280,78
Cerrado
103,72 13
0
0
7,98
2,92
492,84
776,17
83 175,290 34
9,35
Exposed rockCoffee
0 0
0 776,17
5,16 83
2,92 0 2,26
168,98 0 184,20
Other
52,46uses 25
0
17,99%, the class ‘semidecidual seasonal forest’
Reforestation
67,13
26
0
represents only 2,45%, much like that of the class
Cerrado
103,72
0
‘water bodies’,
with 2,95% . 13
The entire
landscape
was composed
Exposed
175,29
rock
34
0 of 704
patches distributed among the different classes of
land-use. The most outstanding, with the largest
number of fragments, were semidecidual seasonal
forest, with 265 patches, and pasture with 130. The
classes ‘other cultures’ and ‘coffee’ were also significantly represented, with 102 and 83 patches, respectively. The class ‘cerrado’ was almost inexpressive, with only 13 patches, adding up to 103.72 ha,
throughout the entire landscape.
The classes of use that presented the
smallest average sizes (AREA_MN) were those
that presented the highest patch density (PD). They
were: pasture (AREA_MN = 25.99; PD = 1.01
fragments|100 ha) and semidecidual seasonal forest (AREA_MN = 6.96; PD = 2.06 fragments|100
ha (Table 5).)
0
52,462,1 25
0 1,88
According to shape indices (SHAPE_
0
67,13
2,58 26
0 2,37
MN), on a whole, landscape patches were of the
0 complex
103,72
7,98
13 shapes,0 as2,92
most
and
irregular
clearly
shown
values
for the34
different types
of land
0 by the175,29
5,16
0 2,92
use. Fragment irregularity in the class semidecidual seasonal forest was the highest at 2.23 (Table 5),
although ‘cerrado’ was also high (1.95). Whereas
only the classes ‘water bodies’ (1.0) and ‘other
cultures’ (1.84) presented simple regular-shaped
patches, the remainder were more complex-shaped,
with results over 2.
The average distance from the nearest
neighbor (ENN_MN) (Table 5) differed in the various classes. The lowest values were ‘pasture’ with
21.02 m and semidecidual seasonal forest with
38.24 m, a clear indication of intense clustering in
both. On the other hand, through presenting few
fragments (n=13), at 492.84, the ENN_MN for the
class ‘cerrado’was extremely high.
0
0
0
0
489,12
398,8
492,84
168,98
115
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 115
09/10/2012 13:44:09
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
DISCUSSION
Land use and occupation
The analysis of land use and occupation indicated that, overall the landscape was mainly dedicated to agro-pastoral activities, such as pasture and
coffee growing. Pasture covered the largest part of the
EPA (49.19%), thus confirming cattle breeding to be
the main local economic activity. Coffee culture, run
on a family basis and occupying 11.35%, was another
important economic source, with a large number of
people depending on this activity for a livelihood.
Other agricultural activities, such as ‘other cultures’
and reforesting, occupied smaller areas of the landscape, to a total of 1.5%. Donald (2004) stated that
agricultural activities constituted the main threat towards maintaining biodiversity in the tropics.
Areas of native vegetation are distributed
throughout the EPA in the form of small and middlesized fragments. This very patchy landscape poses
a grave risk for species extinction (22), through the
consequential changes in both the micro-climate
and fragment physical structure, and the reduction
in environmental heterogeneity, thereby inducing
lower local biodiversity (32).
By crossing field data, it was possible to
analyze the outcome of visual classification using
the Kappa index (16), based on the construction
of error or contingency matrices. The Kappa accuracy index obtained in this classification was
95.75%, which, according to Landis & Koch, is an
excellent result.
According to field observation, areas
dedicated to farming are very often badly conserved, due to inadequate, and, in most cases,
badly planned management, thereby posing a serious problem for populations that depend on this
as their source of income. This dependency could
also account for the low percentage of semidecidual seasonal forest and cerrado, since, as a means of
increasing production, areas set aside for permanent preservation are very often used as a means
of increasing production.
Analysis of landscape structure
According to landscape evaluation indices,
agro-pastoral activities, viz., pasture, coffee culture,
other cultures and reforestation, were predominant.
Similar results were obtained by Tonial (2003), with
47.19% of the area with pasture, and by Valente &
Vettorazzi (2005), who allocated between 2% and
4% for native vegetation in a study area in a region
of São Paulo State. This further corroborates the
thesis that, the predominance of agricultural activities in the EPA landscape, by hindering local forest
remnant conservation, is detrimental to local biodiversity. The similar results encountered in other
sustainable-use conservation units (2005), clearly
show that, in a large part of these areas, consecration to agro-pastoral activities interferes with local
environmental conservation. .
By inference, on analyzing the number of
landscape patches, and based on occupied area, although the class semidecidual seasonal forest notably presented a higher number of fragments than
pasture, these were distributed in smaller-sized
patches. Thus, by pasture occupying an appreciably
larger area, the notion of landscape agricultural predominance was confirmed. According to Tabarelli
& Gascon (2005), high forest fragmentation diminishes its biodiversity.
The average size of patches (AREA_
MN) is considered a trustworthy indication of the
degree of fragmentation, when considering the
number of fragments and the total area occupied
by natural vegetation (18, 17). When evaluated
together with patch density (PD), the different
aspects of a landscape, including forest fragmentation, become comprehensible, thereby facilitating the formation of a profile of the prevailing
degree of this feature. Patch density values were
similar to those encountered by Oliveira (2000),
i.e., 3.3 fragments per 100 ha, for fragments
with an average size of 1.7 ha, when evaluating
a landscape with highly fragmented semidecidual seasonal forest, and by Valente & Vettorazzi
(2005), in hydrographic basin landscapes. In her
study area, the first author encountered the following results: sub-basins of the Mid Corumbataí
(AREA_MN = 2,1 ha; PD = 3,35 fragments/100
ha); the Lower Corumbataí (AREA_MN = 3,2
ha; PD = 2,88 fragments/100ha), and the Ribeirão Claro (AREA_MN = 3,5 ha; PD = 2,48
fragments/100ha), whence the conclusion of intense landscape fragmentation.
According to land-use, shapes were very
irregular, mainly so in the case of semidecidual
116
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 116
09/10/2012 13:44:09
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
seasonal forest fragments. According to Forman
(1997), in relation to diversity and sustainability, the
analysis of forest fragment shape is as important as
size, since the more irregular the fragment, the more
susceptible it is to the edge-effect, especially so in
the case of smaller areas, due to their higher interaction with the matrix (7). With the increase in edgeeffect, there is a proportional reduction in fragment
nuclear area, which, over short, medium or long
term, will possibly have an effect on the structural
quality of the ecosystem, as a whole. Tonial (2003)
arrived at the same results, with 2.40 for the same
class, whereas in the case of Calegari et al. (2010),
the distinct results revealed more regular-shaped
fragments. Apparently, higher shape-complexity
indicates a higher level of disturbance, as a result
of greater interaction with the matrix, through the
increase in the area subject to the edge-effect (23).
According to the Almeida (2008) classification, used here for evaluating the average distance from the closest neighbor, distances between
patches of 60, 120, 200 and >200 m were classified
as low, medium, high, and very high isolation, respectively. Thus, for the landscape studied, isolation in the classes semidecidual seasonal forests and
pasture was low, and for the remainder very high.
Distinct results were encountered by Calegari et
al. (2010), Basile (2006) and Tonial (2003) for the
area ‘natural vegetation, with distances of 244.5,
410 and 119 m, respectively. Valente & Vettorazzi
(2005) came up with similar results for ‘cerrado’,
with 156.65 m. Thus, the results indicate the lower
commitment of the class semidecidual seasonal forest, by demonstrating the small inter-fragment distances of this class, and the higher capacity of the
species for colonization towards forest patches, thus
an inducement to local genic flow (32).
According to some authors, the construction or maintenance of biodiversity corridors is
an important mitigatory measure for perpetuating
connectivity between vegetal fragments, through
facilitating the creation of a system of meta-populations (10, 24).
CONCLUSIONS
The use of geographic information systems
has facilitated the generation and organization of
geo-referenced information, in such a way as to enable the characterization and analysis of the structural elements of the EPA Coqueiral landscape, with
its mosaic of semidecidual seasonal forest and cerrado remnants.
The use of a land-use and occupation map
facilitated the characterization and quantification of
areas of the different types of use, as well as quantification of the number of natural vegetal fragments
(semidecidual seasonal forest and cerrado) of the
Coqueiral EPA. Even so, landscape ecology indices
were still required for characterizing their composition and configuration. The groups of indices that
proved to be efficient for this characterization were
area, density, size, shape, proximity and isolation,
and connectivity.
In the study region, there is a tendency for
agropastoral activities in small rural properties.
These activities account for the high regional fragmentation.
The maintenance of the small fragments in
the EPA is fundamental, as they are liable for connectivity between natural vegetal remnants, and for
conservation of the larger-sized fragments, thereby
aiding in the persistence of local species.
Restoration of EPAs is obviously necessary, since this type of vegetation can function as
ecological corridors, thereby facilitating the movement of fauna and flora. Furthermore, EPAs can
also contribute towards the socio-economic potential of the community, if economically important
species, such as fruit plants, are used.
.
In regards to conservation, through harboring greater biodiversity, the largest-sized fragments
should be considered as priority.
The construction of vegetation corridors
should be considered as a means of increasing interfragment connectivity, as well as metapopulation
auxiliary systems, within the EPA.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
We wish to extend our thanks to the Universidade Federal de Lavras, and the Geosoil Laboratory, Epamig/Lavras for support and incentives,
as well as to CAPES for the grant and FAPEMIG for
financing the project.
117
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 117
09/10/2012 13:44:09
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
RESUMO
Este trabalho analisou a estrutura da paisagem da Área de Proteção Ambiental Coqueiral, localizada na região Sul de Minas Gerais. O objetivo
foi avaliar a estrutura da paisagem a partir de métricas e princípios da Ecologia da Paisagem e apontar
áreas prioritárias para a conservação. Foram utilizados Sistemas de Informação Geográfica e Sensoriamento Remoto para elaborar um mapa de uso
da terra a partir de uma imagem de satélite SPOT 5
HCR. A análise da estrutura da paisagem foi realizada através do software Fragstats, utilizando métricas de paisagem. Os resultados mostraram que a
classe pastagem foi considerada como a matriz da
paisagem e ocupou quase metade da unidade de
conservação. A análise da estrutura da paisagem
mostrou que a paisagem é dominada por atividades
agropastoris. A paisagem apresenta 704unidades.
O tamanho médio dos fragmentos foi maior para o
pasto do que para a floresta estacional semidecidual, enquanto que a floresta estacional semidecidual
apresentou maior densidade de fragmentos. Classes
de uso da terra mostraram formas complexas indicando maiores efeitos de borda. Pastagens apresentaram menor isolamento entre os fragmentos. Os
dados obtidos neste estudo são relevantes para a tomada de decisão e planejamento ambiental da Área
de Proteção Ambiental de Coqueiral, permitindo
sugerir áreas prioritárias para sua conservação.
Palavras-chave: Ecologia de paisagens, Métricas
da paisagem, Sistemas de Informação Geográfica.
REFERENCES
1- ALMEIDA, C. G. Análise espacial dos fragmentos florestais na área do Parque Nacional dos
Campos Gerais, Paraná.2008. 72 f. Dissertação
(Mestrado em Gestão do Território) – Univ. Estadual de Ponta Grossa, Ponta Grossa, 2008.
2- BASILE, A. Caracterização estrutural e física
de fragmentos florestais no contexto da paisagem da Bacia do Rio Corumbataí, SP. 2006. 86
p. Dissertação (Mestrado em Ecologia Aplicada) – Univ. de São Paulo, Piracicaba, 2006.
3- BIERREGAARD, R. O.; LOVEJOY, T. E.; KAPOS, V.; SANTOS, A. A.; HUTCHINGS, R. W.
The biological dynamics of tropical rainforest
fragments. Bioscience, Washington,v. 42, n. 1,
p. 859-866, 1992.
4- CALEGARI, L.; MARTINS, S. V.; GLERIANI,
J. M.; SILVA, E.; BUSATO, L. C. Análise da
dinâmica de fragmentos florestais no município
de Carandaí, MG, para fins de restauração florestal. Revista Árvore, Viçosa, MG, v. 34, n. 5,
p. 871-880, 2010.
5- CAMARA, G. et al. Spring: Integrating remote
sensingand GIS by object-oriented data modelling. Computers & Graphics, New York, v. 20,
n. 3, p. 395-403, 1996.
6- CARVALHO, F. M. V.; MARCO-JÚNIOR, P. D.;
FERREIRA, L. G. The cerrado into-pieces: Habitat fragmentation as a function of landscape use in
the savannas of central Brazil. BiologicalConservation, Boston, v. 142, n. 7, p. 1392-1403, 2009.
7- CEMIN, G.; PERICO, E.; REMPEL, C. Composição e configuração da paisagem da sub-bacia do Arroio Jacaré, Vale do Taquari, RS, com
ênfase nas áreas de florestas. RevistaÁrvore,
Viçosa, MG, v. 33, n. 4, p. 705-711, 2009. DONALD, P. F. Biodiversity impacts of some agricultural commodity production systems. ConservationBiology, Boston, v. 18, n. 1, p. 17-37, 2004.
8- EMPRESA DE ASSISTÊNCIA TÉCNICA E
EXTENSÃO RURAL DE MINAS GERAIS EMATER. Área de proteção ambiental do município de Coqueiral. Belo Horizonte, 2002.
9- FORMAN, T. T. Land mosaics: the ecology of
landscapes and regions. New York: Cambridge
University, 1997. 632 p.
10- FORMAN, R. T. T.; SPERLING, D.; BISSONETTE, J. A.; et al. Road ecology: science and solutions. Washington: Island Press, 2003. 481 p.
11- INSTITUTO BRASILEIRO DE GEOGRAFIA
E ESTATÍSTICA. Cartografia. Rio de Janeiro,
2010. Disponível em: <http://www.ibge.gov.
br/home/geociencia /cartografia/default.shtm>
Acesso em: 26 out. 2010.
12- LANDIS, J.; KOCH, G. G. The measurements
of agreement for categorical data. Biometrics,
Washington, v. 33, n. 3, p. 159-179, 1977.
13- LIMA, V. M. P. Qualidade estrutural e intervalo hídrico ótimos de solos cultivados em área
de proteção ambiental do sul de Minas Gerais.
2008. 85 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Ciências
do Solo) – Univ. Federal de Lavras, Lavras, 2008.
118
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 118
09/10/2012 13:44:09
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
14- LINDENMAYER, D. B.; HOBBS, R. J.; DRAKE, R. M.; et al. A checklist for ecological management of landscapes for conservation. EcologyLetters, Oxford, v. 11, n. 1, p. 78-91, 2008.
15- MARCHETTI, D. A. B.; GARCIA, G. J.
Princípios de fotogrametria e fotointerpretação.
São Paulo: Nobel, 1996. 264p.
16- MOREIRA, M. A. Fundamentos do sensoriamento remoto e metodologias de aplicação. São
José dos Campos: INPE, 2003. 307p
17- MCGARIGAL, K.; CUSHMA, S. A.; NEEL,
M. C.; ENE, E. Fragstats: spatial pattern analysis program for categorical maps. Amherst: University of Massachusetts, 2002.
18- MCGARIGAL, K.; MARKS, B. J. Fragstats:
spatial patterns analysis program for guantifiying landscape structure. Portland: Pacific
Northwest Research Station, 1995. 122p.
19- METZGER, J. P. Editorial conservation issues in
the Brazilian Atlantic forest. Biological Conservation, Boston, v. 142, n. 6, p. 1138-1140, 2009.
20 -METZGER, J. P. Landscape ecology: perspectives based on the 2007 IALE world congress.
LandscapeEcology, Dordrecht, v. 23, n. 5, p.
501-504, 2008.
21- METZGER, J. P. O que é ecologia de paisagens? Biota Neotropica, Campinas, v. 1, n. 1-2, p. 1-9, 2001.
22- METZGER, J. P.Estrutura da paisagem e fragmentação: análise bibliográfica.Anais da Academia Brasileira de Ciências,Rio de Janeiro,
v.71, n.3, p.445-463, 1999.
23- NASCIMENTO, M. C.; SOARES, V. P.; RIBEIRO, C. A. A. S.; SILVA, E. Mapeamento dos
fragmentos de vegetação florestal nativa da Bacia hidrográfica do rio Alegre, Espírito Santo, a
partir de imagens do Satélite Ikonos II. Revista
Árvore, Viçosa, MG, v. 30, n. 3, p. 389-398, 2006.
24- NG, S. J.; DOLE, J. W.; SAUVAJOT, R. M.; et
al. Use of highway undercrossings by wildlife in
southern California. BiologicalConservation, v.
115, p. 499-507, 2004.
25- OLIVEIRA, E. M. Caracterização e qualidade ambiental em dois fragmentos florestais na perspectiva
da conservação de Alouatta guariba (Humboldt,
1812) no interior do Estado de São Paulo. 2009. 93
f.Tese (Doutorado em Ciências) - Universidade Federal de São Carlos, São Carlos, 2009.
26- OLIVEIRA, L. T. Fragmentos de floresta Atlântica Semidecidual no município de Lavras: uma
comparação ecológica entre a cobertura atual e
a cobertura exigida pela legislação. 2000. 103 f.
Monografia (Graduação em Engenharia Florestal)
– Universidade Federal de Lavras, Lavras, 2000.
27- Primack, R. B.; Rodrigues, E. Biologia da
conservação.Londrina: Viva, 2001. 328p.
28- RIBEIRO, M. C.; METZGER, J. P.; MARTENSEN, A. C.; PONZONI, F. J.; HIROTA, M. M. The
Brazilian Atlantic Forest: how much is left, and
how is the remaining forest distributed? Implications for conservation. Biological Conservation,
Boston, v. 142, n. 6, p. 1141-1153, 2009.
29- SAUNDERS, D.A.;HOBBS R.J.;MARGULES,
C. R. Biological consequences of ecosystem
fragmentation: a review. Conservation Biology,
Essex, v. 5, n. 1, p. 18-32, 1991.
30- SILVA, W. G. S. METZGER, J.P..; SIMÕES, S.;
SIMONETTI, C. Relief influence on the spatial
distribution of the Atlantic Forest cover at the
Ibiúna Plateau, SP. BrazilianJournalofBiology,
Rio de Janeiro, v. 67, n. 3, p. 403-411, 2007.
31- SOUZA, C. G. Caracterização Ambiental e
Análise da Estrutura da Paisagem da Área
de Proteção Ambiental de Coqueiral, Minas
Gerais. 2011. 119 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em
Ecologia Aplicada) – Universidade Federal de
Lavras, Lavras, 2011.
32- TABARELLI, M.; GASCON, C. Lições da
pesquisa sobre fragmentação aperfeiçoando
políticas e diretrizes de manejo para a conservação da biodiversidade. Megadiversidade, Belo
Horizonte,v. 1, n. 1, p. 181-188, 2005.
33-TONIAL, T. M. Dinâmica da paisagem da
região nordeste do Estado do Rio Grande do
Sul. 2003. 311 f. Tese (Doutorado em Ecologia
e Recursos Naturais) - Universidade Federal de
São Carlos, São Carlos, 2003.
34-VALENTE, R. O. A; VETTORAZZI, C. A.
Avaliação da estrutura florestal na Bacia do Rio
Corumbatai, SP. ScientiaForestalis (IPEF), Piracicaba, v. 68, p. 45-57, 2005.
119
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 119
09/10/2012 13:44:10
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
120
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 120
09/10/2012 13:44:10
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
MACROALGA SPECIES RICHNESS IN CONSOLIDATED ARENITE SUBSTRATA
AND REEF-POOLS WITH SANDY BOTTOMS AT BEACHES IN PIAUÍ.
Voltolini1, J.C; Batista2, M.G.S; Nascimento3, E.F.I.; Campos2, K.C.G.C.; Resende4, J.S.S.; Machado5,
R.A.; Souza6, L.O.; De Oliveira7, D.; Paiva-Silva8, K.; Lopes-Filho3, E.S.
1 – Group on Research and Teaching in Conservation Biology (ECOTROP), University of Taubaté.
2 - Department of Biology, IB-UESPI, Teresina, PI.
3 - Department of Ecology, IB-USP.
4 - Biologist, Environmental Council. Teresina, PI.
5 – Member of the City Council of Parnaíba (PI), Environmental Vigilance.
6 - Souza & Silva Assessors, Parnaíba.
7 - UFPI, Aberra do Piauí University. Buriti dos Lopes, PI.
8 – Ilha Ativa Committee (CIA), Ilha Grande.
ABSTRACT
Sessile-organism dependence on substrate structure is capable of conducing, both the
manner in which biological communities colonize new environments, as well as richness
and abundance patterns. Comparison of the frequency of macroalga species frequency
on two beaches in Piauí (northeastern Brazil), was the means of testing the hypothesis
that species richness would be higher on a rocky (Barra Grande) than sandy (Coqueiro)
beach. Of the 21 macroalga species recorded, most revealed low occurrence, with Hypnea spinella and H. musciformis as those predominant. Whereas all were recorded on
the Coqueiro beach, only 7 were on the Barra Grande. Hence, our hypothesis remained
unproven. Nonetheless, as Barra Grande beach is subject to a more intense human impact than Coqueiro, this could vindicate this pattern.
Keywords: Landscape ecology, Landscape metrics, Geographic Information Systems.
Introduction
Benthonic coastal ecosystems, which comprise one of the most productive marine environments, planet-wide, present high richness in organisms of outstanding ecological and economic
importance, such as mussels, oysters, crustaceans
and fishes, as well as various seaweeds which play an
important ecological role by supplying oxygen, food,
shelter and substratum, while at the same time functioning as nurseries for various organisms at several
trophic levels in the food chain (Batista, 2011).
Marine algae are ephemeral or perennial
benthonic organisms, which live attached, consolidated or not, to solid substrata. The richest areas in
macroalgae, both in diversity and biomass, are rocky
shores, rocky beaches and reefs (Oliveira et al., 2001).
The distribution of seaweeds along the
Brazilian coast is a result of the complex interaction of factors, such as substratum availability, the
presence of fresh water flows, biotic interactions,
water mass characteristics, and historical and biogeographical factors (Oliveira et al., 2001).
Brazil, considered as the country with the
highest biodiversity planet-wide (Bicudo & Shepherd, 1998), possesses a coastline which extends
from the tropics to regions of warm-temperate waters. The great challenge is diversity and conservation quantification.
In the case of benthonic marine algae, Oliveira
Filho (1977), when compiling the first Brazilian infrageneric taxa, listed 327 Rhodophyta, 113 Chlorophyta
and 64 Phaeophyta, 504 species, all told. Subsequently, Horta et al. (2001), when updating the data base on
121
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 121
09/10/2012 13:44:10
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Brazilian alga diversity, listed 642 taxa, distributed
among 388 Rhodophyta, 166 Chlorophyta and 88
Phaeophyta. According to more recent research, there
are 774 infrageneric taxa, corresponding to 482 Rhodophyta, 191 Chlorophyta and 101 Phaeophyta (Fujii
et al.,2008), with at least 700 species among coraline
reefs alone (Figueiredo et al., 2008).
The Brazilian southeast is the most studied
region. On the other hand, whereas in the north and
northeast the flora is somewhat better-known in
states such as Bahia and Pernambuco, this is not the
case in others, such as Sergipe, Alagoas, Piauí, Pará
and Amapá. This is a direct reflection on the fewer
species known in these regions in comparison to the
southeast. Notwithstanding, the extent of each state
must be taken into account, when comparing these
numbers (Fujii et al., 2008).
In spite of the large diversity of Brazilian marine macroalgae, most studies have
mainly focused on either the morphological, biochemical or systematic aspects, or associated invertebrate fauna. To date, few studies have been
dedicated to information on certain aspects of
Brazilian macroalgae, such as community ecology (Oliveira Filho & Ugadim, 1976; Pedrini et
al., 1989; Gestinari et al., 1998; Yokoya et al.,
1999; de Paula et al., 2005; Amado Filho et al.,
2006; Figueiredo et al., 2008; and Marins et al.,
2008), populations (Guimaraens et al., 1996; Yokoya et al., 1999; Amado Filho et al., 2006; Loureiro & Reis 2008; and Marins et al., 2008 {although many of these studies have mainly dealt
with communities, there is also information on
the ecology of populations}), succession (Eston
et al., 1992), and conservation (Figueiredo et al.,
2008). Worthy of note; most of the cited studies
of communities are really botanic surveys without registration of factors which might interpret
those processes linked to community structure
and dynamics. Published studies on macroalga
population dynamics are almost non-existent.
At the same time, the Brazilian coast presents
problems of pollution and the invasion by exotic
species, whereby the need for further studies of
marine microalgae conservation.
Through floristic surveys on macroalgae
over the last decade along the Piauí coast, it can be
assumed that this presents a characteristic tropical
region flora (Batista, 2011), which is undergoing
gradual alteration, since banks of Sargassum were
visibly encountered, and nowadays Gracilaria have
become perceptibly predominant.
The coastline of the state of Piauí, the
smallest along the Brazilian coast, with only 66 km
in extent, to a large degree corresponds to a strip of
recently formed sediments associated to a series of
islands, basins and channels, all along the coastline,
with sand bars, dunes, mangroves and some cliffs
(Santos-Filho, 2009), all of which subject to the
expressive influence of the Parnaíba delta. In spite
of the observed richness in biodiversity, and being
an Environmental Protection Area (EPA), there are
few studies of the local algae.
The Coqueiro and Barra Grande beaches
are both located along the Piauí coast. The former,
in Luiz Correia county, is mainly characterized by
its rocky formation, propitious for the development
of seaweeds and well-protected from wave-motion,
thus ideal for the formation of microhabitats (Batista, 2011), whereas the latter, in Cajueira da Praia
county, is noted by rocky formation intercalated
with sandy pools. There is a certain degree of anthropic occupation in both, which, together with
biotic and abiotic attributes, exert an influence on
local floral composition.
Objetive
The aim was to compare the number of
macroalgae species on consolidated arenite substrata, as well as in sandy-bottom reef pools along the
beaches of Piauí. Our hypothesis was that species
richness would be higher on that with a consolidated substratum, which would be more stable for the
fixing and establishment of seaweeds, as a whole.
Methodology
Study site
Alga samples came from two locations on
the Piauí coast. The Barra Grande district is located
in the northern part of the state of Piauí (02º55’40”
S and 41º24’40” W), in Cajueiro da Praia county.
The 4-km-long beach, containing the mouths of four
major rivers, viz., Timonha, Ubatuba, Camurupim
and Cardoso, is mainly formed by associations of
122
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 122
09/10/2012 13:44:10
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
marine and continental quartz sands, together with
mangroves, all part of a transition coastal ecosystem
between marine and terrestrial environments. In the
case of Barra Grande beach, there is a consolidated
arenite substratum below the high tide mark (PIAUÍ,
1996). The climate is alternatively humid|dry tropical, with the dry period lasting six months, and an average temperature between 25 ºC and 32 ºC (CEPRO,
1990). On an average, the sand contains 10-30cmsized fragments of consolidated segment (’rocks’),
water temperature is 30ºC, and salinity 35ppm. The
distance between the collecting station and the water-line was 530m. Collections took place on August
19th, 2012 (0.1 tide at 11:0 0 a.m.).
Coqueiro Beach, situated in Luís Correia
county (02º54’35” S and 41º32’03” O), with a high
flow of tourists, is characterized by rocky outcropping harboring a rich biodiversity. The local climate
is alternatively humid|dry tropical, with an average
temperature between 25ºC and 32º, and the characteristic vegetation of dunes and restinga (CEPRO,
2001). The sand is fine. Water temperature at the
time was 28ºC and salinity 35ppm. The distance between the collecting station and the water-line was
5 km. Collections took place on August 20th, 2012
(0.2 tide at 11:30 a.m.).
Sampling planning
Seaweeds were first collected all along the
reef of the two beaches chosen for the study. A species list was compounded after species identification.
A 10mx10m grid with 200 quadrates (parcels) of 50cmx50cm was set up (Figure 1). 10 parcels
of 50cmx50cm were raffled, using a random-number
table. Seaweed-species collected within each parcel
were then registered. Specimens were individually
identified by species on the spot. In the case of doubt,
subsequent laboratory identification was carried out
at the Piauí State University (UESPI).
As a means of comparing the two parcels,
calculations of the percentage of those containing
each seaweed species, as well as the Jaccard similarity index (Sj), were carried out. An estimate of
species richness was calculated through the Chão 1
method on Estimate S software.
Results
21 seaweed species were registered on the
two beaches. Whereas all the species were present
on Coqueiro Beach, only 7 were on Barra Grande
(Table 1; Figures 2 and 3).
Similarity between the two communities was
only % (Sj=0,29). Hypnea spinella was the only species present in all the ten parcels at both sights, whereas the species Hypnea musciformis was only present in
all the parcels in Coqueiro Beach (Figure 3).
Most of the species were present in less
than 50% of the parcels, 16 (76% of the 21 species)
in Coqueiro Beach, and 6 (86% of the 7 species) in
Barra Grande.
Richness estimates showed Coqueiro
Beach to be richer than Barra Grande, the latter
proving to be a poorer and more homogeneous
system (Figure 4). Furthermore, the number of
species at both sites having already reached stabilization, with a little more than half of the sampling effort having been employed, was a clear indication that the number of parcels was sufficient
for estimating richness.
Figure 1 – Parcels, one at Barra Grande Beach with fragments of consolidated sediment (left), and the
other at Coqueiro Beach with fine sand (right).
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 123
Chlorophyta
Acetabularia calyculus
Acetabularia crenulata
Barra
Grande
X
Coqueiro
X
X
123
09/10/2012 13:44:10
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Chlorophyta
Acetabularia calyculus
Acetabularia crenulata
Caulerpa mexicana
Cladophora membranacea
Enteromorpha muscoides
Ulva fasciata
Ulva lactuca
Valonia aegagropila
Barra
Grande
X
X
Phaeophyta
Dictyopteris delicatula
Dictyota menstrualis
Padina gymnospora
Rhodophyta
Acanthophora spicifera
Gelidiella acerosa
Gracilaria birdiae
Gracilaria domingensis
Haloplegma duperreyi
Hypnea musciformis
Hypnea spinella
Jania subulata
Laurencia dendroidea
Palisada perforata
Coqueiro
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Figure 2 – Illustration of the seaweed species registered on the beaches of Coqueiro and
Barra Grande.
Figure 3 – Percentage of parcels containing each of the seaweed species sampled in the beaches of Coqueiro
and Barra Grande in Piauí.
124
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 124
09/10/2012 13:44:10
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Figure 4 – Estimates of species richness (S) at the
beaches of Barra Grande and Coqueiro.
Discussion
Macroalga diversity is directly related to
environmental conditions, especially to the type
of substratum available for spore fixation, and the
quality of the water. The various reproduction strategies function in combination with high spore dispersion ability, and the capacity for regeneration,
as well as certain aspects of intra and inter-specific
competition, thereby very often facilitating rapid
substratum colonization, both organic or inorganic
and natural or artificial. In reef ecosystems, seaweeds occur upon a large number of species that are
fixed on the various substrata, such as shells, corals
and other algae (Dorigo et al., 2005). Hence, reef
substrata are eminently appropriate for the fixation
of spores, and consequently, the efficient development of grasps.
Nonetheless, the initial hypothesis remained unproven, since a larger number of macroalga species were registered on Coqueiro Beach,
where the substratum is sandy.
This pattern was the contrary to those encountered by other authors. In a Papua New Guinea
study, less alga cover, richness and abundance was
registered on arenite substrata with marine monocotyledon banks (Heijs, 1987). In the Antarctic,
less seaweed cover (Richardson, 1979) and biomass
(Quartino et al., 2001) was also observed on arenite
substrata. In the Baltic Sea, Russia, there was accumulation on the bottom of the Neva estuary, due
to human drainage and sand filling, with the con-
sequential lessening of seaweed biomass (Gubelit,
2012). In Brazil, the patterns encountered by Aquino
(2012) in Ceará, were also substratum formation in
the form of sandy reefs. On comparing the beaches
of Flexeiras and Manguinhos, Trairi county, it was
noted that reef heterogeneity exerted an influence
on seaweed distribution, with Manguinhos presenting higher species richness than Flexeiras.
Pollution, brought about by the direct release
of home and industrial pollutants onto beaches via
river courses and the movement of shipping along the
coast, can be cited among the main factors contributing to the decrease in marine diversity (Oliveira et
al., 2011). At Barra Grande, there is a greater flux
of both people and boats throughout the year, when
compared to Coqueiro, which is situated in a region
where summer tourism predominates, thereby undergoing less yearly impact. Furthermore, Barra
Grande is subject to the influence of four main rivers,
viz., Timonha, Ubatuba, Camurupim and Cardoso,
as well as mangroves (CEPRO, 1990), with the consequential inducement of low species richness through
the impact of fresh water.
Conclusion
Species richness was greater at Coqueiro
Beach, with more sand, than at Barra Grande
Beach, which, although with more rocks, is subject
to higher human impact.
At Barra Grande, there is the adverse influence of four rivers and an inappropriate substratum
for fixation in the case of most species. It is also
possible that, depending on tide and wind conditions, those consolidated are also subject to rolling
and abrasion. On the other hand, at Coqueiro Beach,
salinity is probably stable and the substratum more
appropriate for seaweed fixation (consolidated sandy rocks). In this case, the sandy bottom represents
a sand deposit, with seaweed stems possibly being
fixed below the sand on the hard substratum.
Acknowledgement
The present study was developed as part of
the activities involved in a Field Course on Marine
Ecology. Whence, we wish to thank the Piauí State
University (UESPI) for logistic support, Dr. Sérgio
125
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 125
09/10/2012 13:44:10
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Rosso (Department of Ecology, USP) for talks and
suggestions on sampling methods, and Prof. Dr.
Mutue Toyota Fujii (Institute of Botany, São Paulo),
Dr. Estela Maria Plastino (Department of Botany,
USP) and Dr. Carlos Wallace do Nascimento Moura
(Department of Biological Sciences, UEFS), for
help in species identification.
References
1- AMADO FILHO, G.M.; HORTA P.A.; BRASILEIRO, P.S.; BARROS-BARRETO, M.B. &
M.T. FUJII. Subtidal benthic marine algae of the
Marine State Park of Laje de Santos (São Paulo,
Brazil). Brazilian Journal of Oceanography. 54,
4:225-234, 2006.
2- BATISTA, M.G.S. Algas Marinhas Bentônicas
do Litoral do Piauí: contribuição do conhecimento e preservação. In SANTOS FILHO, F. S
& SOARES, A. F. C. L. (Organizadores) Biodiversidade do Piauí: Pesquisas & Perspectivas. 1
edição. Curitiba, PR: CRV. 2011.
3- BICUDO C.E.M. & SHEPHERED G.J. Biodiversidade do Estado de São Paulo, Brasil. Fungos
macroscópicos & plantas. FAPESP, São Paulo,
79p. 1998
4- CEPRO. Macrozoneamento costeiro do estado
do Piauí: Relatório geoambiental e socioeconômico. Teresina: Secretária de Planejamento do Piauí. 1990.
5- CEPRO. Macrozoneamento costeiro do estado do
Piauí: Relatório geoambiental e socioeconômico. Teresina: Secretária de Planejamento do
Piauí. Disponível em: http://www.cepro.pi.gov.
br/download/201102/CEPRO16_9ab2acbd08.
pdf. 2001.
6- CORREIA, M.D., SOVIERZOSKI, H.H. Ecossistemas marinhos: recifes, praias e manguezais. edUFAL/Maceió. Alagoas. 2005.
7- DE PAULA, A.F.; FIGUEIREDO, M.A.O.; &
J.C. CREED. Structure of the Macroalgal Community Associated with the Seagrass Halodule
wrightii Ascherson in the Abrolhos Marine National Park, Brazil. Botanica Marina. 46, 5: 413424. 2005.
8- ESTON, V.R.; BRAGA, R.A.; CORDEIROMARINO, M.; FUJII, M.T. & N.S. YOKOYA.
Macroalgal colonization patterns on artificial
substrates inside southeastern Brazilian mangroves. Aquatic Botany, Elsevier Science Publishers B.V., Amsterdam. 42: 315-325. 1992.
9- FUJII, M.T., BARATA D., CHIRACAVA S. &
GUIMARÃES S.M.P.B. Cenário brasileiro da
diversidade de algas marinhas bentônicas e sua
contribuição para a política de conservação dos
recursos naturais e do meio ambiente. In: 59°
Congresso Nacional de Botânica: Atualidades,
Desafios e Perspectivas da Botânica no Brasil.
Imagem Gráfica e Editora Ltda. p. 375-377. 2008.
10-GESTINARI, L. M.S.; NASSAR, C.A.G;
ARANTES, P.V.S. Algas marinhas bentônicas da Reserva Biológica da Praia do Sul, Ilha
Grande, Angra dos Reis, Rio de Janeiro, Brasil.
Acta Botânica Brasileira, 12, 1: 67-76. 1998.
11-GUBELIT Y.I. Factors, influencing on macroalgal communities in the Neva estuary (eastern
Baltic Sea). Baltic International Symposium
(BALTIC), 2012 IEEE/OES. 8-10 May 2012.
12-GUIMARAENS, M.A.; COIMBRA, C.A. & R.
COUTINHO. Modeling competition between
Laurencia obtusa (Ceramiales, Rhodophyta) and
Hypnea spinella (Gigartinales, Rhodophyta) at
Cabo Frio Island, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Hydrobiologia. 326-327, 1:273-276. 1996
13-HAROUN, R.J. & PRUD´HOMME van REINE,
W.F. A Biogeographycal study of Laurencia and
Hypnea species of the Macaronesian region. Courier Forsch – Inst Sencknberg 159: 119-125. 1993.
14-HEIJS, F. Community structure and seasonality
of macroalgae in some mixed seagrass meadows
from Papua New Guinea. Aquatic Botany, Elsevier Science Publishers B.V., Amsterdam. 27:
139-158. 1989.
15-HORTA P.A., AMANCIO E., COIMBRA C.S. &
OLIVEIRA E.C. Considerações sobre a distribuição e origem da flora de macroalgas marinhas
Brasileiras. Hoehnea 28: 243-265. 2001
16-LOUREIRO, R.L. & R.P. REIS. Efeito do gradiente de salinidade na taxa fotossintética de Polysiphonia subtilissima, Cladophora vagabunda e
Ulva flexuosa subsp. flexuosa na Lagoa Rodrigo
de Freitas, Rio de Janeiro, Brasil. Rodriguésia
59, 2:291-296. 2008
17-MARINS, B. V.; BRASILEIRO, P. S.; BARRETO, M. B. B.; NUNES, J. M. C; YONESHIGUEVALENTIM, Y. & AMADO FILHO, G.M.
126
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 126
09/10/2012 13:44:10
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
Subtidal Benthic Marine Algae of the Todos
os Santos Bay, Bahia State, Brazil. Oecologia
Brasiliensis. 12, 2: 229-242. 2008.
18-OLIVEIRA FILHO, E.C. & Y. UGADIM. A
survey of the marine algae of Atol das Rocas
(Brazil). Phycologia: 15, 1: 41-44. 1976.
19-OLIVEIRA, E. C. Macroalgas marinhas da
costa brasileira - Estado do conhecimento, uso e
conservação biológica. Congresso Brasileiro de
Botânica. Acesso em 10 ago., 2010, http://www.
ib.usp.br/algamare-br/macroalgas.html. 2002.
20-OLIVEIRA, E.C., HORTA, P.A., AMANCIO, E. & ANNA, C.L.S. Algas e angiospermas marinhas bênticas do litoral brasileiro. In:
Ministério do Meio Ambiente. (Org.). Macrodiagnóstico da Zona Costeira do Brasil,RJ. 2001
21-OLIVEIRA-FILHO, E.C. Algas marinhas
bentônicas do Brasil. Tese de livre docência.
Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo. 1977.
22-PEDRINI A.G.; GONCALVES J.E.A.; FON-
SECA M.C.S.; ZAU A.S. & C.C. LACORTE. A
survey of the marine algae fo Trindade Island,
Brazil. Botanica marina. 32, 2:97-99. 1989.
23-PIAUÍ. Secretaria de Planejamento. Fundação
CEPRO. Macrozoneamento costeiro do Estado
do Piauí. Fundação CEPRO, Fundação Rio Parnaíba. Teresina. 1996.
24-QUARTINO, M.L., H. KLOSER, I.R.
SCHLOSS & C. WIENCKE. Biomass and associations of benthic marine macroalgae from the
inner Potter Cove (King George Island, Antarctica) related to depth and substrate. Polar Biol.
24: 349–355. 2001
25-RICHARDSON, M.G. The distribution of Antarctic marine macroalgae related to depth and
substrate. Br. Antarct. Surv. Bull. 49: 1-13. 1979.
26-SANTOS-FILHO, F. S. Composição florística e
estrutural da vegetação de restinga do Estado do
Piauí, (Tese de Doutorado em Botânica) - Universidade Federal Rural de Pernambuco, Recife. 2009.
127
Revista SEB Ano 14 Final.indd 127
09/10/2012 13:44:10
Brazilian Journal of Ecology ISSN 1516-5868
128
RevistaView
SEB
Ano 14
publication
statsFinal.indd 128
09/10/2012 13:44:10